Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Net Ram & Another v. Union Of India & Ors

Delhi High Court
Jul 14, 2000
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Provided Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This judgment addresses a batch of twenty-two writ petitions consolidated because the dispute in all of them was common. A Single Judge referred the matters to a Larger Bench (Full Bench) due to conflicting views expressed by two Division Benches and a Single Judge of the Court, and because the Single Judge did not subscribe to those views.

The factual matrix, as recorded in the opinion, is as follows. On 23.6.1989 a notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 was issued for a large tract of land for the planned development of Delhi (channelisation of the Yamuna). Declarations under Sections 6 and 17(1) followed on 22.6.1990. Awards were made by the Land Acquisition Collector on 19.6.1992. Possession of the land was not taken over at once but in parcels between December 1990 and September 1995. Compensation was paid to the petitioners in the years 1994–1995. The petitioners claimed interest on the compensation from the date of the award until actual payment at rates of 15% or 18% per annum, relying on earlier orders of this Court in "Slier Singh v. Union of India (CWP 3095/92) dated 15.10.1993", "Rampal v. Union of India (CW 3994/95) dated 26.3.1995" and the Single Judge order in CWP 1483/96 dated 25.4.1997.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a direction can be given to grant interest on the amount of compensation from the date of the award until actual payment at rates of 15% or 18% per annum (as claimed by the petitioners).
  2. Whether, when exercising jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution, a court may direct payment of interest in a manner not contemplated by Sections 28 or 34 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners sought interest on compensation from the date of the award until actual payment at rates of 15% or 18% per annum.
  • The petitioners placed reliance on earlier orders of this Court, namely "Slier Singh v. Union of India (CWP 3095/92) dated 15.10.1993", "Rampal v. Union of India (CW 3994/95) dated 26.3.1995", and the Single Judge order in CWP 1483/96 dated 25.4.1997, as authority for awarding such interest.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondents' legal arguments in opposition to the petitioners' claims.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Slier Singh v. Union of India (CWP 3095/92) dated 15.10.1993 Relied upon by petitioners as authority for awarding interest beyond the statutory scheme. The Full Bench held that this decision does not indicate the correct position in law.
Rampal v. Union of India (CW 3994/95) dated 26.3.1995 Relied upon by petitioners as authority for awarding interest beyond the statutory scheme. The Full Bench held that this decision does not indicate the correct position in law.
CWP 1483/96 dated 25.4.1997 (Single Judge) Relied upon by petitioners as authority for awarding interest beyond the statutory scheme. The Full Bench held that this decision does not indicate the correct position in law.
Union of India v. Budh Singh (1995) 6 SCC 233 That Sections 28 and 34 of the Land Acquisition Act are the only provisions dealing with payment of interest to land owners; statute covers the entire field of State liability to pay interest. The Full Bench relied on this Apex Court decision to support the proposition that courts cannot impose interest beyond the statutory rates or for periods not contemplated by the statute.
State of Himachal Pradesh v. Dharam Das (1995) 5 SCC 683 When the statute prescribes payment of interest, a court has no power to award interest other than in the manner prescribed; equitable considerations cannot be used to alter statutory scheme. The Full Bench relied on this decision to reinforce that equitable jurisdiction cannot extend or modify the statutory scheme for awarding interest.
Union of India v. Dhanwanti Devi and Ors. (1996) 5 SCC 44 Rejected the contention that legislative omission (of solatium and interest) obliges the State to pay on equitable grounds; legislative omission does not automatically create equitable liability. The Full Bench cited this decision to support the proposition that courts cannot supplement statutory omissions on equitable grounds.
Ashok Nagar Plot Holders Association v. State of U.P (1997) 10 SCC 77 Liability to pay interest to claimants arises only in accordance with Section 34; the Act is a self-contained code and common law principles of equity cannot be extended contrary to the statute. The Full Bench relied on this authority to conclude that interest is payable only as per the statutory provision (Section 34) and not otherwise.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Full Bench proceeded on the premise that the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 is a complete code governing acquisition of land, payment of compensation, solatium and additional market value, and the manner and rate of payment of interest. It identified Sections 28 and 34 as the only provisions in the Act that deal with payment of interest to persons entitled to compensation.

The Court reproduced and considered the text of Sections 28 and 34. Section 34 prescribes interest at 9% per annum from the date of taking possession until payment, and a proviso increases the rate to 15% per annum on any unpaid portion after one year from taking possession. Section 28 permits a court to direct payment of interest at nine per centum per annum on excess compensation awarded by the Court over the Collector's award, from the date possession was taken until payment into Court.

The Full Bench relied on Supreme Court authorities (Union of India v. Budh Singh; State of Himachal Pradesh v. Dharam Das; Union of India v. Dhanwanti Devi; Ashok Nagar Plot Holders Association v. State of U.P.) to support the legal principle that where a statute prescribes the rates and periods for payment of interest, courts lack power to impose interest in a different manner or beyond statutory terms. The Court quoted the Apex Court's observations that the statute covers the entire field of the State's liability to pay interest and that courts cannot award interest anterior to publication of Section 4(1) notification or in excess of statutory rates.

Applying these principles to the facts, the Full Bench concluded that while exercising jurisdiction under Article 226, the High Court cannot direct payment of interest in a manner not contemplated by Sections 28 or 34 of the Act. Consequently, decisions of this Court (Sher Singh, Ram Pal and the Single Judge's CWP 1483/96) permitting interest in a manner inconsistent with the statutory scheme were held not to represent the correct position of law.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Full Bench held that there is no scope, under Article 226, for directing payment of interest on compensation in a manner not contemplated by Sections 28 or 34 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894. The writ petitions were not entertained (i.e., not allowed).

Implications:

  • The Court expressly concluded that earlier decisions of this Court in Sher Singh, Ram Pal and CWP 1483/96 do not state the correct position of law on awarding interest beyond the statutory provisions.
  • As a remedial direction, the Full Bench noted the petitioners' grievance that amounts payable under Sections 28 or 34 may not have been paid; the Court directed that if such amounts remain unpaid, steps should be taken to effect payment within two months from the date of the judgment.
  • The decision confines the award of interest to the rates and periods prescribed by Sections 28 and 34 and rejects reliance on equitable principles to obtain interest beyond that statutory scheme.

Cases disposed of accordingly.

Show all summary ...

Arijit Pasayat, C.J— As the dispute in these twenty two writ petitions is common, this judgment will govern each one of them. While hearing the batch of writ petitions, learned Single Judge felt that on account of views expressed by two Division Benches and a Single Judge, to which he did not subscribe to avoid uncertainty adjudication by the Full Bench is needed.

2. The question is whether direction for grant of interest can be given in respect of the amount of compensation from the date of award till the actual payment @ 15% or 18%, as the case may be. A brief reference to the factual aspects would suffice. On 23.6.1989, notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act. 1894 (in short, the Act) was issued in respect of large tract of land in the revenue estate of village Kilokari, Nangli Razapur, Khirabad and Behlopur Khadar for the planned development of Delhi i.e channalisalion of Yamuna river. This was followed by declarations under Sections 6 and 17(1) of the Act issued on 22.6.1990 Ultimately, awards were made by the Land Acquisition Collector (ME) on 19.6.1.992 Possession of the land was not taken over by the Collector. Land Acquisition in one go but the same was taken over in parcels from time to time from December 1990 upto September, 1995. Compensation was paid to the petitioner in each case sometime in 1994-1995. Interest has been claimed by the petitioner in each case at the rate of 15% 18% per annum from the date of the award till the date of actual payment. Reliance has been placed by the petitioners in two orders passed by Division Benches of this Court in Slier Singh v. Union of India (CWP 3095/92) dated 15.10.1993 and Rampal v. Union of India, (CW 3994/95) dated 26.3.1995 and the order of the Single Judge in CWP 1483/96 dated 25.4.1997

3. Learned Single Judge noticed that there was no discussion regarding the basis on which interest has been allowed to land owners in the aforesaid three cases. Learned Single Judge was of the view that the Act is complete code covering the entire field of operation of acquisition of land by the State including its liability to pav interest to the land owners in certain contingencies. Therefore, he referred the matter to the Larger Bench, as noted above for opinion.

4. The Act is complete code and lays down detailed procedure for acquisition of land, payment of compensation including solatium and additional market value. It is to be noted that under Section 34 interest @ 9% from the date of taking over the possession till payment for the first year @ 15% for subsequent years is payable. Section 28 is the only other provision which deals with the award of interest. The said provision empowers the Court to award interest on the excess awarded amount over and above the amount awarded by the Collector.

Sections 28 and 34 read as follows:

28. Collector may be directed to pay interest on excess compensation- If the sum which in the opinion of the Court, the Collector ought to have awarded as compensation is in excess of the sum which the Collector did award as compensation, the award of the Court may direct that the Collector shall pay interest on such excess at the rate of ¦nine per centum¦ per annum from the date on which he look possession of the land to the date of payment of such excess into Court.”

34. Payment of interest.— When the amount of such compensation is not paid or deposited on or before taking possession of the land, the Collector shall pay the amount awarded with interest thereon at the rate of nine per centum per annum from the time of so taking possession until it shall have been so paid or deposited.

[Provided that if such compensation or any part thereof is not paid or deposited within a period of one year from the date on which possession is taken, interest at the rate of fifteen per centum per annum shall be payable from the date of expiry of the said period of one year on the amount of compensation or part thereof which has not been paid or deposited before the date of such expiry.”

5. There is no dispute to the position that apart from Sections 28 and 34 which deal with payment of interest to persons entitled to receive compensation, there is no other provision envisaging payment of interest. Collector, Land Acquisition is liable to pay interest on statutory rates to such persons only when possession has been taken over before the payment of the entire compensation to them under Section 34. In Union of India v. Budh Singh (1995) 6 SCC 233, the Apex Court had the occasion to deal with Sections 28 and 34 and it was observed that these were the only provisions which deal with the payment of interest to land owners. While considering the scope and ambit of these Sections, the Apex Court observed:

“Thus, it could be seen that the statute covers the entire field of operation of the liability of the State to make payment of interest and entitlement thereof by the owner when land has been taken over and possession in consequence, thereof, the land owner was deprived of the enjoyment thereof. Thus, it could be seen that the Court has no power to impose any condition to pay interest in excess of the rate of manner prescribed by the statute as well as for a period anterior to the publication of Section 4(1) notification under this Act.”

6. Similar view was expressed in State of Himachal Pradesh v. Dharam Das, (1995) 5 SCC 683. It was held that when the statute provides for payment of interest to the land owners, a Court has no power to award interest in a manner other than the one prescribed by the statute. It was specifically observed that there is no other provision empowering the Court to award interest on equitable grounds as equitable consideration has no role to play in determination of the compensation and the manner of awarding interest as enjoined under the Act. The same has to be administered in the manner laid in the Act and in no other way. As a concomitance the equity jurisdiction of the Court is taken out and the Act enjoins the Court to grant interest as per the statutory rates specified in the Act. A plea was taken in a case before the Apex Court in a matter relating to Jammu & Kashmir Requisitioning and Acquisition of Immoveable Property Act, 1968 which omitted provision for payment of solatium and interest, that in spite of the absence of the provision for solatium and interest in the said Act the State was bound to pay solatium and interest to the land owners on equitable grounds. The Apex Court negatived the contention. It was observed that there was no substance in the plea that by legislative omission to pay solatium the State enriches itself unjustly at the expense of the private party. (See Union of India v. Dhanwanti Devi and Ors., (1996) 5 SCC 44) In Ashok Nagar Plot Holders Association v. State of U.P, (1997) 10 SCC 77, the Apex Court again observed that liability to pay interest to the claimant arises only in accordance with Section 34 of the Act. As the Act is a self-contained code, common law principles of justice, equity and good conscience cannot be extended in awarding interest, contrary to or beyond provisions of the statute.

7. In view of what has been indicated above, conclusion is irresistible that while exercising jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, there is no scope for direction to pay interest in a manner not contemplated by either section 28 or 34. That being the position, decisions rendered by this Court in Sher Singh and Ram Pal cases (supra) and in CWP 1483/96 do not indicate the correct position in law.

8. Normally after answering the reference we could have required the Single Judge to take up the matter on receipt of answer to the reference. But, at the request of learned counsel for the parties we have taken up the ease for final disposal. We do not entertain the petitions. However, one grievance of the petitioners need to be noted. It is stated that even those amount payable either under section 28 or 34 have not been paid if that be so, let steps be taken for making payment within two months from today.

Cases disposed of accordingly.