- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Manoj Pant v. State.
Factual and Procedural Background
Sub-Inspector Manoj Pant (the petitioner) was the subject of FIR No. 118 of 1991 registered following a complaint by Inspector P.S. Patwal of the Special Staff, East District. The complaint described events of 10-11 August 1991 in which the petitioner, after arresting two persons (Anil Kumar Solanki and Lokesh/Lokesh Kumar) for alleged recovery of duplicate gas cylinders, allegedly released the main accused (Anil Solanki) in exchange for illegal gratification of Rs. 75,000/-, substituted another person in his place, and caused official records (personal search memos and an index) to be tampered with or destroyed.
During investigation statements under Section 161 Cr.P.C. were recorded and certain original and torn documents were recovered. The Lt. Governor sanctioned prosecution of the petitioner under sections 218, 220, 221, 342, 143 and 161 of the Indian Penal Code. Although the incident occurred in August 1991, the challan was filed on March 6, 1993.
The petition brought before Jaspal Singh, J., principally raised the scope and ambit of Section 140 of the Delhi Police Act and whether the prosecution should be quashed as time-barred under that provision.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether Section 140 of the Delhi Police Act applies to all offences alleged against a police officer, or is limited to acts done "under colour of duty or authority or in excess of any such duty or authority".
- Whether the prosecution/challan filed on March 6, 1993 is barred by the limitation period prescribed under Section 140 of the Delhi Police Act.
- Whether the particular acts alleged (acceptance of illegal gratification, substitution of accused, destruction/tampering of records, and preparation of official records) were done in the discharge of official duty so as to attract the protective bar of Section 140.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner contended that Section 140 of the Delhi Police Act prescribes a period of limitation for launching prosecution against a police officer; because the challan was filed beyond the prescribed limitation period, the proceedings should be quashed.
State's Arguments
- Counsel for the State (Mr. B.T. Singh) agreed with the proposition that Section 140 prescribes a period of limitation (the opinion records that Mr. B.T. Singh "agrees").
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| P. Arutswami v. State of Madras, AIR 1967 SC 776 | Illustrates that an act done by a police officer in the course of service may sometimes be an offence requiring sanction, but if the act is not in discharge of duty then protection does not apply; distinction between acts in discharge of duty and acts merely in course of service. | The court invoked this example to show that Section 140's protective umbrella does not extend to every act or omission by a police officer — only to acts done under colour of duty or authority or in excess thereof. |
| Baijnath v. State of Madhya Pradesh, AIR 1966 SC 220 | Explains the test for when a public servant can be said to act in discharge of official duty; offers the standard that a public servant acts in virtue of office only if he can reasonably claim that the act was done by virtue of his office (examples include judge taking bribe or a medical officer picking a pocket while examining not being acts in discharge of duty). | The court relied on Baijnath to conclude that acceptance of illegal gratification and other acts done to cover them could not reasonably be claimed to be done in virtue of office, and therefore would not fall within Section 140 protection for the charge under Section 161 IPC. |
| Satwant Singh v. State of Punjab, AIR 1960 SC 271 | Holds that some offences — by their very nature — cannot be regarded as committed by public servants while acting or purporting to act in the discharge of their official duty; specifically indicates acceptance of a bribe (punishable under section 161 IPC in the opinion's reference) as one such offence. | The court cited this authority to support the conclusion that acceptance of illegal gratification (bribe) is not an act that can be regarded as in the discharge of official duty and therefore Section 140 would not protect the petitioner with respect to the bribery-related charge (Section 161 IPC). |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court began by identifying the legislative purpose behind provisions like Section 140 of the Delhi Police Act and Section 197 Cr.P.C.: to provide a measure of protection for public officials against unnecessary harassment. However, it emphasized a limiting principle expressly contained in Section 140: protection applies only when the alleged offence or wrong has been done "under colour of duty or authority or in excess of any such duty or authority."
The court distilled the analytical test from cited Supreme Court authorities: the key question is whether the impugned act is such that the public servant, if challenged, can reasonably claim he did it in virtue of his office. The court quoted Baijnath to explain that certain acts (for example, receiving a bribe) cannot be regarded as acts done in discharge of official duty even if they arise in the course of service.
Applying these principles to the facts, the court separated the alleged misconduct into categories:
- Acts involving acceptance of illegal gratification (bribe), substitution of the real accused by another person, and destruction/tampering of official records: the judge found that these were not acts that the petitioner could reasonably claim to have done in virtue of his office. Relying on Baijnath and Satwant Singh, the court concluded that Section 140 would not provide protection to the petitioner for the charge under Section 161 IPC (the bribery/related charge).
- Acts relating to preparation of records, preparation/issuance of documents (e.g., the index and personal search memos), and acts attracting sections 218, 220, 221, 342 and 193 IPC: the court found a reasonable nexus between these acts and official obligation. The court observed that these records were prepared or got prepared while the petitioner was acting or purporting to act in discharge of his official duty; similarly, actions falling under sections 220 and 221 involved the exercise of authority vested in the petitioner even though he acted contrary to law. For section 342 and 193 the court also saw a connection with discharge of official duty, albeit in derogation of duty.
On the specific point of limitation under Section 140: the petitioner argued that because the challan was filed beyond the period prescribed by Section 140, prosecution must be quashed. The court did not accept this argument in relation to the bribery-related offence (Section 161) because that offence was held not to be within the protective ambit of Section 140. For the other offences, the court's finding of a reasonable nexus to official duty indicates that Section 140's bar could be relevant to those counts; the opinion directs further proceedings rather than finally adjudicating limitation for each count.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
- Section 140 of the Delhi Police Act does not provide protection to the petitioner with respect to the charge under Section 161 of the Indian Penal Code (acceptance of illegal gratification / bribery-related allegations) because those acts cannot reasonably be said to have been done in virtue of the petitioner’s office.
- For the offences under sections 218, 220, 221, 342 and 193 of the Indian Penal Code, the court found a reasonable nexus between the acts complained of and the petitioner’s official duties; the acts were prepared or done while the petitioner was acting or purporting to act in discharge of official duty.
- The court ordered that the trial court proceed in the light of the findings in this order.
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: The petitioner's claim to be protected by Section 140 is rejected in respect of the Section 161 charge, so prosecution on that charge may proceed. For the other charges (218, 220, 221, 342, 193 IPC), the court's finding of a reasonable nexus to official duty means Section 140's protective considerations remain relevant and will need to be addressed by the trial court in the course of trial or pre-trial proceedings.
- No new overarching legal precedent was declared beyond application of established Supreme Court authorities (Baijnath, P. Arutswami, Satwant Singh) to the facts; the court applied existing principles to distinguish which alleged acts fall within the protective scope of Section 140 and which do not.
Jaspal Singh, J.— It is a petition which principally revolves around the ambit and scope of Section 140 of the Delhi Police Act. However, before I come into grip with the said provision, let us have a hard-eye view of the case.
2. Sub-Inspector Manoj Pant of the Delhi Police is facing trial in FIR 118 of 1991 under sections 218, 220, 221, 342, 193 and 161 of the Indian Penal Code. It appears that the case was registered on the complaint made to the Station House Officer, P.S Geeta Colony on August 11, 1991 by Inspector P.S Patwal of the Special Staff, East District. Since that report is self-speaking, I feel tempted to reproduce the same. It runs as under:
On 10th August, 1991 S.I Manoj Pant alongwith the staff of Special Staff, East Distt has apprehended one Lokesh Kumar s/o Mam Chand r/o A/1595, Mansarovar Park, Delhi in case FIR No. 304 dated 10/8/91 under section 411 I.P.C and 7 - X/55 E.C Act, P.S Krishna Nagar. On his disclosure statement, S.I Manoj Pant has apprehended one Anil Solanki s/o Sukhbir r/o A-92, Laxmi Garden, Loni Ghaziabad (UP) which was produced before me. I directed S.I to book the accusdes as per law and on their disclosure 146 Gas cyclinders were received from both the accused. During process, it is reported that SI Manoj Pant has let loose the main accused Anil Solanki and in his place his relative Gajinder Singh s/o Bhami Chand r/o 1/11154 A, Panchsheel Garden Navin Shahdara Delhi was involved in this case with the ulterior motives. It has come in the notice of the senior officers that SI Manoj Pant has released the main accused in the above case with the malafide intention and for illegal gratification. Thus SI Manoj being a public servant framed incorrect record with intention to save proper person from punishment and wrongfully confined to Gajinder Singh. Thus an offence under section 218/220/221/342/193/161, I.P.C prima facie is made out. A case may be registered and investigation be taken up by the local police as per order. The rukka is being sent through ASI Ishwar Singh of Special Staff.
P.S Patwal
I/C Special Staff,
East Distt.
11/6/91”
3. It appears that after the registration of case and during investigation statements of number of persons were recorded under section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. What emerges out from the investigation makes an unfortunate reading. It appears that on August 10, 1991 the petitioner produced two persons namely Anil Kumar Solanki and Lokesh Kumar, before Inspector P.S Patwal and told him that the said two persons had got recovered 144 duplicate gas cylinders. The Inspector, thereupon, instructed the petitioner to book them as per law and directed S.I Shiv Raj and others who were also present there at that time, to assist the petitioner in the matter of registraton of the case and preparation of required documents. Later it was decided to get the case registered against the said two persons under section 411 of the Indian Penal Code and under Section 7 of the Essential Commodities Act and a ruqqa to that effect was written by Head Constable Aftab at the dictation of the petitioner which after having been duly signed by the petitioner, was sent to the Police Station through Constable Pawan Kumar and Sunil Kumar for registration of the case.
4. It further appears that the petitioner had also got prepared from the said Head Constable not only the personal search memos of Lokesh Kumar and Anil Kumar Solanki but the Index of the file as well. On August 11, 1991 not only the said Index but even the said personal search memos were found missing from the file. As if all this was not enough, even Anil Kumar Solanki was found to have been replaced by another gentleman and it so transpired that this was the handiwork of the petitioner and his associates who had charged Rs. 75000/- as illegal gratification.
5. What is further required to be noticed is that during investigation the police managed to recover the original Memo of Personal Search of Anil Solanki, one torned carbon copy of the said Memo of Personal Search and the Original “Index Misai” in which Anil Solanki was shown as one of the accused persons.
6. Two things more need to be noticed before I bring this narrative to a close. First, the Lt. Governor has sanctioned the prosecution of the petitioner under sections 218, 220, 221, 342, 143 and 161 of the Indian Penal Code. Second, though the incident relates to the month of August, 1991, the challan was filed on March 6, 1993.
7. Time now to examine what the petitioner says.
8. The case of the petitioner is that since Section 140 of the Delhi Police Act prescribes period of limitation for launching prosecution against a police officer and as the challan in this case was filed beyond that prescribed period of limitation, therefore, the proceedings need to be quashed.
9. What does Section 140 of the Delhi Police Act say? Let us see.
“140. Bar to suits and prosecutions
(1) In any case of alleged offence by a police officer or other person, or of a wrong alleged to have been done by such police officer or other person, by any act done under colour of duty or authority or in excess of any such duty or authority, or wherein it shall appear to the court that the offence or wrong if committed or done was of the character aforesaid, the prosecution or suit shall not be entertained and if entertained shall be dismissed if it is instituted, more than three months after the date of the act complained of;
Provided that any such prosecution against a police officer or other person may be entertained by the court, if instituted with the previous sanction of the Administrator, within one year from the date of the offence.
(2) In the case of an intended suit on account of such a wrong as aforesaid, the person intending to sue shall give to the alleged wrongdoer not less than one month's notice of the intended suit with sufficient description of the wrong complained of, and if no such notice has been given before the institution of the suit, it shall be dismissed.
(3) The plaint shall set forth that a notice as aforesaid has been served on the defendant and the date of such service and shall state what tender of amends, if any, has been made by the defendant and a copy of the said notice shall be annexed to the plaint endorsed or accompanied with a declaration by the plaintiff of the time and manner of service thereof.
Does section 140 apply to all the offences referred to above? Mr. K.B Andley Advocate appearing for the petitioner says Yes and Mr. B.T Singh appearing for the State, agrees.
I disagree, though partly.
10. The legislature in India has considered it necessary to provide a large measure of protection for public officials from unnecessary harassment. In this respect reference may be made to section 197 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Section 140 of the Delhi Police Act is also indicative of the same legislative policy.
11. One thing is certain and it is that in order to come under the protective umbrella of Section 140 of the Delhi Police Act, the act must have been done “under colour of duty or authority or in excess of any such duty or authority.” In other words, the Section does not extend its protective cover to every act or omission done by a police officer in service but restricts its scope of operation to only those acts or omissions which are done under colour of duty or authority or in excess of any such duty or authority. For instance, and I am borrowing it from P. Arutswami v. State of Madras AIR 1967 SC 776, a police officer in discharge of his duty may have to use force which may be an offence for the prosecution of which sanction may be necessary. But if the same officer commits an act in course of service but not in discharge of his duty then the bar is not attracted.
12. To what extent an act or omission performed by a public servant in discharge of his duty can be deemed to be official was explained by the Supreme Court in Baijnath v. State of Madhya Pradesh AIR 1966 SC 220. The following observations appearing therein, I feel, clinch the issue as far the case before me is concerned:
“A public servant can be said to act or to purport to act in the discharge of his official duty, if his act is such as to lie within the scope of his official duty. Thus, a judge neither acts nor purports to act as a Judge in receiving a bribe, though the judgment which he delivers may be such an act; nor does a Government medical officer act or purport to act as a public servant in picking the pocket of a patient when he is examining though the examination itself may be such an act. The test may well be whether the public servant, if challenged, can reasonably claim that, what he does, he does in virtue of his office.”
(emphasis supplied)
13. In Satwant Singh v. State of Punjab AIR 1960 SC at page 271 it was observed by the Supreme Court:
“It appears to us to be clear that some offences cannot by their very nature be regarded as having been committed by public servants while acting or purporting to act in the discharge of their official duty. For instance, acceptance of a bribe punishable under section 161, Indian Penal Code, is one of them….”
(emphasis supplied)
14. Can the petitioner who, after arresting Anil Solanki under section 411, Indian Penal Code and under Section 7 of the Essential Commodities Act, let him off after accepting illegal gratification and substituted in his place another person as an accused and destroyed official documents to cover his offence, reasonablly claim that the act of accepting illegal gratification was in virtue of his office? Would not the instance of a Judge given in Baijnath's case, apply to the petitioner also? It is the quality of the act that is important. I have no manner of doubt that it was no part of his official duty to accept illegal gratification and in consideration thereof to let off the real culprit despite clear directions by the superiors to proceed against him and to further replace him by anoher person and to destroy the record to cover up the whole affair. Section 140 of the Delhi Police Act would thus provide no protection to the petitioner as far as section 161 of the Indian Penal Code is concerned.
15. Coming to sections 218, 220, 221, 342 and 193 of the Indian Penal Code, I do feel that there was a reasonable nexus between the acts complained of and the official obligation. The record was prepared or got prepared while acting or purporting to act in the discharge of his official duty. Similarly the acts attracting the application of sections 220 and 221 of the Indian Penal Code were in the exercise of authority vested in the petitioner though he was acting contrary to law. Same can be said about section 342 and 193 of the Penal Code since the action relates to the discharge of an official duty, although in derogation of that official duty.
16. Let the trial court proceed in the light of this order.
Alert