Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Jatinder Nath v. Delhi Development Authority .

Delhi High Court
Sep 21, 2000
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner’s father was allotted plot No. 48, Masjid Moth Extension Residential Scheme (now Udai Pak, New Delhi-49) through an open auction by the Delhi Development Authority (DDA), and a lease deed was executed in his favour on 24-7-1973. Upon the father’s demise, the property devolved upon his two sons, Jatinder Nath (the petitioner) and Narender Nath. Both brothers applied for mutation with the DDA, and the property was mutated in their names on 22-7-1993. The petitioner claims to have cleared all dues. Subsequently, out of love and affection, Narender Nath executed a registered Relinquishment Deed on 21-12-1998 in favor of the petitioner, relinquishing his share in the property. The petitioner applied for deletion of Narender Nath’s name from the records of the respondent (DDA), but the respondent refused, demanding a registered Gift Deed instead of the Relinquishment Deed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a registered Relinquishment Deed executed by a co-owner is sufficient for deletion of that co-owner’s name from property records maintained by the DDA, or whether a registered Gift Deed is mandatorily required.
  2. Whether the respondent’s reliance on its internal guidelines, which require a Gift Deed for deletion of a co-owner’s name, is legally tenable in the context of a residential property.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The demand for a Gift Deed by the respondent is illegal and unwarranted.
  • Narender Nath relinquished his share out of love and affection by executing a duly registered Relinquishment Deed, which constitutes a conveyance.
  • The Relinquishment Deed operates as a transfer of interest and the respondent cannot insist on a separate Gift Deed.
  • Relied on the Supreme Court decision in Kuppuswami Chettiar v. A.S.P.A Arumugam Chettiar, AIR 1967 SC 1395, which held that a registered release deed without consideration can operate as a transfer by way of gift if it clearly shows the intention to transfer and is properly executed and attested.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • As per guidelines issued by the Lt. Governor, deletion of a co-owner’s name requires execution of a regular conveyance or Gift Deed.
  • The guidelines relied upon allow addition or substitution of family members only on execution of a registered conveyance/gift deed, even though a deed has been registered.
  • Insistence on the Gift Deed is based on internal procedural guidelines and is necessary for mutation purposes.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kuppuswami Chettiar v. A.S.P.A Arumugam Chettiar, AIR 1967 SC 1395 A registered release deed without consideration may operate as a transfer by way of gift if it clearly shows intention to transfer and is properly executed and attested. The Court relied on this precedent to hold that the registered Relinquishment Deed executed by Narender Nath is a valid conveyance and sufficient for deletion of his name without requiring an additional Gift Deed.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the nature of the Relinquishment Deed executed by Narender Nath and distinguished it from the requirement of a Gift Deed under the respondent’s guidelines. It observed that the guidelines cited by the respondent pertain to industrial and commercial plots and do not apply to residential plots, such as the one in question. The Court noted that a Relinquishment Deed cannot be equated with a conveyance deed as contemplated by the guidelines, rendering the respondent’s insistence on a Gift Deed legally untenable. The Court emphasized that no specific guideline mandates a Gift Deed for deletion of a name in residential property mutation records. Accordingly, the Court quashed the impugned order demanding a Gift Deed and directed the respondent to delete the name of Narender Nath based on the registered Relinquishment Deed.

Holding and Implications

The petition is allowed.

The Court ordered the respondent to delete the name of Narender Nath from the property records within four weeks based on the registered Relinquishment Deed. Furthermore, the petitioner’s pending application for conversion of the property from leasehold to freehold will be disposed of in accordance with law after the deletion. This decision directly affects the parties by allowing mutation based on the Relinquishment Deed without requiring a Gift Deed. No new precedent beyond the immediate facts was established.

Show all summary ...

Father of the petitioner was allotted plot No. 48, Masjid Moth Extension Residential Scheme, now known as Udai Pak. New Delhi-49 in an open auction conducted by the Delhi Development Authority. A lease Deed was executed in his favour by the President of India on 24-7-1973. After the demise of the father of the petitioner the property devolved upon his two sons namely Jatinder Nath, the present petitioner and his brother Narender Nath. Both the brothers applied for mutation with the DDA. Property was mutated in the name of the petitioner and his brother Narender Nath vide letter of respondent dated 22-7-1993.

2. It is the case of the petitioner which is not disputed by the respondent, that petitioner cleared entire amount and nothing is due from him. On account of oral settlement and out of love and affection both the brothers settled the matter with regard to their property and Narender Nath executed a Relinquishment Deed dated 21-12-1998 duly registered in the office of the Sub-Registrar relinquishing his share in the property in question in favour of his brother Jatinder Nath, who is petitioner before this Court. On the basis of the said Relinquishement Deed the petitioner applied for deletion of the name of his brother Narender Nath from the records of the respondent.

3. Respondent refused to transfer/mutate/delete the name of Narender Nath and strangely by the impugned order demanded from the petitioner that until and unless a Gift Deed duly registered with the office of the Sub-Registrar is given to the respondent the name of Narender Nath can not be deleted as co-owner of the property in question.

4. Mr. Thanai, learned counsel for the petitioner has contended that demand of the respondent is totally illegal and unwarranted. He has contended that Narender Nath happens to be younger brother of petitioner and out of love and affection he relinquished his share from the property which devolved upon them after their father. He has contended that Relinquishment Deed duly registered in the office of Sub-Registrar is also a Conveyance and inspite of Relinquishment Deed having been executed the respondent can not insist for execution of another Gift Deed. Learned counsel for the petitioner has cited Kuppuswami Chettiar v. A.S.P.A Arumugam Chettiar, AIR 1967 SC 1395 where the Supreme Court held that a registered instrument styled release deed releasing right, title and interest of releasor without consideration may operate as transfer by way of gift when document clearly shows intention to effect transfer and is signed by or on behalf of releasor and attested by at least two witnesses.

5. On the other hand, counsel for the respondent has contended that as per guidelines issued by the Lt. Governor to the respondent, the deletion in the name would be effected when Gift Deed is executed by Narender Nath in favour of petitioner as Narender Nath is also co-sharer in the property. Respondent has filed counter affidavit alongwith the guidelines appearing at page 43 of the paper book and has relied upon clause II ‘where a deed has been registered’. Sub-clause of this Clause reads as under :—

i) Where a deed has been registered addition and substitution of “family members” shall be allowed without any charge but on execution of a regular conveyance/gift deed.

6. At the outset, I must say as to how these guidelines can come in the way of the respondent in deleting the name of Narender Nath. According to the guidelines relied upon by respondent the word occuring in sub-clause (i) of clause 2 is a regular conveyance/gift deed. A Release Deed or Relinquishment Deed can not be said to be a Conveyance Deed. The insistence on the part of the respondent is totally untenable in law. I would not dwell much on this controversy becuase what has been filed by the respondent in this Court and has been heavily relied upon by counsel for the respondent is some guidlines which pertain to the substitution/addition/deletion of names in industrial/commercial plots. Unmindful of the fact that guidelines under which the respondent wants to take shelter pertains to industrial and commercial plots yet the respondent has been insisting to produce a Gift Deed pursuant to these guidlines which do not apply in case of residential plots. Nothing has been filed to show that there is any guideline by the respondent in relation to any residential plot which specifically, as a matter of principle and policy, requires for deletion of a name a gift deed. In the circumstances, I quash the impugned letter whereby the respondent is insisting upon execution of Gift Deed by Narender Nath in favour of his brother i.e the petitioner.

7. I allow the petition and direct respondent to delete the name of Narender Nath within four weeks.

8. After deletion of the name of Narender Nath the application of the petitioner pending for conversion of property from lease hold to freehold will also be disposed of in accordance with law.

Rule is made absolute.

Petition allowed.