- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Desh Raj Singh v. Triveni Engineering & Industries Ltd. & Anr.
Summary of Opinion — Civil Revision Petition under Section 115 CPC
Factual and Procedural Background
This Civil Revision Petition was filed under Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure against the order dated 8.11.2005 passed by the Civil Judge, Delhi and the order dated 19.12.2005 passed by the Additional District Judge, Delhi in execution proceedings. The predecessor of respondent No.1 filed a suit against respondent No.2, Sarvan Singh (the father of the objector/petitioner) seeking direction to hand over possession, demolition of unauthorised construction and injunction against further construction. The suit was decreed on 21.2.1989. The judgment debtor (respondent No.2) appealed and the appeal was dismissed on 3.9.1991; a Regular Second Appeal was dismissed on 16.12.1991. The decree-holder then filed application(s) for execution of the decree.
The judgment debtor did not himself raise objections in the execution proceedings; objections were filed by his son (the petitioner/objector) under Section 47 read with Order 21 Rules 97–107, alleging: change of the decree-holder’s name, time-bar of the execution application, that the objector resided in different premises belonging to one Tej Pratap Singh, that the land was leased by the Land & Development Office (L&DO), and that the site plan was not filed. In reply, the decree-holder contended that the objector had no independent status or locus standi to object (the judgment debtor being alive), that identity disputes were self-contradictory, and that the decree-holder’s name change (from Gangeshwar Limited to Trivani Engineering and Industries Limited) was effected under Section 21 of the Companies Act with Central Government approval dated 31.3.2000.
By consent order dated 11.5.2004 the execution Court directed the L&DO to depute an officer to demarcate the suit property and appointed Ms. Nisha Gautam, Advocate, as local commissioner for execution. The local commissioner’s report (submitted 28.8.2004) described the land and found part of it (approximately 4'‑8") belonged to the decree-holder while another part was government land; the judgment debtor admitted some portion belonged to the decree-holder but refused to give possession. The objector filed a Section 151 CPC application on 13.9.2004 seeking to prevent warrants of possession; the execution Court treated this as an attempt to review the consent order and again issued warrants of possession. An appeal against the execution Court’s order was dismissed by the Additional District Judge on 19.12.2005. This civil revision follows.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the objector (the son of the judgment debtor) had locus standi to file objections in the execution proceedings under Section 47 read with Order 21 Rules 97–107 CPC.
- Whether the execution application was barred by limitation (time-bar) as contended by the petitioner/objector.
- Whether there was a bona fide dispute regarding the identity of the suit property sufficient to stall execution.
- Whether the execution Court acted properly in appointing an independent officer from the L&DO and a local commissioner to demarcate and identify the suit property and in issuing warrants of possession thereafter.
- Whether interference under Section 115 CPC with the orders of the execution Court and the Appellate Court was warranted.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's (Objector's) Arguments
- The execution application was barred by time (limitation).
- The decree-holder had changed its name and therefore execution was challenged on identity/representation grounds.
- The objector was residing in premises belonging to Tej Pratap Singh and the decree-holder was not attempting to execute against that property.
- The land underneath the premises had been leased by the Land & Development Office (L&DO), raising questions about ownership and right to execute.
- The site plan of the property was not filed with the execution application, creating an identity dispute.
- The objector sought an order under Section 151 CPC (filed 13.9.2004) praying that warrants of possession not be issued.
Respondents' (Decree-holder's and Caveators') Arguments
- The objector has no independent status in the suit property and therefore lacks locus standi to file objections, particularly while the judgment debtor (his father) is alive.
- The dispute about identity is self-contradictory and unfounded; there is only one relevant property (portion of Property No. 124, Jan Path Lane known as Shanti Niwas), not Windsor Mansion as alleged by the objector.
- The decree-holder’s change of name (from Gangeshwar Limited to Trivani Engineering and Industries Limited) was lawfully effected under Section 21 of the Companies Act and approved by the Central Government (order dated 31.3.2000), supported by a fresh certificate of incorporation.
- The decree-holder was not attempting to execute against the property of Tej Pratap Singh.
- The execution Court had only one property to deal with and the original suit file was destroyed in a fire in the District Court record room; nonetheless the decree-holder identified the property said to be in possession of the judgment debtor.
- The local commissioner’s demarcation and report supported the decree-holder’s claim and showed the judgment debtor’s refusal to hand over possession.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| T. Arivandandam v. Satpal, 1978 Rajdhani Law Reporter (SC) 21 | Expressed the view that courts must use contempt power to deal with litigants who abuse court process and that the law must not permit repetitive, frivolous litigation that undermines the judiciary’s credibility. | The court invoked this authority to underscore that the father-and-son’s conduct (repeated delays and refusal to give possession) warranted decisive action and should not be tolerated. |
| S.P. Chengalvaraya Naidu (dead) by LRs v. Jagannath (dead) by LRs, (1994) 1 SCC 1 : AIR 1994 SC 853 | Affirmed the principle that finality of litigation cannot be abused to perpetrate fraud; a party whose case is based on falsehood has no right to approach the Court and can be summarily thrown out. | The court relied on this precedent to support the finding that the objector and the judgment debtor were indulging in delaying tactics and falsehoods, justifying dismissal of the petition and prompt execution. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court heard counsel for both sides, examined the impugned orders and the record, and reviewed the execution Court’s proceedings, the consent order dated 11.5.2004 (appointing an L&DO officer and a local commissioner), the local commissioner’s report dated 28.8.2004, and the subsequent interlocutory applications and orders.
Key steps in the court’s analysis were:
- The court concluded that the execution application could not be treated as time-barred in effect because it was "practically and in effect" a suit for possession; thus the petitioner’s contention of limitation lacked force.
- On the identity issue, the court found that the lower courts had adequately dealt with the contention and that the decree-holder’s identification of the property (portion of Property No.124, Jan Path Lane known as Shanti Niwas) was not convincingly challenged by the objector.
- The court held that the objector (the son) had no locus standi to file objections: he neither had tenancy nor licensee rights; even tenants or licensees cannot challenge the title of the landlord (citing Section 116 of the Indian Evidence Act as authority for the proposition that a tenant/licensee cannot challenge landlord's title).
- The court accepted the execution Court’s procedure of appointing the L&DO officer and a local commissioner by consent to demarcate and identify the property, and relied upon the local commissioner’s report which found part of the area belonged to the decree-holder and that the judgment debtor refused to hand possession.
- The court characterized the conduct of the judgment debtor and objector as a long-standing pattern of delaying litigation through multiple rounds of appeals and objections (spanning about three decades), amounting to mala fide, vexatious and frivolous tactics potentially involving falsehood and attempts to mislead the courts.
- Relying on precedents from the Supreme Court condemning abuse of process and prolongation of litigation, the court concluded that intervention under Section 115 CPC was not appropriate; rather, the execution Court’s orders should be enforced and execution expedited.
Based on these findings the court directed immediate and concrete execution steps rather than further protracted litigation.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
The court DISMISSED the Civil Revision Petition. The court found the petition to be mala fide, vexatious and frivolous.
Direct Orders and Immediate Consequences:
- The execution Court was directed to expedite execution of the decree, provide police aid to the Court Commissioner or bailiff, oust the judgment debtor and his son (objector) from the unlawful possession, and restore possession to the decree-holder within seven days.
- The petition was dismissed with costs of Rs. 50,000 (Rupees fifty thousand) awarded against the petitioner and in favour of the respondents.
- A copy of this order was directed to be sent to the execution Court.
Broader Implications:
The opinion applies existing Supreme Court principles condemning abuse of process and prolonged litigation. It did not purport to lay down a new legal principle; the decision’s practical effect is to permit immediate execution in this specific factual matrix and to penalize the petitioner for frivolous litigation. No new precedent was announced beyond the application of established authorities to the facts of this case.
Final Disposition: Petition dismissed. (Order: execute decree within seven days; costs Rs.50,000).
1. This Civil Revision Petition has been filed under Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure against the order dated 8.11.2005 passed by Civil Judge, Delhi and the order dated 19.12.2005 passed by Additional District Judge, Delhi, in the execution proceedings. I have heard Mr. R.S Endlaw, learned Counsel for the petitioner and Mr. Sanjeev Anand, learned Counsel for respondents/caveators, on the point of admission, and have gone through the impugned order and the judgment and copies of the documents placed on the file.
2. Briefly the facts are that the predecessor of respondent No. 1 herein filed a suit against respondent No. 2 herein, Sarvan Singh, father of the objector (petitioner herein) for directing respondent No. 2, Sarvan Singh, father, who is alive to hand over the possession, demolish unauthorized construction made by him and further for restraining him (father of objector) from making any further construction in future. The said suit was decreed on 21.2.1989 Respondent No. 2 (father of objector/petitioner herein) filed an appeal which was dismissed on 3.9.1991, then he filed Regular Second Appeal which also was dismissed on 16.12.1991 Thereafter, the decree holder filed an application for execution of the decree.
3. It appears that the judgment debtor did not raise any objections but his son, the petitioner herein, raised objections under Section 47 read with order 21 Rule 97 to 107 alleging that the decree holder had changed his name the application for execution was barred by time, the objector was residing in a different premises belonging to one Tej Pratap Singh, the land underneath the premises has been leased by the L and DO and that the site plan of the property is not filed.
4. In the reply, preliminary objections were raised that the objector has no independent status in the suit property, therefore, he has no locus standi to file the objections, specially, when the judgment debtor is still alive. That the dispute about identity is self-contradictory and the decree holder was not going to execute the decree on the property of Tej Pratap Singh. It is stated by Decree Holder that there is no dispute about the identity of the property, the same is a portion of Property No. 124. Jan path Lane known as Shanti Niwas and is not a portion of Windsor Mansion (as alleged by the objector).
Moreover, the objector was in possession through his father and has to be ejected in execution of the decree. It is submitted that the decree holder is the same entity who had filed the suit, only the name has changed from Gangeshwar Limited to Trivani Engineering and Industries Limited pursuant to a special resolution under Section 21 of the Company Act and after approval of the Central Government vide order dated 31.3.2000 A fresh certificate of incorporation of the change of name has been issued by the authorities and this has been mentioned in para ‘b’ of the execution application. It is also mentioned in the application that the decree holder does not have the site plan of the suit property but there is only one property of the decree holder which is in possession of the judgment debtor. It has been submitted that the original file was destroyed in the District Court in a fire in the record room. The suit property is stated to be on a piece of land measuring 10′ × 10′ (sic) in one corner behind a garage.
5. The chequered history of this case shows how a judgment debtor or his son can prolong the matter for about three decades and the decree holder is not allowed to reap the fruits of the decree in its favour despite the appellate Courts (including the High Court qua judgment debtor) having dismissed the contentions firstly of the judgment debtor and then of his son-objector. After having failed in their repeated efforts to delay the delivery of possession, the judgment debtor and his son also appear to have taken the help of the owner of adjoining building namely. Tej Pratap Singh to file a suit not only against the decree holder but against the objector (petitioner herein) as well obviously, to start the 5th round of litigation.
6. I have gone through the order dated 11.5.2004 passed by the execution Court. It is apparent from the said order that when arguments on the objections were being heard, both the parties agreed that it will be convenient if an independent person from L and DO is appointed to demarcate the suit property and execute the decree. So accordingly, the learned Civil Judge directed the Land and Development Office, Ministry of Rural Development, to depute an officer to demarcate the suit property and identify the same and also appointed an Ms. Nisha Gautam, Advocate as local commissioner for execution of the decree and then warrants of possessions were issued.
7. The Local Commissioner submitted her report to the effect that suit property was found to be 47′-9′ (sic.) in total out of which 43’ 0” (sic.) was the leased portion of the lane and 4′-9″ (sic.) was the service lane area which was unauthorizedly occupied. Part of land i.e, 4′-8″ (sic.) belonged to decree holder and rest i.e 4′-9″ (sic.) was Government land. A shop was existing on the entire land. Above that also there was constructed portion. Though the judgment debtor admitted that some portion belonged to the decree holder but he refused to give possession. In my view this was prima facie contempt of the Court. This report was submitted on 28.8.2004
8. Thereafter the objector moved an application under Section 151, CPC on 13.9.2004 praying that warrants of possession be not issued. The learned Civil Judge opined that a consent order was passed on 11.5.2004 appointing a local commissioner besides an officer of the L&DO to identify the property and the objector was in a way seeking review of the said consent order and the execution Court also referred to order dated 3.9.2004 in which the execution Court has dealt with the report of the local commissioner and observed how the objector was trying to back out from the consent and raised objections repeatedly on one or another pretext to compel the execution Court to go behind the decree, whereas no such objections were taken by the JD even before the higher Courts. The execution Court, therefore, again issued warrants of possession and sought report for 17.9.2004 It seems thereafter the appeal against the execution Court order was filed, which has been dismissed by the Additional District Judge on 19.12.2005 and now this civil revision petition.
9. I have also gone through the order of the Appellate Court. The learned Additional District Judge has once again dealt with all the objections which were raised before the execution Court like the bar of limitation, the identify of the property, the consent order, the second order dated 3.9.2004, vide which contentions of the objector were dismissed by the learned Civil Judge and also referred to the report of Local Commissioner and finally dismissed the appeal.
10. The contention of the learned Counsel for the petitioner that the execution application was barred by time has no force because practically and in effect it was a suit for possession. The matter regarding the identity has been very aptly dealt with by the Courts below. I am of the view that the objector who is son of the judgment debtor has no locus standi at all to file the objections. He neither had any tenancy right nor was he a licensee. Even a tenant or a licensee cannot challenge the title of the landlord (Section 116 of the Indian Evidence Act). If the decree includes the Government land or public passage, the Government authorities will protect their property but the judgment debtor or his son (objector) have no legal right or title in any part of the property. Therefore, they must vacate.
11. In my view, this father and son duo have made a mockery of law and have prolonged the litigation for about three decades because they are in unlawful possession. In fact objector was a total stranger and had started delaying the matter after his father lost the case up to the High Court. All this shows that the objector and the judgment debtor were indulging in delaying tactics based on falsehood and fraud. They have been trying to mislead the trial Court, appellate Court and the execution Court. It appears that the Courts have been very lenient to the judgment debtor and the objector and that is why the objector has dared to file this mala fide, vexatious and frivolous civil revision petition. In a rather similar case in which a father and son were delaying delivery of possession, titled T. Arivandandam V.T v. Satpal, 1978 Rajdhani Law Reporter (SC) 21, the Supreme Court of India opined as under:
“……..The long arm of the law must throttle such litigative caricatures if the confidence and credibility of the community and if the judicature is to survive. The contempt power of the Court is meant for such persons as the present petitioner………”
12. In another matter relating to prolongation of litigation by devious means, the Supreme Court of India in the matter titled S.P Chengalvaraya Naidu (dead) by LRs v. Jagannath (dead) by LRs, (1994) 1 SCC 1 : AIR 1994 SC 853, opined as under:
“The principle of ‘finality of litigation’ cannot be pressed to the extent of such an absurdity that it becomes an engine of fraud in the hands of dishonest litigants. The Courts of law are meant for imparting justice between the parties. One who comes to the Court, must come with clean hands. We are constrained to say that more often than not, process of the Court is being abused. Property-ghabbers, tax-evaders, bank loan dodgers and other unscrupulous persons from all walks of life find the Court process a convenient lever to retain the illegal gains indefinitely. We have no hesitation to say that a person whose case is based on falsehood, has no right to approach the Court. He can be summarily thrown out at any stage of the litigation.”
13. Considering all the facts and circumstances, I do not find it a fit case for interference under section 115 of the cpc. The execution Court is directed to expedite execution, provide police aid to the Court Commissioner or bailiff and oust the judgment debtor and his son (objector) from the unlawful possession and restore possession to the decree holder within seven days. The petition being mala fide, vexatious and frivolous is dismissed with Rs. 50,000/- (Rupees fifty thousand) as costs against the petitioner and in favour of the respondents.
14. Copy of this order be sent to the execution Court.
Petition dismissed.
Alert