- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sonu Systems Pvt. Ltd v. Chairman, Central Board Of Direct Taxes & Ors
Factual and Procedural Background
The writ petition challenged the correctness of searches conducted under Section 132 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 and the legality of an order under Section 142(2A) of the Act. The searches in question were carried out on 22 June 1998 and 7 July 1998 at premises identified as C-397, Chadha Complex, Main Market, Bhajanpura, Delhi. The petitioner is a company incorporated on 31 May 1993 with a registered office in Bhajanpura.
On 22 June 1998, the Assistant Director of Income-tax (A.D.I.T) searched and sealed the premises and a panchnama was prepared. The search warrant and panchnama referred to Sonu Systems Pvt. Ltd., whereas the petitioner is a private limited company. A further search on 7 July 1998 was said to be a continuation; that panchnama recorded that seals placed on 22 June 1998 were intact and noted materials relating to New Star Cable (N.S.C), with which the petitioner claimed no connection.
The petitioner learned of departmental action after receiving a notice dated 25 May 2000 under Section 158-BC, asking it to file a return for the block period. On inspection of the seized records, the petitioner contended there was no authorisation for searching the petitioner company and replied to the notice claiming the search was unauthorized and the action incompetent because Clauses (a), (b) or (c) of sub-section (1) of Section 132 were not violated. The petitioner also stated that its business had ceased on 15 February 1997 and that books of account had been destroyed in a fire on 10 December 1996.
On 14 July 2000, the Joint Commissioner passed an order under Section 142(2A) appointing Dinesh Mehta & Co. to audit the seized material and the regular books of the assessee for the entire block period. The petition challenges that action and seeks relief on the ground the search authorisation was improper.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the searches conducted on 22 June 1998 and 7 July 1998 were validly authorised under Section 132 of the Income-tax Act, 1961, given the petitioner's contention that there was no proper authorisation by a competent person in respect of the property searched.
- Whether the order passed under Section 142(2A) of the Income-tax Act, dated 14 July 2000 (appointing an auditor to examine the seized material and books), was legally sustainable. (Note: the opinion records that no argument was advanced on this second plea at the time of hearing.)
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The search authorisation was invalid because it was purportedly issued by an "Additional Deputy Director of Income-tax," but, according to the petitioner, there is no post of Additional Deputy Director under Section 2(28) (or related definitions) and therefore the authorisation was not by a competent person.
- The petitioner asserted it had carried on business only until 15 February 1997, suffered losses, had no positive income and had not filed returns; books of accounts were allegedly destroyed in a fire on 10 December 1996.
- On the basis that the alleged authorisation was defective, the petitioner asked that the notice dated 25 May 2000 be vacated and the proceedings dropped.
Revenue's Arguments
- The search was conducted after valid authorisation by the competent authority. The warrant and panchnama referred to Sonu Systems Pvt. Ltd., and the A.D.I.T (Investigation), Unit-III, issued and signed the authorisation dated 22 June 1998.
- The A.D.I.T sealed the premises at C-397, Chadha Complex, and the panchnama recorded that the pancha witnesses were called on 22 June 1998 on the basis of the warrant of authorisation. The 7 July 1998 search was a continuation of the proceedings begun on 22 June 1998; inventories were made and a further panchnama was prepared.
- During the 7 July search, it emerged that the premises had been given on rent to New Star Cable (N.S.C). Statements recorded (including that of Atul Kapoor, proprietor of N.S.C) noted that a Sonu Systems board was on the premises and that T.R. Chadha was the main person in Sonu Systems Pvt. Ltd., supporting the relevance of seized documents.
- Reference was made to departmental records (including a sales-tax return showing the address) and it was submitted that the Chief Commissioner’s transfer order of 7 September 1998 (transferring certain cases) did not affect the validity of the action taken against the premises where incriminating documents were found.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court first examined the statutory framework and relevant definitions in the Income-tax Act as they stood after legislative amendments. The opinion notes insertion and substitution of defined expressions by various Finance Acts (references to insertion w.e.f. 1 October 1998 and changes effected by earlier amendments), and it quotes the then-current definition of "Director General or Director" as including Additional Director, Joint Director, Assistant Director or Deputy Director of Income-tax.
The court addressed the petitioner's contention that there was no post of "Additional Deputy Director" and that the panchnama's reference to "Additional Deputy Director" rendered the authorisation invalid. The court observed the following facts from the original records:
- The order was in fact passed by the Additional Director of Income-tax on 22 June 1998.
- The authorisations were issued to named officers (Shri Rattan Singh, Anil Kumar, Yogesh Kumar and Vikram Sahay) and were in respect of Sonu Systems Pvt. Ltd., at the C-397 address.
- The authorisation on the record was done by the Additional Director; the panchnama contained a clerical omission whereby the printed format showed "Deputy" which was corrected by addition of the word "Additional" without deletion of "Deputy."
The court held that this clerical omission in the panchnama was innocuous. It stated that an innocuous clerical mistake in the printed form (failure to delete the word "Deputy" when adding "Additional") cannot invalidate or nullify a legitimate action where the substantive record shows the officer acted in the capacity of Additional Director and the authorisation was in fact signed by that officer. The court observed that the petitioner's counsel had fairly accepted there was no post of Additional Deputy Director and that the officer who signed the warrant was acting as Additional Director, which supported the Revenue's position.
The court therefore found no substance in the petitioner's contention that the search was illegal for want of competent authorisation. The opinion also records that no other plea was pressed by the petitioner at the hearing.
Holding and Implications
DISMISSED.
The writ petition was dismissed. The direct effect is that the court upheld the validity of the searches conducted on 22 June 1998 and 7 July 1998 and did not grant relief to the petitioner on the ground of defective authorisation. The court treated the reference to "Additional Deputy Director" in the printed panchnama form as a clerical error that did not vitiate the authorisation actually signed by the Additional Director.
The opinion does not discuss broader implications or purport to lay down a new precedent; its effect, as recorded in the text, is the dismissal of the petition and the validation of the impugned search authorisation on the facts and records before the court.
Arijit Pasayat, C.J— In the writ petition filed correctness of a search conducted, in terms of Section 132 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (in short the “Act”), and legality of an order under Section 142(2A) of the Act have been questioned. Legality of the search conducted on 22nd June 1998 and 7th July 1998 is questioned on the ground that there was no proper authorisation for the search by a competent person in respect of the property, wherein the said search was carried out. But at the time of hearing no argument was advanced in respect of the second plea i.e relating to order under Section 142 (2A) of the Act.
2. Background, as projected by the petitioner, is essentially as follows:—
Petitioner company was incorporated on 31st May 1993 having its registered office at B-362/17, Gali No. 16, Block B, Bhajanpura, Delhi. On 22nd June 1998 Assistant Director of Income-tax, Unit IV (in short “A.D.I.T”) searched the premises C-397, Chadha Complex, main market, Bhajanpura, Delhi and sealed the premises. A Panchnama was prepared. Search party was authorised to search on Sonu Systems, whereas the petitioner is a private limited company. On 7th July 1998 a second search party again searched the premises in question. It was stated that the search was in continuation of the proceedings on 22nd June 1998. Panchnama was prepared and some loose papers and books containing cable connection holders and receipt books belonging to New Star Cable television (in short “N.S.C”) were found, with which the petitioner has no concern. Name of N.S.C did not find place in the panchnama dated 22nd June 1998, but in the panchnama dated 7th July 1998, name of N.S.C was specifically mentioned in bracket. In the said panchhnama, it was also specifically mentioned that seals placed on 22nd June 1998 were fdund intact. On 7th September 1998 Chief Commissioner of Income-tax (in short the “Chief Commissioner”) passed an order under Section 127 of the Act, whereby cases relating to Shri Tilak Raj Chadha, Chadha Cloth House, Prop. Smt. Veena Chadha and one Sonu Systems were transferred from Ward 24(6) to Deputy Commissioner, SR-36 for investigation and administrative convenience. Petitioner came to know about it on 9th June 2000, when he inspected departmental records after receipt of notice dated 25th May 2000. By the said notice, purported to have been issued under Section 158-BC of the Act, petitioner was asked to file true and correct return in the prescribed form No. 2B for the block period, mentioned in the notice. After receipt of said notice on 30th May 2000, petitioner applied for inspection of the seized records. After inspection, petitioner came to know that there was no authorisation for search against the petitioner company, and obtained copies of the documents. On 9th June 2000 petitioner submitted its reply to the notice dated 25th May 2000. It was specifically mentioned that, the notice is bad and illegal, as there was no authorisation for search in relation to the petitioner. As there was no violation of the provisions of Clauses (a), (b) or (c) of sub-section (1) of Section 132, the action was incompetent. It was further stated that, petitioner only carried on business between 31st May 1993 to 15th February 1997, and suffered huge losses and ultimately on 15th February, 1997 business was closed down. As there was huge losses and there was no positive income, return had not been filed under the Act. Therefore the Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax (in short the “Dy. Commissioner”) was requested to vacate the notice dated 25th May 2000 and drop the proceedings. On 19th June 2000, Joint Commissioner of Income-tax (in short “Jt. Commissioner”) issued a letter, whereby petitioner was informed that the case had been transferred to his jurisdiction and that reply dated 12th June 2000 to the notice dated 25th May 2000 was without substance, as from the panchnama dated 22nd June 1998 and 7th July 1998, it was evident that warrants were issued to search premises at C-397, Chadha Complex, Main Market, Bhajanpura, Delhi. Petitioner was again directed to file the return of income in form 2B.
On 5th July 2000 Petitioner supplied the details of sales and brought to the notice of the Jt. Commissioner that books of accounts were not available, as they were burnt in the fire, which broke out on 10th December 1996. On 14th July 2000 Jt. Commissioner passed an order under Section 142(2A) of the Act, whereby Dinesh Mehta & Co., a Chartered Accountant firm, were appointed to audit the seized material, alongwith regular books of accounts maintained by the assessee for the entire block period, and submit report by 8th December, 2000. Petition has been filed to challenge such action.
3. Petitioner in support of the stand, that there was no proper authorisation by the competent authority, submitted that the same was by Additional Deputy Director of Income-tax (Investigation). Reference is made to Section 2(28) of the Act to contend that there was no post of Additional Deputy Director of Income-tax in existence and therefore, the authorisation was not in order. Learned counsel for the Revenue, on the other hand, submitted that the search was conducted after authorisation by the competent authority. A copy of the warrant clearly mentioned the name of Sonu Systems Pvt. Ltd. The Panchnama also mentions the name of the party searched i.e Sonu Systems Pvt. Ltd. The A.D.I.T sealed the premises on 22nd June 1998. The premises sealed were at C-397, Chadha Complex, Main Market, Bhajanpura, Delhi. The Panchnama was prepared on the basis of proper warrant of authorisation in the name of Sonu Systems Pvt. Ltd., which was issued and signed by the A.D.I.T (Investigation), Unit-III. On 7th July 1998 search was conducted in continuation of the proceedings, which started on 22nd June 1998. Inventories were made of the seized documents and a panchnama was prepared. On 7th July 1998 during search operation, it was found that the premises had been given on rent by the assessee to N.S.C, as stated by Atul Kapoor, proprietor of N.S.C His statement was also recorded. In the statement, Atul Kapoor stated that the board of Sonu Systems Pvt. Ltd. was hanging on the premises prior to his taking the premises on rent. He also stated that, to the best of his knowledge, Sh. T.R Chadha was the main person in Sonu Systems Pvt. Ltd. That being the background, seized documents can be used against the petitioner. Search was a consequence of an action on Shri T.R Chadha Group, as is evident from the search warrant and the same has been signed and authorised by the A.D.I.T, Unit-III on 22nd June 1998. Name of Sonu Systems Pvt. Ltd. C-397, Chadha Complex, Main Market, Bhajanpura, Delhi is duly mentioned in the authorisation on page (2) para (1) of the panchnama. It is clearly stated that the panchas were called on 22nd June 1998 at 8.30 A.M on the basis of warrant of authorisation dated 22nd June 1998. The date 19th June 1998 mentioned in the restraint order under Section 132(3) of the Act is the date on which original warrant in the case of T.R Chadha group was signed. Reference was made to the copy of Sales-tax return, wherein the party's address was stated to be C-397, Main Market, Bhajanpura, Delhi, from where the incriminating documents were seized. It was submitted that order dated 7th September 1998 by the Chief Commissioner of Income-tax, Delhi does not pertain to the assessee and is irrelevant for the purpose of the case at hand. In the aforesaid background, it has been contended that the writ petition is thoroughly misconceived.
4. Before we go to the factual position, highlighted by the parties, it is necessary to take note of a few provisions of the Act. Section 2(28C) was inserted w.e.f 1st October 1998 by Finance (No. 2) Act, 1998. Section 2(28D) was also inserted w.e.f the said date. Expression “Joint Commissioner” means a person appointed to be a Joint Commissioner or an Additional Commissioner under sub-section (1) of Section 117. “Joint Director” means a person appointed to be a Joint Director or an Additional Director under sub-section (1) of Section 117. Section 2(21) deals with Director General or Director. By Direct Tax Laws (Amendment) Act, 1987, w.e.f 1st April 1998, the definition was changed. Prior to the substitution it reads as follows:
“'Director of Inspection’ means a person appointed to be a Director of Inspection under sub-section (1) of Section 117 and includes a person appointed to be an Additional Director of Inspection, a Deputy Director of Inspection or an Assistant Director of Inspection”.
After substitution, it reads presently as follows:
“'Director General or Director’ means a person appointed to be a Director General of Income-tax or, as the case may be, a Director of income-tax, under sub-section (1) of Section 117, and includes a person appointed under that sub-section to be an Additional Director of Income-tax or a Joint Director of Income-tax or an Assistant Director or Deputy Director of Income-tax.”
It is to be noted that expression “an Additional Director of Income-tax” was inserted by Finance Act, 1994 w.e.f 1st June 1994. The word “Joint” as presently appearing was substituted for “Deputy” by Finance (No. 2) Act, 1998 w.e.f 1st October 1998. Similarly the expression “word Deputy Director” was inserted by said Finance (No. 2) Act 1998.
Much has been made of what is mentioned in the panchnama where the expression “Deputy Director” which was already existing was corrected by addition of the word “Additional” without deletion of the word “Deputy”. It is fairly accepted by learned counsel for the petitioner that there is no post of Additional Deputy Director. We have perused the original records produced before us. They clearly show that the order was passed by the Additional Director of Income-tax on 22nd June 1998. The authorisations were issued to Shri Rattan Singh, Anil Kumar, Yogesh Kumar and Vikram Sahay. The authorisation was in respect of Sonu Systems Pvt. Ltd., C-397, Chadha Complex, Main Market, Bhajanpura, Delhi. The records clearly reveal that the authorisation was done by the Additional Director. An innocuous omission to delete the word “Deputy” from the panchnama in the printed format cannot effect validity of the search. If such clerical mistake or omission are used as the foundation for nullifying or otherwise to prevent legitimate action, that would be improper and inappropriate. It has been fairly accepted by learned counsel for petitioner that the officer who had signed the warrant of authorisation was acting as the Additional Director. That lends credence to the stand of the Revenue. An innocuous mistake in deleting the word “Deputy” should not be fatal to the legality of the search. We find no substance in the plea that the search conducted was illegal. As indicated above, no other plea has been pressed into service.
Writ application is accordingly dismissed.
Alert