Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Hari Ram Kakkar. v. Union Of India & Others

Delhi High Court
Jun 1, 2001
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary — Arun Kumar, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner moved this writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India challenging land acquisition proceedings in respect of multiple khasra numbers (total 32 bighas 1 biswas) in village Satbari, Delhi. Notifications under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act were published on 5/25 November 1980 for “planned development of Delhi.” Subsequent Section 6 notifications were issued in May/June 1985 and January/February 1986 and were challenged in court.

Earlier litigation included: (i) dismissal of challenges to the Section 4 notification by this Court in Munni Lal v. Lt. Governor of Delhi (judgment dated 15 November 1983); (ii) disagreements between Benches on whether Section 6 notifications were issued beyond the three-year statutory period, resolved by a Full Bench in Balak Ram Gupta… v. Union of India (Full Bench judgment dated 27 May 1987), which held that periods of stay must be excluded when computing the three-year period; and (iii) further Division Bench proceedings in Balak Ram Gupta… v. Union Of India… and Others (37 (1989) DLT 150) that examined compliance with Section 5A of the Act and concluded that no proper inquiry under Section 5A had been conducted, quashing acquisition proceedings in relation to 73 writ petitions covering 11 villages (including Satbari).

The Supreme Court later considered the scope of the benefit of the Balak Ram Gupta judgment in Abhey Ram v. Union of India (1997) and Delhi Administration v. Gurdip Singh Uban and Others (2000), holding that the benefit of the Balak Ram Gupta decision was confined to those petitioners who had filed writ petitions; landowners who did not file Section 5A objections or did not approach the court were not entitled to the benefit.

In the present petition the petitioner affirmed (by amendment) that he had filed objections under Section 5A; this fact was not disputed by respondents and the petitioner's name appeared in the Collector's list of persons who filed Section 5A objections. The petitioner sought production of the records of Section 5A hearings; respondents produced only the written objections and the Collector's report, but not any record of the hearings or proceedings purportedly held by the Collector.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the statutory requirement of an opportunity to be heard under Section 5A of the Land Acquisition Act was complied with in respect of the landowner-objectors (including the petitioner).
  2. Whether the Collector's report under Section 5A—without accompanying record of proceedings or evidence of hearings—could sustain the subsequent sanction/Section 6 declaration and the acquisition proceedings.
  3. Whether hearing by one Collector and the subsequent report made by another Collector (without fresh hearings) suffices to comply with Section 5A and with principles of natural justice.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner (by amendment) alleged that he had filed objections under Section 5A and that there was total non-compliance with Section 5A in respect of hearings by the Collector.
  • The petitioner's case was that the Collector's report was vitiated because no hearings or record of proceedings were produced, and therefore the sanction under Section 6 based on that report must fall.
  • The petitioner relied on the factual findings in Balak Ram Gupta's Division Bench decision as supporting evidence that hearings had not been effectively conducted and that reports were an "eye wash."

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents submitted that Section 5A hearings are administrative (not judicial or quasi-judicial) and that a hearing conducted by one officer and a report made by another could not be a ground for challenge.
  • They argued that the petitioner did not request a personal hearing and was therefore deemed to have waived the right to one.
  • The respondents contended that the Balak Ram Gupta view on sanction under Section 6 had been implicitly overruled by the Supreme Court in Gurdip Singh Uban's case; however, the bench stated it need not address that point in light of the Section 5A findings.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Munni Lal v. Lt. Governor of Delhi (ILR (1984) 1 Delhi 469) — judgment dated 15 November 1983 Dismissal of challenges to the Section 4 notification; relied upon by the Collector in his report when rejecting objections as repetitive of judicial findings. The Court found the Collector had mechanically relied on Munni Lal to reject objections without independent consideration; such reliance did not substitute for the mandatory hearings and record required by Section 5A.
Balak Ram Gupta… v. Union Of India… (Full Bench) — AIR 1987 Delhi 239 (judgment dated 27 May 1987) Held that periods during which stay orders were in operation must be excluded while computing the three-year statutory period for issuing a Section 6 notification after Section 4 notification. The Full Bench's computation rule on delay is described as background; it led to remand for merits. The present Court relies on subsequent Division Bench findings in Balak Ram Gupta about Section 5A compliance.
Balak Ram Gupta… v. Union Of India… and Others — 37 (1989) DLT 150 (Division Bench) Examined compliance with Section 5A, importance of the right to be heard, and held that no proper inquiry under Section 5A had been conducted; Collector's reports and sanction vitiated. The present Court adopts and recounts the Division Bench's detailed findings: no hearings shown on record, reports were non‑speaking and based on mechanical application of Munni Lal, and thus acquisition proceedings were unsustainable.
Abhey Ram v. Union of India, (1997) 5 SCC 421 Addressed whether the benefit of the Balak Ram Gupta judgment extended beyond the petitioners whose cases were disposed by that judgment. The Court records that the Supreme Court held the benefit of Balak Ram Gupta was confined to the petitioners who had filed writ petitions; this informs the context of who may claim relief but the present decision proceeds on Section 5A non-compliance.
Delhi Administration v. Gurdip Singh Uban and Others, (2000) 7 SCC 296 Affirmed that the benefit of the Balak Ram Gupta decision did not flow to landowners who had not approached the court; held that landowners who filed objections under Section 5A alone were entitled to independent hearing of their writ petitions. The Court notes the Supreme Court's pronouncement limiting the scope of Balak Ram Gupta; however, because the present case is quashed for Section 5A non-compliance, the bench did not decide issues relating to the effect of Uban on Balak Ram Gupta in respect of sanction under Section 6.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court undertook a fact-specific examination of the record produced in response to the petitioner's application for production of Section 5A hearing records. The respondents produced only: (a) the written objections filed under Section 5A and (b) the Collector's report under Section 5A to the Administrator (Lt. Governor). There was no record of proceedings or notes of hearings before the Collector, either of the original Collector (Shri Shiv Raj Tyagi) who issued notices in January 1984 or of his successor (Shri G. C. Pillai) who made the report on 23 May 1985.

Statutory structure and text: Section 5A(2) requires that every objection be made to the Collector in writing and that the Collector "shall give the objector an opportunity of being heard ... and shall, after hearing all such objections and after making such further inquiry, if any, as he thinks necessary, ... make a report ... together with the record of the proceedings held by him, for the decision of that Government." The Court emphasized the statutory language "together with," indicating that the Collector's report must be accompanied by the record of proceedings.

The Court assessed the Collector's report and found it to be non-speaking and vitiated: it merely tabulated objections, noted the pendency and dismissal of earlier writ petitions (specifically Munni Lal), and disposed of objections by reference to the Munni Lal judgment rather than by independent consideration of each objection. The Division Bench in Balak Ram Gupta had already observed that the reports and the sanction were "an eye wash" and that hearings had not in fact been conducted in a meaningful manner.

On principles of natural justice the Court rejected the respondent's contention that Section 5A hearings are merely administrative and that hearing by one officer and decision/report by another was acceptable. The Court held that where a statute mandates an opportunity to be heard, that requirement cannot be reduced to a formality or circumvented by administrative convenience. The argument that the petitioner did not seek a personal hearing and thus waived it was also rejected, because the statutory duty is on the Collector to give the opportunity to be heard; waiver by silence was not a substitute for the Collector's statutory obligation.

Since the Court found clear non-compliance with Section 5A in the present factual matrix—absence of hearing records, an apparently mechanical and non‑speaking report, and no fresh hearings by the Collector who made the consequential report—it concluded the acquisition proceedings could not be sustained on legal grounds.

The Court explicitly noted that because it was quashing the acquisition proceedings on the basis of Section 5A non-compliance, it need not decide whether Balak Ram Gupta had been overruled by the Supreme Court on the point of sanction under Section 6.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court's final decision was to quash the acquisition proceedings in the facts and circumstances of the case on account of non-compliance with the provisions of Section 5A of the Land Acquisition Act. The opinion states:

ACQUISITION PROCEEDINGS QUASHED.

The Court ordered that there would be no order as to costs.

Implications

  • Direct effect: The acquisition proceedings in respect of the lands in question (village Satbari and the related notifications where Section 5A compliance was absent) are quashed, restoring the direct legal position of the affected landowners as per the Court's ruling.
  • Procedural principle reinforced: The decision underscores that Section 5A's mandatory requirements—an effective opportunity to be heard and a Collector's report accompanied by the record of proceedings—are essential safeguards for landowners and cannot be circumvented by administrative practice or mechanical reports.
  • Scope of decision: The Court did not decide broader questions about the continued effect of Balak Ram Gupta versus subsequent Supreme Court rulings on sanction under Section 6; the judgment rests on non-compliance with Section 5A and does not purport to settle every related point of law between Balak Ram Gupta and the later Supreme Court authorities.

No additional information or inferences beyond those expressly contained in the provided opinion have been included in this summary.

Show all summary ...

Arun Kumar, J.— By this petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India the petitioner has challenged the acquisition proceedings with respect to land comprised in Khasra Numbers 571, 577, 578, 580min, 581, 555, 591, 593, 592, 554 and 592min, totalling 32 bighas 1 biswas situated within the revenue estate of village Satbari within the territory of the State of Delhi. Briefly the facts are that notifications under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act were issued on 5/25th November, 1980 covering large tracts of lands falling in several villages within the Union Territory of Delhi including village Satbari. The object for which the lands were sought to be acquired was stated in the notification as ‘planned development of Delhi’. There have been several rounds of litigation in this court with respect to these lands covered under notifications under Section 4 of the Act. First, the validity of the said notification was challenged by way of writ petitions. These petitions were dismissed vide judgment dated 15th November, 1983 in Munni Lal v. Lt. Governor of Delhi, ILR (1984) 1 delhi 469. section 6 notifications with regard to these villages were issued in May/June 1985 and January/February 1986. These notifications were again challenged. One of the main grounds for challenge was that Section 6 notifications were issued beyond the statutory period of three years provided under the Act There was some difference of opinion between two Benches of this court on the point in issue. Therefore, a Full Bench was constituted which decided the question of delay vide its judgment dated 27th May, 1987 reported as Balak Ram Gupta… v. Union Of India…., AIR 1987 Delhi 239. It was held that the period during which stay orders were in operation had to be excluded while computing the period of three years which is the outside limit set by the statute for issuing a notification under Section 6 of the Act after the notification under Section 4. the cases were remanded back for decision on merits to the Division Bench. The judgment of the Division Bench is reported as Balak Ram Gupta… v. Union Of India…. and Others, 37 (1989) DLT 150. In this case the Division Bench examined in detail the importance of the right of the land owners under Section 5A of the Act. The Bench also examined whether the provisions of section 5a of the Act have been duly complied with. For this purpose the relevant Government records were called and examined in court and on the basis of the records it was found that no proper inquiry under Section 5A of the Act had been conducted and the proceedings were totally vitiated. The court also held that the sanction of the Lt. Governor based on the report of the Collector under Section 5A of the Act was vitiated and was liable to be quashed. Accordingly the petitioners succeeded. In all there were 73 writ petitions challenging the acquisition of land in 11 villages falling in Sough Delhi. These villages included village Satbari in which the lands subject matter of the present writ petition fall. The acquisition proceedings in regard to the 11 villages were quashed. A controversy arose whether the benefit of the decision in Balak Ram Gupta's case was confined to the 73 petitioners whose petitions were disposed of by the said judgement or the benefit will flow to other land owners also. The controversy was ultimately decided by the Supreme Court in Abhey Ram v. Union of India, (1997) 5 SCC 421 followed by Delhi Administration v. Gurdip Singh Uban and Others, (2000) 7 SCC 296. These decisions of the Supreme Court hold that the benefit of the judgment in Balak Ram Gupta's case is confined to the petitioners who had filed writ petitions which were being disposed of by the said judgment i.e 73 writ petitions mentioned in the judgment. According to the Supreme Court the benefit does not flow to rest of the land owners who had not approached the court. It was further held in Uban's case (supra) that land owners who had filed objections under Section 5A of the Act alone were entitled to independent hearing of their writ petitions challenging the acquisition proceedings. Therefore, those land owners who did not file Section 5A objections at all had their fate sealed and they could not challenge the acquisition proceedings.

2. In the present case although the petitioner stated in the original writ petition that he had not filed objections under Section 5A of the Act, the writ petition was amended to state that the petitioner had filed Section 5A objections and the petitioner challenged the acquisition proceedings with respect to his lands. The fact that the petitioner had filed Section 5A objections was not disputed by the respondents. As a matter of fact the name of the petitioner occurs in the list of persons filing Section 5A objections in the report of Collector regarding Section 5A objections. Thus there is no dispute that petitioner had filed objections under Section 5A of the Act.

3. The learned counsel for the petitioner argued that facts in the present case are similar to those in the case of Balak Ram Gupta… v. Union Of India…. and this Court should follow the said judgment. The case turns on the manner in which objections under Section 5A of the Act are said to have been dealt with by the Collector. According to the petitioner there has been total non-compliance of Section 5A of the Act in the present case and the report of the Collector under Section 5A is liable to be struck down with the result that sanction of the Lt. Governor for issuance of Section 6 declaration will also fall. The sanction under Section 6 has to be on the basis of the Collector's report under Section 5A. At this stage it may be worthwhile to reproduce Section 5A:

“5A. Hearing of objections—

(1) Any person interested in any land which has been notified under Section 4, sub-section (1), as being needed or likely to be needed for a public purpose or for a company may, within thirty days from the date of the publication of the notification, object to the acquisition of the land or of any land in the locality, as the case may be.

(2) Every objection under sub-section (1) shall be made to the Collector in writing, and the Collector shall give the objector an opportunity of being heard in person or by any person authorised by him in this behalf or by pleader and shall, after hearing all such objections and after making such further inquiry, if any, as he thinks necessary, either make a report in respect of the land which has been notified under Section 4, sub-section (1), or make different reports in respect of different parcels of such land, to the appropriate Government, containing his recommendations on the objections, together with the record of the proceedings held by him, for the decision of that Government. The decision of the Appropriate Government on the objections shall be final.

(3) For the purposes of this section, a person shall be deemed to be interested in land who would be entitled to claim an interest in compensation if the land were acquired under this Act.”

4. An application was moved on behalf of the petitioner seeking directions to the respondents to produce the relevant records regarding Section 5A hearings. Inspite of several opportunity having been granted to the respondents for purposes of producing the record relating to Section 5A hearings, the counsel for respondents was able to produce only the record containing objections under Section 5A and the report of the Collector under Section 5A to the Administrator i.e the Lt. Governor of Delhi. No record regarding the proceedings held by the Collector under Section 5A or the hearings which the Collector was required to give to the land owners like the petitioner was produced. The learned counsel for the petitioner invited our attention to certain relevant facts in the behalf which are noted in the Division Bench decision of this court in Balak Ram Gupta's case, it appears that the relevant record had been produced before the Bench at that time. The Bench observed that the original record produced before it demonstrated that the reports under Section 5A and sanction for issuance of the declaration under Section 6 issued by the Administration were an eye wash. There had been no hearings before the Collector. Since the record was bulky the Government counsel appearing before the Division Bench tabulated the relevant information based on the records and submitted the same to the Court. The tabulation coming from the Government counsel himself is reproduced in the said judgment. It shows that so far as village Satbari is concerned (to which the present petition relates) Shri Shiv Raj Tyagi was the Land Acquisition Collector who had issued the notices regarding hearing of Section 5A objections to the land owners in January 1984. It is further noted in the said judgment that as per the counter affidavit of the Government filed in the said case Shri Tyagi, the Land Acquisition Collector was transferred in January 1984 itself. There is nothing on record to show that Shri Tyagi conducted any hearings before him under Section 5A of the Act. Shri G.C Pillai succeeded Shri Tyagi as the Land Acquisition Collector of the area. He joined as the Land Acquisition Collector much later. The report under Section 5A with respect to village Satbari was made by Shri G.C, Pillai, the Land Acquisition Collector on 23rd May, 1985. He had ample time to give hearing to the land owners under Section 5A. There is nothing on record to show that Shri pillai ever gave any hearing to the objectors who had filed objections under Section 5A. In fact it is noted in the judgment in Balak Ram Gupta's case that Shri R.K Anand, the counsel appearing for the Government in those cases conceded that he could not support Section 6 notification in regard to the seven villages, which included village Satbari, where Section 5A objections were heard by one Land Acquisition Collector and the report was made by another Land Acquisition Collector without fresh hearings. Thus there is nothing on record to show that there was any compliance of Section 5A of the Act, Section 5A sub-section (2) casts a duty on the Collector to give the objectors an opportunity of being heard either in person or by pleader and it is after hearing of such objections and after making further inquiry, if any, that he has to make a report with respect to the land notified under Section A of the Act to the appropriate government containing his recommendations on the objections together with report of proceedings held by him. Thus the requirement of section is that the report of the Collector has to accompany the record of proceedings held by the Collector under Section 5A. The words used are “together with”. The record submitted with the report of the Collector in the present case contains only the objections under Section 5A and the report of the Collector. There is no record of any hearing conducted either before the previous Collector or before Shri Pillai who made the report under Section 5A to the appropriate Government. Thus in the facts of the present case there has been a complete negation of the right conferred on the land owners under Section 5A of the Act. The importance of the right under Section 5A can hardly be overemphasised. This right is the only safeguard for a land owner who is deprived of his land compulsorily by the Government in exercise of its power of eminent domain.

5. Apart from the fact that there is no record of hearing under Section 5A of the Act by the Collector in the present case, the report of the Collector itself is totally vitiated. In the report of Collector notes that consequent to the notice for hearing under Sections 5A, 183 persons filed objections. They were given opportunity to file evidence i.e documentary evidence or written arguments “for proper hearing”. Thereafter the report gives the list of 183 persons who filed objections. The objections are thereafter tabulated into different heads. The Collector notes that Munni Lal etc. filed writ petitions in the High Court of Delhi, being CWP No. 426 of 1981 challenging the validity of the notification under Section 4 of the Act. Thereafter several other writ petitions were filed and stay orders were obtained from the High Court. He notes that all the writ petitions were dismissed by the High Court by the judgment dated 15th November, 1983 in Munni Lal's case (supra). The Collector then proceeds to note that all the objections tabulated by the Collector in his report were dealt with by the High Court in the writ petition filed by Munni Lal etc. CWP No. 426 of 1981. The Collector opined that there was no force in the objections. The objections are of general nature and are not tenable. Accordingly the Collector recommended acquisition of the land. It will be seen that this report proceeds only on the basis of the judgment of this court in Munni Lal's case. It does not show any independent consideration of the issues raised before the Collector. The Division Bench in Balak Ram Gupta's case observed that it was incumbent on the Collector to consider each objection separately. Further it was observed that the report of the Collector was non-speaking and was vitiated on account of non-application of mind. It showed a mechanical approach on the part of the Collector in disposing of the objections on the basis of the judgment in Munni Lal's case and at places the judgment in Munni Lal's case was wrongly interpreted and applied by the Collector. The basic fallacy in compliance of the provisions of section 5a was also highlighted. The original file did not contain any notes of hearing maintained by the previous Land Acquisition Collector Shiv Raj Tyagi who supposedly heard the objections. The Land Acquisition Collector Shri Pillai who made the report under Section 5A admittedly did not give any hearing. Thus he did not have any benefit of the alleged hearing before his predecessor. Arbitrariness, therefore is writ large. It is gross violation of principles of natural justice that hearing is given by one authority and decision is given by another. The Division Bench in Balak Ram Gupta's case also observed that it had inde-pendently examined the legal requirements under Section 5A of the Act and the original record which showed that there was no effective and real opportunity of being heard to the petitioners. Therefore, it had come to the conclusion that the land acquisition proceedings could not be sustained in law. A hearing under Section 5A has to be an effective hearing. As already stated Section 5A is the only protection for a land owner whose land is sought to be acquired without his consent in exercise of power of eminent domain by the Government.

6. The learned counsel for the respondent tried to argue that conducting Section 5A hearing is an administrative act. It is not a judicial or quasi judicial inquiry. The Collector only makes a report to the appropriate Government and the final decision is to be taken by the Government. Therefore, hearing by one person and report by another person cannot be a ground of challenge. We do not agree. It is a basic principle of natural justice that when a hearing is required to be given under a mandatory provision in a statute, it cannot be allowed to be reduced to a farce in the sense that hearing is provided by one officer and decision is taken by another officer. The very argument is reprehensible.

7. Next it was argued on behalf of the respondents that the petitioner did not ask for any personal hearing and, therefore, he is deemed to have given up the right of hearing. This argument is contrary to the very provision of the statute which requires the Collector to give an opportunity of being heard to the person concerned. The Act says - “the Collector shall give the objector an opportunity of being heard. “As already held there is nothing on record to show that the Collector complied with this mandatory requirement in the present case. The fact that similar objections were considered and rejected by this court in another case is no ground to suggest that Section 5A need not have been complied with in the present case.

8. We find no merit in any of the submission made on behalf of the respondents.

9. The learned counsel for the respondents argued that Balak Ram Gupta's case has been overruled by the Supreme Court in Gurdip Singh Uban's case (supra) on the point of sanction of the Lt. Governor under Section 6 of the Act. In view of the fact that we are quashing the acquisition proceedings on account of non-compliance of the Section 5A of the Act, we need not go into this aspect.

10. The result of the above discussion is that on account of non-compliance with the provisions of section 5a of the Act in the facts and circumstances of the case, the acquisition proceedings are quashed. There will be no order as to costs.