- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Relaxo Rubber Limited v. Selection Footwear
Structured Summary of the Opinion — Vikramajit Sen, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
This is a suit for permanent injunction, infringement of copyright and trade mark, passing off and rendition of accounts brought by the Plaintiffs. Summons were ordered to be issued to the defendants on 14.8.1998 for the next date of hearing fixed on 14.10.1998. On 14.10.1998 the matter was adjourned to 22.1.1998. On 22.1.1999 a request for time to file Written Statement and Reply was made and an adjournment was granted. On 18.3.1999 a further request for four weeks to file the Written Statement was allowed. When the matter came up on 21.7.1999 before the Joint Registrar (O) it was noted that the Written Statement had not been filed and the matter was placed before the Court. On 6.8.1998 there was no appearance on behalf of Defendants. The Plaintiffs relied on Order 8 Rule 10 of the Civil Procedure Code and pressed for judgment against the Defendants. Arguments were heard and judgment was reserved.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether Order 8 Rule 10 should be invoked to pronounce judgment or make such order when parties required to file a written statement fail to do so within the time permitted by the court.
- Whether the Plaintiffs are entitled to permanent injunctive relief, rendition of accounts and/or damages for alleged copyright and trade mark infringement and passing off by the Defendants.
Arguments of the Parties
Plaintiffs' Arguments
- The Plaintiff No.1 manufactures rubber chappals and other footwear; Plaintiff No.2 handles marketing, sale and publicity since 10.10.1990.
- The trade mark RELAXO has been in continuous and extensive use by Plaintiff No.1 since 1968; in 1976 the word 'RELAXO' was drawn in an artistic and distinctive style as contemplated by Section 2(c) of the Copyright Act, 1957.
- Three artistic works related to 'RELAXO' were registered under the Copyright Act, 1957 (Registration Nos. A16964/77, A42720/83 and A42721/83), and extracts from the register of Copyrights were filed.
- Registration to protect proprietary rights in the trade mark RELAXO was carried out under the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958, and relevant orders were filed.
- The mark RELAXO has acquired valuable reputation in national markets; publicity expenses from 1978–1998 exceed Rs. 16 crores and sales from 1976–1998 exceed Rs. 312 crores.
- The Defendants have been selling rubber chappals bearing the identical trade mark RELAXO in the same style; photographs of both parties' chappals were produced to support the claim.
- The Plaintiffs asserted that an injunction is the appropriate remedy to protect their reputation and statutory rights; they sought rendition of accounts to ascertain profits (tentatively estimated at Rs. 5 lacs) and damages.
Defendants' Position
- No written statement or substantive defence was filed by the Defendants in the proceedings; the opinion records that no defence is forthcoming.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court first examined the text and effect of Order 8 Rule 10 (O.8 R.10). The Rule was quoted in full. The Court noted that the Amendment Act, 1976 replaced the word "may" with "shall" in the Rule, which superficially appears to make pronouncement of judgment mandatory where a required written statement is not filed. However, the Court observed that the subsequent phrase allowing the Court to "make such order in relation to the suit as it thinks fit" preserves judicial discretion and moderates the literal mandatory appearance created by the substitution.
Given that the Defendants had been granted at least four opportunities to file a Written Statement and had not availed themselves of those opportunities, the Court considered the case fit for invoking the provisions of Order 8 Rule 10. Nonetheless, because no defence had been put forward, the Court considered it its duty to examine the correctness of the Plaintiffs' case on its merits before passing any decree. For that purpose the plaint and the documents filed with it were perused and arguments on behalf of the Plaintiffs were heard.
On the merits, the Court accepted the Plaintiffs' factual averments as supported by documentary evidence: long and continuous use of the RELAXO mark since 1968, registration of artistic works (copyright registrations A16964/77, A42720/83 and A42721/83), registration under the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958, substantial publicity and sales figures, and photographic evidence showing the Defendants' goods bearing an identical mark in the same style. The Court found it obvious that the Defendants intended to pass off their goods as the Plaintiffs' products.
The Court concluded that injunctive relief was the appropriate and necessary remedy to protect the Plaintiffs' legal and statutory rights. As to monetary relief, although the Plaintiffs sought rendition of accounts to determine profits (tentatively estimated at Rs. 5 lacs), the Court, noting the absence of any defence and the available material, declined the prayer for rendition of accounts and instead assessed and decreed a consolidated sum of Rs. 3 lacs as damages. The Plaintiffs were also awarded costs. Directions were given for the drawing up of a decree after payment of additional court fee.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: The suit was decreed in favour of the Plaintiffs with the following principal outcomes:
- Permanent injunction restraining the Defendants (through proprietor/partners, servants, agents, representatives, dealers and others acting for and on their behalf) from infringing or reproducing the Plaintiffs' artistic works RELAXO and from manufacturing, selling, offering for sale, advertising or dealing in rubber chappals or any other footwear under the trade mark RELAXO or any deceptively similar mark.
- Monetary relief: a decree for Rs. 3,00,000 (three lakhs) as damages was granted; the Plaintiffs' prayer for rendition of accounts was disallowed.
- Costs: the Plaintiffs were awarded all costs incurred in the proceedings.
- Directions were given that after payment of additional court fee, a decree be drawn up accordingly.
- Final disposition: Suit and interlocutory application stand disposed of in the above terms.
Implications: The decision directly and finally restrains the Defendants from using the RELAXO mark or deceptively similar marks and awards the Plaintiffs specified damages and costs. The opinion does not state or purport to establish any broader legal precedent beyond the decision in this matter.
Vikramajit Sen, J.— This is a suit for permanent injunction, infringement of copyright and trade mark, passing off and rendition of accounts. Summons were ordered to be issued to the defendants on 14.8.1998 for the next date of hearing which was 14.10.1998 On 14.10.1998 the matter was adjourned to 22.1.1998 On 22.1.1999 a request for time to file Written Statement and Reply was made and an adjournment was granted for this purpose. On 18.3.1999, which was the next date of hearing, yet on another request further time of four weeks for filing the Written Statement was granted. When the matter came up on 21.7.1999 before the Joint Registrar(O) it was noted that the Written Statement had not been filed and hence the matter was placed before Court. On 6.8.1998 there was no appearance on behalf of Defendants. In these circumstances, Order 8 Rule 10 was relied upon by the learned counsel for the Plaintiffs and it was pressed before me that the Court should pronounce judgement against the Defendants. Arguments were heard in the suit and judgment was reserved.
2. Order 8 Rule 10 reads as under:
“O.8 R.10 When any party from whom a written statement is required under rule 1 or rule 9 fails to present the same within time permitted or fixed by the court, as the case may be, the Court shall pronounce judgment against him or make such order in relation to the suit as it thinks fit and on the pronouncement of such judgment, decree shall be drawn up.
2.1 These provisions were altered by the Amendment Act, 1976, and the word ‘shall’ replaced the word ‘may’ in this Rule. Even though the use of the word ‘shall’ appears to make it mandatory that a judgment should be pronounced, this mandate has been watered down by the subsequent part of the sentence which protects the discretion of the Court inasmuch as it can “make such order in relation to the suit as it thinks fit”. I had, therefore, not pronounced the judgment on 6.8.1999
3. Keeping in perspective the fact that at least four opportunities for filing Written Statement have not been availed of by the Defendants I feel this is a fit case for invoking the provisions of Order 8 Rule 10. However, since no defence has come forward, it would be, to my mind, the duty of the Court to consider the correctness of the Plaintiffs case. For this reason the plaint as well as documents filed along with it were perused and arguments were heard on behalf of Plaintiffs.
4. The Plaintiff No. 1 is engaged in the manufacture of rubber chappals and all other kinds of footwears and since 10.10.1990 the Plaintiff No. 2 is marketing, selling and making publicity of these products manufactured by Plaintiff No. 1 Trade mark RELAXO is continuously and extensively in use by the Plaintiff No. 1 since 1968. In 1976 the word ‘RELAXO’ was drawn up in an artistic manner and in a unique and distinctive style as contemplated by Section 2(c) of the Copyright Act, 1957. The three artistic works related to the word ‘RELAXO’ have been registered under the Copyright Act, 1957 under Registration Nos. A16964/77, A42720/83 and A42721/83. Copies of the extracts in the register of Copyrights have been filed.
5. In order to protect the proprietary rights in the trade mark RELAXO registration was carried out under the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958 and copies of the relevant orders have also been filed along with the suit.
6. It has been averred in the plaint that due to excellent quality of the Plaintiffs products the said trade name RELAXO have acquired in all the markets of the country a valuable reputation. The publicity expenses pertaining to the trade mark RELAXO during the period 1978 to 1998 is stated to exceed Rs. 16 crores. The sales for the period 1976 to 1998 exceeds Rs. 312 crores.
7. It has further been averred in the plaint, and this stands undisputed, that the Defendants have been selling rubber chappals bearing identical trade mark RELAXO in the same style of writing as that adopted by the Plaintiff No. 1. Photographs of the Plaintiffs' chappal and the Defendants' chappal are on the record and support the Plaintiffs case. It is obvious that the Defendants intention was to pass off his spurious goods as the genuine products of the Plaintiff. It has been asserted, in my view correctly, that the Plaintiffs reputation cannot be estimated in terms of money and that, therefore, an injunction is the only appropriate remedy available to the Plaintiffs to protect its legal and statutory rights. It is averred that the Plaintiffs estimate that by the illegal trade activities the Defendants might have earned the profits to the turn of Rs. 5 lacs, although this could only be definitely ascertained on the Defendant's rendition of accounts.
8. In these circumstances, in my view, this is a fit case for passing a decree in favour of the Plaintiffs permanently injuncting and restraining the defendants through their proprietor/partners, servants, agents, representatives, dealers and others acting for and on its behalf from infringing or reproducing copies of ‘artistic works’ RELAXO in respect of which the Plaintiffs are the owners and or to do anything, the exclusive right to do which is conferred upon the Plaintiffs as owners of the said copyright. The Defendants through their proprietor/partners, servants, agents, representatives, dealers and others acting for and on its behalf are further restrained from manufacturing, selling, offering for sale, advertising, directly or indirectly dealing in rubber chap-pals or any other footwear under the trade mark RELAXO or any other trade mark which may be deceptively similar to the Plaintiffs registered trade mark RELAXO.
9. The Plaintiffs have sought rendition of accounts to ascertain the profits earned by the Defendants, which had been tentatively ascertained as Rs. 5 lacs so that a decree can be passed for the amount so found due on the basis of sales. No defence of the Defendants is forthcoming in these proceedings. I think it appropriate to decree a sum of Rs. 3 lacs as damages. For this reason the prayer for rendition of accounts is disallowed. The Plaintiffs will, however, be entitled to all the costs incurred in these proceedings.
10. After payment of additional court fee a decree be drawn up accordingly.
11. Suit & I.A stand disposed of in the above terms.
Alert