Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Savitri Minda v. Minda Indsutries, Chandigarh

Delhi High Court
Jul 1, 1996
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judicial Summary — Lokeshwar Prasad, J. (Order on IA 327/96)

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff, a sole proprietress, claimed proprietorship of the trade mark "MINDA" registered under Trade Mark No. 241844 (Class 9) and No. 357811 (Class 12), and ownership of an artistic work titled "MINDA" registered as Copyright No. A-47612/85. She filed a suit under sections 105 and 106 of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958 and under Section 55 of the Indian Copyright Act, 1957, seeking permanent injunction, rendition of accounts and other reliefs against the defendant.

The defendant denied the plaintiff's subsisting right to sue and challenged the legal validity of the deed of assignment dated 10 May 1993 relied upon by the plaintiff, contending that the assignment had not received legal validity. The defendant also denied other averments of the plaint. The plaintiff filed a replication.

On 26.10.94 the court framed issues for trial (listed in the next section). On 2.2.95 both parties agreed to proceed by affidavit evidence with specified filing timelines. The plaintiff filed IA 327/96 on 9.1.96 seeking permission to amend the plaint and to continue the suit in the name of M/s Minda Industries Ltd.

The plaintiff's application alleged that by deed dated 19 January 1995 she assigned the trademarks and goodwill to M/s Minda Industries Ltd., filed Form TM 24 on 6 June 1995 to record the assignment, and that the Registrar of Trade Marks allowed the request by order dated 11.7.95 and made entries in the register. It was further averred that by deed dated 16 October 1995 she assigned the registered copyright A-47612/85 to M/s Minda Industries Ltd. The plaintiff sought amendment of the plaint and permission to continue the suit in the company's name, and stated that H.C. Dhamija was authorised to continue the suit on behalf of the company.

The defendants filed a reply opposing the application. They raised preliminary objections as to the validity of the plaintiff's registration and assignment, alleged that the assignment transaction contravened statutory provisions, and charged that the plaintiff had withheld relevant facts from the Registrar of Trade Marks. The defendants contended that the proposed amendment would change the nature of the suit and was unnecessary to determine the controversy.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Deed of Assignment assigning the trade mark in question in favour of plaintiff is legal and valid? (OPP)
  2. Whether Delhi Courts have territorial jurisdiction to try the suit?
  3. Whether plaintiff is entitled to relief of rendition of accounts?
  4. Whether defendant has infringed the trade mark and copyright of the plaintiff? If so, its effect?
  5. Whether defendants have passed off their goods as those of the plaintiff, as alleged? If so, its effect?
  6. Whether plaintiff is the owner of trade mark and the copyright, as alleged?
  7. Relief.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The plaintiff (sole proprietress) had assigned the trademarks "Minda" together with the goodwill to M/s Minda Industries Ltd. by deed dated 19 January 1995.
  • The plaintiff filed Form TM 24 on 6 June 1995 requesting recording of the assignment and bringing subsequent proprietors on record; the Registrar of Trade Marks allowed the request by order dated 11.7.95 and made entries in the relevant register (Annexure-1 to the application).
  • By deed dated 16 October 1995 the plaintiff assigned the registered copyright No. A-47612/85 to M/s Minda Industries Ltd.
  • As a consequence of the assignments, M/s Minda Industries Ltd. were the proprietors of the trademarks and copyright, and the previously alleged "Permitted User" agreements did not survive.
  • The plaintiff sought to amend the plaint to reflect the change and to permit continuation of the suit in the company's name; H.C. Dhamija was authorised to represent the company.

Defendant's Arguments

  • The registration of the trade mark in favour of the plaintiff was asserted to be not proper and not valid, and therefore conferred no right on the plaintiff.
  • The validity of the assignment in favour of the plaintiff was in dispute; hence the plaintiff could not validly further assign the trade mark.
  • The assignment transaction allegedly contravened various statutory provisions; the defendant had previously challenged the original assignment.
  • The plaintiff failed to disclose material facts to the Registrar of Trade Marks and thereby purportedly committed a fraud on the Registrar.
  • On merits the defendant contended the plaintiff could not execute the deed of assignment as there was no proper and valid assignment in her favour.
  • The proposed amendment was said to change the nature of the suit and was unnecessary for determining the real question of controversy; consequently, the application should be dismissed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
54 P.L.R 176; AIR 1952 Punj. 266 Amendments should be allowed to decide rights; an amendment should not be allowed if it substitutes one cause of action for another or deprives the other side of a legal right accrued by lapse of time; injustice can be obviated by compensation in costs. The Court applied this principle to hold that an amendment is permissible where it does not alter the fundamental character of the suit and where the other side can be compensated by costs; accordingly costs were imposed.
AIR 1951 Cal. 262 It is the duty of the Court to allow amendment of pleadings when necessary for determining the real questions in controversy so that substantial justice may be done. The Court relied on this duty to permit amendment that assists adjudication of the real controversy.
Hari Das Aildas Thadani v. Godrej Rustom Kermani (AIR 1983 SC 319) The Supreme Court held courts should be extremely liberal in granting amendments of pleadings unless serious injustice or irreparable loss is caused to the other side. The Court followed this approach and allowed the amendment as no serious injustice or irreparable loss was shown.
C.M Vareekutty v. C.M Mathukutty (AIR 1981 SC 1533) Court can allow amendment where properties were not correctly or fully described or were omitted from original pleadings. Used to support a liberal approach to permitting amendments necessary for clarity or completeness of pleadings.
Bikram Singh v. Ram Baboo (AIR 1981 SC 2036) A consequential amendment should be allowed by the Court. The Court treated the plaintiff's proposed amendment as consequential to subsequent events and allowable.
Mrs. Evelyn J. Disney v. Rajeshwar Nath Gupta & Ors. (AIR 1996 Delhi 86) Bonafide amendments vital for adjudication of the real question should be allowed however neglected or delayed, if the opposite party can be compensated by costs or other terms. The Court observed there was no delay here and applied the principle that bonafide amendments should be permitted with compensation (costs) to the defendant.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court considered the settled law that courts should be liberal in allowing amendments because amendments exist to decide the rights of parties and not to punish procedural mistakes. The judge identified two express limitations on the power to permit amendments:

  • An amendment cannot be allowed if it would substitute one cause of action for another or change the subject-matter of the suit.
  • An amendment ought not ordinarily to be allowed where it would deprive the other side of a legal right accrued by lapse of time (the relevant time being when the question falls to be considered).

The court cited authority to the effect that an amendment adding a new cause of action or new defence should be allowed if it can be made without injustice to the other side, and that compensation by costs can remove such injustice. The court emphasised its duty to allow amendments when necessary to determine the real questions in controversy so substantial justice may be done.

Applying those principles to the present application, the court found:

  • The necessity for amendment arose from circumstances that occurred after filing of the suit (subsequent assignment of the trademark and copyright by the plaintiff to M/s Minda Industries Ltd.).
  • The proposed amendment did not alter the fundamental or basic character of the suit.
  • There was no prejudice to the defendant that could not be addressed by costs; further, the plaintiff had not delayed unduly and sought the amendment within a reasonable time.

On this basis, and relying on cited precedents endorsing a liberal approach to amendments (subject to the stated limitations), the court exercised its discretion to permit the amendment but imposed costs as compensation for any prejudice.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The application (IA 327/96) under Order VI Rule 17 and Order XXII Rule 10 read with Section 151 CPC was allowed, subject to payment of costs.

Direct consequences and orders:

  • The plaintiff was permitted to amend the plaint and to continue the suit in the name of M/s Minda Industries Ltd.
  • Costs were fixed at Rs. 2,000 (Rupees two thousand only) and awarded to the defendant.
  • The application was disposed of accordingly; the matter was listed on 12 August 1996 for payment of costs in terms of the order and for further directions.

The opinion applies established principles on amendments to pleadings and does not state that it is laying down any new legal precedent beyond applying cited authorities to the facts before the Court.

Disposition: IA disposed of.

Show all summary ...

Lokeshwar Prasad, J.— This Order will dispose of plaintiff's application filed under Order VI Rule 17, Order XXII Rule 10 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the CPC). The facts relevant for the disposal of the above mentioned application briefly stated are that the plaintiff as the sole proprietress of the trade mark ‘MINDA’, registered under Trade Mark No. 241844 in Class 9 and 357811 in Class 12 and also as proprietress of the artistic work entitled ‘MINDA’, alleged to have been duly registered at No. A-47612/85 under the Indian Copyright Act, 1957, filed a suit under sections 105 & 106 of the trade and merchandise marks act, 1958 as well as under Section 55 of the Indian Copyright Act, 1957 for the relief of permanent injunction and rendition of accounts etc. against the defendant named above. The defendant resisted the claim of the plaintiff and filed a written statement inter-alia contending that the plaintiff has no subsisting right to file the present suit and unless the deed of assignment is executed under the relevant statutory provisions, on which reliance is being placed by the plaintiff, no cause of action can be said to have arisen in favour of the plaintiff. On merits it is contended that the alleged assignment deed dated the 10th May, 1993 is yet to receive legal validity and as such the plaintiff cannot base her claim on the basis of assignment deed dated the 10th May, 1993. In the written statement the defendant has also denied the other averments of the plaint. The plaintiff filed a replication controverting the contentions raised in the written statement and re-iterating the averments made in the plaint.

2. On the pleadings of the parties and the material on record the learned Predecessor of this Court vide order dated 26.10.94 framed the following issues:

1. Whether the Deed of Assignment assigning the trade mark in question in favour of plaintiff is legal and valid? OPP

2. Whether Delhi Courts have territorial jurisdiction to try the suit?

3. Whether plaintiff is entitled to relief of rendition of accounts?

4. Whether defendant has infringed the trade mark and copyright of the plaintiff? If so, its effect?

5. Whether defendants have passed off their goods as those of the plaintiff, as alleged? If so, its effect?

6. Whether plaintiff is the owner of trade mark and the copyright, as alleged?

7. Relief.

3. On 2.2.95 the learned Counsel for both the parties agreed to have the evidence on affidavits and the parties were directed to file the affidavits of their witnesses within four weeks and within two weeks thereafter they were directed to file affidavits by way of evidence in rebuttal. The present application (IA 327/96) with the prayer to allow the suit to be amended and also to allow the suit to be continued by M/s Minda Industries Ltd. having its registered office at 36-A, Rajasthan Udyog Nagar, Delhi has been filed on behalf of the plaintiff on 9.1.96

4. In the above said application it has been stated that the plaintiff vide deed of assignment dated the 19th January, 1995 executed between herself and M/s Minda Industries Ltd., a Company incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956, having its registered office at 36-A, Rajasthan Udyog Nagar, Delhi has assigned the trade marks ‘Minda’ together with the goodwill of the business on the goods for which the said trade marks are being used to said M/s Minda Industries Ltd. It is also averred in the application that the plaintiff also filed a request in Form No. TM 24 dated the 6th June, 1995 before the Registrar of Trade Marks for. the purpose of recording the assignment and to bring the subsequent proprietors on record. It is alleged that the Registrar of Trade Marks vide order dated 11.7.95 has allowed the said request and has allowed the said registration under Nos. 241844 and 357811 in favour of M/s Minda Industries Ltd. and necessary entries to that effect have been made in the relevant register (copy annexed with the application and marked as Annexure-1). It is averred that the plaintiff vide deed of assignment dated the 16th October, 1995 executed between herself and the above said Minda Industries Ltd. has assigned the registered Copy Right No. A-47612/85 to the above said Company i.e M/s Minda Industries Ltd.

5. Thus M/s. Minda Industries Ltd., as per the case of the plaintiff are the proprietors of the trade marks duly registered under No. 241844 in Class 9 and 357811 in Class 12 and the registered Copy Right under No. A-47612/85. It is further averred that as a consequence of the above assignments in favour of M/s Minda Industries Ltd. of the above said trade marks and copy right by the plaintiff the ‘Permitted User’ agreements referred to in para 6 of the plaint do not survive. It is further alleged that Shri H.C Dhamija, DGM (Finance)-cum-Company Secretary has been duly authorised to continue the present suit as also to do all acts necessary for the conduct of the instant suit including signing and verifying the pleadings and depose the facts. It is prayed that in view of the above facts and circumstances the plaintiff be permitted to amend the plaint as prayed in paragraph 10 of the application and be also permitted to continue the suit in the name of M/s Minda Industries Ltd., having its registered office at 36-A, Rajasthan Udyog Nagar, Delhi.

6. The defendants filed a reply to the above application resisting the prayer of the plaintiff. In the reply the defendants have taken preliminary objections to the effect that the registration of the trade mark in favour of the plaintiff is not proper and valid and, therefore, no right is conferred on the plaintiff and that the validity of the assignment being in dispute the plaintiff could not further assign the trade mark; that the entire transaction of assignment is in contravention of the various provisions of the Act and the plaintiff cannot seek any protection for the infringement under the Act and that the defendant had challenged the original assignment and, therefore, the plaintiff was not empowered to further assign the trade mark. It is contended that the above fact ought to have been disclosed by the plaintiff to the Registrar of Trade Marks and it appears that the plaintiff has played a fraud upon the Registrar of Trade Marks by withholding the true facts. On merits it is contended that the plaintiff could not have executed a deed of assignment as there was no proper and valid assignment in favour of the plaintiff herself. The defendant in the reply have also contended that the plaintiff is not entitled to amend the plaint as prayed as the proposed amendment would change the nature of the suit and is not necessary for determining the real question of controversy between the parties. It is contended that the plaintiff is not entitled to any relief and the application filed by the plaintiff is liable to be dismissed.

7. I have heard the learned Counsel for the parties at length and have also carefully gone through the material on record. As per settled law the Courts should be liberal in the matter of allowing amendments since they exist to decide the rights of parties and not to punish them for the mistakes they make in the conduct of their cases. Two limitations on the power are these. An amendment cannot be allowed which would have the effect of substituting one cause of action for another or changing the subject-matter of the suit. The other is that an amendment ought nor ordinarily to be allowed which would deprive the other side of a legal right accrued by lapse of time—The relevant point of time being the time when the question falls to be considered. An amendment of pleadings adding a new cause of action or a new defence, should be allowed if it and be made without injustice to the other side. There is no injustice if the other side can be compensated by costs: 54 P.L.R 176: AIR 1952 Punj. 266. It is the duty of the Court to allow amendment of pleadings when it is necessary for the purpose of determining the real questions in controversy in the suit. It is a duty which has been cast upon Courts so that substantial justice may be done for which alone Courts exist: (AIR 1951 Cal. 262).

8. The Supreme Court in case Hari Das Aildas Thadani v. Godrej Rustom Kermani, (AIR 1983 SC 319) have held that the Courts should be extremely liberal in granting prayer of amendment of pleadings unless serious injustice or irreparable loss is caused to the other side. The Supreme Court in case C.M Vareekutty v. C.M Mathukutty., (AIR 1981 SC 1533) have held that the Courts can allow amendment where certain properties were not correctly and fully described and some properties had been omitted from the original plaint schedule. In case Bikram Singh v. Ram Baboo, (AIR 1981 SC 2036) the Supreme Court have held that a consequential amendment should be allowed by the Court. The Division Bench of this Court in a recent case of Mrs. Evelyn J. Disney. v. Rajeshwar Nath Gupta & Ors., (AIR 1996 Delhi 86) have held that it is a trite proposition of law, culled out from various pronouncements that bonafide amendments vital for adjudication of the real question in controversy between the parties should be allowed howsoever neglected the first omission and howsoever delayed the proposed amendment, if the opposite party can be compensated with costs or other terms to be imposed in the order. It may be observed that in the present case there is no element of delay and the plaintiff has approached for the proposed amendments within a reasonable time. In the present case the necessity for amendment of plaint has arisen out of circumstances which happened after the filing of the suit i.e subsequent assignment of the Trade Mark and the Copyright by the plaintiff in favour of M/s. Minda Industries Ltd. As a result of the proposes amendment there is no alteration in the fundamental/basic character of the suit and no prejudice is going to be caused to the defendant.

9. In view of the above discussion, the application (IA 327/96) filed by the plaintiff under Order VI Rule 17 and under Order XXII Rule 10 read with Section 151, CPC is allowed subject to payments of costs. Costs fixed Rs. 2,000/- (Rupees two thousand only) and awarded to the defendant.

10. The application stands disposed of in above terms. List on 12th August, 1996 for payment of costs in terms of the above orders and also for further directions.

IA disposed of.