- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Trafalgar House Const. India Ltd. v. Western India Shipyard Ltd
Judgment Summary — Trafalgar House Construction India Ltd. v. Western India Shipyard Ltd. (Dalveer Bhandari, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioners, Trafalgar House Construction India Limited, filed a company petition in September 1996 against the respondents, Western India Shipyard Limited, claiming Rs. 357.94 lakhs (as per particulars of claim, Exhibit 'A') plus interest, for civil work relating to strengthening an existing quay wall. The tender submitted by the petitioners was accepted on 6 October 1993 and the contract was awarded to them. The work was completed and accepted by the respondent-company, which certified the value of work executed as Rs. 577.23 lakhs.
After adjustments, the petitioners claimed Rs. 357.94 lakhs remained unpaid. From 1996 to 1998 the respondent repeatedly acknowledged liability in various letters and telefaxes and promised payment in instalments or by specific dates, but failed to pay. The petitioners served a statutory notice on 9 July 1996; the respondent replied on 16 July 1996 admitting financial difficulties and proposing instalments but ultimately did not make payments. At one stage, through counsel, the respondent alleged defects in the work and abandonment by the petitioners.
The petition was instituted in September 1996 and notice was issued on 17 October 1996. During the pendency of the petition the parties exchanged further communications (including a direction from the respondent to a third party on 27 December 1996 to pay sums directly to the petitioners), and the respondent filed a counterclaim. Arguments were heard in August 1999. After considering the documentary admissions and financial disclosures, the Court admitted the petition for hearing and directed publication of citations for 25 October 1999, subject to withdrawal if the respondent paid the outstanding amount within three weeks.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the company petition for winding up should be admitted where the petitioner’s claim has been repeatedly admitted by the respondent-company by written communications and certifications.
- Whether the respondent-company's counterclaim and later allegations (challenging quality of work and alleging abandonment) amount to a bona fide and substantial defence sufficient to refuse a winding up petition.
- Whether the respondent-company is unable to pay its debts such that the petition should be admitted for hearing (i.e., whether insolvency or inability to meet current liabilities is established).
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The respondent accepted the tender and awarded the contract and later certified the value of the work executed as Rs. 577.23 lakhs.
- The work was completed to the respondent's satisfaction and no dispute as to quality or time was raised by the respondent in initial communications.
- The respondent repeatedly admitted liability and gave written assurances and promises to pay (telefaxes and letters dated between 1996 and 1998), yet defaulted each time, causing financial hardship to the petitioners.
- The respondent's later allegations of defective work and abandonment (raised through counsel in a reply to the statutory notice) were repudiated by the petitioners' solicitors and, the petitioners contend, are not genuine.
Respondent's Arguments
- The respondent circulated a synopsis incorporating a counterclaim, and contended that in view of its counterclaim the petition was devoid of merit and should not be entertained.
- Through its counsel the respondent sought to challenge the petitioners' claim by alleging faults in the quality of work and abandonment of the work by the petitioners (as set out in the respondent's reply to the statutory notice).
- The respondent's counsel relied on precedent (including decisions cited as J.N. Roy Chaudhary (Traders) Pvt. Ltd. v. Jainti Enterprises and Madhusudan Gordhandas & Company v. Madhu Woolen Industries Pvt. Ltd.) for the proposition that a court may refuse to wind up a company if the claim is bona fide disputed or the defence is raised in good faith and is of substance.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| J.N. Roy Chaudhary (Traders) Private Limited v. Jainti Enterprises; 1987 (61) Company Cases 504 (Calcutta) | Authority for the proposition that the Court may refuse a winding up petition where the petitioner's claim is bona fide disputed by the respondent-company. | The Court stated its respectful agreement with this proposition but found that, on the facts of the instant case (documentary admissions by the respondent), no bona fide dispute existed and therefore the precedent did not rescue the respondent. |
| Madhusudan Gordhandas & Company v. Madhu Woolen Industries Private Limited; AIR 1971 SC 2600 | Authority supporting the proposition that a winding up petition may be refused where the respondent raises a defence in good faith and of substance. | The Court accepted the legal principle from this authority but concluded that the respondent's defence in the present case was devoid of merit and not taken in good faith, so the precedent did not bar admission of the petition. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court first acknowledged the established legal proposition (from decisions relied upon by the respondent) that a winding up petition can properly be refused if the claim is bona fide disputed or the defendant has raised a genuine defence in good faith and of substance. The judge stated respectful agreement with that legal principle.
Applying those principles to the facts, the Court examined the documentary record of communications between the parties from 1996 to 1998. The record included multiple written acknowledgements by the respondent of the debt, explicit assurances of payment (telefaxes and letters promising payment by certain dates or by instalments), and certifications from the respondent attesting to satisfactory completion and high quality of the work.
The Court observed that, despite these acknowledgements and undertakings, the respondent failed to make payment and subsequently attempted to advance contrary allegations (through a later reply to the statutory notice and by raising a counterclaim). The Court characterized those later defences as "totally devoid of any merit" and as not being taken in good faith.
Additionally, the Court considered evidence of the respondent's financial position. It referred to the balance sheet filed for the year ending 31 March 1998, which showed a net loss of Rs. 2002.36 lakhs, and concluded that the respondent was not in a position to pay its debts.
On the totality of the documentary admissions, repeated promises and subsequent defaults, the lack of a bona fide substantive defence, and the respondent's demonstrated inability to pay, the Court concluded that it could not refuse the petition on the basis of a bona fide dispute and therefore had to admit the petition for hearing.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Court admitted the company petition for hearing.
Direct implications for the parties:
- The Court ordered that citations be published in Hindustan Times (English edition), Nav Bharat Times (Hindi edition) and the Delhi Gazette for 25 October 1999.
- If the respondent company pays the outstanding debts of the petitioners within three weeks from the order, the directed citation publication shall not be carried out.
No broader implications or attempt to lay down new legal precedent were discussed in the opinion; the Court applied existing principles to the facts and made a fact-specific determination admitting the petition for hearing.
Dalveer Bhandari, J.— The petitioners Trafalgar House Construction India Limited filed a Company Petition in September, 1996 against the respondents Western India Shipyard Limited. In the petition it is mentioned that the respondent company is indebted to the petitioners in a sum of Rs. 357.94 lakhs as per particulars of claim, Exhibit ‘A’ alongwith interest at the rate of 18% from the date thereof till payment.
2. It is incorporated in the petition that the petitioners submitted a tender of civil work pertaining to strengthening of the existing quay wall to the respondent-company. The said tender was accepted by the company vide its letter dated 6th October, 1993 and the contract was awarded to the petitioner. The said work was duly completed in all respects to the satisfaction of the respondent company. The respondent company accepted the said work without raising any dispute as to the quality or as to the time taken by the petitioners in completing the work. The respondent company has certified that the value of the work actually executed by the petitioners is Rs. 577.23 Lakhs.
3. After adjustment of some payments, the petitioner company submitted that Rs. 357.94 Lakhs is due and payable by the respondent company to the petitioners. A number of letters were sent by the petitioners to the respondent company. The respondent company unequivocally and unconditionally admitted its liability and assured the petitioners that the payments would be released soon. Despite a number of assurances in various letters, the respondent company defaulted on every occasion resulting in financial hardship and substantial costs to the petitioners. It is also incorporated that no dispute of any nature whatsoever was raised/set up by the respondent company at any time.
4. It is also incorporated in the petition that the respondent company has failed to meet its financial obligations. It was submitted that the respondent company is in serious financial difficulties and is not in a position to meet its current liabilities. The petitioners sent a statutory notice dated 9.7.1996 The company by its letter dated 16.7.1996 respond to the statutory notice wherein it is admitted that the company had gone through a critical phase due to its Cost-Over-Run-and other matters in the last few months and had started recovering. The respondent company offered to settle the dues in three instalments. But in fact no amount has been paid by the respondent company to the petitioners.
5. The learned counsel appearing for the petitioners has drawn my attention to various letters sent by the respondent company to the petitioners to demonstrate that the respondent company admitted its liability and they were always satisfied with the quality of work done by the petitioners. The respondent Company was also satisfied that the work was also done within the prescribed timer. A reference has been made to the telefax dated 13.1.96 sent by the respondent company to the petitioners. The telefax reads as hereunder:
“Dear Sir,
With due respect, may I bring to your kind notice that all efforts are “ON” at this end to settle your outstandings at our earliest. I think by this month end, you will have no reason to complaint.
This delay is basically on account of non-release of our funds (through the proceeds of Public Issue as well as Khoka Buy Back money) by our financial institutions. I was in Bombay to meet them personally and they have assured that they would release (almost Rs. 12 crore) the funds soon.
I understand your position and I am sorry for causing concern. Kindly ask your Board to bare with me for a few days more and I will ensure payment of outstanding before the month end.
This is very unfortunate that this payment to THCIL got delayed but be sure it is due to the reason that almost payment of Rs. 30 crore from institutions got delayed due to overall money market crunch. Now that I have been assured that the funds will be released soon.
As an alternate means to clear our outstandings with THCIL, I have asked by bankers in open the LC for Graving Dock and that would not only settle the present outstanding amount but future payment also.
I am aware that Mr. Chatterjee, the Director Operations is visiting me on Monday to discuss the outstandings. He is most welcome to see the yard as he missed the inauguration.
My full time occupation now to ensure your payment and kindly bare with me for a few days.
Best regards
Yours sincerely,
(Dr. S. Shekhar Singh)
6. Thereafter another fax message dated 20.3.96 was sent by the Managing Director of the respondent company to the petitioners. The message reads as under:
“Dear Sir,
Sub: Outstanding Payments.
This has reference to your letter No. MD/BB/6 dated 13 March ‘96 on the above subject. At the outset. I must apologise for taking unduly prolonged period to settle your account. I could have settled your amount by mid-March ‘96. However I got preoccupied and was away from office for almost 15 days due to the sudden demise of my Mother who expired on 24th Feb ‘96.
I have taken adequate measures to see that the total amount is paid by lumpsum. I myself am in a hurry for an early payment for the works carried out on the Graving drydock. Kindly resume the works as we are loosing consideration time and non-completition of the Graving dock will hereby effect the cash flow of the Company for the year 1996-1997. This is also for your kind information that the Company has approached Financial Institutions for Project Cost Over Run of Rs. 28 Crores and they are being analysis by our Financial Institutions on priority basis to ensure additional funding of the project. Not withstanding this, I am independently processing to ensure payment of almost two and a half crores to THCIL. My proposal is resting with the agency and they have assured that they would provide additional funding before 31st Mar’96. I am also hopeful that by this time I will be able to resolve the issue. I could not reply your letter earlier as I was away and rejoined my office today.
You have awaited for a good time and would only request you to wait for some more time. Kindly bear with us until then.
Thanking you,
Regards,
Yours sincerely,
Cdr. S. Shekhan Singh, Managing Director.
7. On 16.4.96 yet another fax message was sent by the respondent company to the petitioners in which the respondent company promised to remit one crore to the petitioners within a week.
8. On 6.5.1996, a letter was sent by the respondent to the petitioners promising to clear 60% of the outstanding amount in May, 1996 and the balance in June, 1996. In reply to the statutory notice on 9.7.1996, the respondent did not dispute the amount demanded by the petitioners and in its reply dated 16.7.1996, promised to settle the payment in three instalments. It may be pertinent to mention that another reply to the notice was sent through Mr. U.R Timble, Advocate. In this notice of course, the respondent has taken a complete somersault and made an endeavour to find fault with the quality of work done by the petitioners and accused the petitioners for abandoning the work and causing loss to the respondent company.
9. A reply to this notice was sent by the advocates of the petitioners on 4th September, 1996 repudiating the averments mentioned in the reply to the notice sent by the respondent. Thereafter the petitioners filed a company petition before this Court in September, 1996 and the notice of the company petition was issued on 17.10.1996 It may be pertinent to mention that during the pendency of this petition before this Court a telefax was sent on 27.12.1996 by the respondent company to Essar Sisco Ship Management Company Limited asking Essar to pay Rs. 22.87 Lakhs payable by Essar to the respondent company directly to the petitioners.
10. On 10.2.1997, the Managing Director of the respondent company had sent letter to the petitioners. The same is quoted as under:
“I am very hopeful that all your debts will get settled before the end of financial year 1996-1997.”
11. During the pendency of this petition on 12.12.1996, the Managing Director of the respondent company had sent a letter to the petitioners in which it is mentioned that the respondent company proposed to pay the running bill amounting, to Rs. 280 Lakhs in six equal instalments, commencing from January, 1996.”
12. The learned counsel for the petitioner has drawn my attention to the letter dated 13.1.1998 sent by the respondent company to the petitioners. The same reads as under:—
13.1.1998
Trafalgar House Construction India Ltd.
5, Chowringhee Approach,
Calcutta-700072.
Dear Sir,
As per our books of accounts your accounts shows an credit balance of Rs. 2,68,51,079/76 payable to you as on 31.12.1997 Kindly confirm the same to US, in our office address, within 15 days from the date of receipt of this latter otherwise our balance will be treated as final. In case of any difference in the balances kindly send your statement of account for reconciliation.
Thanking you,
Yours sincerely,
for Western India Shipyard Limited,
Gagan Sahoo
Manager(Accounts)
13. The learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that from 1996 to 1998, the respondent company on several occasions admitted the liability but despite a number of promises and undertakings the respondent Company did not pay the amount to the petitioners.
14. The learned counsel for the petitioners has drawn my attention to the letter dated 18.10.1995 sent by the General Manager of the respondent company to the petitioners congratulating them and their staff for carrying out the entire work by the petitioners successfully within a scheduled period agreed upon and that the work done by petitioners was of high standard. Another certificate was issued by the Managing Director of the respondent company. The relevant portion of the certificate reads as under:
“They (petitioners) have carried out all the works within the time schedule of completion of time with excellent site set-up, proper equipments and maintaining high quality of work with their experience in specialised civil construction.
15. It may be pertinent to mention that during the pendency of this petition on various occasions a number of Judges of this Court have made serious efforts to see that the matter is settled between the parties and the outstanding amount is paid by the respondent to the petitioners. On 20.8.1999 the arguments were heard at length and after arguing for some time, the learned counsel for the petitioners took one week's time to advise the respondent-company. The learned counsel appearing for the respondent-company could not offer reasonable terms of repayment to the satisfaction of the petitioners and opted to argue the matter again. The arguments were concluded on 30.8.1999 It was submitted that the respondent company has raised a counter claim and in view of the respondents' counter claim, this petition devoid of any merit and should not be entertained by this Court.
16. The counsel for the respondent company also circulated synopsis incorporating counter claim of the respondent company. It is not necessary to recapitulate the details of the counter claims of the respondent-company. Mr. Zaiwalla learned counsel also placed reliance on some of the decided cases of the Supreme Court and of other Courts. He has particularly relied on J.N Roy Chaudhary (Traders) Private Limited v. Jainti Enterprises; 1987 (61) Company Cases 504 Calcutta and on Mad-husudan Gordhandas & Company v. Madhu Woolen Industries Private Limited; AIR 1971 SC 2600.
17. I am in respectful agreement with the propositions of law as laid down in these cases that the Court could rightly refuse a petition for winding up of the company when the claim of the petitioners is bonafide disputed by the respondent company or it can refuse and relieve the petitioners in case the respondent company has raised defence in good faith and is one of substance.
18. In the instant case only on the basis of unequivocal admissions of the petition, from. 1996 till 1998, the claim of the petitioners is abundantly established. This is one of those unusual cases, where even during the pendency of winding up petition in this Court, the respondent-company admitted the liability of the petitioners in categoric terms. The defence as set up by the respondent is totally devoid of any merit and has not been taken in good faith.
19. Despite clear acknowledgement of the liability of the petitioners and undertaking to the respondent company to pay the amount, the respondent company is unable to clear the outstanding debts of the petitioners. A number of opportunities were given by this Court to the respondent company to pay the outstanding amount in reasonable instalments, but the respondent company has failed to clear the outstanding liability. The Court is of the considered opinion that the respondent company is not in a position to pay the debts of the petitioners. This is also corroborated from the fact that even in the balance sheet filed before this Court ending 31.3.1998 the net loss of Rs. 2002.36 Lakhs have been shown.
20. On consideration of the totality of facts and circumstances of this case, this Court is left with no option but to admit this petition for hearing. Let the citations be published in Hindustan Times (English edition), Nav Bharat Times (Hindi edition) and Delhi Gazette for 25th October, 1999.
21. In case the respondent company pays the outstanding debts of the petitioners within three weeks, citation as directed shall not be published.
Alert