Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

State Bank Of India v. Smt. Pushpa Arora .

Delhi High Court
Sep 1, 1996
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The defendant-appellant (a bank) has preferred an appeal under Section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure against the judgment and decree dated 18.10.1993 passed by Shri Shiv Charan, Additional District Judge, Delhi in Suit No. 478/91. The trial court decreed the plaintiff-respondent's suit for possession of the suit premises and awarded damages at Rs. 8,000 per month w.e.f. 1.9.1991 until delivery of possession, together with interest at 15% p.a.

Factual background as set out in the opinion: In November 1970 the plaintiff let one ground-floor room at L-71, Malviya Nagar, New Delhi to the defendant-Bank. The tenancy was renewed periodically and rent rose from an initial Rs. 700 per month to Rs. 2,700 and later (by agreement via letters in 1985-86) to Rs. 4,100 per month effective 28.11.1985. On 19.7.1986 the Branch Manager of the Bank sent letter Ext. D-1 conveying Regional Office approval for renewal of lease for five years with an option of additional five years by one-year renewals with a 25% increase after the initial five years; the Bank also reserved the right to vacate within the lease period on one month's notice. Ext. D-3 (2.9.1986) clarified certain points and the plaintiff accepted these terms by letter Ext. D-2 (17.9.1986).

The plaintiff instituted the suit (dated in the record as 20.9.1981 according to the opinion) alleging that tenancy was terminated by notice dated 17.7.1991 and that possession was to be given up by 31.8.1991. The defendant allegedly failed to deliver possession and thus was liable for mesne profits/damages; the plaintiff claimed damages/mesne profits at Rs. 20,000 per month w.e.f. 1.9.1991 and interest at 15% p.a. The trial court framed issues, heard evidence, and granted possession and damages at Rs. 8,000 per month with interest; this judgment is under challenge on appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the tenancy of the defendant was validly terminated vide notice dated 17.7.1991?
  2. Whether the relationship of landlord and tenant was still subsisting between the parties as alleged?
  3. Whether the plaintiff was entitled to mesne profits/damages, and if so at what rate and for what period?
  4. Whether the plaintiff was entitled to interest, and if so at what rate?
  5. Whether the plaintiff was entitled to the relief of possession of the suit property as prayed?
  6. Whether the defendant could invoke the doctrine of part performance under Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act to protect its possession or to claim that the lease had been renewed for a further period after 28.11.1990?
  7. Whether the lease terms contained in letter Ext. D-1 (allegedly creating a five-year lease with renewal options) could be relied upon despite absence of a registered lease deed (reference to Section 107, Transfer of Property Act)?
  8. Issues touching the applicability of the Delhi Rent Control (Amendment) Act, 1988 and Section 3(c) of the Delhi Rent Control Act were also raised in the written statement (including a constitutional challenge), though the appellate court treated that issue with reference to Supreme Court authority.

Arguments of the Parties

Defendant's Arguments

  • The defendant contended the amendment to the Delhi Rent Control Act (fixing a cutoff at Rs. 3,500 per month) was not retrospective and that, since the defendant was a tenant before the amendment, the suit was barred under Section 50 of the Delhi Rent Control Act; constitutional validity of Section 3(c) was also challenged.
  • On merits the defendant argued that a five-year lease with an option for renewal was agreed to take effect from 28.11.1985 and, by reason of acceptance of rent after 28.11.1990, the lease stood renewed for at least one year to November 1991; hence the termination purportedly effected by the plaintiff was premature.
  • The defendant relied on the doctrine of part performance under Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act to protect its possession even if a registered lease deed was not executed.
  • The defendant asserted that the plaintiff had accepted rent after the alleged termination and therefore the defendant was not liable to pay mesne profits/damages; the defendant also contested the quantum of damages claimed by the plaintiff (claimed Rs. 20,000 per month) as unsupported by cogent evidence.

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The plaintiff argued that no plea of part performance under Section 53A had been taken in the written statement and therefore the defendant could not raise it for the first time in the first appeal.
  • The plaintiff further submitted that even on merits the conditions for Section 53A were not fulfilled — specifically, there was no readiness and willingness on the part of the defendant to perform the contract (e.g., to pay the increased rent) — and consequently Section 53A did not protect the defendant's possession.
  • The plaintiff relied on the correspondence (Ext. D-1, D-2, D-3) to show that the tenancy from 28.11.1985 was on the agreed terms, and that the plaintiff was entitled to terminate the tenancy by notice dated 17.7.1991.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Biswabani Pvt. Ltd. v. Santosh Kumar Dutta, (1980) 1 SCC 185 Held that if a lease is void for want of registration, neither party can take advantage of the lease terms; only Section 53A (part performance) may, if its conditions are satisfied, protect possession for the period reserved under such a void lease, but other terms inadmissible for want of registration cannot form the basis of relief. The court applied this principle to hold that Ext. D-1 (the letter purporting to create a five-year lease with renewal terms) was inadmissible as a registered lease was not executed; therefore the renewal clause in Ext. D-1 could not form the basis of relief for the defendant.
D.C. Bhatia v. Union of India, (1995) 1 SCC 104 Upheld validity of the Delhi Rent Control (Amendment) Act, 1988 and held that fixation of cut-off at Rs. 3,500 was not arbitrary; Section 3(c) would apply even to tenancies created prior to 1.12.1988. The court relied on this authority to indicate that it need not examine other pleas raised by the defendant in the written statement concerning the Amendment's validity, since the Supreme Court decision upheld the Amendment and the applicability of Section 3(c).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded by addressing the legal effect of the correspondence relied upon to establish the 1985 lease, the requirements of registration for certain leases, the availability of Section 53A (part performance) and the procedural adequacy of pleas raised in the written statement.

1. Registration requirement and effect on Ext. D-1: The court noted that a lease from year to year or for any term exceeding one year (or reserving yearly rent) falls under Section 107 of the Transfer of Property Act and must be made by a registered instrument. No registered lease deed was produced. Applying the principle in Biswabani Pvt. Ltd.'s case, the court held that Ext. D-1 is void for want of registration and, while Section 53A may protect possession if its conditions are met, other terms of the unregistered instrument cannot be used as a basis for relief.

2. Applicability of Section 53A (doctrine of part performance): The court set out the necessary conditions for Section 53A to apply: (a) a contract to transfer immovable property for consideration; (b) the contract is signed by/for the transferor; (c) the terms can be ascertained with reasonable certainty; (d) transferee is put in possession or continues in possession; (e) transferee has done some act in furtherance of the contract; and (f) the transferee has performed or is willing to perform his part.

The court found that the defendant had not specifically pleaded part performance in the written statement. The plea was only raised during arguments and was negatived by the trial court on facts. The appellate court emphasized that part performance necessarily involves factual questions and cannot be raised for the first time in appeal when not pleaded at trial. Moreover, there was no evidence that the defendant took any steps after 28.11.1990 in furtherance of the renewal clause or that the defendant was willing to perform its obligation (i.e., to pay an increased rent by 25%). Accordingly, the court concluded Section 53A did not apply to protect a renewal period beyond 28.11.1990.

3. Effect of expiry of initial lease and nature of tenancy thereafter: The court held that, even if possessory protection under Section 53A were available for the initial five-year period to 28.11.1990, there was no renewal for the subsequent one-year term because the defendant neither requested renewal nor paid increased rent. Consequently, after expiry of the initial term, the tenancy was treated as month-to-month.

4. Validity of notice dated 17.7.1991: Given the tenancy was month-to-month, the court found that notice Ext. PW 1/3 dated 17.7.1991 validly terminated the tenancy at the close of August 1991. Therefore the defendant's possession from 1.9.1991 was unauthorized and the defendant was liable for mesne profits/damages.

5. Quantum of mesne profits/damages and interest: The trial court's determination of damages at Rs. 8,000 per month was examined on the basis of the witness statements and materials on record. Although the plaintiff claimed Rs. 20,000 per month, the appellate court found no ground to interfere with the trial court’s finding that damages equal to double the rent (i.e., Rs. 8,000 per month) was reasonable in view of locality and rise in rent levels. The plaintiff was also entitled to interest at 15% p.a., as held by the trial court.

6. Treatment of other pleas and legislative challenge: The appellate court indicated it need not decide other pleas raised by the defendant in the written statement, since the Supreme Court in D.C. Bhatia had upheld the Delhi Rent Control (Amendment) Act, 1988 and held that Section 3(c) applied even to tenancies created prior to 1.12.1988.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appellate court APPEAL DISMISSED and held that the judgment and decree of the trial court were not liable to be interfered with. The trial court's decree for possession in favour of the plaintiff and for damages at Rs. 8,000 per month (w.e.f. 1.9.1991 until delivery of possession) together with interest at 15% p.a. was affirmed. The appeal was dismissed with costs.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The plaintiff's decree for possession and mesne profits/damages at Rs. 8,000 per month and interest at 15% p.a. has been upheld; the defendant-Bank remained liable for unauthorised occupation from 1.9.1991 and to pay the awarded sums until possession is delivered.
  • Legal principles reinforced by the decision (as applied): (a) terms of an unregistered lease which is required to be registered cannot be relied upon to claim relief except possibly to the limited extent Section 53A protects possession if its conditions are strictly satisfied; (b) Section 53A's protection requires specific factual proof that the transferee did acts in furtherance and was willing to perform obligations (e.g., paying increased rent); and (c) a plea of part performance generally must be pleaded at trial and cannot be raised for the first time in appeal.
  • Broader precedent: The court relied on existing Supreme Court authority (Biswabani and D.C. Bhatia) and did not purport to lay down any new legal principle; no new precedent was announced by this opinion beyond application of established authority to the facts of the case.

Disposition

The appeal was dismissed with costs. (Final line of the opinion: "Appeal dismissed.")


Note: This summary is compiled exclusively from the content of the provided opinion and does not add facts or inferences beyond that text.

Show all summary ...

Devinder Gupta, J.— Defendant appellant has preferred this an appeal under Section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure against the judgment and decree passed on 18.10.1993 by Shri Shiv Charan, Additional District Judge, Delhi in Suit No. 478/91 decreeing the suit of the plaintiff respondent for possession in respect of the suit premises and also for damages at the rate of Rs. 8,000/- p.m w.e.f 1.9.1991 till delivery of possession.

2. In November 1970 one room in the ground floor of property bearing L-71, Malviya Nagar, New Delhi was let out by the plaintiff to defendant-Bank. The tenancy of the room was renewed. Rent which initially was Rs. 700/- p.m was also increased. On additional space being provided to the defendant-Bank, rent was increased to Rs. 2,700/- p.m On 19.7.1986, letter, Ext. D-1, was sent by the Branch Manager of the defendant-Bank to the plaintiff, with reference to the discussion held amongst the parties on 28.5.1986, conveying the approval of the Regional office of the defendant-Bank to the plaintiff for renewal of lease for a further period of five years in respect of the premises which were in occupation of the defendant. The proposal was that the rent of the premises will be raised from Rs. 2,758.25 to Rs. 4,100/- p.m from 28.11.1985 and that the same will be released only after the plaintiff withdraws her eviction petition filed against the defendant-Bank. The letter further stated that the lease initially will be for a period of five years with further option of five years of one year each in favour of the Bank with 25% increase after completion of the initial lease period of five years. Bank also reserved the right to vacate the premises within the period of lease by giving one month's notice to the plaintiff. This letter was followed by another letter dated 2.9.1986 Ext. D-3 making some clarification, in response to the plaintiff's letter dated 21.7.1986 which the plaintiff intended were to be incorporated. On 17.9.1986 through letter Ext. D-2 plaintiff responded to the defendant's letter dated 2.9.1986 conveying her acceptance to the terms and conditions for renewal of the lease stating that the eviction suit will be withdrawn on the next date of hearing, namely, 1.10.1986

3. The suit which has now given rise to the instant appeal was instituted on 20.9.1981 by the plaintiff alleging that the defendant was inducted as a tenant in ground floor of the property bearing No. L-71, Malviya Nagar, New Delhi on a rental of Rs. 4,100/- p.m Tenancy was terminated by the plaintiff through notice dated 17.7.1991 The defendant was called upon to deliver possession by 31.8.1991 when tenancy came to an end on its expiry. Defendant failed to deliver back possession to the plaintiff and as such the possession of the defendant on and from 1.9.1991 was not authorised. Defendant was liable to vacate the premises and hand over its vacant possession to the plaintiff. The plaintiff also claimed mesne profits/damages at the rate of Rs. 20,000/- p.m w.e.f 1.9.1991 and also claimed interest at the rate of 15% p.a on the amount found due as mesne profits.

4. Suit was resisted by the defendant on numerous grounds. It was alleged that the amendment in the Delhi Rent Control Act; whereby tenants paying rent above Rs. 3,500/- p.m had lost the protection under the Act; is not retrospective in nature and since the defendant was a tenant prior to coming into force of the amendment, the same would not apply and thus the suit was barred under Section 50 of the Delhi Rent Control Act. Constitutional validity of Section 3(c) of the Delhi Rent Control Act was also challenged. On merits it was alleged that as per agreement entered into between the parties, lease initially was for a period of five years w.e.f 28.11.1985 with an option of five years renewal, of one year, each in favour of the defendant-Bank with 25% increase in rent after completion of initial lease period of five years. After 28.11.1990 the plaintiff had accepted rent, which resulted in extending the lease period at least for one year up to November, 1991, therefore, termination of lease prior to November, 1991 is bad and suit is pre-mature. The lease could not have been terminated on 31.8.1991 Defendant also pleaded that after the alleged termination of tenancy by notice dated 17.7.1991 the plaintiff had accepted rent and that the defendant was not liable to pay mesne profits/damages.

5. On the pleadings of the parties a the trial Court framed the following issues:

“1. Whether the tenancy of the defendant was validly terminated vide notice dated 17.7.91? OPP (Onus object)

2. Whether relationship of landlord and tenant is still subsisting between the parties as alleged? OPD (onus objected to)

3. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to mesne profits, if so at what rate and for what period and to what amount? OPP

4. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to interest, if so at what rate and to what amount? OPP

5. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to relief of possession of the suit property as prayed? OPP”

6. Plaintiff examined her husband and attorney S.S Arora as PW 1 in support of her case. In addition Girish Kumar, PW 2, Upinder Singh, Clerk Canara Bank, Malviya Nagar PW3 and Shiv Charan Goyal, PW 4 were also examined by the plaintiff. Defendant examined only Gulshan Bhayana, Shopkeeper, as DW 1.

7. The Trial Court held that after the expiry of the period of the lease there has been no renewal thereof. Had the defendant been interested in renewal of the lease for a further period of one year nothing prevented the defendant to pay to the plaintiff rent at the increased rate by 25% and, thus, the plaintiff was within her right to terminate the lease through notice dated 17.7.1991 Tenancy being from month to month it was held that notice Ext. PW 1/3 dated 17.7.1991 had validly terminated the defendant's tenancy. On the basis of the oral and documentary evidence the Trial Court further held that the rate of damages, which can reasonably be claimed by the plaintiff, keeping in view the locality of the adjoining area would be Rs. 8,000/- p.m which is almost double of the rent payable by the defendant. The plaintiff was also held entitled to interest at the rate of 15% p.a It is this judgment and decree which is under challenge by the defendant-Bank.

8. It has been contended that the defendant-Bank is entitled to protect its possession on the doctrine of part performance under Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act. Even if no valid agreement was executed or got registered the plaintiff will be entitled to have the benefit of the doctrine of part performance and on the expiry of the period of five years on 28.11.1990 the tenancy will be deemed to have been renewed for a further period of one year expiring on 28.11.1991 and as such service of notice of termination, during the continuation of the tenancy would be bad in law. The plaintiff is not entitled to decree for possession and on the findings of mesne profits it was urged that there was no cogent evidence adduced by the plaintiff in support of the plea of damages at the rate of Rs. 20,000/- and decree at the rate of Rs. 8,000/- cannot be sustained.

9. On behalf of the plaintiff-respondent it was contended that in the absence of any plea of part performance under Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act it will not be permissible for the defendant-Bank to raise this plea in first: appeal. Otherwise also ingredients of Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act are not fulfilled. There is no readiness and willingness on the part of the defendant-Bank which is one of sine qua non for the applicability of the doctrine of part performance.

10. Admittedly no formal lease deed was executed. It was only on the basis of exchange of letters that there has been renewal of lease in 1985-1986. Letter Ext. D-1 dated 19.7.1986 was sent by the defendant-Bank to the plaintiff conveying the approval of its Regional Office for continuing with the tenancy on the terms and conditions stated in the said letter. Terms and conditions with respect of the period and rent being:

“(i) The rent of the premises will be raised from Rs. 2758.25 to Rs. 4,100/- per month from 28.11.85 However, it will be released only after the eviction suit filed by you in the Court is withdrawn.

(ii) The lease will be initially for 5 years with further option of 5 years of one year each in favour of the Bank with 25% increase after completion of the initial lease period of 5 years. Bank also reserves right to vacate the premises should it choose to within a period of 5 years by giving one month's notice to you.”

11. As noticed above, the terms of Ext. D-1 and subsequent letter of defendant Ext. D-3 were accepted by the plaintiff through letter Ext. D-2. The defendant, thus, was treated as a tenant by the plaintiff with effect from 28.11.1985 for a period of five years on payment of Rs. 4,100/- p.m as rent. According to defendant, as per terms of Ext. D-1, lease for five years came into being which contains a renewal clause.

12. A lease of immovable property from year to year or for any term exceeding one year or reserving an yearly rent under Section 107 of the Transfer of Property Act can be made only by a registered instrument. Admittedly no registered lease deed came into being. In the absence of a registered lease deed the terms contained in letter, Ext. D-1, cannot be made use of by the defendant. It is a void document for want of registration. In Biswabani Pvt. Ltd. v. Santosh Kumar Dutta, (1980) 1 SCC 185, it was held that if the lease is void for want of registration neither party to the indenture can take advantage of any of the terms of the lease. At best the provisions contained in Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act, which incorporates the doctrine of part performance, can, if the terms thereof are satisfied, be relied upon to protect possession for the period reserved under such a void lease. But no other term of such an indenture, inadmissible for want of registration, can be the basis for a relief.

13. At the most on the applicability of the doctrine of part performance, the period of lease, in case both parties have acted on the terms of the lease, expired on 28.11.1990 The question which now arises for consideration would be that whether the lease stood renewed for a further period of one year after 28.11.1990 Answer obviously would be in the negative. Lease could be renewed for a further period of one year with 25% increase, after completion of the initial period of five years. Admittedly there has been no request on behalf of the defendant for renewal of lease and there has been no payment of rent over and above the agreed amount of Rs. 4,100/-. Plea of part performance under Section 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act was not specifically taken by the defendant in written statement though it was taken during the course of arguments before the Trial Court, which was negatived on facts. Plea of part performance, which necessarily involves questions of fact cannot be permitted to be raised in appeal, when it was not taken in the written statement in the Trial Court. The question will be different in a case when a defendant in written statement states all the facts on which he can base his defence, without stating the effect of those facts and his plea cannot be rejected merely on the ground that there is no specific mention of Section 53-A in written statement and that also will not debar the defendant from raising such a plea in appeal. However, from reading of the entire written statement of the defendant it is dear that there is no plea of part performance raised therein in any form. The stand taken by the defendant in the written statement is also not compatible with the plea of part performance. Necessary conditions for the applicability of Section 53-A are: (a) there is a contract to transfer immovable property for consideration; (b) the contract is signed by and on behalf of the transferor; (c) the terms can be ascertained with reasonable certainty from the document; (d) the transferee is put in possession or if he has already been in possession continues in possession; (e) he has done some act in furtherance of the contract; and (f) the transferee has performed or is willing to perform his part of contract. In case these necessary conditions are not fulfilled the right given under Section 53A cannot be invoked. There is neither any plea nor evidence nor any material on the record of the case that the defendant has done some act in furtherance of the term for renewal contained in Ext. D-1 for a further period after 28.11.1990 or that the defendant has performed or was willing to perform his part of contract by enhancing rent by 25%. In the absence of this, the Trial Court was also justified in rejecting this plea which was sought to be raised by the defendant during course of arguments. This is apart from the findings recorded above that in terms of the ratio in Biswabani Pvt. Ltd.'s case (supra), renewal Clause being a term in an admissible document Ext. D-1, for want of registration cannot form the basis of relief.

14. The tenancy being from month to month, notice Ext. PW 1/3 dated 17.7.1991 terminating the defendant's tenancy on the close of the month of August, 1991 was valid and the Trial Court rightly held that defendant's possession on and from 1.9.1991 is unauthorised and defendant-Bank is liable to pay mesne profits or damages for use and occupation of the property.

15. We have examined the statements of PWs, 1, 2, 3 and 4. Though the claim of the plaintiff was for damages at the rate of Rs. 20,000/- p.m but in view of the statements and other material on record we find no ground to interfere with the findings recorded by the Trial Court that the plaintiff would be entitled to double the amount of rent as damages for use and occupation. The locality is such in which there has been rise in the rates of rent and in case in 1985 the agreed rent was Rs. 4,100/- p.m, it will not be unreasonable to assume that in the year 1991 the plaintiff, would have been in a position to realise an amount not less than Rs. 8,000/- p.m as rent for the premises in question.

16. The judgment and decree, in view of the above is not liable to be interfered with. We need not say anything on the other pleas, which had been raised by the defendant in the written statement, which rightly were not discussed by the Trial Court in its judgment in view of the decision of the Supreme Court in D.C Bhatia v. Union of India, (1995) 1 SCC 104, upholding the validity of the Delhi Rent Control (Amendment) Act 1988 holding that fixation of cut off point at Rs. 3,500/- is not arbitrary and that Section 3(c) would apply even to the tenancies created prior to 1.12.1988

17. Resultantly, the appeal is dismissed with costs.

Appeal dismissed.