Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Dental Council Of India v. Integrated Education Development Organisation And Others

Delhi High Court
Jul 13, 2000
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary — Anil Dev Singh, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The first respondent filed a writ petition seeking directions to the Dental Council of India (DCI) and the Central Government to grant statutory permission to start Bhagwan Mahavir Dental College and Hospital at Ghaziabad. The Single Judge directed the DCI to allow the first respondent to admit sixty students for the academic year 2000 and to grant permission to start the college within six (later recorded as eight) weeks. The DCI challenged that order by filing a letters patent appeal.

After the college's scheme was referred to the DCI, inspectors were deputed and submitted an initial report finding non-compliance with norms. A second inspection (report dated 30.12.1997) reportedly found compliance, but the DCI remained dissatisfied and sought a fact‑finding committee; the DCI affidavit before the Single Judge alleged the college did not permit that committee to inspect infrastructural facilities.

The Single Judge appointed two experts (Mrs. Tulika Tripathi and Mr. R. Pradhan) who inspected the present and proposed sites and produced a detailed report identifying numerous deficiencies in land ownership/area, built‑up area, lecture halls, laboratories, library, hostel documentation, central stores, staffing (absence of a Principal; many staff on retainer; inadequate records), and hospital attachment documentation. Despite this expert report, the Single Judge appointed a Local Commissioner (Mr. Vivek Singh, Advocate) who submitted a report on 11.8.1999, after which the Single Judge directed respondent No.2 (DCI) to allow admission of sixty students and to grant permission within eight weeks, subject to the petitioner taking steps to secure required teaching staff.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court (Single Judge) was justified in directing the Dental Council of India to grant permission to admit students and to start a technical (dental) college.
  2. What is the proper role of the writ court under Article 226 of the Constitution in interfering with academic and technical regulatory decisions taken by statutory authorities such as the Dental Council of India?
  3. Which expert reports should be considered by the Dental Council of India and the Central Government when deciding whether to grant permission to start the dental college, and what procedural steps should follow?

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Baba Mungipa Medical College and Research Centre Studies Guardian Forums and Another v. Government of Tripura and Others, AIR 1997 SC 3999 That recognition/permission should not be granted until defects pointed out by the statutory medical authority are removed; college may cure defects and seek further inspection; the regulatory body (Medical Council) must decide whether facilities are adequate; courts cannot direct recognition where defects exist. The court relied on this authority to hold that until defects are remedied the DCI/Central Government should not be directed to grant permission; the Single Judge's order directing immediate admission/recognition could not be sustained on the facts.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court concluded the Single Judge was not correct in directing the DCI to permit admissions and to grant permission to start the college. The reasoning proceeded as follows:

  1. Decisions whether to grant permission to start a technical/academic institution fall within the province of the statutory authority constituted for that purpose (here, the Dental Council of India and ultimately the Central Government). The High Court, exercising jurisdiction under Article 226, should normally not interfere with such administrative/academic decisions.
  2. A writ court should be reluctant to interfere in academic matters unless the decision of the academic body is tainted by malafides, arbitrariness, or is unjust, unfair or unreasonable. The court quoted and applied this principle.
  3. The court examined the expert inspection report appointed by the Single Judge (the two experts) which detailed material deficiencies — land ownership and area, built‑up space, inadequate lecture halls and labs, lack of proper records, staffing deficiencies (no Principal; many teachers on retainer), inadequate library and hostel documentation, and unverifiable hospital attachment — and observed that these defects showed the institution did not meet statutory requirements for permission.
  4. The court accepted that the DCI had conducted inspections and that there was controversy among reports. It held the DCI should act in accordance with Section 10‑A of the Dentists Act and consider the expert reports previously made, but exclude the report of Mr. Vivek Singh (the Local Commissioner) because he was not an expert in the field.
  5. The court directed the DCI to make its recommendation to the Central Government after considering the expert reports (except Vivek Singh's). It further directed the Central Government to consider the DCI's recommendations together with the three expert reports and the factors specified in sub‑section (7) of Section 10‑A of the Dentists Act, 1948, and to decide whether to approve or disapprove the scheme within six weeks of receiving the DCI's recommendations.

Holding and Implications

THE IMPUGNED JUDGMENT AND ORDER OF THE SINGLE JUDGE IS SET ASIDE.

Direct consequences and directives issued by the court:

  • The Dental Council of India is directed to act in accordance with the relevant provisions of Section 10‑A of the Dentists Act and to consider all expert committee reports referred to in the opinion, except the reports of Shri Vivek Singh, Advocate, who was not an expert in the field, and thereafter make its recommendation to the Central Government.
  • The Central Government is directed to consider the DCI's recommendations and the three expert reports and the factors specified in sub‑section (7) of Section 10‑A of the Dentists Act, 1948, and to take a decision according to law, either approving or disapproving the first respondent's scheme, within six weeks from receipt of the DCI's recommendations.
  • The interim order dated 24.12.1999 is vacated. The court ordered that there be no costs.

The opinion does not purport to lay down a new legal precedent beyond applying established principles restricting judicial interference in academic and technical regulatory decisions; it confines itself to directing the statutory process to be followed and to excluding the non‑expert report from consideration.

Show all summary ...

Anil Dev Singh, J.— Admit.

The first respondent filed a writ petition seeking direction to the Dental Council of India and the Central Government to grant statutory permission to the first respondent to start a new Dental College and Hospital at Ghaziabad under the name of Bhagwan Mahavir Dental College and Hospital. The learned Single Judge before whom the matter came up directed the appellant, Dental Council of India, to allow the first respondent to admit sixty students for the academic year 2000 and grant permission to start the college within a period of six weeks. The Dental Council of India aggrieved by the order of the learned Single Judge has filed the instant letters patent appeal.

There is no dispute that after the scheme by the first respondent to open a new dental college was referred to the Dental Council of India, inspectors were deputed by it to inspect the college and pursuant thereto a report, was submitted by the inspector. As per the report, the college did not fulfil the norms laid down in that regard. The Dental Council of India, thereafter had a second inspection done by a fresh set of inspectors. The inspectors gave their report on December 30, 1997. As per that report the college was found to have complied with the requisite criteria. It appears that the Dental Council of India was not satisfied with the second report and, therefore, it wanted a fact finding committee to inspect the college. According to the affidavit filed by the Dental Council of India before the learned Single Judge, the College did not permit the fact finding committee to inspect the infrastructural facilities which the college claimed to have set up. At the same time, the first respondent filed the above mentioned writ petition in this Court.

During the course of the proceedings the learned Single Judge appointed two more experts, namely, Mrs. Tulika Tripathi, Prof, of Orthodontics, Dental Wing, Maulana Azad Medical College, New Delhi, and Mr. R. Pradhan, Prof, and Head, Department of Oral and Maxillofacila Surgery, Faculty of Dental Sciences, K.G.M.C, Lucknow, to inspect the College. As a sequel to the orders of the learned Single Judge, an inspection of the college was conducted by the experts who gave the following report:—

“With reference to the aforesaid inspection the undersigned went to the present and future sites of Bhagwan Mahavir Dental College, Ghaziabad. It was noted that:—

1. The present site of the college building is not owned by the management (Integrated Educational Development Organisation, Delhi), but is on lease to them upto 31.7.2001 (Annexure 1).

2. The present site is approximately 2 acres of land (Annexure 2).

3. The total built up area available at the present site is 19,180 sq.ft as per the certified blue prints provided by the management. An area of 1800 sq.ft made only out of tin sheds and brick walls shown as animal house, workshop and generator room (Annexure 3).

4. Two lecture halls are available out of which the bigger hall cannot accommodate 100 students and the smaller cannot accommodate more than 30 students.

5. The lapse seen were for Physiology, Histology and Dental Materials and were big enough only to accommodate 25 students. However, there was no provision for a Prosthodontic lab.

6. The anatomy dissection hall was present with four tables and sitting 440 students only. Cadaver tank was also present. Few museum specimens were also present.

7. The labs had equipments sufficient only for 25 students. Even though physically present, there were no relevant records regarding their purchase and their entry in the stock register, etc.

8. Regarding Library facilities: (a) The room was small and would accommodate only about 15 students. Few books (Medical and Dental) were present but there was no documentary evidence regarding their purchase and maintenance in the stock register and putting them in proper serial numbering.

9. There was no playground at the present site.

10. Regarding hostel: A block of Type D, GDA Flats (24 in number) were requested to Indirapuram Scheme, Ghaziabad, on 9.9.97 for 10 more flats. However, no documentary evidence regarding the allotment/possession was available.

11. There was no area earmarked or provision for Central Stores.

12. Regarding the Staff following are the observations:

(a) There is no Principal.

(b) Out of twelve teaching staff members shown only five are on actual pay roll as stated by the management, i.e S. No. 2, 3, 4, 7 and 8. All the rest are on the retainer basis. However, no documentary evidence was available and shown to us to confirm the salary drawn, neither were the personal files of the employees available (Annexure 4).

As per the technical and office staff, all of them as shown in the list are on pay rolls as stated by the management. However, it could not be verified because no personal files or financial statement regarding their salary drawn was available (Annexure 5).

13. Regarding attachment with a 100 bedded hospital the management claims to have obtained permission from one Yasoda Hospital, Ghaziabad. However, it could not be verified because the documentary proof provided for the same did not have any date or despatch number (Annexure 6).

14. Then the team of Court Commissioners visited the proposed site of the Dental College at Abupur near Modinagar (about 30 kms from the present Dental College building). At present it is an agricultural land 0.5 km off the main highway of Meerut and is being used for crop cultivation.”

It is not denied that as per the aforesaid report the institution does not meet the requirements laid down for according permission to start the dental college. In spite of the aforesaid report of the experts, the learned Single Judge appointed a Local Commissioner, Mr. Vivek Singh, Advocate, to inspect the college in order to see whether the college fulfils the relevant norms for granting permission to start the dental college. Mr. Vivek Singh submitted his report on August 11, 1999. The learned Single Judge thereafter heard the learned counsel for the parties and directed as follows:—

“Therefore, I direct respondent No. 2 to allow the petitioner to admit sixty students from the next academic year and grant permission thereof within a period of eight weeks. The petitioner is, however, directed to take further steps in order to have required number of the teaching staff as per paragraph 11 of the affidavit filed by respondent No. 2 dated 8.9.1999 within eight weeks, so that before the ensuing academic session, the required teaching staff is available in the college.”

It seems to us that the learned Single Judge was not right in directing the Dental Council of India to allow the petitioner to admit 60 students and to grant permission to start the college. The question whether or not a technical college should be granted permission to admit students and to start classes has to be left to the concerned authority constituted for such purpose and the High Court sitting in extra ordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution normally ought not to interfere as such a matter does not lie in the province of the Court. It is well settled that in academic matters, a writ court should be loathe to interfere unless that decision of the academic body suffers from malafides and arbitrariness and is unjust, unfair or unreasonable.

The Supreme Court in Baba Mungipa Medical College and Research Centre Studies Guardian Forums and Another v. Government of Tripura and Others, AIR 1997 SC 3999, held as follows:—

“We are of the view that until and unless the defects pointed out by the Medical Council are removed, there cannot be any question of granting recognition to the college. The college authorities will be entitled to cure the defects pointed out in the report. After curing the defects, they may apply to the Medical Council for a further inspection. It is for the Medical Council of India to decide whether the college had all the facilities for imparting proper medical education. But on the facts brought out in the report, no direction can be given to the Medical Council of India or the Union of India to take any steps for granting recognition to the college. Admission of first year students to the college even before grant of the recognition by the Medical Council of India or affiliation by the University was a very irresponsible step. The college is directed not to admit any student till it obtains proper recognition.”

In view of the aforesaid discussion, the impugned judgment and order of the learned Single Judge can not be sustained and is accordingly set aside. The Dental Council of India is directed to act in accordance with relevant provisions of Section 10-A of the Dentists Act, and while doing so consider all the report of the expert committees referred heretofore except the reports of Shri Vivek Singh, Advocate, who was not an expert in the field, and make its recommendation to the Central Government. We also direct the Central Government to consider the recommendations of the Dental Council of India and the aforesaid three reports of the experts and the factors specified in sub-section (7) of Section 10-A of the Dentists Act, 1948 and take a decision according to law, either approving or disapproving the scheme submitted by the first respondent within a period of six weeks from the date of receipt of the recommendations of the Dental Council of India as to whether or not permission is to be granted to the first respondent to start the dental college.

Interim order date December 24, 1999 stands vacated. No costs