Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Indian Overseas Bank v. R. M. Marketing And Services Pvt. Ltd.

Delhi High Court
May 16, 2001
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Indian Overseas Bank, a nationalised bank constituted under the Banking Companies (Acquisition and Transfer of Undertakings) Act, 1970, filed this suit for recovery of Rs. 7,92,563.46p. The plaint alleges that the defendant No. 1 (a company engaged in consultancy, engineering services, assembly and fabrication of automatic capsule machinery) sought various loan facilities from the bank, including a cash credit limit of Rs. 1,00,000. For that facility several documents were executed, including board resolutions (dated 19 October 1981 and 31 August 1983), a demand promissory note dated 20 October 1983, a continuity letter (F-16), a deed of hypothecation dated 20 October 1983, Form No. 8 under the Companies Act, 1956, and a letter of undertaking by the company.

Defendants 2 and 3 furnished personal guarantees (guarantee dated 30 April 1983 for Rs. 12 lakhs), and defendant 2 furnished additional guarantees dated 12 October 1983 and 20 October 1983 each for Rs. 1 lakh. A cash credit account was opened and Rs. 1 lakh was transferred into that account. The account was overdrawn and the defendant company failed to clear the cash credit. On 28 June 1986 the bank sought adjustment; the defendants confirmed a debit balance of Rs. 4,36,217.45p and defendant No. 2 signed a revival letter (No. F-301 dated 28 June 1986) as Managing Director. Interest was agreed at 13.5% with quarterly rests, and by the date of filing the plaint the outstanding (including interest debited periodically) was stated as Rs. 7,92,563.46p.

Summons were served on all defendants. Only defendants 1 and 2 initially appeared and filed a written statement; issues were framed on 18 September 2000. Subsequently, defendants 1 and 2 ceased to appear and all defendants were proceeded against ex parte. The plaintiff was permitted to lead evidence by affidavit. The bank filed the affidavit of Shri B. S. Jait, Assistant Manager, and exhibited various transaction documents, guarantees, balance confirmation and revival letter, a certified statement of account and a legal notice. The affidavit also recorded that defendant No. 3 paid Rs. 5,92,887.70p during the pendency of the suit and was thereby absolved from liability; after adjusting that payment the bank sought a decree for Rs. 1,96,675.76p.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the plaint has been signed and filed by the authorised person?
  2. Whether the plaint has been filed within limitation?
  3. To what rate of interest the plaintiff is entitled from the defendants?
  4. Whether the suit is maintainable against defendant No. 2?

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Procedural posture and evidence: After defendants ceased to appear, the court proceeded ex parte and permitted the plaintiff to prove its case by affidavit. The plaintiff placed on record a Power of Attorney (Exh. PW.1/1) evidencing authority of the bank officer who signed and verified the plaint, documentary loan documentation executed by the defendant company (Exh. PW.1/4 to PW.1/8), personal guarantees of defendants 2 and 3 (Exh. PW.1/9 to PW.1/12), a balance confirmation by the corporate defendant (Exh. PW.1/13), the revival letter (Exh. PW.1/14), a legal notice (Exh. PW.1/15) and a statement of account certified by bankers under the Evidence Act.

Proof of liability: The court accepted the bank's documentary proof as establishing the existence of the cash credit facility, the overdrawn account and the personal guarantees furnished by defendants 2 and 3. The balance as claimed (Rs. 7,92,563.46p) was supported by the certified statement of account and related exhibits. The affidavit also established that defendant No. 3 made a payment of Rs. 5,92,887.70p during litigation and was subsequently absolved from liability by the bank.

Liability of other persons: The defendants 4 to 6 were impleaded as directors of defendant No. 1, but the court noted (on the basis of the materials) that they had not given personal guarantees. The opinion states that merely being directors of a company incorporated under the Companies Act does not render them personally liable for the company's borrowings in the absence of personal guarantees; accordingly, they could not be fastened with the loan liability.

Application of relief: Taking the admitted and proved figures together with the payment made by defendant No. 3 and the bank's discharge of defendant No. 3, the court calculated the adjusted balance due from the remaining liable defendants. The court then passed a decree for the adjusted amount together with interest and costs. The order does not elaborate any broader legal principle beyond these findings, nor does it provide an extended analysis of the interest rate applied in the decree.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Decree for Rs. 1,96,675.76p was passed against defendants No. 1 (the corporate borrower) and No. 2 (a personal guarantor), together with interest at the rate of 16.5% per annum from the date of institution of the suit until recovery, and costs.

Direct consequences for the parties: - The bank obtains a monetary decree for Rs. 1,96,675.76p plus interest at 16.5% p.a. from the date of institution until recovery and costs against defendants 1 and 2. - Defendant No. 3, having paid Rs. 5,92,887.70p and been absolved by the bank, is not subject to a decree in this suit. - Defendants 4 to 6 (directors) are not held personally liable because they did not furnish personal guarantees; the company (defendant No. 1) remains the liable corporate entity.

Wider implications: - The opinion contains no statement of a new legal principle or precedent. The decision operates as a final determination of the bank's claim on the facts presented in this case and the documentary proof accepted by the court.

Order: Order accordingly.

Show all summary ...

This suit is filed by Indian Overseas Bank which is a nationalised Bank and a body corporate constituted under the Banking Companies (Acquisition and Transfer of Undertakings) Act, 1970. The suit is for recovery of Rs. 7,92,563.46p. Averments contained in the plaint are that the defendant No. 1 which is engaged in carrying on business of providing consultancy and engineering service to foreign and Indian buyers, assembly and fabrication of automatic capsule etc. approached the plaintiff-Bank for sanction of various loan facilities and among these was a cash credit limit of Rs. 1 lakh. The plaintiff-Bank considered the request of the defendant No. 1 and sanctioned among other facilities a cash credit limit to the tune of Rs. 1 lakh for which the following documents were executed:—

1. Resolutions dated 19th October, 1981 and 31st August, 1983.

2. Demand Promissory Note for Rs. 1 lakh dated 20th October, 1983.

3. Letter of continuity F-16) for Rs. 1 lakh.

4. Deed of Hypothecation in case of open advance dated 20th October, 1983 for Rs. 1 lakh.

5. Form No. 8 on the Companies Act, 1956.

6. Letter of Undertaking by the Company.

2. The defendants 2 and 3 gave personal guarantees dated 30th April, 1983 for Rs. 12 lakhs and defendant No. 2 gave another guarantee dated 12th October, 1983 for Rs. 1 lakh and another personal guarantee dated 20th October, 1983 for Rs. 1 lakh. A Cash Credit Account was opened with the plaintiff-Bank in its Defence Colony Branch and the amount of Rs. 1 lakh was transferred to the said account. The defendant No. 1 availed the loan and it was kept over drawn however it did not adhere to the clearing of cash credit limits. The plaintiff approached the defendant No. 1 for adjusting the loan amount on 28th June, 1986. The defendants confirmed the debit balance of Rs. 4,36,217.45p. Revival letter No. F-301 dated 28th June, 1986 was also signed by the defendant No. 2 as Managing Director of the defendant No. 1. However, even thereafter the outstanding amount was not adjusted. The defendant had agreed to pay interest @ 13.5% at quarterly rests. The amount was debited from time to time with the aforesaid interest and as on the date of filing of the suit the amount came to Rs. 7,92,563.46p.

3. Summons in the suit were duly served on all the defendants. However, only the defendants 1 and 2 appeared and filed the written statement. Following issues were framed on 18th September, 2000:—

1. Whether the plaint has been signed and filed by the authorised person?

2. Whether the plaint has been filed within limitation?

3. To what rate of interest, the plaintiff is entitled from the defendants?

4. Whether the suit is maintainable against defendant No. 2?

4. Thereafter, the defendants 1 and 2 also stopped appearing and all the defendants were proceeded ex parte. The plaintff was allowed to lead evidence by way of affidavit. The plaintff has filed the affidavit of Shri B. S. Jait, Assistant Manager, Indian Overseas Bank, Defence Colony Branch, Defence Colony, New Delhi. He has proved on record various documents as well. Exh. PW. 1/1 is the Power of Attorney in favour of Shri S. S. Sharma, the then Chief Manager, Indian Overseas Bank, Defence Colony Branch, Defence Colony, New Delhi who has signed and verified the plaint and have filed this suit. Various documents executed by the defendant No. 1 are exhibited as Exh. PW. 1/4 to PW. 1/8. The personal guarantees of the defendants 2 and 3 are exhibited as Exh. PW. 1/9 to PW. 1/12. The balance confirmation given by the defendant No. 1 is exhibited as Exh. PW. 1/13 and the revival letter is Exh. PW. 1/14. The plaintiff-bank has also given legal notice which is Exh. PW. 1/15. The witness has also stated that as per the record a total amount of Rs. 7,92,563.46p. is outstanding. Statement of account duly certified by the bankers under the Evidence Act has been filed along with the plaint. In the affidavit, it is also stated that the defendant No. 3 has paid a sum of Rs. 5,92,887.70p during the pendency of the suit and the defendant has absovled him from the liabilities. After adjusting the aforesaid payment, as per this affidavit, balance sum of Rs. 1,96,675.76p only is due and decree for this amount is prayed for.

5. The defendants 4 to 6 are also implead-ed on the ground that they were Directors of the defendant No. 1. However, these defendants did not give any personal guarantee for due payment of loan and simply because they were Directors of the defendant No. 1 they could not be fastened with the liability as the defendant No. 1 which is a Company incorported under the Companies Act is separate legal entity. The defendants 2 and 3 would be liable as Guarantors. Since the defendant No. 3 has also been absolved from the liabilities no decree need to be passed against the defendant No. 3 as well.

6. Decree in the sum of Rs. 1,96,675.76p is accordingly passed against the defendants 1 and 2 along with interest on this amount @ 16.5% per annum from the date of institution of suit till recovery thereof. The plaintiff shall also be entitled to cost. Decree be drawn accordingly.

Order accordingly.