- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sinhal Metal Industries Pvt. Ltd v. Royal Enterprises.
Factual and Procedural Background
The plaintiff filed a suit for passing off concerning its mark ‘CLASSIC’ used for tooth brushes, hair brushes, and nail brushes. During the pendency of the suit, the plaintiff obtained registration of the mark under the Trade and Merchandise Mark Act, 1958. Subsequently, the plaintiff filed an application under Order 6 Rule 17 read with Section 151 of the CPC to amend the plaint to add a claim for infringement in addition to passing off, and to amend the title and certain paragraphs of the plaint. The defendants opposed the amendment application.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the plaintiff can amend the plaint to add a claim for trademark infringement after initially filing a suit solely for passing off.
- Whether allowing such amendment would amount to changing the cause of action and thereby be impermissible.
- Whether refusal of the amendment would result in multiplicity of proceedings and should be avoided.
Arguments of the Parties
Defendant's Arguments
- The proposed amendment changes the fundamental nature and basis of the suit.
- Passing off and infringement are distinct causes of action and cannot be combined in the same suit after the suit has been filed.
- If the plaintiff wants to claim damages for infringement, it must file a separate suit specifically for that cause of action.
- Relied on a prior judgment of the Court (IA No. 442/94 in suit No. 607/85 dated 19.10.1995) to support this position.
Plaintiff's Arguments
- The cause of action for passing off and infringement arises from the defendants' wrongful acts and thus are connected.
- Infringement constitutes a statutory wrong, representing an enlargement of the wrong claimed under passing off.
- The suit for passing off can be converted into a suit for infringement by amendment.
- Refusal to allow amendment would cause multiplicity of proceedings by forcing the plaintiff to file a separate suit.
- Relied on A Abdul Karim Sahib v. A Shanmugha Mudaliar (1967) and Anglo Dutch Colour & Varnishing Works Limited v. Indian Trading House (1984 PTC 54) to support these contentions.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| IA No. 442/94 in suit No. 607/85 (19.10.1995) | Distinction between passing off and infringement as separate causes of action. | Referenced by defendants to argue against amendment allowing infringement claim in passing off suit. |
| A Abdul Karim Sahib v. A Shanmugha Mudaliar (1967, 2 Madras Law Journal 468) | Support for the proposition that a suit for passing off can be converted into a suit for infringement by amendment. | Followed by the Court to allow amendment and avoid multiplicity of proceedings. |
| Anglo Dutch Colour & Varnishing Works Limited v. Indian Trading House (1984 PTC 54) | Supports the principle that infringement and passing off claims are related and amendment is permissible. | Followed by the Court in allowing the amendment application. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined whether the amendment sought was mala fide or barred by limitation and found no such objections. It recognized that the fundamental legal principles governing passing off and infringement are essentially the same, differing primarily in that infringement involves a registered trademark and statutory wrong, whereas passing off involves unregistered marks. Since the plaintiff alleges deceptive similarity causing damage in both claims, the Court held that the cause of action is not fundamentally different. The Court also emphasized the need to avoid multiplicity of proceedings between the parties. It agreed with precedents from the Madras High Court and this Court that a suit for passing off can be amended to include infringement claims. Accordingly, the Court allowed the amendment application.
Holding and Implications
The Court allowed the plaintiff's application to amend the plaint to include a claim for trademark infringement alongside the existing passing off claim.
This decision permits the plaintiff to consolidate related claims in a single suit, thereby avoiding multiplicity of litigation. No new legal precedent was established; rather, the Court followed established principles permitting amendment of plaints to reflect the registered status of a mark during the pendency of a passing off suit.
Vijender Jain, J.— IA 35/94 inS.738/92
This is an application under Order 6 Rule 17 read with Section 151 of the CPC filed by the plaintiff/applicant. During the pendency of the suit, the plaintiff obtained the registration of its mark ‘CLASSIC’ bearing No. 503609B for tooth brushes, hair brushes, nail brushes in Clause-21 under the Trade and Merchandise Mark Act, 1958. The plaintiff had filed the suit for passing off. After obtaining the registration of its mark, by this application plaintiff wants to amend plaint and in addition to the relief of passing off, wants to add relief for infringement. Plaintiff wants to amend the title of the suit and paragraphs 5,11,17 and 19 of the plaint.
Amendment application has been opposed by the learned counsel appearing for the defendants/non-applicants. Mr. Ajay Sahni has contended that by proposed amendment the plaintiff wants to change the very basis and nature of the suit. Mr. Sahni has contended that action of passing off and infringement are two distinct cause of actions and plaintiff cannot be permitted to now claim the cause of action on account of infringement of trade mark after having filed a suit for passing off. Mr. Sahni has contended that if plaintiff wants to claim any damages on account of infringement then the remedy is open for it to file a separate suit on this cause of action. In support of his contentions, Mr. Sahni has relied upon a judgement of this Court in IA No. 442/94 in suit No. 607/85, which was delivered on 19.10.1995
On the other hand, Mr. Praveen Anand, learned counsel appearing for the plaintiff/applicant has contended that the cause of action for maintaining the suit on account of passing off or infringement is on account of the wrong of the defendants. In cases of infringement the defendants are committing statutory wrong. Therefore, by amending the plaint and incorporating the relief on account of infringement, it is enlargement of that wrong which is claimed by virtue of filing suit for passing off. Learned counsel for plaintiff/applicant has also contended that suit of passing off can be converted into suit for infringement. In support of his contentions, he has relied upon A Abdul Karim Sahib v. A Shanmugha Mudaliar 1967. (2) Madras Law Journal 468 and Anglo Dutch Colour & Varnishing Works Limited v. Indian Trading House 1984 PTC 54. Mr. Anand has contended that if amendment is not allowed, it will lead to multiplicity of proceedings as plaintiff has to file another suit.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties at length. In an application for amendment what the Court has to see is whether the amendment sought for is not mala fide and it does not extend the period of limitation. The application for amendment has been filed at the early stage. Issues in the suit have not yet been framed and it is not the case of the non-applicant/defendants that amendment sought for is mala fide. Dealing with the arguments advanced by the learned counsel for both the parties whether the application amounts to change the cause of action, to my mind the fundamental principle, which governs the law relating to infringement are same as are governed the law of passing off. Action for passing off is brought by a user of trade mark when the trade mark is not registered. The fact remains that plaintiff alleges that it has suffered on account of similar goods being passed off by the defendant deceptively as that of plaintiff. Action for infringement on the same principle lies when the trade mark is registered. That being so then to say that is in a different cause of action to maintain a suit for infringement when suit for passing off is still pending, is not correct. Even otherwise, if the amendment application is rejected, this will lead to multiplicity of proceedings between the parties, which should be avoided. I am in agreement with the view taken by the Madras High Court in A Abdul Karim Sahib v. A. Shanmugha Mudaliar's case (supra), which was followed by this Court in Anglo Dutch Colour & Varnishing Works Limited v. Indian Trading House's case (supra).
I, therefore allow the application.
S.738/92
Mr. Anand says that amended plaint has already been filed. Let the same be taken on record. Let amended written statement be filed within 6 weeks. Replication thereto before the date fixed.
List this matter before Joint Registrar on 27.4.1998
Alert