Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Kochhar Construction Works v. Delhi Development Authority.

Delhi High Court
Feb 1, 1996
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (K. Ramamoorthy, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion reviews objections filed to an arbitral award. The arbitrator published the award on 30 August 1994, awarding a total of Rs. 10,78,859.95 with simple interest at 12% per annum from the date of the award until payment. The respondent (DDA) filed objections under IA.2355/95 challenging various individual claims (16 claims in total) adjudicated by the arbitrator. The court considered each claim and the objections raised by DDA and rendered decisions confirming or rejecting the arbitrator's awards, with a single modification concerning interest on interest.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the arbitrator gave adequate reasons for the awards on individual claims (notably claim No. 1 and claim No. 7) so as to satisfy contractual requirements and avoid setting the award aside.
  2. Whether the arbitrator had jurisdiction to entertain and award amounts under particular contract heads (for example, the separate claim under clause 10(C) raised as claim No. 4).
  3. Whether the arbitrator's findings on quantum for various claims (including payment withheld, extra charges, prolongation damages, and watch-and-ward expenses) were supported by the record or tainted by misconduct or error apparent on the face of the award.
  4. Whether the award of interest by the arbitrator — including pre-award interest and payment of interest on amounts representing interest (i.e., "interest on interest") — was legally permissible.
  5. Whether the court should confirm, modify, or set aside parts of the arbitral award in response to the DDA's objections across the 16 claims.

Arguments of the Parties

Objector / Respondent (DDA) — Mr. V.K. Sharma

  • On claim No. 1: Contended that the arbitrator gave no reasons for awarding Rs. 1,14,177/- and thus violated clause 25 of the contract; argued that the award on this claim should be set aside.
  • On claim No. 4: Argued that because claim No. 1's rejoinder showed modification to include payment under clause 10(C) (Rs. 2,94,693.87), a separate claim under clause 10(C) could not be entertained and the arbitrator lacked jurisdiction to award Rs. 5,892.65.
  • On claim No. 7: Asserted that the arbitrator merely indicated conclusions without giving reasons or basis for awarding Rs. 54,700 (noting discrepancy in amounts in the record) and that this was an error apparent on the face of the award.
  • On claim No. 8 (prolongation damages): Pointed to arbitrator's observations that the claimant bore some responsibility for delay (shortage of labour, sub-standard work, diversion to defect removal), arguing that the arbitrator was not justified in awarding Rs. 4,81,650/-.
  • On claim No. 14 (watch and ward): Complained that the arbitrator awarded Rs. 55,000/- without giving reasons.
  • Challenged other awards or portions thereof as erroneous or unsupported in various particulars (seeking interference with parts of the award).

Claimant

  • On claim No. 4: Submitted that the claimant had given details of payment due (Rs. 2,94,693.87) but had separately modified the claim under clause 10(C) to Rs. 15,284.46; the arbitrator, after consideration, awarded Rs. 5,892.65 and there was no error apparent on the face of the record or misconduct.
  • On claim No. 7: Relied on the arbitrator's expertise (he was Chief Engineer, C.P.W.D.) and the arbitrator's application of relevant practice to justify the figure awarded; contended the arbitrator had applied his mind and given sufficient reasons.
  • On claim No. 8 (prolongation): Pointed to the accepted hindrances and hindrance register; noted that even without considering some delays, the accepted hindrances period was longer than the required period, supporting the arbitrator's award of Rs. 4,81,650/-.
  • Generally: Argued that the arbitrator considered relevant material, applied his mind, and that no misconduct or lack of evidence justified upsetting the awards.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court reviewed each of the 16 claims considered by the arbitrator and the DDA's objections to them. The analysis below follows the court's sequential treatment of the claims as stated in the opinion.

  1. General context:

    The arbitrator's award dated 30 August 1994 totaled Rs. 10,78,859.95 with simple interest at 12% per annum from the date of the award until payment. DDA filed objections to that award under IA.2355/95. The arbitrator had considered 16 claims.

  2. Claim No. 1 (Final bill):

    Claim was for Rs. 4,00,000; arbitrator awarded Rs. 1,14,177/-. DDA argued lack of reasons and violation of clause 25. The court found "no substance at all" in this contention, rejected the objection, and confirmed the arbitrator's award on this claim.

  3. Claim No. 2 (Withheld amount):

    Original claim Rs. 1,84,135; modified to Rs. 90,135. Arbitrator awarded Rs. 90,135. The court reviewed the arbitrator's reasoning, found no reason to differ, and confirmed the award on claim No. 2.

  4. Claim No. 3 (Refund of Rs. 1 lakh):

    Claimant admitted withdrawal of this sum on 16 April 1991; arbitrator gave no award on this claim. The court records this factual position (no award).

  5. Claim No. 4 (Clause 10(C)):

    Claim initially Rs. 2,00,000, later modified to Rs. 15,284.46; arbitrator awarded Rs. 5,892.65. DDA argued arbitrator lacked jurisdiction because clause 10(C) had been subsumed in claim No. 1's modified figure. Claimant's counsel contended the claimant had separately modified the claim and the arbitrator, after considering, awarded Rs. 5,892.65. The court agreed with the claimant, held there was no error apparent on the face of the record or misconduct, and affirmed the arbitrator's award on this claim.

  6. Claims Nos. 5 and 6:

    These claims were rejected by the arbitrator; the claimant did not file objections. The court notes there were no objections by the claimant and does not disturb those rejections.

  7. Claim No. 7 (Extra charges for 4th storey):

    Claimant claimed Rs. 2,00,000 (details showed Rs. 1,18,241); arbitrator awarded Rs. 54,700 (held elsewhere as Rs. 54,200 in some passages). DDA argued the arbitrator indicated conclusions without reasons. The court emphasized the arbitrator was a Chief Engineer (C.P.W.D.), had referred to relevant aspects and practices, had applied his mind, and had stated his conclusion that Rs. 54,200/54,700 was justified. The court found no legal obligation for more detailed reasoning than that provided and confirmed the award on this claim.

  8. Claim No. 8 (Damages for prolongation):

    Claimant advanced two valuation methods leading to Rs. 19,92,834 (method 1) or Rs. 22,89,805 (method 2). Arbitrator noted the contract period of 9 months was extended by more than three years and found that major part of delay was attributable to respondents though claimant shared some responsibility (shortage of labour, sub-standard work, removal of defects). Arbitrator awarded Rs. 4,81,650. DDA argued the claimant's contribution to delay precluded such award. The claimant pointed to accepted hindrances and supporting registers. The court, having regard to the events noticed by the arbitrator and the hindrance evidence, found no basis to disbelieve or to conclude misconduct or that the award was based on no evidence, and accordingly confirmed the award on claim No. 8.

  9. Claim No. 9 (Interest):

    Claimant sought interest at 24% pre-suit, pendentelite and future interest. Arbitrator awarded simple interest at 12% per annum amounting to Rs. 2,63,083.00 from 16.5.86 up to the date of the award for amounts awarded on claims 1, 2, 4 and 7, and also awarded future interest at 12% per annum. The court considered 12% simple interest reasonable, confirmed the award of 12% for pre-award and future interest, but later addressed an issue about interest-on-interest (see final modification below).

  10. Claim No. 10 (Costs of proceedings):

    Claim for Rs. 25,000; arbitrator awarded Rs. 5,000. The court found nothing objectionable and confirmed this award.

  11. Additional Claim No. 1 (Claim No. 11 — monthly rebate deductions):

    Claim Rs. 11,921.87; arbitrator awarded Rs. 4,891. Court found no ground to interfere and confirmed the award.

  12. Additional Claim No. 2 (Claim No. 12 — extra recovery of steel):

    Claim Rs. 46,059; arbitrator rejected this claim. The court notes the rejection and does not disturb it.

  13. Additional Claim No. 3 (Claim No. 13 — cost of locks):

    Objector claimed Rs. 4,903.30 deducted from claimant. Arbitrator observed that locks should have been intimated at the time and returned; deduction was not justified. The court found no error in the arbitrator's reasoning and confirmed the award on this claim.

  14. Additional Claim No. 4 (Claim No. 14 — watch and ward):

    Claim Rs. 6,00,000; arbitrator awarded Rs. 55,000 after detailed reasoning: defect liability obligations, conditional completion certificate, evidence of notices to the claimant to remove defects until March 1986, claimant's inability to produce vouchers for long-term expenses, and limited justification only for engaging two chowkidars at Rs. 50 per month for the period May 1986 to December 1990, giving the computation resulting in Rs. 55,000. DDA objected that no reasons were given; the court found the arbitrator's reasoning legally sound and rejected the objection.

  15. Additional Claim No. 5 (Claim No. 15 — 24% interest on withheld amounts and bank guarantee):

    Arbitrator rejected this claim; the court records the rejection and confirms it.

  16. Additional Claim No. 6 (Claim No. 16 — clause 12A claim):

    Claim Rs. 2,00,000; arbitrator rejected the claim; the court confirmed the rejection.

  17. Final overall award and specific modification:

    The arbitrator's final award ordered the respondent to pay Rs. 10,78,859.95 plus future simple interest of 12% per annum from the making and publishing of the award until payment (or until the award was made rule of a competent court). The court identified that the arbitrator had directed payment of 12% interest "even on the sum of Rs. 2,63,083.00," which related to pre-award interest (interest component). The court held that "There can be no interest on interest." Accordingly, while making the award rule of the Court, the court modified the interest calculation: there shall be a decree directing the respondent to pay Rs. 10,78,859.95 with future interest at 12% per annum from the date of the decree up to payment on the sum of Rs. 8,15,776.95. The court ordered no costs.

Holding and Implications

Core ruling: The court confirmed the arbitrator's award in substance, made the award rule of the Court, but modified the award to eliminate "interest on interest" by directing future interest at 12% per annum from the date of the decree only on a specified sum (Rs. 8,15,776.95).

Direct consequences and practical effects:

  • The total monetary award of Rs. 10,78,859.95 remains payable by the respondent to the claimant.
  • The court rejected the DDA's objections to individual claim awards in almost all respects, confirming the arbitrator's findings on claims 1, 2, 4, 7, 8, 9 (subject to the interest-on-interest modification), 10, 11, 13, 14 and 16, and recorded the arbitrator's rejections for claims 3, 5, 6, 12, and 15.
  • The court modified the arbitrator's interest direction to prevent interest being paid on amounts that themselves represent earlier interest (explicitly disallowing interest on the Rs. 2,63,083.00 figure), and fixed the base for future interest at Rs. 8,15,776.95 from the date of the decree until payment.
  • No costs were awarded against either party ("There shall be no order as to costs").

Precedential impact:

The opinion confirmed the arbitrator's exercise of fact-finding and valuation discretion in multiple respects, and it applied the principle that an arbitrator's reasons will not be set aside where the arbitrator has applied his mind to relevant matters and the record does not disclose misconduct or error apparent on the face of the award. The court also applied the principle that interest should not be compounded by paying interest on earlier interest. The opinion itself does not cite or discuss any reported authorities; it resolves the objections on the basis of the arbitrator's reasons and the court's review of those reasons.

Show all summary ...

K. Ramamoorthy, J.— The arbitrator published the award on 30th of August 1994 awarding a sum of Rs. 10,78,859.95 with simple interest at 12% per annum from the date of the award till actual payment. The DDA had filed objections to the award. In all the arbitrator has considered 16 claims.

2. DDA has filed the objections IA.2355/95. On claim No. 1 a sum of Rs. 4 lakhs on account of final bill was claimed. The arbitrator having considered the matter in detail awarded the sum of Rs. 1,14,177/-. In the objection petition, it is stated that on this claim no reasons have been given by the arbitrator and, therefore, it is in violation of clause 25 of the contract and accordingly the award is liable to be set aside.

3. I do not find any substance at all in the contention. Therefore, the objection made by the DDA in regard to claim No. 1 is rejected and the award on this claim is confirmed.

4. On claim No. 2, a sum of Rs. 1,84,135/- was claimed on the ground that the amount was withheld unjustifiably by the DDA. The claimant subsequently modified the claim to Rs. 90,135/-. The arbitrator has considered all the aspects of the matter and has arrived at a conclusion that a sum of Rs. 90,135/- is payable by the DDA to the claimant.

5. I have gone through the reasoning given by the arbitrator. I do not find any reason to differ from the view taken by him. Accordingly, the award on claim No. 2 is confirmed.

6. The claim No. 3 relates to refund of Rs. 1 lakh and it is admitted by the claimant that on 16th of April 1991 it was withdrawn and, therefore, the arbitrator has not given any award on this.

7. On claim No. 4 the claimant claimed Rs. 2 lakhs under clause 10(C) of the agreement. Subsequently, it was modified to Rs. 15,284.46. The arbitrator after considering the matter in detail has come to the conclusion that a sum of Rs. 5,892.65 alone is payable by the DDA to the respondent. Mr. V.K Sharma, learned counsel for the DDA submitted that under claim No. 1 the arbitrator himself has noted “the claimant in their rejoinder dated 13.2.92 modified the claim amount to Rs. 2,94,693.87 including payment under clause 10(C)”. Therefore, according to the learned counsel a separate claim under clause 10(C) cannot at all be entertained. Therefore, the arbitrator had no jurisdiction to award a sum of Rs. 5,892.65.

8. Learned counsel for the claimant contended that the claimant had given only the details of the payment due from the DDA as Rs. 2,94,693.87 and the claim on this head was modified at Rs. 15,284.46 and the arbitrator after considering all the points has awarded Rs. 5,892.65 and it cannot be said that there is any error apparent on the face of the record or the arbitrator is guilty of misconduct.

9. I entirely agree with the submission of the learned counsel for the claimant. I affirm the award by arbitrator on this claim.

10. Claims made by the claimant on claim Nos. 5 and 6 were rejected by the arbitrator and no objections have been filed by the claimant.

11. On claim No. 7 a sum of Rs. 2 lakhs on account of extra charges towards the construction of 4th storey was claimed. In the objection petition it is stated as under:—

“Under claim No. 7, the petitioner claimed Rs. 2.00 lakhs on account of extra charges for constructing the fourth storey. As per details furnished by the claimant, the amount came to Rs. 1,18,241/- but the claim was put forth for Rs. 2.00 lakhs. The learned Arbitrator has awarded Rs. 54,700/- as partially justified claim. The learned Arbitrator has only indicated the conclusions reached by him and has failed to give any reasons or the basis for awarding the said amount. This is an error apparent on the face of the award and renders the award liable to be set aside.”

12. The arbitrator who was Chief Engineer, C.P.W.D, whose competency to consider the matter has not been disputed. After referring to the relevant aspects of the matter, arbitrator held that the claim to the extent of Rs. 54,200/- is justified. The argument by Mr. Sharma is that no reasons have been given by the arbitrator to arrive at the figure Rs. 54,200/-. This argument overlooks what is stated by the arbitrator in arriving at the figure. The arbitrator has applied his mind to the relevant practice and he has come to the decision that the claimant would be entitled to Rs. 54,200/-.

13. I am not able to appreciate what other reasons the law obliges the arbitrator to give in this behalf. I do not find any justification to accept the submission of the learned counsel Mr. V.K Sharma. The award against this claim is confirmed.

14. On claim No. 8, the claimant claims damages due to prolongation period. The arbitrator on the basis of the submissions made and the pleadings had asked himself the question whether one or two methods, referred to by him, could be adopted, as submitted by the claimant in Ex. C-79. On method No. 1, the claimant had calculated on the basis of tender rates of similar works during the extended period of contract and adding other relevant elements. Method No. 2 is on the basis of comparison and approved building cost index from time to time. If method No. 1 is adopted, the claim would come to Rs. 19,92,834/-. If method No. 2 is adopted the amount will come to Rs. 22,89,805/-. The arbitrator has noticed the work which was to be completed in 9 months was extended by a period of more than three years. Mr. V.K Sharma, learned counsel for DDA brought to my notice the following observations of the arbitrator:—

“Shortage of labour, execution of sub standard work, diverting part of the labour force for removal of defects on the part of the claimants also added to the delay to some extent in the completion of the project. The slow progress was brought to notice of claimant from time to time. Major part of the delay was due to the reasons attributable to the respondents.”

According to the learned counsel Mr. V.K Sharma having found that the claimant was also responsible for the delay, the arbitrator was not justified in awarding a sum of Rs. 4,81,650/- to the claimant.

15. In the reply to the objection on this claim, the claimant has stated “The accepted hindrances even without considering the delay due to non-availability of site and departmental stores is for a period of 1284 days against the required period of 1136 days (i.e upto final date of completion).” The learned counsel referred to the hindrance register maintained by the respondent. Having regard to the conspectus of the events noticed by the arbitrator, I do not find any reason to disbelieve from him by awarding on this claim to the extent of Rs. 4,81,650/- it cannot be said that the arbitrator has misconducted himself or his award is based on no evidence. Accordingly, I confirm the award on this claim.

16. On claim No. 9 interest @ 24% presuit, pendentelite and future interest is claimed, the arbitrator has awarded simple interest @ 12% per annum amounting to Rs. 2,63,083.00 from 16.5.86 upto the date of the making of the award in respect of the amounts awarded on claims 1, 2, 4 and 7. Simple 12% rate of interest is very reasonable and, therefore, I confirm the award on this claim. The arbitrator has awarded future interest also @ 12% per annum. That is also perfectly reasonable.

17. On claim No. 10, as against the claim of Rs. 25,000/- towards cost of the proceedings, the arbitrator has awarded Rs. 5,000/-. I don't think anything could be said against the amount awarded by the arbitrator on this claim. Therefore, it is also confirmed.

18. On additional claim No. 1 (Claim No. 11), a sum of Rs. 11,921.87 is claimed on the ground of unjustifiably deductions were made on monthly rebate, the arbitrator has awarded Rs. 4,891/- after considering all the facts. No ground has been made out to interfere with the same. Therefore, it is confirmed.

19. Additional claim No. 2 (Claim No. 12), on this a sum of Rs. 46,059/- is claimed on account of extra recovery of steel. This is rejected by the arbitrator.

20. Additional claim No. 3 (Claim No. 13) towards cost of charges of locks, the objector claims Rs. 4,903.30 and deducted from the amount payable to the claimant.

21. The arbitrator has observed that if the cost of locks were to be charged, the game should have been intimated to the claimant at that time and the locks should have been returned to the claimant after handing over the flats and, therefore, according to the arbitrator the deduction made by the respondent was not justified.

22. I do not think that the arbitrator has committed any error in his reasoning. Therefore, I confirm the award on this claim.

23. Additional claim No. 4 (Claim No. 14), the claimant claims Rs. 6 lakhs on account of money spent extra on watch and ward after the date of completion. Learned counsel Mr. V.K Sharma submitted that the arbitrator awarded Rs. 55,000/- and no reasons are given by him. The arbitrator has said-

“After recording completion certificate by the respondent, it is the responsibility of the claimant to attend to rectification of defects which come to notice for a period of 6 months. The completion certificate recorded by the respondent on 15.11.85, in reality, was not a reflection of completion of the work in all respects. It was conditional and pointed out various items left incomplete and defects existing even at the time of recording the completion certificate. As such it was the responsibility of the claimant to attend to all the points mentioned therein. Various letters exhibited by the respondent in the counter statement of facts also indicate that the respondent was constantly reminding the claimant till end of March 1986 to remove the defects and complete the left over items.

The claimant submitted details of expenses in which he had included the salaries of suprvisor, chowkidars, masons, labour, conveyance charges, head office accounts, materials such as Badarpur sand etc. The claimant could not produce any record of vouchers to prove the actual expenditure incurred for such labour force for such a long time. It was the responsibility of the claimants to attend to the defects and incomplete items which were pointed out in the completion certificate as well as in the notices issued by respondent during the defect liability period for which purpose it is understandable that there was necessity for engaging supervisor, masons, labour, conveyance, head office expenses, materials etc. There is no justification for engaging such a labour force for a period of 5 years. Moreover it was the liability of the claimant to engage such categories of labour force and materials for attending to the defects and incomplete items and the respondent has no liability on this account.

Since the handing over of flats to the occupants was delayed and continued till December 1990, as claimed by the claimant the only justification in favour of the claimant is for engaging 2 chowkidars at the rate of Rs. 50/- per month for the period from May 1986 to December 1990, towards watch and ward, which amount works out to 55 × 2 × 500 + 55,000/-. Accordingly, I award, the respondents will pay Rs. 55,000/- to the claimant.”

24. I feel that the objector is trying to challenge the award just for the sake of it. The objection by the DDA is rejected. The reasoning given by the arbitrator is in accordance with law. Therefore, the award on this claim is upheld.

25. Additional claim No. 5 (Claim No. 15), the claimant claims 24% interest on the amount withheld and the bank guarantee. This was rejected by the arbitrator.

26. Additional claim No. 6 (Claim No. 16), a sum of Rs. 2 lakhs is claimed on account of clause 12 A and that was rejected by the arbitrator and that is confirmed.

27. The arbitrator finally passed the following award:—

“Now, therefore on consideration of the claims and additional claims of the claimant, I do hereby make this award that the respondent will pay to claimant a sum of Rs. 10,78,859.95 (Rupees ten lacs seventy eight thousand eight hundred fifty nine and paise ninety five only) plus future simple interest of 12% per annum with effect from the making and publishing of the Award, till the actual payment thereof, or till the date of Award being made a rule of competent court, whichever is earlier.”

28. The arbitrator has directed the payment of 12% interest even on the sum of Rs. 2,63,083.00, which was awarded on claim No. 9 relating to the pre-period prior to the passing of the award. There can be no interest on interest. Therefore, the award is made rule of the Court with this modification and there shall be a decree directing the objector/respondent to pay the petitioner a sum of Rs. 10,78,859.95 with future interest @ 12% per annum from the date of the decree upto the date of payment on the sum of Rs. 8,15,776.95. There shall be no order as to costs.