- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Continental And Eastern Agencies v. Coal India Limited
Factual and Procedural Background
This is a suit by an Indian agent (the plaintiff) of an Italian company (defendant No. 3) for recovery of Rs. 5,89,434 as agency commission. Defendant No. 1 is a Public Sector Undertaking and a unit of defendant No. 2. Defendant No. 1 floated a global tender on 24-9-1986 for two Hydraulic Crankshaft Grinding Machines; the plaintiff placed an order on 22-9-1986. The plaintiff had earlier supplied four similar machines (order dated 5-2-1985).
The plaintiff's original commission offer was 15% of FOB value. By letters in March and August 1987 the plaintiff offered a 5% discount on commission subject to conditions (notably that the entire order be placed on the plaintiff and that 100% commission be paid on presentation of shipping documents). Defendant No. 1 placed an order dated 25-4-1988 addressed to defendant No. 3 (for two machines) and subsequently issued an amendment dated 6-5-1988 which included an installation clause making the Indian agent responsible for installation after foundations and infrastructure were ready so machines could be commissioned within 60 days of arrival at site.
The plaintiff alleges that defendant No. 1 unilaterally reduced commission from 15% to 10% although the discount of 5% applied only if four machines were ordered; the plaintiff protested and accepted the order on 17-5-1988 except the discount clause. Defendant No. 1 established a Letter of Credit in favour of defendant No. 3 and two machines were shipped on 9-1-1989. The machinery was received at site by defendants on or before 30-8-1989 (acknowledgments issued).
The plaintiff repeatedly requested site readiness to enable commissioning. The plaintiff served a legal notice dated 8-4-1989 demanding 15% commission; later correspondence (including a letter of 8/9-8-1991 by defendant No. 1) acknowledged prolonged site non-readiness and defendant No. 2 informed the plaintiff (29/30-8-1991) that balance 10% had been released to the principal and that agency commission would be released on receipt of an excavation certificate. The plaintiff inspected the site in 1992 and alleged the machines had become defective due to exposure.
Procedurally, the court framed issues by order dated 7-2-1996 (nine issues). Both parties filed affidavits and led evidence: the plaintiff examined one witness (a partner of the plaintiff firm) and produced numerous documentary exhibits; the defendants examined one witness (their Commercial Manager) and produced documents and additional communications. The court heard contentions on jurisdiction, authority to institute suit, privity, the conditionality of commission on commissioning, site readiness, breach and entitlement to commission.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether this Court has the territorial jurisdiction to try and entertain the suit?
- Whether the plaintiff has been instituted, signed and verified by a duly authorised person?
- Whether the plaintiff is entitled to receive Rs. 4,39,466.20 being 15% agency commission or any lesser amount?
- Whether the plaintiff is entitled to interest on Rs. 4,39,466.20 or any lesser amount and if so at what rate and period thereof?
- Whether the plaintiff agreed to give discount of 5% and charge 10% commission payable after commissioning of machine?
- Whether the discount of 5% was available only on conditions set out in the plaintiff's letters dated 7-3-1987 and 14-8-1987 being fulfilled?
- Whether the plaintiff is not entitled to any commission due to its breaches and failure to perform its obligations as set out in the written statement?
- Whether the defendants Nos. 1 and 2 had the site ready for installation of the equipment/machinery in terms of amendment to the contract dated 6-5-1988?
- Relief.
Arguments of the Parties
Plaintiff's Arguments
- The plaintiff asserted entitlement to agency commission at the rate originally offered (15%) and protested the unilateral reduction to 10% by defendant No. 1; the plaintiff accepted the order except the discount clause (letter dated 17-5-1988).
- The plaintiff maintained that the discount of 5% applied only where four machines were ordered and was not applicable to the two-machine order placed.
- The plaintiff alleged repeated requests to defendants for site readiness; despite acknowledgments of machine receipt, the site was not made ready and therefore the plaintiff could not commission the machines.
- The plaintiff pointed to correspondence (including Ex. P-4, the defendants' letter of 8/9-8-1991) showing defendants acknowledged that if sites were not ready for years, the Indian agent should not suffer non-payment—thus shifting blame for non-commissioning to defendants.
- The plaintiff relied on documentary evidence and notices (legal notice dated 8-4-1989 and follow-up letters) to show attempts to secure payment and to prompt commissioning.
Defendants' Arguments
- Defendants challenged the territorial jurisdiction of the court, contending the contract was entered into and communicated at Calcutta and relevant business divisions and registered offices were in Calcutta.
- Defendants contended that the plaintiff had offered a discount of 5% on FOB price (in their view applicable) and that the purchase order expressly stated the terms of discount and that agency commission was payable only after commissioning by the plaintiff.
- Defendants alleged that the plaintiff failed to perform its obligations (for example, non-cooperation in supplying site drawings in time) and that delay in site preparation and eventual spoiling of machines was attributable to the plaintiff.
- On the question of authority to sue, defendants relied on precedent under Section 69 of the Partnership Act to argue that a person who is not a partner or duly authorised cannot file suit on behalf of the firm.
- Defendants produced multiple letters asserting non-commissioning by the plaintiff and relied on those communications to show plaintiff's culpability or non-performance.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Gandhi and Company v. Krishna Glass Private Limited, AIR 1987 Bombay 348 | The proposition (relying on Section 69 of the Partnership Act) that a suit on behalf of a firm cannot be filed by a person who is neither a partner nor a duly authorised person. | The court considered this authority when addressing whether the person who signed, verified and instituted the suit was duly authorised. The court examined Ex. P-6 showing the plaintiff firm's registration and found Mr. V. P. Verma to be Karta of a Hindu Undivided Family and a partner/duly authorised person for instituting the suit; accordingly the court rejected the defendants' objection and decided the issue in favour of the plaintiff. |
| Mohana Krishnan v. Chiman Lal and Company, AIR 1960 Madras 452 | Principle: personal liability for commission is a question of fact; whether contract gives rise to personal liability depends on whether there is privity between the parties or a specific contractual term imposing such liability. | The court considered this ratio in relation to defendants' contention that there was no privity between the plaintiff and defendants Nos. 1 and 2 (because the plaintiff had an independent contract with defendant No. 3). The court held that Mohana Krishnan did not apply on the facts: the purchase order evidenced direct deduction of 10% FOB from the price and required payment to the Indian agent, thereby establishing privity and liability of defendants Nos. 1 and 2 to the plaintiff. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court addressed the framed issues sequentially and applied statutory provisions, documentary evidence and the parties' admissions:
- Territorial jurisdiction (Issue No. 1): The court relied on Section 20 of the Code of Civil Procedure (cause of action wholly or in part arising within the local limits) and found that key parts of the cause of action arose in Delhi because the contract was communicated to the plaintiff in Delhi and payment of commission was to be made at Delhi. The court held that Section 20(c) permits suit where part of the cause of action arises and that it would be unduly burdensome to require the plaintiff to sue in Calcutta. Result: issue decided for the plaintiff.
- Authority to institute suit (Issue No. 2): The defendants argued the signatory was not a partner/duly authorised and relied on authority under Section 69 of the Partnership Act. The court examined the registration evidence (Ex. P-6) and communications showing that Mr. V. P. Verma acted as the contact and negotiator; finding him to be Karta of a Hindu Undivided Family and thereby a duly authorised person for the firm, the court decided the issue in favour of the plaintiff.
- Privity and entitlement to commission; commissioning condition (Issues Nos. 3, 6, 7 and 8): The defendants argued there was no privity between plaintiff and defendants Nos. 1 and 2 because the plaintiff had a separate contract with defendant No. 3 and that commission was payable only after commissioning (which did not occur). The court considered the precedent Mohana Krishnan but concluded the precedent did not apply on the facts. The court found that the purchase order showed a deduction of 10% of FOB from the price paid by defendants to defendant No. 3 and the order required payment directly to the Indian agent; this fact, together with the order terms, established privity between the plaintiff and defendants Nos. 1 and 2.
- On the commissioning condition, the court closely scrutinised the amendment (Ex. of 6-5-1988) which required the consignee to ensure site readiness and infrastructure so the machine could be commissioned within 60 days of arrival. The court observed (and relied on) evidence and correspondence showing repeated requests by the plaintiff to the defendants to make the site ready, and a defendant letter (Ex. P-4, 8/9-8-1991) acknowledging that if sites remained unready for years the Indian agent should not thereby suffer non-payment. The court placed the onus on defendants to prove that the sites had been made ready; it found the defendants had not discharged that burden and that the failure to commission resulted from defendants' failure to keep the sites ready.
- Quantum and period: The court concluded the plaintiff was entitled to commission at the rate of 10% (not 15%) for the relevant period identified. It determined entitlement to commission at 10% from 9-8-1991 until 2-4-1993 (the date of filing of the suit) and calculated the commission due as Rs. 2,92,977.46.
- Interest and decree: On the basis of the above findings, the court decreed the suit for Rs. 2,92,977.46 together with pendente lite and future interest at 9% per annum with effect from 1-4-1993 until realisation.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The suit is decreed in favour of the plaintiff for Rs. 2,92,977.46, together with pendente lite and future interest at the rate of 9% per annum from 1-4-1993 until realisation.
Implications:
- The direct practical effect is that the plaintiff obtains a monetary decree in the specified amount and interest against the defendants; the Decree Sheet was to be drawn accordingly and the suit is decreed.
- The court applied established doctrines (territorial jurisdiction under Section 20 CPC; partnership authority principles under Section 69/precedent; and principles governing privity and personal liability for commission) to the facts without announcing novel legal principles. No broader new precedent is articulated by the opinion beyond the application of these existing principles to the specific factual matrix.
Suit decreed.
This is a suit for recovery of Rs. 5,89,434/- towards agency commission. Plaintiff is agent of defendant No. 3, an Italian company, in India. Defendant No. 1 is a Public Sector Undertaking and is a unit of defendant No. 2. Brief resume of facts pleaded by the plaintiff in respect of its claim is like this :—
2. Defendant No. 1 floated a global tender for purchase of two Hydraulic Crankshaft Grinding Machines on 24-9-1986. Plaintiff gave an order dated 22-9-1986 for two machines. Earlier plaintiff had supplied four similar machines to defendant No. 1 vide their order dated 5-2-1985. Later defendant No. 1 sought some clarifications and also the amendment in terms if four machines were purchased instead of two.
3. In original offer the plaintiff had offered that agency commission would be 15% of FOB value of order. By letter dated 7-3-1987, plaintiff offered discount of 5% on commission if entire order was placed on plaintiff and 100% commission was paid on receipt of shipping documents. By letter dated 10-8-1987, defendant No. 1 wrote to plaintiff that requirement was raised to four Grinder Machines, and the plaintiff should submit reduced price bid accordingly. By letter dated 14-8-1987 plaintiff did the needful and informed defendant No. 1 that price of machine will be same and be multiplied by four in place of two and discount of 5% on agency commission of 15% would be valid if (i) entire order is placed on plaintiff and (ii) 100% agency commission released on presentation of shipping documents. By letter dated 9-11-1987, defendant No. 3 informed defendant No. 1 that plaintiff would not accept any amount less than already offered by them, as their work involved lot of expenditure. Defendant No. 1 thereupon placed order dated 25-4-1988 addressed to defendant No. 3 on plaintiff at Delhi who in turn forwarded it to defendant No. 3 at Italy only for two machines. An amendment dated 6-5-1988 was issued by defendant No. 1 to this order. Clause 2 of amendment was as follows :—
“B. Installation — Indian Agent of the supplier will instal and demonstrate the equipment at site free of cost after foundations are laid, equipment placed on foundation electrical and air liners brought to the site by the consignee. The consignee however, will ensure readiness of the infrastructure well in advance so that the machine can be commissioned within 60 days for the date of the arrival at project site.
4. In the order placed, defendant No. 1 unilaterally reduced the commission payable to plaintiff from 15% to 10% of FOB value, even though discount of 5% was offered only as quantity discount on four machines and was not applicable to two machines only. Plaintiff protested against this unilateral action of defendant No. 1. Plaintiff never consented to 5% discount for only two machines. By letter dated 17-5-1988 plaintiff accepted the order at Delhi with the exception of the discount clause.
5. The defendant did not issue any amendment but acted on the plaintiffs letter allowing 5% discount and established Letter of Credit in favour of defendant No. 3. Two machines were shipped on 9-1-1989 by the foreign seller. The complete machinery was received by defendant Nos. 1 and 2 at site on or before 30-8-1989 and in this respect they issued acknowledgments. Thereafter plaintiff repeatedly wrote to defendant Nos. 1 and 2 asking for readiness of site to enable plaintiff to commission the machines. Since there was no response, plaintiff served legal notice dated 8-4-1989 on defendant Nos. 1 and 2 demanding 15% commission. It was also pointed out in the notice that the site was not made ready even though two years had passed since the receipt of the machines. No reply was sent by the defendants but telegram was received from them to defer the legal action as matter was being looked into. Plaintiff deferred legal action and again sent letter dated 3-8-1991 to defendant Nos. 1 and 2 pointing out that site was not made ready nor plaintiffs commission was being released.
6. Defendant No. 1 in letter dated 8/9-8-1991 wrote to defendant No. 2 that if the sites do not get ready for number of years, the plaintiff cannot suffer for non payment of agency commission. In response defendant No. 2 wrote on 29/30-8-1991 to plaintiff that balance 10% had been already released to the principal and agency commission will be released on receipt of certificate from Excavation Department. By letter dated 29-11-1991 plaintiff again sought confirmation that the site had been made ready or not. Thereafter, on verbal message of defendants, plaintiff again visited site on 2-12-1992 to install the machines and found that site was still not ready. In Feb. 1992 plaintiff again visited the site and found the site was not ready and machines had become useless due to exposure to nature. This was confirmed by plaintiff from site camp itself by detailed letter dated 4-2-1992.
7. Besides challenging the territorial jurisdiction of this Court on the premise that contract between the parties was entered into and communicated at Calcutta, defendant Nos. 1 and 2 have in their common written statement taken the following defence:—
“The plaintiff by letter dated 22-9-1986, had offered to allow discount of 5% on the FOB price on placement of order for two machines. After correspondence between the parties, the defendant No. 1 in the order dated 25-4-1988 had specifically stated the term of the discount. Even otherwise, there was no such condition that the said discount would be payable only if four machines are purchased. In the purchase order dated 25-4-1988 issued by defendant No. 1, it was specifically mentioned that the Agency Commission shall be payable after commissioning is completed by the plaintiff and hence there was no question for lease of 100% Agency Commission to the plaintiff just on receipt of the shipping documents. There was delay in the preparation of the site because of the non-cooperation on the part of the plaintiff especially in supplying the Drawings of the site, which, if supplied in time would have helped the defendants Nos. 1 and 2 in preparation of the foundation work and which ultimately resulted in the spoiling of the machines. In fact the defendants Nos. 1 and 2 have been put to heavy losses because of the non-commissioning of the machines. The plaintiff is not entitled to any agency commission because the part of the contract regarding the commission of the machines has not been performed by them. The commissioning of the machines by the plaintiff was a condition precedent for the payment of the agency commission to the Plaintiff. As per the terms of the order dated 25-4-1988 agency commission is payable after commissioning of the equipment is completed by the plaintiff. Thus, no commission is due and payable to the plaintiff and such demand is totally devoid of any substance.”
8. In the replication, the averments made in the plaint were reiterated by the plaintiff.
9. Vide order dated 7-2-1996 following issues were framed :—
1. Whether this Court has the territorial jurisdiction to try and entertain the suit? OPP
2. Whether the plaintiff has been instituted, signed and verified by a duly authorised person ? OPP
3. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to receive Rs. 4,39,466.20 being 15% agency commission or any lesser amount ? OPP
4. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to interest on Rs. 4,39,466.20 or any lesser amount and if so at what rate and period thereof ? OPP
5. Whether the plaintiff agreed to give discount of 5% and charge 10% commission payable after commissioning of machine ? OPD
6. Whether the discount of 5% was available only on conditions set out in the plaintiffs letter 7-3-1987 and 14-8-1987 being fulfilled ? OPD
7. Whether the plaintiff is not entitled to any commission due to its breaches and failure to perform its obligations as set out in para 3(c) of the preliminary objection and 23 and 24 of the written statement on merits ? OPD.
8. Whether the defendants Nos. 1 and 2 had the site ready for installation of the equipment/machinery in terms of amendment to the contract dated 6-5-1988 ? OPD
9. Relief.
10. Both the parties filed affidavits by way of evidence. Plaintiff examined the solitary witness who was the partner of the plaintiff and has been visiting the site. Similarly both the defendants examined one witness who is their Commercial Manager is acquainted with the commercial side of the transaction.
11. P.W 1 at the outside denied that contract was executed at Calcutta as according to him defendant No. 1 after signing the said contract at Calcutta had forwarded the same at Delhi and he transmitted the same to defendant No. 3 for signatures to Italy and after receiving back the same duly signed by defendant 3 again sent it back to defendants Nos. 1 and 2. According to him, letter of credit was opened in the name of defendant No. 3 by him and he had never informed defendant No. 3 about the non-acceptance of the terms by defendants Nos. 1 and 2 regarding discount on agency commission. However, he could not recollect whether he had seen the letter dated 23-9-1987 regarding change in condition relating to agency commission payable to the plaintiff, though he volunteered that this letter was prior to the execution of contract (Exhibit P-2) as he had entered into agency commission with defendant No. 3 much prior to the said contract. However, he failed to produce any agreement entered into with defendant No. 3. He denied the suggestion whether plaintiff was called upon by defendants Nos. 1 and 2 to install machinery at the project site. Rather sites were not made ready by defendants Nos. 1 and 2 so as to facilitate the plaintiff to install and commission the machinery. He also denied, the suggestion that he never visited the site. According to him he had informed defendants Nos. 1 and 2 in writing about not making the sites available. He also denied that he never gave measurement of basement in writing for construction of foundation for installing the machines.
12. Various documents and letters exchanged between the parties were proved by this witness which are as under :—
(i) Exhibit P1 is the letter dated 10-8-1987 whereby defendant No. 1 wrote to plaintiff that their requirements of machines had been enhanced to 4 nos. and further requested the plaintiff to submit its bid for reduced price.
(ii) Exhibit P-2 is the formal order dated 25-4-1988 placed by defendant No. 1 to defendant No. 3 for two machines.
(iii) Exhibit P-3 is the letter/amendment dated 6-5-1988 to the purchase order in which it was stated that the plaintiff shall install the equipments at site free of cost after foundations were laid, equipment placed etc. and that consignee will ensure readiness of the infrastructure well in advance so that machines could be commissioned within 60 days from the date of its arrival at project site.
(iv) Exhibit P-5 is the letter dated 3-8-1991 sent by defendant No. 1 to defendant No. 2 to the effect that site for erection of the machinery had not been made ready. Copy of this letter was sent to the plaintiff also.
(v) Exhibit P-5 is the letter dated 29/30-8-1991 written by defendant No. 2 to the plaintiff that balance 10% had already been released but agency commission of the plaintiff would be payable on receipt of certificate from excavation department.
(vi) Exhibit P-6 is the certified copy of registration of the plaintiff firm.
(vii) Exhibit P-7 is the letter dated 26-2-1987 wherein defendant No. 3 had certified that agency commission of 15% was payable to the plaintiff.
(viii) Exhibit P-8 is the plaintiffs letter dated 7-3-1987 to defendant No. 1 stating the terms of agency commission payable to commission.
(ix) Exhibit P-9 is the letter dated 14-8-1987 written by plaintiff to defendant No. 1 wherein plaintiff again reiterated discount on agency commission.
(x) Exhibit P-10 is the plaintiff's letter dated 3-5-1988 to defendant No. 1 again acknowledging receipt of letter including pro forma invoice for issue of separate order for additional machines. This document is the document of defendant No. 1 which was initially marked as D-4.
(xi) Exhibit P-11 is again plaintiffs letter dated 17-5-1988 regarding 15% agency commission.
(xii) Exhibit P-12 is the letter dated 10-1-1989 regarding shipment of machines.
(xiii) Exhibit P-13 is the plaintiffs letter dated 5-6-1989 seeking confirmation and readiness of site to enable commission of machines.
(xiv) Exhibit P-14 is the acknowledgment by defendant No. 2 on receipt of machines dated 6-9-1989.
(xv) Exhibit P-15 is again acknowledgment on receipt of machines by defendant No. 2 dated 27/29-10-1990.
(xvi) Exhibit P-16 is another receipt dated 19-11-1990 by defendant No. 2 on receipt of machines.
(xvii) Exhibit P-17 is the confirmation dated 29-11-1990 issued by defendant No. 2.
(xviii) Exhibit P-18 is the letter dated 21/22-12-1990 by defendant No. 1 to defendant No. 2 regarding receipt of machine at site.
(xix) Exhibit P-19 is plaintiffs letter dated 22-3-1990 to defendant No. 2 including receipt of machines issued.
(xx) Exhibit P-20 is the legal notice dated 8-4-1991 served on defendants Nos. 1 and 2 for remaining 15% commission and interest @ 24%.
(xxi) Exhibit P-21 is the copy of reminder notice.
(xxii) Exhibit P-22 is plaintiff's registered letter dated 3-8-1991 to defendant No. 1 for release of agency commission pointing out that site was not made ready.
(xxiii) Exhibit P-23 is the letter dated 29-11-1991 thereby plaintiff again sought confirmation whether suit had been ready or not.
(xxiv) Exhibit P-24 is plaintiff letter dated 4-2-1992 to defendant No. 2 that site was not ready.
(xxv) Exhibit P-25 is the letter dated 8-12-1992 from plaintiff to defendant No. 2 after again inspecting the machines and giving inspection report pointing out that machines have become defective due to exposure to nature.
(xxvi) Exhibit P-26 is the telex from defendant No. 3 to defendant No. 1 with copy to plaintiff pointing out that for repair of machines, machines have to be sent to Italy.
(xxvii) Exhibit P-27 is the letter from defendant No. 2 dated 12/16-4-1994 to plaintiff inviting plaintiff to settle the matter without prejudice to the rights and contentions of the parties in the present suit.
(xxviii) Exhibit P-28 is the letter of defendant No. 1 to plaintiff alleging that machines were not being installed.
(xxix) Exhibit P-29 is the plaintiffs letter to defendants in reply to above letter.
(xxx) Exhibit P-30 is the letter dated 20-4-1993 from plaintiff to defendant No. 3 with copy to defendant No. 1 pointing out the state of machinery and that it was not possible to commission the machines at that stage without visit of Engineers from Italy.
(xxxi) Exhibit P-31 is the notice served by plaintiff on the defendants along with postal receipts Exhibits P-32 and P-33.
13. Defendants witness produced and proved the following documents :—
i) Exhibit DW 1.A is the original copy of letter dated 22-9-1986.
ii) Exhibit DW 1.B is the original formal order dated 25-4-1988 from defendant No. 1.
iii) Exhibit DW 1.C is the original letter dated 6-5-1988 from defendant No. 1 to defendant No. 3 which is the amendment of the original order.
iv) Exhibit DW 1.D is the letter dated 17-5-1988 from plaintiff to defendant No. 1 wherein plaintiff stated that the amendment carried out by defendant No. 1 was acceptable to the plaintiff.
v) Exhibit DW 1.E is the original telex dated 19-5-1998 from defendant No. 3 to defendant No. 1.
vi) Exhibit DW 1.F is the original letter dated 9-14/6-1988 whereby defendant No. 1 informed defendant No. 3 about the amendment carried in the order and that other terms and conditions of the above order would remain unaltered.
vii) Exhibit DW 1.G is the original telex copy of the letter dated 30-31/1-1989 from defendant No. 1 to plaintiff.
viii) Exhibit DW 1.I is the carbon copy of letter dated 7-1-1992 by defendant No. 1 to plaintiff with regard to commission of machines.
ix) Exhibit DW 1.J is the carbon copy of letter dated 9-2-1993 from defendant No. 1 to plaintiff regarding commission of machines.
x) Exhibit DW 1.K is the telex dated 16-3-1993.
xi) Exhibit DW 1.L is the carbon copy of letter dated 2-4-1993 from defendant No. 1 to plaintiff for commission of machines.
xii) Exhibit DW 1.M is the carbon copy of letter dated 12-4-1993 from defendant No. 1 to the plaintiff.
xiii) Exhibit DW 1.N is the carbon copy of the letter dated 16/19-4-1993 from defendant No. 2 to defendant No. 1.
xiv) Exhibit DW 1.O is the original copy of letter dated 9-6-1993 from defendant No. 1 to defendant No. 3 complaining about the non-commissioning of the machines by the plaintiff.
14. Besides the aforesaid documents, the defendant has also produced the copies of letters sent by the defendant to the plaintiff regarding non-commissioning of the machinery. These are letters dated 23-6-88, 24-10-88, 29-6-89, 1-3-93 and 28-5-94. These letters have been filed by separate list and could not be exhibited. However, these are the receipt of communications which have not been denied by the plaintiff and thus the same shall be read in evidence as Ex. DX 1 to DX 5.
ISSUE NO. 1
15. The contention of the learned counsel for the defendant that the contract between the parties was entered into and communicated at Calcutta and the defendants No. 1 and 2 have their registered office at Calcutta and the whole transaction relates to Material and Management Division of Defendant Nos. 1 and 2 which is situated at Calcutta and therefore, this Court has no territorial jurisdiction, is completely devoid of merit. Section 20 of the Code of Civil Procedure relates to territorial jurisdiction of Courts and relevant clause/sub-section reads as under :—
“That further suit shall be instituted in Court within the local limits of whose jurisdiction the cause of action wholly or in part arises”.
16. Admittedly, the contract was communicated to the plaintiff at Delhi and payment of the commission to the plaintiff was to be made at Delhi. To expect the plaintiff to go to Calcutta to claim his commission is not the intention of the provisions of Section 20 of the Code of Civil Procedure. It would be too much and highly jeopardic to ask the plaintiff to file the suit at Calcutta as Section 20(C) entitles a person to sue when part of cause of action arises. In the instant case the part of cause of action has arisen in Delhi inasmuch as the contract was communicated at Delhi and payment of commission was also payable at Delhi. As such the issue is decided in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendants.
ISSUE NO. 2
17. The only objection raised by the defendant in this regard is that the plaintiff is a registered partnership firm and the person who has signed, verified and instituted the suit was not the partner of the firm at the relevant time nor was he authorised by the partnership firm to sign, verify and institute the suit. In support of the proposition that only partner has an authority to sign, verify and institute the suit, learned counsel has placed reliance upon Gandhi and Company v. Krishna Glass Private Limited, AIR 1987 Bombay 348 wherein it has been held that Section 69 of the Partnership Act debars filing of the suit on behalf of the firm by the person who is neither one of its partners nor the duly authorized person. As Ex. P 6 itself shows that Mr. V. P. Verma in his individual capacity was not shown partner of the firm but as Karta of Hindu Undivided Family he was partner of the firm and therefore duly authorized person to institute the suit. Moreover, the entire communication between defendants Nos. 1 and 2 was exchanged between and directed to V.P Verma and it was through him that all negotiations took place and now to say that he is not duly authorized person on behalf of the plaintiff firm is not correct and is like taking a somersault. Mr. V.P Verma has the authority to sign, verify and institute the suit and as a consequence issue is decided in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant.
ISSUES NO. 3, 6, 7 and 8
18. The main plank of the contention of the learned counsel for the defendant is that there was no privity of contract between the plaintiff and defendants Nos. 1 and 2 regarding the payment of commission as the plaintiff has admitted in cross-examination that for payment of commission he has independent contract with defendant No. 3 . In support of its contention the learned counsel has relied upon Mohana Krishnan v. Chiman Lal and Company, AIR 1960 Madras 452 wherein it was held :—
“That for the personal liability which is the question of fact in each case whether the contract is between the principal and the foreign principal directly or whether the home agent of the foreign principal have entered in the contract and if he has is personally liable, is exempted under the general principle, unless there is a specific term of the contract stipulating such a liability.”
19. However, I am afraid the ratio of the aforesaid authority does not attract in the given facts of the case. Since the order was placed for supply of machines vide 10% of the FOB price of the machines was deducted by defendant No. 1 from the price of machines given to defendant No. 3 and in that order defendant No. 1 was required to pay directly to Indian agent and, therefore, the privity of contract between the plaintiff and defendants Nos. 1 and 2 flows from the term of the order itself coupled with the actual deduction of 10% of F.O.B from the price of machines by defendants Nos. 1 and 2 while forwarding the price thereof to defendant No. 3.
20. The next contention of the learned counsel is with regard to commissioning of the machines as the payment of the commission under the contract was subject to the commissioning of the machines and since in the instant case, the machines were not commissioned, the plaintiff was not entitled for the commission even in the face of amendment under the contract by way of Clause 2. In this regard, the learned counsel has placed reliance upon series of letters sent by defendants Nos. 1 and 2 referred above calling upon the plaintiff to commission the machines but to no avail.
21. Learned counsel for the plaintiff has met the aforesaid contention successfully by contending that if the contract is read with amendment then the site for inspection of machines was to be kept ready by the consignee i.e defendant No. 2 in advance along with the infrastructure etc. and in this regard the plaintiff had sent large number of letters to defendant No. 2 for making the site ready but defendant No. 2 did not pay any heed and last such communication was dated 8/9-8-91 (Ex. P 4) wherein defendant No. 1 admitted that if the sites were not ready for number of years, the Indian Agent cannot suffer for non-payment of agency commission. This document proved to be proverbial last straw on the back of the camel showing that the blame for not keeping the site ready lay at the door of defendant No. 2 alone and as such the plaintiff cannot be saddled with the liability of non-commissioning of the machines. Even otherwise, the onus to prove that the sites were made available and kept ready to facilitate the plaintiff to commission the machines was heavily upon defendant No. 2 but the evidence in this regard is utterly wanting.
22. The plaintiff has successfully proved that on account of the fact that the sites were not kept ready in advance, the machines could not be commissioned and has therefore made himself entitled for the commission at the rate of 10% with effect from 9-8-91 till 2-4-93, the date of the filing of the suit as even service of legal notice for keeping the site ready so as to facilitate the plaintiff to commission the machines did not cut ice. By way of calculation the commission comes to Rs. 2,92,977.46. Issues are decided accordingly.
RELIEF
23. The suit of the plaintiff is decreed for the sum of Rs. 2,92,977.46 together with pendente lite and future interest at the rate of 9% with effect from 1-4-93 till its realization. Decree Sheet be drawn accordingly.
Suit decreed.
Alert