Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mrs. Kaushalya Mehta v. State .

Delhi High Court
Dec 5, 2001
Smart Summary (Beta)

Case Summary: Probate Petition under Section 276, Indian Succession Act, 1925

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a petition under Section 276 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925, seeking grant of probate to the last Will and testament of the late Shri Hans Bali (son of late Shri Chiranji Lal Bali). Shri Hans Bali died issueless on 2 August 1992; his wife pre-deceased him, and his brother Shri Dev Dutt Bali had died issueless in 1948. The deceased was in possession of movable and immovable assets specified in Annexure-C of the petition. The Will (Annexure-D) was notarised before a Notary Public in the presence of Shri Sunil Dutt Bali and Smt. Kiran Dutta.

Notice of the petition was issued and served by publication to the general public; no objections were filed. Because the deceased had movable property in Calcutta, a Local Commissioner was appointed to open lockers and prepare an inventory. The petitioner examined three witnesses (including herself) and proved several documents (death certificates, the Will, the Local Commissioner’s list, a valuation report, an amended statement of properties, and the document in which the Will was proved).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether probate to the last Will of Shri Hans Bali should be granted under Section 276 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925, based on the evidence presented.
  2. Whether this Court has jurisdiction to entertain the petition where the deceased had no fixed place of abode but had a portion of property situated within the Court's jurisdiction.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Babu Devi Baksh Singh v. Mrs. Ashtbhuja Rattan Kanwar, AIR 1937 Allahabad 670 Support for the proposition that a Court may entertain an application for grant of Letters of Administration (or probate) where the deceased had no fixed place of abode but possessed a small portion of property within the jurisdiction of that Court. Relied upon to support the Court's conclusion that it had jurisdiction to entertain the petition despite the deceased not having a fixed residence.
Govind v. Anant, AIR 1923 Nagpur 145 Support for the same jurisdictional proposition described above. Relied upon alongside the other cited authority to justify the Court's exercise of jurisdiction over the petition.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court considered the evidentiary record produced by the petitioner: death certificates of Shri Hans Bali and his wife, the Will (Annexure-D), the Local Commissioner's inventory (Exhibit PW-1/4), a valuation report (Exhibit PW-1/5), an amended statement of properties (Exhibit PW-1/6), and the document in which the Will has been proved (Exhibit PW-1/7). The petitioner identified the deceased's signatures on the Will.

The Court evaluated witness testimony: PW-2 (Smt. Kiran Dutta), an attesting witness, deposed that she and her husband knew the deceased and that the Will was signed and executed by the deceased in their presence; PW-3 (Shri Sunil Dutt Bali) corroborated this account. Both attesting witnesses stated the deceased was of sound and disposing mind at the time of execution. The Will had been executed while the deceased was residing in Delhi, and some of the properties for which administration is sought are located in Delhi.

On the jurisdictional point, the Court applied the settled principle (supported by the two cited cases) that a Court may entertain a probate/administration application where the deceased had no fixed place of abode but possessed a small portion of property within that Court's jurisdiction. Applying the facts and the cited authority, the Court concluded that the petitioner’s claim was established.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The petition is allowed and probate is granted in respect of the assets and properties mentioned in Annexure-C of the petition. The probate petition is disposed of.

Consequences and directives:

  • The petitioner is granted probate for the estate assets listed in Annexure-C.
  • The requisite Court-fee is to be filed within two weeks.

Broader implications: The opinion applies established jurisdictional authority to permit a probate application where the deceased lacked a fixed abode but had property within the Court’s jurisdiction. The opinion does not state that it establishes any new legal precedent beyond applying the cited authorities; its direct effect is to grant probate to the petitioner and dispose of the petition.

Disposition: Probate Petition disposed of.

Show all summary ...

J.D Kapoor, J.— This is a petition under Section 276 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 for grant of probate to the last Will and testament of late Shri Hans Bali son of late Shri Chiranji Lal Bali.

2. It is averred that Shri Hans Bali died issueless on 2nd August, 1992 whereas his wife has pre-deceased him. The brother of Shri Hans Bali namely Shri Dev Dutt Bali also died issueless in 1948. Shri Hans Bali, the deceased was in possession of the movable and immovable assets, details of which have been given in Annexure-C. The Will was duly notarised before the Notary Public in the presence of Shri Sunil Dutt Bali and Smt. Kiran Dutta.

3. The notice of the petition was issued and served by way of publication to the general public. Nobody has filed any objection to the present petition. Since the deceased has some movable properties at Calcutta, a Local Commissioner was appointed for opening the lockers and preparing the inventory of the articles.

4. In order to prove the aforesaid facts and the execution of the Will by the deceased, the petitioner has examined three witnesses including herself. The petitioner has proved the following documents:

(1) Exhibit PW-1/1 is the death certificate of Shri Hans Bali issued by the Registrar.

(2) Exhibit PW-1/2 is the death certificate of Smt. B. Bali, wife of Shri Hans Bali issued by the Registrar.

(3) Annexure-D is the Will.

(4) Exhibit PW-1/4 is the list prepared by the Local Commissioner.

(5) Exhibit PW-1/5 is the valuation report.

(6) Exhibit PW-1/6 is the amended statement of properties.

(7) Exhibit PW-1/7 is the document in which the Will has been proved.

5. The petitioner has identified the signatures of the deceased on the Will. PW 2 Mrs. Kiran Dutta who is one of the attesting witnesses has deposed that the deceased was personally known to her and her husband and had signed and executed the Will in her presence and in the presence of Shri Sunil Dutt Bali. PW 3 Shri Sunil Dutt Bali has corroborated his co-witness. Both the witnesses have stated that the deceased was in sound and disposing mind at the time of the execution of the Will. The deceased at the time of the execution of the Will had been residing at Delhi. Some of the properties in respect of which the Letter of Administration is sought are also at Delhi.

6. It is averred that the deceased was not having his fixed place of residence. Sometimes he was residing at Delhi and sometimes at Calcutta. According to the petitioner, before his death the deceased was residing at Vasant Kunj, New Delhi and the petitioner had been rendering all sorts of services and looking after the deceased.

7. As regards the jurisdiction of this Court it is settled law that where an application for grant of Letter of Administration is made to the Court within whose jurisdiction the deceased had no fixed place of abode but has a small portion of the property situated within the jurisdiction of that Court the said Court can entertain such an application. This view finds support from the following two cases:

(i) Babu Devi Baksh Singh v. Mrs. Ashtbhuja Rattan Kanwar, AIR 1937 Allahabad 670; and

(ii) Govind v. Anant, AIR 1923 Nagpur 145.

8. The deposition of the aforesaid witnesses and the documents proved show that the deceased Shri Hans Bali had lastly executed the Will (Annexure-D). The petitioner is the close relation of the deceased. The deceased died issueless. So much so his wife also pre-deceased him and his brother also pre-deceased him. The said brother also died issueless.

9. The aforesaid facts establish the claim of the petitioner for grant of the probate in favour of the petitioner. Accordingly the petition is allowed and the probate is granted in respect of the assets and the properties mentioned in Annexure-C of the petition.

10. The requisite Court-fee shall be filed within two weeks.

11. The probate petition stands disposed off.

Probate Petition disposed of.