- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Dev Pharmcy v. Nova International
Factual and Procedural Background
The plaintiff instituted a suit for passing off against the defendant. The plaintiff sought leave to amend paragraph 10 of the plaint to record that a cease-and-desist notice dated 19.7.2003 was issued to the defendant and to summarise the defendant's replies dated 23.7.2003 and 26.7.2003, described in the application as “illegal, vague and baseless.” The defendant had not filed a written statement but had moved an application under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC which was pending.
Separately, the defendant applied for return of the plaint on the ground that the plaint had inconsistent valuations: four reliefs (including injunction, passing off, infringement of copyright and delivery of material) were each valued at Rs. 200 for court-fee and jurisdiction (total Rs. 800), while in paragraph 15(e) the plaintiff valued the rendition of accounts relief for jurisdiction at Rs. 20,01,000 (and made higher valuations for court-fees in paragraph 15(e)). The defendant contended that the aggregate valuation shown elsewhere (Rs. 800) meant this Court lacked pecuniary jurisdiction and the plaint should be returned.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the plaintiff should be permitted to amend paragraph 10 of the plaint to include the cease-and-desist notice and the defendant's replies.
- Whether the plaint should be returned for want of pecuniary jurisdiction because of alleged inconsistent or incorrect valuation of reliefs, particularly the valuation of the rendition of accounts relief.
Arguments of the Parties
Plaintiff's Arguments
- The proposed amendment does not change the nature of the suit and causes no prejudice to the defendant.
- The amendment is not mala fide; there is no gross delay or laches by the plaintiff.
- The amendment is necessary to decide the real controversy between the parties.
- For valuation, the plaintiff relied on the High Court rules under Section 9 of the Suits Valuation Act (Rule 4) to value rendition of accounts differently for jurisdiction and court-fee purposes.
- The plaintiff relied on authorities (including Fenner India Ltd. and STP Limited) to justify separate valuation for rendition of accounts and to permit amendment/clarification of valuation language.
Defendant's Arguments
- The proposed amendment should be permitted only if it causes no prejudice; defendant noted the plaintiff had not yet filed a written statement but had moved under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC.
- On jurisdiction, the defendant pointed to paragraph 15 where the four reliefs were each valued at Rs. 200 (court-fee Rs. 20 each), so the aggregate value for jurisdiction is Rs. 800; relying on Globe Super Parts, it argued that the Court therefore lacks pecuniary jurisdiction and the plaint must be returned to be presented to a court of competent jurisdiction.
- Alternatively, the defendant contended that where the plaintiff has fixed the value for rendition of accounts at Rs. 200 in sub-paragraph (d), the later valuation in sub-paragraph (e) (for jurisdiction) is redundant and must be ignored.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Akshaya Restaurant v. P. Anjanappa, 1995 Supp (2) SCC 303 : AIR 1995 SC 1498 | Principles governing amendments of pleadings (permitted amendment jurisprudence). | The court relied on the principles from this and other authorities to permit the amendment of paragraph 10 of the plaint. |
| Jayanti Roy v. Dass Estates Pvt Ltd., 2002 (4) SCALE 275 | Principles governing amendments of pleadings. | Applied as part of the body of authorities supporting allowance of the proposed amendment. |
| Sampath Kumar v. Ayyakannu (2002) 7 SCC 559 : AIR 2002 SC 3369 | Principles governing amendments of pleadings. | Relied upon as authority supporting the amendment of the plaint. |
| Prem Bakshi v. Dharam Dev, (2002) 2 SCC 2 : AIR 2002 SC 559 | Principles governing amendments of pleadings. | Relied upon with other decisions to allow the amendment application. |
| Globe Super Parts, Faridabad v. Domestic Appliances, 1981 PTC 78 | Held that ordinarily value for court-fee and value for jurisdiction must be the same (reference to Suits Valuation Act, Section 8) and Section 9 permits High Court rules in specified cases; where inconsistent valuations appear the court's jurisdiction may be affected. | The court considered Globe Super Parts as supporting the defendant's contention but found it distinguishable on facts (there the rendition of accounts relief was not separately valued for jurisdiction), and did not follow its result here. |
| Fenner India Ltd. v. Salbros Enterprises Pvt. Ltd., 1997 IV (Del) 24 : 1997 (17) PTC 447 (Del) (DB) | In rendition of accounts suits, Rule 4 of the Rules framed under Section 9 of the Suits Valuation Act governs valuation; plaintiff may value the suit for jurisdiction separately and fixed court-fees are payable accordingly. | The court relied on this Division Bench decision to hold that the plaintiff permissibly fixed a separate jurisdictional valuation for rendition of accounts and that such valuation was legally permissible. |
| STP Limited v. Shalimar Tar Products P. Ltd., 2002 (24) PTC 172 (Del) | Addressed amendment of a valuation clause where the words “and jurisdiction” were treated as superfluous and an amendment was allowed to correct a mistake. | The court noted this decision as supportive of permitting interpretation/amendment of valuation wording; it reinforced the view that apparent drafting errors in valuation clauses can be corrected. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The opinion deals with two distinct applications: (1) the plaintiff's application to amend paragraph 10 of the plaint, and (2) the defendant's application for return of the plaint for lack of pecuniary jurisdiction because of alleged inconsistent valuations.
On the amendment application:
- The court examined the proposed amendment textually and procedurally: the amendment did not change the nature of the suit, did not cause prejudice to the defendant, and was not shown to be mala fide or delayed.
- The court observed that the amendment appeared necessary to decide the real controversy between the parties and that the defendant had not yet filed a written statement (though an O.7 R.11 application was pending).
- The court applied settled principles (as cited: Akshaya Restaurant, Jayanti Roy, Sampath Kumar, Prem Bakshi) and allowed the amendment. The amended plaint was to be supplied to defendant's counsel and the defendant was directed to file a written statement to the amended plaint within four weeks, with replication, if necessary, within a further four weeks. The matter was renotified for completion of pleadings before the Joint Registrar.
On the return-of-plaint application (valuation / jurisdiction issue):
- The court recited the defendant's contention: paragraph 15 initially valued four reliefs at Rs. 200 each (total Rs. 800) but paragraph 15(e) separately valued rendition of accounts for jurisdiction at Rs. 20,01,000; relying on Globe Super Parts, defendant argued that the lower aggregate figure governed and thus this Court lacked pecuniary jurisdiction.
- The court analysed the applicable statutory framework: Globe Super Parts was discussed with reference to Sections 8 and 9 of the Suits Valuation Act — Section 8 requiring, generally, that value for court-fee and for jurisdiction be the same except in specific categories, and Section 9 empowering High Courts to make rules about valuation of certain suits.
- The court examined the jurisprudence in Fenner India Ltd., where a Division Bench held that rendition-of-accounts suits are governed by Rule 4 made under Section 9 and that the plaintiff may value the suit for jurisdiction as he wishes, subject to payment of fixed court-fee; STP Limited was noted as permitting amendment where “and jurisdiction” was superfluous and was read as a mistake.
- Reading paragraph 15(d) and (e) together, the court found that the plaintiff had in fact valued the rendition of accounts relief in accordance with Rule 4 under Section 9: paragraph 15(d) gave a nominal value but paragraph 15(e) expressly fixed the rendition-of-accounts valuation at Rs. 1,000 for court-fee and Rs. 20,01,800 for jurisdiction (the opinion records these figures as the plaintiff's clear valuation). The court held that such a separate jurisdictional valuation was permissible under law and supported by Fenner India Ltd.
- The court therefore distinguished Globe Super Parts on its facts (there the rendition-of-accounts relief had not been separately valued for jurisdiction), and concluded that the defendant's application lacked merit.
- Consequently, the application for return of the plaint was dismissed and the defendant was directed to file its written statement within four weeks.
Holding and Implications
Holding: (a) The plaintiff's application to amend paragraph 10 of the plaint is allowed; (b) The defendant's application for return of the plaint on the ground of lack of pecuniary jurisdiction is dismissed.
Implications / Consequences:
- Direct procedural consequences ordered by the court: the amended plaint has been filed and furnished to defendant's counsel; the defendant must file the written statement to the amended plaint within four weeks; replication, if necessary, within four weeks thereafter; pleadings completion was renotified before the Joint Registrar and further dates (including hearing on 4.11.2003) were fixed for subsequent steps.
- On the valuation issue, the court accepted that in rendition-of-accounts matters the plaintiff may fix a separate jurisdictional valuation in accordance with Rule 4 framed under Section 9 of the Suits Valuation Act; the court distinguished Globe Super Parts on the facts and relied on Fenner India Ltd. for this proposition.
- The decision addresses only the parties' procedural and jurisdictional positions in this suit; the court did not purport to lay down any novel general precedent beyond the application and interpretation of existing decisions and rules referred to in the opinion.
Mahmood Ali Khan, J.:— Plaintiff has filed this application for amendment of paragraph 10 of the plaint. The proposed amendment is specified in paragraph 4 of the application, which is as under:—
“Further the plaintiff also issued upon the defendant cease and desist notice dated 19.7.2003 to discontinue forthwith their impugned activities under the trademark Paurush Jiwan Label of the plaintiff. This notice was duly replied to on 23.7.2003 and 26.7.2003 respectively wherein instead of complying with the terms of the notice, the defendant blatantly denied the knowledge of the plaintiff's products under the impugned trademark. Besides the replies are illegal, vague and baseless.”
2. The plaintiff has filed this suit for passing off action against the defendant. The defendant has not filed the written statement as yet. Instead has filed an application under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC which is yet to be heard. The proposed amendment does not change the nature of the suit. It does not cause any prejudice to the defendant. This is not mala fide, there is no gross delay or laches on the part of the plaintiff. The amendment seems necessary for deciding the real question in controversy between the parties. Counsel for the plaintiff has requested for allowing the application and has cited Akshaya Restaurant v. P. Anjanappa, 1995 Supp (2) SCC 303 : AIR 1995 SC 1498; Jayanti Roy v. Dass Estates Pvt Ltd., 2002 (4) SCALE 275; Sampath Kumar v. Ayyakannu, (2002) 7 SCC 559 : AIR 2002 SC 3369 and Prem Bakshi v. Dharam Dev, (2002) 2 SCC 2 : AIR 2002 SC 559 in support of his argument. Following the principles of law laid down in the cited judgments the application is allowed. Amended plaint has already been filed. Copy thereof has already been supplied to the counsel for the defendant. Defendant shall file written statement to the amended plaint within four weeks. Replication if necessary be filed within four weeks thereafter. Renotify before the Joint Registrar for completing the pleadings on 19.11.2003 The case now need not be listed the Joint Registrar on 24.9.2003
IA No. 8398/03
3. Defendant has filed this application for return of the plaint on the ground that the plaintiff has valued the plaint for the relief of decree of injunction for passing off and infringement of copyright and delivery of the material at Rs. 200 each and court fee of Rs. 20 each has been affixed. However, for the purpose of rendition of accounts the plaintiff vide paragraph 15(d) has valued the suit for rendition of accounts of profits both for the purposes of court fees and jurisdiction at Rs. 200 and has affixed court fees of Rs. 20, therefore, the total value of the suit for the purpose of jurisdiction is only Rs. 800. It is further alleged that the plaintiff in paragraph 15(e) of the plaint has again valued the suit for the purpose of jurisdiction this relief at Rs. 20,01,000 as the plaintiff estimates that such an amount shall be found due to the plaintiff from the defendant on rendition of accounts. It is accordingly submitted that once the plaintiff has valued the relief of rendition of accounts of profits both for the purposes of court fees and jurisdiction at Rs. 200 as per paragraph 15(d) of the plaint then the pleading contained in paragraph 15(e) of the plaint are completely redundant and are liable to be ignored. It is therefore, submitted that this Court has no pecuniary jurisdiction to entertain and try the suit and the plaint is liable to be returned to the plaintiff to be presented to a court of competent jurisdiction. Plaintiff has not filed reply to this application. However, he wants to argue on the existing material.
4. Counsel for the defendant applicant drew my attention to paragraph 15 of the plaint where the various reliefs have been valued for the purpose of court fees and jurisdiction. All the four reliefs have been valued for the purpose of court fees and jurisdiction at Rs. 200 each and a court fee of Rs. 20 in respect of each of these reliefs has been affixed. But in sub-paragraph (e) of paragraph 15 of the relief for rendition of account is again valued at Rs. 20,01,000 for the purpose of jurisdiction. He has relied upon a judgment of this court in Globe Super Parts, Faridabad v. Domestic Appliances, 1981 PTC 78 in support of his agreement that the aggregate value of the suit for all four reliefs being Rs. 800 this Court has no pecuniary jurisdiction to hear the suit.
5. Conversely counsel for the defendant has stated that in sub-paragraph (d) of paragraph 15 the plaintiff has inadvertently mentioned that the value of the suit to the purpose of court fees and jurisdiction is Rs. 200 since in the next para 15(e) it has been clearly alleged that the valuation of the suit for the purpose of jurisdiction in respect of relief for rendition of accounts is Rs. 20,01,000. It is submitted that the plaintiff has a right to value the suit for the relief of rendition of account for the purpose of court fee and jurisdiction differently under Rule 4 of the Rules framed by the High Court under Section 9 of the Suits Valuation Act. He relied upon the judgment of this Court in Fenner India Ltd. v. Salbros Enterprises Pvt. Ltd., 1997 IV (Del) 24 : 1997 (17) PTC 447 (Del) (DB) in support of his argument and also a judgment of this Court in STP Limited v. Shalimar Tar Products P. Ltd., 2002 (24) PTC 172 (Del).
6. I have given careful consideration to the submissions made at the bar and have gone through the case law cited in support of the respective arguments. This court in Globe Super Parts, Faridabad (Supra) has held that the question of jurisdiction is dependent on the terms of the suits valuation Act. Section 8 of the said Act requires that except in certain types of cases, the value of the suit for the purposes of court fees and the value for the purpose of jurisdiction shall be the same. It was further observed that Section 9 empowered the High Court to make rules to govern the determination the valuation of certain suits and the High Court has made rules regarding various types of suits.
7. It was observed that valuation of court fees and jurisdiction has been given in regard to the four different reliefs claimed in the suit and the value for jurisdiction and the value for court fees is the same with regard to all of them. But later the plaintiff stated that the value for the purpose of court fees is Rs. 800 and value for jurisdiction is Rs. 2,00,600. It was held that if the value for jurisdiction is Rs. 2,00,600 then the court fees is also payable on Rs. 2,00,600 but the value for jurisdiction and the value for the court fees can only be altered in certain cases covered by the rules otherwise it has to be same. It was further observed that there were two possibilities. Either the present suit has to be tried on the basis of the jurisdictional value i.e Rs. 800 or it has to be tried on the basis that the value is Rs. 2,00,600 in which case full court fees on that sum has to be paid. It was further held that the court has no jurisdiction since the plaintiff has shown the jurisdictional value of Rs. 800. Accordingly, the plaint was directed to be returned to the plaintiff for presentation to the court of competent jurisdiction. In Fenner India Ltd. (Supra) the Division Bench of this Court was considering the valuation of the suit in a copyright case. It was held that in a case for rendition of accounts the suit is to be governed by Rule 4 of the Rules framed by the High Court under Section 9 of the Suits Valuation Act and the plaintiff can value the suit for the purposes of jurisdiction as he wishes it to be valued and fixed court fees was payable. In STP Limited (Supra) this Court was dealing with an application for amendment of the valuation clause. It was more or less similar to the valuation clause of this suit. The court while dealing with this application observed that the word “and jurisdiction” similar to the words mentioned in clause (e) of paragraph 15 was superfluous and reading of the prayer clause as a whole would show that it was by mistake and accordingly the application for amendment was allowed.
8. It is true that the plaintiff has given valuation for the relief of rendition of account for the purpose of court fees and jurisdiction at Rs. 200 but in the next paragraph the plaintiff has specifically stated that the valuation of suit for the relief of rendition of accounts is being fixed at Rs. 1000 for the purpose of court fees and Rs. 20,01,800 for the purpose of jurisdiction. Reading clauses (d) and (e) together makes it abundantly clear that the plaintiff has valued the suit for rendition of accounts in accordance with Rule 4 of the Rules framed by the High Court under Section 9 of the Suits Valuation Act and has valued the suit for the purpose of jurisdiction at Rs. 20,01,800 which was permissible under law. This view finds support from the judgment of the Division Bench in Fenner India Ltd. (Supra). The judgment in Globe Super Parts (Supra) was on its own distinguishable facts. In that case the suit has not been valued for the jurisdiction for relief of rendition of account separately but a different valuation for the purpose of jurisdiction was mentioned in respect of the four reliefs claimed. Even otherwise in view of the judgment of the Division Bench I do not find merit in the application. It is therefore, dismissed. Defendant shall file the written statement within four weeks.
IA No. 7629/03
9. Additional reply if any be filed within two weeks. Notify for hearing on 4.11.2003
Alert