Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Manjari v. Ranjit Singh .

Delhi High Court
Nov 29, 2006
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from a judgment and decree dated 15.2.2006 by the Additional District Judge, Delhi, in a suit under Order 37 of the CPC for recovery of Rs. 6,72,000/- with interest. The defendant-appellant was served by publication of summons in the "Statesman" newspaper but did not appear within the stipulated 10-day period under Order 37 Rule 2(3) of the CPC. Consequently, the Trial Court decreed the suit ex parte. The defendant later applied under Order 37 Rule 4 of the CPC to set aside the decree on the ground that service by publication was not in accordance with law, relying on a precedent that a copy of the plaint must also be published along with the summons. The Trial Court found service defective but dismissed the application to set aside the decree on the basis that the defendant had not raised any triable issue. The defendant appealed against both the judgment and the order declining to set aside the decree.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Trial Court was justified in refusing to set aside the ex parte decree despite finding that service of summons was not in accordance with law.
  2. Whether a defendant must raise triable issues in an application under Order 37 Rule 4 to set aside an ex parte decree when service of summons is defective.
  3. The proper interpretation and application of Order 37 Rule 4 of the CPC in cases involving defective service of summons.

Arguments of the Parties

Defendant-Appellant's Arguments

  • Service by publication was incomplete and invalid without publishing a copy of the plaint along with the summons, relying on the decision in Hans Raj v. Lakhi Ram.
  • The ex parte decree should be set aside due to defective service of summons.

Plaintiff-Respondent's Arguments

  • This information was not available in the provided opinion.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Hans Raj v. Lakhi Ram, 114 (2004) DLT 264 Requirement that service by publication in suits under Order 37 must include publication of a copy of the plaint along with summons. The court accepted that service was not in accordance with law based on this precedent.
Rajni v. Suresh, (2003) 5 SCC 315 : AIR 2003 SC 1322 Interpretation of Order 37 Rule 4 regarding setting aside ex parte decrees and the requirement to claim all reliefs in one application. The court distinguished this precedent as not supporting the Trial Court’s requirement of triable issues where service was defective; it clarified that defective service itself is a special circumstance warranting setting aside the decree.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court noted that the Trial Court’s finding that service was defective was not challenged by the plaintiff. The key legal question was whether the Trial Court was correct in refusing to set aside the ex parte decree on the basis that the defendant had not raised triable issues. The Court analyzed the Supreme Court decision in Rajni v. Suresh and found that it did not support the Trial Court’s interpretation of Order 37 Rule 4. The Supreme Court had held that defective service constitutes a special circumstance to set aside an ex parte decree and that all reliefs must be claimed in one application. However, the Court distinguished that case as involving defective service by registered A.D., unlike the present case involving defective service by publication.

The Court reasoned that where service itself is defective, the law and equity require the ex parte decree to be set aside without the defendant having to show triable issues at that stage. Triable issues become relevant only after the decree is set aside and the defendant seeks leave to defend. The Trial Court erred in prematurely demanding triable issues before setting aside the decree, which resulted in a miscarriage of justice.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF

The Court allowed the appeal, set aside the impugned judgment and decree dated 15.2.2006 and the order dated 18.7.2006, and remanded the suit to the Trial Court. The defendant’s appearance under Order 37 Rule 4 is deemed to have been entered on 8.1.2007. The plaintiff is directed to serve summons for judgment in the prescribed manner within the stipulated period. The defendant may then apply for leave to defend, which the Trial Court shall consider in accordance with law. No costs were awarded. This decision directly affects the parties by reinstating the defendant’s opportunity to defend the suit but does not establish new precedent beyond clarifying the application of Order 37 Rule 4 in cases of defective service.

Show all summary ...

T.S Thakur, J. (Oral)— This appeal arises out of a judgment and decree dated 15.2.2006 passed by the Additional District Judge, Delhi in a suit under Order 37 of the CPC for recovery of a sum of Rs. 6,72,000/- and an order dated 18.7.2006 passed under Order 37 Rule 4 of the CPC declining to set aside the said decree.

2. The plaintiff respondent claimed a decree for a sum of Rs. 6,72,000/- with interest @ 12% p.a in a suit under Order 37 of the CPC filed against the defendant-appellant. The defendant, it appears, was served by publication of a notice in “Statesman” in its issue dated 22.12.2005 Since the defendant did not enter appearance within the stipulated period of 10 days as required under Order 37 Rule 2(3) of the CPC, the Trial Court proceeded to decree the suit in terms of judgment and decree dated 15.2.2006 treating the averments made in the plaint to be admitted. The defendant, thereafter, made an application under Rule 4 of Order 37 of the CPC for setting aside the aforementioned judgment and decree on the ground that service of summons upon him was not in accordance with law. Relying upon the decision of this Court in Hans Raj…Plaintiff v. Lakhi Ram…Defendant, 114 (2004) DLT 264, it was contended by the defendant before the Trial Court that service by publication was not complete in a suit under Order 37 unless a copy of the plaint was also published along with the summons. That contention found favour with the Trial Court, who recorded a clear finding to the effect that service of summons upon the defendant-appellant was not in accordance with law. Having said so, the Trial Court proceeded to hold that the decree passed by it could not be set aside as the defendant-appellant had not raised any triable issue upon which he could claim the leave to defend the suit. The defendants' application under Order 37 Rule 4 was on that finding dismissed by the Court below by its order dated 18.7.2006 The appellant has, as noticed earlier, appealed to this Court against the aforementioned two judgments and orders.

3. We have heard the learned Counsel for the parties at some length and perused the orders under challenge.

4. The finding recorded by the Trial Court that the service effected upon the defendant-appellant herein was not in accordance with law has not been assailed before us by the plaintiff-respondent. That being so, the only question that falls for our consideration is whether the Trial Court was justified in refusing to exercise its powers under Order 37 Rule 4 of CPC even after it came to the conclusion that the defendant had not been properly served. The Trial Court has, as noticed above, declined to invoke its powers on the ground that the defendant-appellant had not raised any triable issue. It has, in support of that line of reasoning, relied upon a decision of the Supreme Court in Rajni v. Suresh, (2003) 5 SCC 315 : AIR 2003 SC 1322. We have gone through the said decision but find it difficult to hold that the same interprets the provision of Order 37 Rule 4 in the manner understood by the Trial Court. That was a case in which the defendant was served by registered A.D whereafter an application under Order 37 Rule 4 of the CPC was filed seeking an order setting aside the ex parte decree. This application was dismissed by the Trial Court on the ground that the same did not disclose any special circumstance to warrant an order under Rule 4 of Order 37 of CPC. The High Court before whom the said order was challenged also agreed with the Trial Court and dismissed the revision petition filed against the said order. In a further appeal before the Supreme Court, Their Lordships held that non-service of summons will undoubtedly be a special circumstance within the meaning of Rule 4 of Order 37 of CPC. Having said so, Their Lordships also observed that if in an application, more than one relief could be granted by the Court, all such reliefs must be claimed by the party concerned. The Court declared that it was impermissible to claim such reliefs in successive petitions as it would be contrary to the letter and spirit of the provision. The Court observed:

“Where on an application, more than one among the specified reliefs may be granted by the Court all such reliefs must be claimed in one application. It is not permissible to claim such reliefs in successive petitions as it would be contrary to the letter and spirit of the provision. That is why where an application under Rule 4 of Order 37 is filed to set aside a decree either because the defendant did not appear in response to summons and limitation expired, or having appeared, did not apply for leave to defend this suit in the prescribed period, the Court is empowered to grant leave to defendant to appear to the summons and to defend the suit in the same application. It is, therefore, not enough for the defendant to show special circumstances which prevented him from appearing or applying for leave to defend, he has also to show by affidavit or otherwise, facts which would entitle him leave to defend the suit. In this respect, Rule 4 Order 37 is different from Rule 13 of Order 9.”

5. It is evident from the above that the situations in which the law expects the party concerned to seek all the reliefs available to it have been limited to only two classes of cases viz. one where the defendant did not appear in response to summons and the period of limitation for doing so expired and the second where having appeared, the defendant did not pray for any leave to defend the suit within the prescribed period. In either of these cases, the Court could grant leave to the defendant to appear in response to the summons and to defend the suit in the same application which ought to raise triable issues to justify grant of leave. That is not, however, the position before us. We are dealing with a case where the service of summons upon the defendant was itself defective. In such a case, the Court passing an ex parte decree can and is indeed bound by law and equity both to set aside the decree passed by it. It would be unnecessary in any such case for the defendant to go a step further and not only establish that he had not been served with summons but also that he had a triable issue to raise in the suit. The occasion for raising a triable issue would arise only if the ex parte decree is first set aside and the defendant relegated back to the position where he can make an application for grant of leave to defend. It would be premature to require the defendant to show whether or not he has a triable issue to raise at a stage at which he was yet to get rid of the ex parte decree. That is precisely what the Trial Court appears to have done in the present case. Instead of invoking its powers under Order 37 Rule 4 of the CPC and setting aside the ex parte decree, the Court appears to have prematurely demanded the existence of triable issues. That approach was not in our view legally correct and has resulted in miscarriage of justice.

6. In the result, we allow this appeal, set aside the impugned judgment and decree dated 15.2.2006 and order 18.7.2006 and remand the suit back to the Trial Court with the direction that the appearance entered by the defendant along with the suit under Order 37 Rule 4 shall be deemed to have been entered on 8.1.2007 with liberty to the plaintiff-respondent to serve a summon for judgment in the prescribed manner within the period stipulated for the purpose under Order 37 Rule 3(4). Upon service of any such summons, the defendant shall be free to make an application seeking leave to defend the suit which the Trial Court shall examine and dispose of in accordance with law. Parties are directed to appear before the Trial Court on 8.1.2007

7. No costs.

Appeal allowed.