- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Bal Vikas Public School And Another Petitioners v. Govt. Of N.C.T Of Delhi And Another S
Judgment Summary — Manmohan Sarin, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner sought writ relief for upgradation of a school from Secondary level to Senior Secondary level pursuant to an application dated 15.3.1999. The Deputy Director of Education declined the petitioner's request by order dated 21.3.2000. The petitioner appealed and the appeal was dismissed by the Lt. Governor of Delhi on 31.5.2000 in appeal No. 26/2000 titled Bal Vikas Public School v. Govt. of NCT of Delhi and Others.
Relevant facts recorded in the opinion: the school had CBSE affiliation by certificate dated 13.9.1995 and recognition up to Class X. The petitioner initially had 800 sq. meters of land; with 293 students the petitioner calculated the land requirement under CBSE affiliation bye-laws at 1,043 sq. meters. Additional land measuring 822 sq. meters was acquired, bringing total land to 1,622 sq. meters. Earlier applications for upgradation dated 13.1.1997 had been rejected (20.1.1998) due to insufficient area and other shortcomings (inadequate playground, absence of Directorate nominee on managing committee, non-provision of PF facilities). The petitioner made representations and was advised to avail appellate remedies and later to reapply when applications were invited for 1999-2000, which led to the 15.3.1999 application.
The rejection dated 21.3.2000 relied on a Directorate of Education letter dated 24.12.1999 that set a revised minimum land requirement for a Senior Secondary school with two streams at 3,000 sq. meters and instructed that pending and future cases be processed in accordance with that norm.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the petitioner's school should be governed by the norms that were in existence at the time the petitioner applied for upgradation (15.3.1999) or by the revised norms contained in the Directorate letter dated 24.12.1999 which were applied to the application when decided on 21.3.2000.
- Whether the letter dated 24.12.1999 (a Directorate communication setting out revised land norms) has the character of statutory rules and, if not, whether it can be applied retrospectively to an application made before the letter was issued.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner's application was made on 15.3.1999 and therefore must be considered according to the norms prevailing at that time; the respondents cannot apply revised norms adopted later.
- Section 4(2) of the Delhi School Education Act, 1973 prescribes a four-month period within which the appropriate authority must decide an application for recognition and, if recognition is denied, to communicate reasons; respondents failed to decide within that period and cannot attribute the delay to the petitioner to justify applying later norms.
- Counsel relied on Vellore Education Trust v. State of Andhra Pradesh (AIR 1988 SC 130) and Anjuman-E-Islam v. State of Karnataka (2001 9 SCC 465 : AIR 2001 SC 2884) to support the proposition that a subsequent change in policy should not affect an application filed before the policy change.
- The Directorate letter of 24.12.1999 is at best an executive proposal or instruction and not statutory rules under Section 28 of the Delhi School Education Act, 1973; it was not approved or published as required for statutory rules and therefore lacks statutory character and cannot be applied retrospectively.
Respondent's Arguments
- The Directorate and the Lt. Governor were entitled to change policy and revise norms; the decision to apply the revised norms was lawful.
- Reliance was placed on State of Punjab v. Ram Lubhaya (AIR 1998 SC 1703) for the proposition that it is within the executive's province to frame and revise policy in public interest.
- The revised norms aimed to improve quality of education and provide adequate accommodation and amenities for sports and extracurricular activities, and thus were correctly applied when the petitioner's application was decided in March 2000.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Vellore Education Trust v. State of Andhra Pradesh, AIR 1988 SC 130 | Principle that a change in government policy adopted after an application was filed cannot be used as the sole ground to refuse a permission or recognition applied for before the policy change. | The court relied on this authority to support the conclusion that the petitioner's application, filed on 15.3.1999 (before the 24.12.1999 letter), should be considered under the norms then applicable and not be refused solely on the basis of the later policy. |
| Anjuman-E-Islam v. State of Karnataka, (2001) 9 SCC 465 : AIR 2001 SC 2884 | Relied upon by petitioner’s counsel in support of the proposition that subsequent policy changes should not adversely affect pending applications. | The opinion records that counsel relied on this decision, but does not elaborate further on its application; the court principally applied the reasoning it drew from Vellore Educational Trust. |
| State of Punjab v. Ram Lubhaya, AIR 1998 SC 1703 | Authority cited by respondents for the proposition that the executive may frame and revise policy in public interest. | The court noted the respondent's reliance on this case to justify policy revision but proceeded to examine the statutory and temporal character of the Directorate letter and its retrospective application. |
| Bal Vikas Public School v. Govt. of NCT of Delhi and Others (Appeal No. 26/2000) | Recorded as the order by which the Lt. Governor dismissed the petitioner's appeal (factual/decisional record rather than an abstract legal principle). | The opinion records that the petitioner's appeal was dismissed by the Lt. Governor on 31.5.2000 in this appeal; the court treated that decision as part of the procedural history that it was called on to review. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded through a focused factual-legal analysis:
- Admitted position: the sole ground for rejecting the petitioner's application was non-compliance with the land requirement of 3,000 sq. meters as stated in the Directorate letter dated 24.12.1999; the petitioner had applied on 15.3.1999 and had 1,622 sq. meters.
- The court noted Section 4(2) of the Delhi School Education Act, 1973 requires the appropriate authority to decide an application for recognition within four months and, in case of non-grant, to communicate reasons. The authorities did not take a decision within that time; there is nothing on record to show the delay was due to any clarification or information required from the petitioner.
- On the effect of the Directorate letter of 24.12.1999 the court examined the letter’s text: it stated the Directorate had "finalised" norms and asked that proposals pending with CBSE be settled as per the norms mentioned and that pending and future cases be processed according to those minimum land requirements. The court observed that the letter indicated the norms were intended to operate "henceforth."
- The court distinguished executive instructions from statutory rules: it held that the December 1999 letter was at best an executive proposal or instruction and not the statutory rules contemplated by Section 28(2) of the Act. The opinion states that the letter did not have the legal sanction to be applied retrospectively.
- Applying the principle in Vellore Educational Trust, the court accepted that where an application is filed before a policy is adopted, the subsequent policy cannot be used as the sole ground for refusal. The court therefore concluded that the norms contained in the 24.12.1999 letter could not be retrospectively applied to the petitioner's application of 15.3.1999.
- Because the authorities failed to decide within the four-month period and because the December 1999 norms could not be applied retrospectively, the impugned orders (to the extent they applied the 24.12.1999 criteria) were unsustainable.
- The court thus quashed the impugned orders insofar as they applied the 24.12.1999 criteria and directed the Authorities to decide the petitioner's case according to the norms applicable in March 1999 within one month from the date of the judgment.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The writ petition is allowed. The impugned orders dated 21.3.2000 and 31.5.2000, insofar as they apply the land criteria contained in the Directorate letter dated 24.12.1999, are quashed. The Authorities are directed to decide the petitioner's application applying the norms that were applicable in March 1999 within one month.
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: the petitioner’s application must be reconsidered and decided by the relevant authorities according to the norms in force at the time of the application (March 1999), within one month as directed by the court.
- On broader law: the court treated the Directorate letter as an executive instruction/proposal rather than a statutory rule and held there was no legal basis for retrospective application of that letter to pending applications. The opinion relies on established authority (notably Vellore Educational Trust) for the proposition that a subsequent policy cannot be used to defeat rights or expectations created by a pending application. The judgment does not purport to lay down a novel legal principle beyond applying those authorities to the facts of the case.
Order: Petition allowed; impugned orders quashed insofar as they apply the December 1999 criteria; authorities directed to decide under March 1999 norms within one month.
Manmohan Sarin, J.:—
Order
Petitioner by this petition seeks a writ of mandamus for upgradation of the school from Secondary level to Senior Secondary level, as applied for vide application dated 15.3.1999 Request of the petitioner was declined by the Deputy Director of Education, vide orders dated 21.3.2000 Petitioner preferred an appeal against the order dated 21.3.2000, which was dismissed by the Lt. Governor of Delhi, vide orders dated 31.5.2000, passed in the appeal No. 26/2000 titled Bal Vikas Public School v. Govt, of NCT of Delhi and Others.
2. Petitioner seeks a writ of certiorari for quashing of the aforesaid orders dated 21.3.2000 and 31.5.2000
3. F.acts relevant for the purposes of disposal of the writ petition may be briefly noted :-
(i) Petitioner's school was granted affiliation with the Central Board of Secondary Education vide certificate dated 13.9.1995, issued by CBSE. The school was recognised up to Class X. Petitioner had in his possession 800 sq. mtrs. of land on which a three storeyed building for the school was constructed. As per the affiliation bye-laws of CBSE, the requirement of land was 750 sq. mtrs of area plus 1 sq. mtr. for every student on the roll for a Senior Secondary School. Petitioner claims that with 293 students enrolled in the petitioner's school, the requirement of land worked out to 1043 sq. mtrs. Petitioner initially had 800 sq mtrs and additional land admeasuring 822 sq. mtrs. was acquired, making the total available area as 1622 sq.mtrs Petitioner thus was fully eligible for being granted upgradation to the Senior Secondary School level.
(ii) On a point of background, it may be noted that the petitioner had initially applied for upgradation on 13.1.1997 The said application for upgradation was rejected on 20.1.1998 due to the availability area not being as per CBSE bye-laws. There were other shortcomings. Playground available was not sufficient/adequate. It was also pointed out that there was no nominee of Directorate of Education in the managing committee. PF facilities were not being provided to staff. Petitioner represented against the said decision vide its communication of 3rd June, 1998 informing of the acquisition of addition land and the availability of a playground. Response to other objections was also given. Petitioner was advised by the Education Officer that since the Directorate had rejected the case, petitioner may avail of the appellate remedies. Petitioner was also advised subsequently vide letter dated 20.8.1998, that the matter had been reviewed at the headquarters and the school may apply for upgradation afresh for the year 1999-2000, when applications are invited by the Department. It is in this background that petitioner had submitted its application on 15.3.1999
4. The rejection of the petitioner's application vide order dated 21.3.2000, is on the ground that the School has a total plot area admeasuring 1622 sq.meters, while according to the new policy of the Directorate of Education, minimum land requirement for the Senior Secondary School with two streams is 3000 sq. meters. The new policy which is referred to in the impugned order dated 21.3.2000, is contained in a letter dated 24.12.1999, written by the Directorate of Education and addressed to the Secretary, CBSE.
5. It is the above letter which is the bone of contention. As per the letter, the Directorate of Education after taking into account all factors had finalised and the land norms applicable for recognition to private schools henceforth. The land required for a Senior Secondary School for two streams was given as 3,000 sq. meters. The post script to the said letter carries an instruction to various District Education Officers of the Directorate that pending and future cases of recognition should be processed only in accordance with the minimum land requirement mentioned in para 5 of the letter.
6. The question that arises for consideration in the present writ petition is whether the petitioner's school is to be governed by the norms that were in existence at the time when the petitioner applied for upgradation on 15.3.99 or the norms as are laid out in the letter dated 24.12.1999, which have been applied by the Deputy Director of Education, while taking a decision on the petitioner's application on 21.3.2000?
7. Learned counsel for the petitioner has assailed the impugned orders and their reliance on the norms set out in the letter dated 24.12.1999 It is urged that the petitioner's application having been moved on 15.3.1999, the petitioner is entitled to have his application considered on the basis of the norms prevalent at the time of application., Counsel has also referred to sub-section (2) of Section 4 of the Delhi School Education Act, 1973, where a period of four months is prescribed within which the appropriate authority is enjoined to decide the application for recognition and in case of non-grant of recognition to communicate the reasons for not granting the recognition. Mr. Rahul Gupta submitted that respondents having themselves not disposed of the application, cannot shift the blame to the petitioner's door and then claim that revised norms should be applied. Counsel for the petitioner relied on Vellore Education Trust v. State of Andhra Pradesh, 1987 Supp SCC 543 : (AIR 1988 SC 130) and Anjuman-E-lslam v. State of Karnataka, (2001) 9 SCC 465 : (AIR 2001 SC 2884). Learned counsel further submitted that the letter was a mere proposal or at best executive instructions. It could not be treated as statutory rules, which are required to be framed under S. 28 of the Delhi School Education Act, 1973 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act). The said instructions have neither the previous approval of Central Government nor published by notification and placed before the Houses of Parliament. They do not have any statutory character. He submitted that in any case, these could not be applied retrospectively.
8. Counsel for the respondent refute the submissions made and urges that the decision taken by the Directorate of Education and the Lt. Governor, while disposing of the appeals was fully in consonance with law. He submits that the respondents were fully entitled to change the policy and the norms. He places reliance on State of Punjab v. Ram Lubhaya, AIR 1998 SC 1703 to submit that it is within the province of the Executives to frame a policy and revise the same in public interest.
9. Learned counsel submits that the revised norms were intended to improve the quality of education and provide reasonable accommodation and amenities for sports and extra-curricular activities. Petitioner's application was decided in March, 2000. The revised norms had come into being and have been correctly made applicable.
10. Having perused the pleadings and noted the rival submissions, the admitted position which emerges is that the sole ground on which the petitioner's application for upgradation has been rejected is the petitioner not having the area in terms of the norms given in the letter of 24.12.1999 i.e 3000 sq. meters. The petitioner had, admittedly, applied on 15.3.1999 even if the earlier applications were to be ignored. Respondents Authorities were required to take a decision within four months in terms of S. 4(2) of the Act. However, they failed to take a decision. Nothing has been placed on record to suggest that the delay in taking decision was on account of any clarification or information required from the petitioner.
11. Undoubtedly, petitioner's school was entitled for upgradation if the decision had been taken within the four month period envisaged in S. 4(2) of the Act. Be it may, the next question to be considered is whether the norms of 24.12.1999, can be made applicable to the petitioner. Petitioner's application was complete on 15.3.1999 As observed by the Supreme Court in Vellore Educational Trust (AIR 1988 SC 130) (supra) while dealing with the case of change in the policy of the Government, the Supreme Court observed in para 10 as under:
“10. The impugned order made by respondent 1 refusing to grant permission solely on the ground of policy of the Government, is in our considered opinion not at all tenable as we have stated hereinbefore that such permission has already been accorded to establish private engineering college to Nagarjuna Education Society on November 15, 1985. Moreover, the application for permission was filed long before the alleged policy in question was adopted by respondent 1”.
12. A perusal of the letter in the instant case dated 24.12.1999, shows that it’ was in response to certain suggestions and norms given by the Central Board of Secondary Education. The letter in para 5 mentions “after taking into account all relevant factors and after thoughtful consideration, the Directorate of Education has finalised the following norms relating to land for recognition of private schools henceforth”. The concluding part mentions “I should be grateful if the proposals pending with you for affiliation could be settled as per the norms of land suggested in para (5) above.” It would follow from the foregoing that the norms were intended to be made applicable henceforth. Further, the CBSE was requested to settle the proposal for affiliation as per the norms given in the letter.
13. It is also to be noted that the above letter is at best an execute proposal/instruction and not the statutory rules as are envisaged in Section 28(2) of the Act. There is no legal sanction for making these executive instructions applicable retrospectively. In view of the foregoing discussion, petitioner is entitled to have his application for upgradation considered and decided based on the norms as were applicable in March, 1999 and the norms as are set out in the letter of 24.12.1999, cannot be made applicable to the petitioner whose application was duly submitted in March, 1999. The impugned orders in as much as they apply the criteria given in the letter of 24.12.1999, cannot be sustained and are hereby quashed. The Authorities are directed to decide the case of the petitioner as per the norms applicable in March, 1999 within one month from today.
The writ petition is allowed in the above terms.
Petition allowed.
Alert