Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Union Of India v. Madhya Pradesh Export Corporation Ltd

Delhi High Court
Aug 24, 1998
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Y.K. Sabharwal, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The disputes between the Union of India, Ministry of Railways (appellant) and Madhya Pradesh Export Corporation Ltd. (respondent, "the Corporation") were submitted to arbitration before Shri V.K. Raizada, Sole Arbitrator. By an Award dated 31 August 1994 the Arbitrator directed the appellant to pay the Corporation Rs. 40,91,531. The Arbitrator rejected the Corporation's claim for interest on the ground that the contract did not provide for interest and, relying on para 2401 of the Indian Railways Standard Conditions of Contract, held that no interest was payable on sums withheld.

The appellant accepted the Award and did not object. The Corporation filed objections only to the part of the Award denying interest. The Single Judge set aside the Award insofar as it denied interest, concluded para 2401 did not apply, and—invoking Section 15 of the Arbitration Act, 1940—modified the Award to grant the Corporation interest at 12% per annum from 1 May 1990 until realisation on the sum of Rs. 40,91,531. The appellant appealed.

The learned Arbitrator Shri V.K. Raizada had since retired. The Court (Y.K. Sabharwal, J.) set aside the Single Judge's modification of the Award and remitted the question of interest to arbitration. The Court appointed Mr. Justice Jaspal Singh (former Judge) as sole arbitrator to decide only the question of interest and directed procedures for the re-reference, fee payment, time limit and maintenance of deposited interest in fixed deposit. The appeal was disposed of and a copy of the judgment was to be given dasti to counsel.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the court had jurisdiction under Section 15 of the Arbitration Act, 1940 to modify the Arbitrator's Award in respect of the denial of interest.
  2. Whether Clause/para 2401 of the Indian Railways Standard Conditions of Contract applied so as to preclude payment of interest in the facts of this case.
  3. If the court had jurisdiction, whether interest could be awarded and, if so, from which date (the Single Judge awarded interest from 1 May 1990; the appellant contended Section 29 permits interest only from the date of the decree).

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent (Madhya Pradesh Export Corporation Ltd.)

  • Contended that the case fell within Clause (b) of Section 15 as an instance of an "obvious error" in the Award, thus permitting the Court to modify the Award.
  • Requested that, if the Arbitrator who made the Award had retired, a retired Judge may be appointed as arbitrator to reconsider the question of interest; the Corporation offered to pay the fee of such arbitrator.

Appellant (Union of India, Ministry of Railways)

  • Contended that the Court lacked jurisdiction to modify the Award under Section 15 because none of clauses (a) or (c) applied and Clause (b) (obvious error) did not permit changing an award where the Court merely takes a different view from the Arbitrator.
  • Submitted that, on the merits, the Court could grant interest only from the date of the decree as required by Section 29 of the Act; relied on Union of India v. Jain Associates and another, 1994 (1) Arb.L.R 494 (para 4) for the proposition that Section 29 carries a negative import that the court has no power to grant interest pendente lite which the arbitrator had not granted.
  • Representations by Government counsel (Mr. Kapur) that the Government would have no objection to the appointment of a retired Judge as arbitrator so long as the Government was not directed to pay the arbitrator's fee.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
<a href="/judgement/in/5609ac9ae4b014971140f45c" id="jud0">Union of India v. Jain Associates and another</a> 1994 (1) Arb.L.R 494 Para 4: proposition that Section 29 carries a negative import that the court has no power to grant interest pendente lite which the arbitrator had not granted. The Court noted the authority relied upon by the appellant but did not decide the Section 29 issue because it held that the Single Judge had no jurisdiction to modify the Award under Section 15; hence the Section 29 question was left to the Arbitrator on remittance.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined Section 15 of the Arbitration Act, 1940 and emphasised that the Court's power to modify or correct an Award is strictly confined to the contingencies enumerated in clauses (a) to (c) of that section. The Court reasoned that it would act without jurisdiction if it modified an Award merely because it preferred a different view from the Arbitrator.

The Court found that Clauses (a) and (c) of Section 15 were inapplicable on the facts. The Corporation invoked Clause (b) (obvious error). The Court analysed the scope of Clause (b) and concluded that an "obvious error" may be corrected only when the correction can be made without affecting the Arbitrator's decision on the merits. The Court illustrated that certain clerical or patent errors (for example, misnaming a party) may be corrected under Section 15 without affecting the merits. By contrast, where the Arbitrator had conscientiously decided that no interest was payable, the Court could not substitute its own view and thereby modify the Award.

Applying this principle, the Court held that the Single Judge erred in modifying the Award to grant interest because that modification altered the result of the Arbitrator's decision; hence the Single Judge acted beyond jurisdiction under Section 15. The Court observed that one appropriate course would have been to remit the question to the Arbitrator for reconsideration.

On the issue of para 2401 of the Indian Railways Standard Conditions of Contract, the Court agreed with the Single Judge that para 2401 did not apply because it operates when the purchaser has a claim against the contractor and withholds payment; here the purchaser (Union of India) had no claim against the Corporation, so para 2401 did not preclude interest.

Regarding the date from which interest could be awarded, the Court recorded the appellant's submission that Section 29 permits interest only from the date of the decree and noted the cited authority (Union of India v. Jain Associates). However, the Court refrained from deciding that question because it had already concluded that the Award could not be modified under Section 15. Consequently, the question of whether interest (and if so at what rate and from which date) should be granted was remitted to the Arbitrator to be decided in accordance with law.

Because the original Arbitrator had retired, the Court appointed Mr. Justice Jaspal Singh (former Judge) as sole arbitrator to decide only the question of interest. Procedural directions were given: the appointed arbitrator was to pronounce the Award under Section 16(2) within two months of entering the reference; the arbitrator would fix his fee to be paid by the Corporation; the arbitration record would be forwarded; and the amount of interest already deposited by the appellant would remain in fixed deposit pending the arbitrator's Award and further orders.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The impugned judgment of the Single Judge is set aside to the extent it modified the Arbitrator's Award and granted interest. Instead, the Award is remitted to arbitration for decision solely on the question of interest. The Court appointed Mr. Justice Jaspal Singh (former Judge) as sole arbitrator to decide the question of interest and directed procedural steps (award under Section 16(2) within two months, arbitrator's fee to be paid by the Corporation, preservation of deposited interest in fixed deposit).

Implications:

  • The Arbitrator (the newly appointed sole arbitrator) must reconsider whether interest is payable, and if so the rate and period, in accordance with law. The Single Judge's modification awarding 12% interest from 1 May 1990 is vacated.
  • The Court limited its intervention because Section 15 does not permit substitution of the Court's view for that of the Arbitrator where no clause of Section 15 is satisfied; where necessary, the proper remedy is remittance to the Arbitrator.
  • No broader change in law or binding precedent beyond the application of Section 15 principles in this case is announced by the Court; the decision affects only the parties by remitting the interest question to arbitration and by appointing the new arbitrator under the terms set out above.
Show all summary ...

Y.K Sabharwal, J.— The disputes between Union of India, Ministry of Railways, appellant in this appeal and respondent-Madhya Pradesh Export Corporation Ltd. (for short ‘the Corporation’) were adjudicated by Shri V.K Raizada, Sole Arbitrator in terms of his Award dated 31st August, 1994. The Award directed the appellant to pay to the Corporation a sum of Rs. 40,91,531/_. The claim of the Corporation for interest was, however, rejected by the Arbitrator in the following words:

“As regards the claimant's prayer for the payment of interest on the balance amount due on account of the difference in rates at which payment was due and the rates at which the payment has actually been made, I am of the view that no interest is payable in this case as the contract did not provide for payment of any interest. Also, para 2401 of the Indian Railways Standards Conditions of Contract entitles the purchaser to withheard payment of any sum which the purchaser claims as his own and on such a sum no interest is payable. Therefore, no interest of any kind is considered justified on the balance amount due to the claimant.”

The appellant accepted the Award and did not file any objections thereto. The Corporation, however, filed objections to only that part of the Award where the Arbitrator had decline to grant interest to it. Learned Single Judge held that the Award declining grant of interest to the Corporation cannot be sustained at all and it was set-aside. It was also held by learned Single Judge that Para-2401 of the Standard Conditions of Contract did not apply to the facts of the case. After setting-aside the Award in this manner, learned Single Judge instead of remitting the Award to the Arbitrator for fresh decision of question of interest, modified the award under Section 15 of the Arbitration Act, 1940 and held that the Corporatior is entitled to interest at the rate of 12% per annum from 1st May, 1990 till date of realisation on sum of Rs. 40,91,531/-. The appellant is in appeal before us.

Section 15 confers the power on court to modify or correct an Award on the existence on one of the contigencies mentioned in clause (a) to (c) of the section. The court will have no jurisdiction to modify or correct an Award in absence of fulfilment of one of the Clauses a, b or c. A plain reading of Section 15 shows that the power of the Court is limited by these three clauses. The court would be acting without jurisdiction, if an Award is modified only for the reason that the court takes a view different than the Arbitrator. Admittedly, Clauses (a) and (c) of Section 15 have no applicability to the facts of the present case. Learned counsel for the Corporation, however, submits that the present case is covered by Clause (b) as it is a case of an obvious error in the Award. Under Clause (b) it is not only an obvious error simpliciter which vests power with the court to modify or correct an Award. An obvious error in the Award can be modified or corrected only when it can be amended without affecting the decision of the arbitrator. There can be various illustrations of obvious errors which can be amended without decision of the Arbitrator. One such illustration can be where the Arbitrator while intending to make Union of India Liable, by mistake makes President of India liable. Such an error can be corrected under Section 15 without affecting the decision of the Arbitrator on merits. In the present case, the Arbitrator has, however, come to the conclusion that the Corporation was not entitled to any interest. The Court taking a different view, as in the present case, has modified the Award. In our view, the court has no such jurisdiction and, therefore, the impugned order correcting the Award cannot be sustained. Under the circumstances of the case, one of the courses open to the Court was to remit the Award to the Arbitrator for reconsideration upon question of interest.

The learned Arbitrator held that the contract did not provide for payment of any interest and further that the Clause—2401 entitles the purchaser to withhold payment on any sum which the purchaser claims as his own and on such a sum no interest is payable. Having heard counsel for the parties, we are of the view that the learned Single Judge rightly came to the conclusion that Para 2401 did not apply to the facts of the case. A bare reading of Clause 2401 shows that it applies when the purchaser i.e Union of India has a claim against the contractor and in that eventuality it can withhold the payment due to the contractor and on such payment being withheld contractor is not entitled to the interest. Admittedly, the purchaser-Union of India had no claim against the Corporation and, therefore, it was rightly held that Clause 2401 had no applicability.

It appears that the Corporation was claiming the amount due from the appellant from 30th April, 1990. Reference to Arbitration was made in 1994. By the impugned judgment, the interest was awarded w.e.f 1st May, 1990 till date of payment. Learned counsel for the appellant on the facts of the case besides questioning the jurisdiction of court to modify the Award, further submitted that the Court could grant interest only from the date of the decree as postulated by Section 29 of the Act and not from 1st May, 1990. Reliance has been placed by learned counsel for the appellant upon the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Union of India v. Jain Associates and another 1994 (1) Arb.L.R 494, in particular para-4 holding that Section 29 also carries a negative import that the court has no power to grant interest pendente lite which the arbitrator had not granted. We, however, need not go into this question, for that, we have held that the Award could not be modified under Section 15 of the Act. The result of this would be that the question whether any interest is to be granted and if so rate thereof and for which period i.e from 1st May, 1990 or from some other date would have to be decided by the Arbitrator in accordance with law.

In view of aforesaid discussion, the impugned judgment is set-aside to the extent it modifies the Award and grants interest to the Corporation and instead we direct the remission of the Award to arbitration for decision on the question of interest alone as no other point is under challenge. The question of interest would be reconsidered by the Arbitrator in the light of this decision and in accordance with law.

The learned counsel for the parties submit that the Arbitrator Shri V.K Raizada has since retired. In this view, counsel for the Corporation submits that a retired Judge of this Court may be appointed as an Arbitrator to reconsider the question of interest. Mr. Kapur very fairly contends that the Government will have no objection to the appointment of a retired Judge as an Arbitrator so long as the Government is not directed to pay the fee of learned Arbitrator to be appointed by this court. Counsel for the Corporation states that under these circumstances his client is ready to pay the fee of the learned Arbitrator.

Accordingly, we appoint Mr. Justice Jaspal Singh, a former Judge of this Court as sole-Arbitrator to decide the question of interest. The learned Arbitrator will pronounce the Award under Section 16(2) within a period of two months from the date he enters the reference. The learned Arbitrator will fix his fee which would be paid by the Corporation. The Arbitration record in Suit 2214/94 shall be sent forthwith to the learned Arbitrator. The amount towards interest deposited by the appellant herein shall continue to be kept in a fixed deposit so as to be dispursed after the reconsideration by the Arbitrator and further orders which may be passed in the suit on filing of Award by the learned arbitrator.

The appeal is disposed of in the above terms. A copy of this judgment be given dasti to counsel for the parties.