- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Mahesh Gupta Petitioner v. Nct Of Delhi & Anr S
Structured Summary of the Opinion (S.K. Agarwal, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
This order disposes of a petition by the complainant under Section 439(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure seeking cancellation of bail granted to accused Rajeev Gupta by an Additional Sessions Judge by orders dated 4.12.2001.
Relevant factual and procedural points stated in the opinion:
- On 15.4.2001, Mahesh Gupta (complainant) lodged a complaint concerning the partnership firm M/s National Meal Industries, of which he alleged he held a 5% share; other partners named included Smt. Indira Gupta, Rajeev Gupta and Krishan Gupta.
- Civil litigation between the partners was pending. The complaint alleged that other partners, with an intention to defraud the complainant and misappropriate partnership funds, opened a separate bank account in the firm’s name at Punjab and Sind Bank, Azadpur Mandi Branch, Delhi, which was secretly operated by Krishan Gupta and Rajeev Gupta.
- The complainant discovered the separate account on 4.4.2001, went to the bank to stop operation of the account and was shown a forged partnership deed purportedly recording his retirement as a partner; his signature on that deed was alleged to be forged. A criminal case was registered on the basis of that complaint.
- Anticipatory bail applications of Smt. Indira Gupta and Krishan Gupta were dismissed by the Sessions Court and by this Court on different dates.
- Rajeev Gupta was arrested on 5.11.2001. His bail application was declined on 19.11.2001 by an Additional Sessions Judge. On 3.12.2001 he moved a subsequent (described in the record as a "third") bail application, and by order dated 4.12.2001 he was released on bail on furnishing personal bond of Rs. 25,000 with one surety of like amount, subject to depositing an FDR of Rs. 5.0 lakhs in any nationalised bank in the name of the Metropolitan Magistrate of P.S. Prashant Vihar along with the bail bond; that FDR was ordered to be dealt with by the trial court in accordance with law at the conclusion of trial.
- The FDR of Rs. 5.0 lakhs was deposited and Rajeev Gupta was released on bail. The complainant filed the present petition seeking cancellation of that bail order; the present order disposes of that petition.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the bail granted to accused Rajeev Gupta by the Additional Sessions Judge on 4.12.2001 should be cancelled under Section 439(2) Cr.P.C.
- Whether the circumstances relied upon by the complainant — including alleged gravity of allegations, the early stage of investigation, the accused's familial connection (his father being absconding), and the risk of hampering investigations — justify cancellation of bail.
- Whether the accused improperly suppressed material facts (specifically, whether the accused misrepresented the number of prior bail applications by describing the present application as the "third" when it was contended to be a fourth).
- Whether a subsequent bail application ought to have been entertained only by the same Additional Sessions Judge who earlier rejected a bail application (i.e., a procedural challenge to the competency of the judge who heard/granted the later application).
Arguments of the Parties
Complainant's (Petitioner's) Arguments
- The order granting bail to Rajeev Gupta is wholly unjust, arbitrary and an abuse of the process of law, resulting in a miscarriage of justice.
- The allegations against the accused are grave and investigations were at an initial stage; release of the accused would have hampered investigations.
- The accused's father was absconding, increasing the risk of the accused absconding as well.
- There was no change in circumstances that would justify releasing the accused on bail.
- The earlier bail application was dismissed by the court of Shri P.C. Ranga, Additional Sessions Judge; therefore, according to the petitioner, any subsequent application ought to have been dealt with only by that court.
- The accused did not disclose that the current application was actually his fourth application for bail and mischaracterised it as his third.
- Reliance was placed on several precedents (Baldev Singh v. Durga Prasad; State of Maharashtra v. Captain Buddhikota Subha Rao; Shalini Rawat v. The State) to support cancellation.
Respondents' Arguments
- The opinion records that learned counsel for respondents argued to the contrary, but no detailed account of the respondents' specific submissions is provided in the text of the opinion.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Subhendu Mishra v. Subrat Kumar Mishra and another, AIR 1999 SC 3026 | Approved the law laid down in Dolat Ram regarding strict requirements for cancellation of bail already granted; endorses that very cogent and overwhelming circumstances are necessary to cancel bail. | The Court relied on this decision to state the governing principle that bail once granted should not be cancelled except on cogent grounds; it treats Subhendu Mishra as an approval of Dolat Ram and applies that standard here. |
| Dolat Ram v. State of Haryana, (1995) 1 SCC 349 | Set out that very cogent and overwhelming circumstances are necessary for cancellation of bail -- grounds include interference with administration of justice, evasion of justice, abuse of concession, or risk of absconding; bail once granted should not be cancelled mechanically. | The Court quoted and applied these principles to hold that cancellation requires strong material; it found no such cogent circumstances on the record to cancel the bail granted to Rajeev Gupta. |
| Kashmira Singh v. Duman Singh, AIR 1996 SC 2176 | Addressed contentions of suppression of facts by accused when seeking bail; held that imputing knowledge of co-accused's rejected bail applications to the accused may be weak, and the prosecution bears responsibility to bring such facts to the Court's notice. | The Court relied on this decision to reject the complainant's contention that the accused suppressed earlier bail-related facts; it held the suppression argument to have no merit following the principles in Kashmira Singh. |
| Baldev Singh v. Durga Prasad, 1989 Crl.LJ NOC 94 | Relied upon by the complainant in support of cancellation of bail (the opinion records reliance but does not state a specific principle quoted from it). | The Court observed that the ratio of the decisions cited by the complainant (including this case) was not applicable to the facts of the instant case. |
| State of Maharashtra v. Captain Buddhikota Subha Rao, AIR 1989 SC 2292 | Relied upon by the complainant (cited in support) — the opinion does not extract a specific rule from this decision in its text. | The Court indicated that the decisions relied upon by the petitioner (including this one) did not have an applicable ratio to the facts of the present matter. |
| Shalini Rawat v. The State, 1998 1 AD (Cr.) Delhi 77 : 1998 (44) DRJ 81 | Relied upon by the complainant (cited in support); the opinion does not state a particular principle extracted from it in the text. | The Court considered the array of authorities cited by the petitioner and concluded that their ratio was not applicable to the case before it. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded by identifying the governing legal principle and then applying it to the facts.
- Principle articulated: The Court reiterated the settled law that an accused does not have a right to bail in non-bailable offences, and that once bail is granted it cannot be cancelled merely on the request of the complainant. Cancellation is permissible only when the accused has misused the privilege of bail or when it is no longer conducive to allow the accused to remain on bail. The Court relied on Subhendu Mishra (AIR 1999 SC 3026) which approved the law in Dolat Ram ((1995) 1 SCC 349) setting out that very cogent and overwhelming circumstances are necessary to cancel bail that has already been granted.
- Application of principle to facts: The Court reviewed the record and observed: (a) a civil dispute between the parties was pending; (b) the complainant held only a 5% share in the partnership; (c) the respondent was the nephew of the complainant; (d) the accused had been arrested on 5.11.2001 and had remained in judicial custody for almost a month prior to being released on bail; (e) the Additional Sessions Judge who granted bail had heard the learned APP for the State, the Investigating Officer was present and the complainant was present at the hearing; (f) an FDR of Rs. 5.0 lakhs had been deposited as ordered; and (g) there was no manifest illegality in the order granting bail.
- On suppression of facts: The Court rejected the argument that the accused had suppressed material facts by misdescribing the number of prior applications. Relying on Kashmira Singh v. Duman Singh (AIR 1996 SC 2176), the Court explained that imputing knowledge of co-accused's earlier rejected applications to the accused was weak, and that the prosecution/complainant bore responsibility to place such facts before the Court.
- On assignment of bail applications to particular judges: The Court addressed the contention that because an earlier application was rejected by Shri P.C. Ranga, only that judge should have dealt with the subsequent application. The Court explained that in Sessions Courts, bail applications are dealt with by one of the Additional Sessions Judges assigned to bail applications for the district and noted it was not the case of the petitioner that the judge who heard the later application had refused to deal with other bail applications. The Court concluded that the ratio of the decisions cited by petitioner's counsel was not applicable on these facts.
- Conclusion of analysis: Viewing the totality of the material on record, the Court found no cogent or overwhelming circumstances warranting cancellation of bail already granted; consequently, there was no merit in the petition.
Holding and Implications
DISMISSED. The petition seeking cancellation of bail was dismissed.
Direct consequences and implications expressly stated in the opinion:
- The bail granted to Rajeev Gupta by the Additional Sessions Judge on 4.12.2001 stands; the deposit of FDR of Rs. 5.0 lakhs remains and is to be dealt with by the trial court in accordance with law at the conclusion of the trial (as originally ordered when bail was granted).
- The Court found no manifest illegality in the grant of bail and did not find grounds to cancel bail in exercise of Section 439(2) Cr.P.C.
- The opinion does not purport to lay down a new precedent; it applies established Supreme Court authority (Subhendu Mishra approving Dolat Ram) and follows Kashmira Singh on suppression-of-facts contentions to the facts of this case.
Note: This summary is limited to and derived solely from the content of the provided opinion and does not add information beyond what the opinion itself states.
S.K Agarwal, J.:— This order will dispose of a petition by the complainant under Section 439(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure seeking cancellation of bail of accused Rajeev Gupta granted by Additional Sessions Judge vide orders dated 4.12.2001
2. Facts in brief are that on 15.4.2001, petitioner Mahesh Gupta lodged a complaint that M/s. National Meal Industries is a partnership firm comprising of (i) complainant Mahesh Gupta, (ii) Smt. Indira Gupta, (iii) Rajeev Gupta,.and (iv) Krishan Gupta. The complainant has 5% share in this firm. Civil litigation between the parties arising out of partnership was pending; other partners of the firm with a view to defraud the complainant and to misappropriate funds of the partnership firm unauthorisedly opened a separate account in the name of the firm, in Punjab and Sind Bank, Azadpur Mandi Branch, Delhi which was being operated by Krishan Gupta and Rajeev Gupta secretly. The complainant came to know about it on 4.4.2001; he went to the bank to stop operation of the account and he was shown a forged partnership deed containing a clause that he had retired as a partner from the firm; his signature on this deed was forged. On his complaint, above-noted case was registered. Applications for anticipatory bail, of Smt Indira Gupta and Krishan Gupta were dismissed by the Sessions Court, as well as by this Court on different dates.
3. Rajeev Gupta (respondent No. 2) was arrested on 5th of November, 2001. His application for bail was declined on 19.11.2001 by learned Additional Sessions Judge. On 3.12.2001, Rajeev Gupta moved third application and by order dated 4.12.2001, he was released on bail by learned Additional Sessions Judge, on his furnishing personal bond in the sum of Rs. 25,000/- with one surety in the like amount to the satisfaction of the trial court, subject to the condition that he shall deposit an FDR of Rs. 5.0 lacs in any nationalised bank in the name of Metropolitan Magistrate of P.S Prashant Vihar along with bail bond. The said amount of Rs. 5.0 lacs was ordered to be dealt with by the trial court in accordance with law at the conclusion of the trial. The amount was deposited and he was released on bail. This order is under challenge.
4. Learned counsel for the petitioner has argued that the said order is wholly unjust, arbitrary and constitutes the abuse of the process of law, which has resulted into miscarriage of justice. Learned counsel argued that the allegations against him were grave in nature; investigations were at initial stages; father of the accused was absconding and release of petitioner would have hampered investigations of the case and that there is no change in the circumstances, necessitating his release. Learned counsel also argued that earlier application was dismissed by the court of Shri P.C Ranga, Additional Sessions Judge and the subsequent application ought to have been dealt with only by that court alone; and that the accused did not disclose that it was his fourth application and not the third one, In support of his submissions reliance is placed on the observations made in Baldev Singh v. Durga Prasad, 1989 Crl.LJ NOC 94 (State Of Maharashtra v. Captain Buddhikota Subha Rao ., AIR 1989 SC 2292 and Shalini Rawat v. The State, 1998 1 AD (Cr.) Delhi 77 : 1998 (44) DRJ 81. Learned counsel for respondents argued to the contrary.
5. It is well established principle of law that the accused cannot claim bail as of right in a non-bailable offence but once the bail is granted, it cannot be cancelled on the mere request of the complainant. The bail can only be can celled when it is shown that either the accused has misused the privilege of bail or it is no longer conducive to allow him to remain on bail. The Supreme Court in Subhendu Mishra v. Subrat Kumar Mishra and another, AIR 1999 SC 3026 approved the law laid down by the Court in Dolat Ram v. State of Haryana, (1995) 1 SCC 349, wherein it was held as under:—
“.... Very cogent and overwhelming circumstances are neces sary for an order directing the cancellation of the bail, already granted. Generally speaking, the grounds for cancellation of bail, broadly (illustrative and not exhaustive) are: interference or attempt to interfere with the due course of administration of justice or evasion or attempt to evade the due course of justice or abuse of the conces sion granted to the accused in any manner. The satisfaction of the Court, on the basis of material placed on the record of the possibility of the accused absconding is yet another reason justifying the cancel lation of bail. However, bail once granted should not be cancelled in a mechanical manner without considering whether any supervening circumstances have rendered it no longer conducive to a fair trial to allow the accused to retain his freedom by enjoying the concession of bail during the trial. These principles, it appears, were lost sight of by the High Court when it decided to cancel the bail, already granted. The High Court it appears to us overlooked the distinction of the fac tors relevant for rejecting bail in a non-bailable case in the first in stance and the cancellation of bail already granted.”
6. Admittedly, a civil dispute is pending between the parties; respondent No. 2 is the nephew of petitioner, petitioner had only a 5% share in the partnership firm; respondent was arrested on 5.11.2001 and remained in judi cial custody for almost a month; he was granted bail by learned Additional Sessions Judge after hearing learned APP for State, Investigating Officer was also present and the complainant was also present, FDR of Rs. 5.0 lacs has al ready been deposited and that there is no manifest illegality in the granting bail.
7. The arguments that the accused did not stated that it was his fourth application for bail and instead captioned the bail application as “ third application for bail under Section 439 Cr.P.C,” and that he did not bring to the notice of the Court that the earlier applications for anticipatory bail of the co-accused were declined have also no merit. The Apex Court, while rejecting similar contentions in Kashmira Singh v. Duman Singh., AIR 1996 SC 2176 held as under:—
“The ground regarding suppression of facts by accused was still weaker. In the first place, knowledge of two bail applications of the co-accused having been rejected has been imputed to the accused without valid basis. Secondly, the fact that the co-accused had applied for bail and had later not pressed the application, had been disclosed since it was known to the accused. That was sufficient indication that the co-accused had not been enlarged on bail. His decision not to press for bail would be indicative of the fact that the Court was disinclined to grant bail or, he did not see sufficient grounds to press the bail application. Be that as it may, the fact remains that the Court was aware that the co-accused was not granted bail. That was sufficient for the Court when it considered the accused's application for bail. Besides, it was the prosecution/complainant's duty to bring to the Court's notice that two applications of the co-accused for bail were rejected. If the accused did not mention it, nothing prevented the opposite side from placing it on record. It seems to be an omisjsion on the part of the prosecution/complainant's side but, for that it would be wrong to charge them with having suppressed facts.”
8. Now coming to the contention that the application for bail of the accused was earlier rejected by the Court of Sh. P.C Ranga, Additional Sessions Judge, Delhi, therefore, the subsequent application for bail ought to have been dealt with by the same court; it may be noted here that in Sessions Courts, all bail applications are dealt with, by one of the Additional Sessions Judge, to whom the bail applications are assigned of a particular district. It is not the case of the petitioner that the Court of Sh. M. L. Sahni, Additional Sessions Judge, did not deal with the other bail applications when the bail was granted to the respondent. The ratio of the various decisions cited by the learned counsel for the petitioner is not applicable to the facts of this case.
9. For the foregoing reasons, I find no merit in the petition and the same is dismissed.
Alert