Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sarin International (P) Ltd v. Appellate Authority For Indus. & Fin. Reconstruction

Delhi High Court
Aug 19, 1996
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion — Dalveer Bhandari, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This writ petition challenges the Appellate Authority for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction's (AAIFR) order dated 30 April 1996, which confirmed the Board for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction's (BIFR) orders dated 22/29 December 1995 sanctioning a rehabilitation scheme for M/s Stallion Shox Limited (SSL). The AAIFR had earlier disposed of Appeals No. 23/96, 24/96 and 54/96 (in case no. 9/94) by an order dated 16 April 1996 (and confirmed on 30 April 1996).

Background facts in the opinion: SSL was promoted by Mr. Ajit Sarin (Sarin International Pvt. Ltd.) with technical collaboration from Monroe Auto Equipment Company (Monroe/Tenneco). The company's financial condition deteriorated rapidly; it failed to pay significant amounts collected from workers (Provident Fund contributions and insurance premiums). Institutions and banks decided in principle to recall loans/working capital in January 1993; recall notices were sent and asset-sale suits were filed in March 1993. A receiver was appointed and sales were stayed by the Bombay High Court.

Existing promoters proposed a “One Time Settlement” (OTS) and later sought to put that proposal on hold pending interest from Monroe/Tenneco. Because the existing promoters failed to produce a viable revival plan or required bank guarantee, BIFR appointed ICICI as operating agency on 6 February 1995 to invite bids. Two bidders emerged: (i) a joint venture of Tenneco Automotive and Hydraulics Limited (Tenneco-HL), and (ii) Gabriel India Ltd. (GIL). The bids were discussed; BIFR circulated a draft scheme based on the Gabriel offer (which proposed payments and capital investment) and decided that Rs. 72 lakhs royalty be paid to Monroe. The draft scheme was published and objections invited. BIFR sanctioned a scheme with modifications on 22/29 December 1995; AAIFR later modified and sanctioned it. The petition contested jurisdiction under the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985 (SICA) and various terms of the scheme.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the BIFR (and therefore AAIFR) had jurisdiction to proceed under the provisions of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985 (SICA) in relation to SSL, given the contention that SSL had ceased to be a "sick industrial company" or an "industrial undertaking" (due to closure and reduction in the number of workers).
  2. Whether the rehabilitation scheme sanctioned by the BIFR (and confirmed with modifications by the AAIFR) was invalid because unsecured creditors' dues and promoters' unsecured loans had been wholly or partially waived without their consent.
  3. Whether the scheme unlawfully deprived existing shareholders of property by writing down shareholding by 90% and compelling transfer at 10% of face value without fair compensation or consent.
  4. Whether the differential treatment in relation to payment (or provision) for Monroe's royalty (Rs. 72 lakhs) and the settlement amounts for other sundry creditors (e.g., Rs. 94 lakhs) was inappropriate or amounted to unequal treatment of similarly placed creditors.
  5. Whether, on the record and in light of the bidding process and ICICI's appointment as operating agency, the acceptance of Gabriel India Ltd.'s offer (and the rejection of the existing promoter's proposals) was reasonable and consistent with the object of SICA and the rehabilitation process.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The BIFR lacked jurisdiction under SICA because SSL had ceased to be a "sick industrial company" or an "industrial undertaking" — the unit had been closed since October 1992 and the workforce had fallen from about 370 to only seven, so it no longer satisfied section 3(1)(f) of SICA read with section 3(c) of the Industries (Development & Regulation) Act, 1951.
  • The sanctioned scheme was bad in law because dues of some unsecured creditors were wholly or partially waived without their consent.
  • The existing shareholders were unfairly deprived of property: their shareholding was written down by 90% and compulsorily transferred to GIL at 10% of face value without consent or fair compensation.
  • The unsecured loans of existing promoters were written off, and Monroe's unsecured loan (royalty of Rs. 72 lakhs) was treated in a particular manner without Monroe's consent; there was alleged unequal treatment of similarly placed creditors.

Respondent / BIFR / AAIFR / Scheme Proponents' Arguments

  • At the time of making the reference to BIFR the number of workers was 50 or more; a subsequent reduction in workforce after the reference cannot defeat the reference — wage rights continue and dues must be settled either by negotiation, revival or winding up; hence BIFR/AAIFR retained jurisdiction under SICA.
  • Existing promoters repeatedly failed to present a viable revival proposal or provide required upfront funds (including a bank guarantee of Rs. 2.5 crores). The promoters did not place a competitive or feasible offer, so BIFR properly appointed ICICI as operating agency and invited bids publicly.
  • Two competitive bids were received and evaluated; Gabriel's offer was the best available on objective considerations (higher NPV, lower sacrifices, higher payments and capital infusion — Rs. 26.95 crores to meet liabilities and Rs. 9 crores capital investment).
  • The draft scheme was circulated publicly, objections and suggestions were invited and considered, and the scheme was sanctioned only after hearing all concerned parties.
  • The provision for payment/settlement of Monroe's royalty (Rs. 72 lakhs) was justified on public policy grounds to maintain confidence of foreign technical collaborators and ensure perceptions that legitimate dues to foreign suppliers will be honored; treating Monroe differently did not amount to an impermissible discrimination given this policy consideration.
  • In a sick industrial company where accumulated losses exceed net worth, unsecured creditors and shareholders ordinarily receive nothing on winding up; thus the claim that shareholders/creditors were deprived without compensation is not persuasive given the financial reality.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded through a fact-specific analysis and administrative-law reasoning based on the record before BIFR and AAIFR. The principal strands of the court's reasoning are as follows:

  1. Jurisdiction / "Industrial undertaking" issue:

    The court accepted AAIFR's reasoning that if, at the time of making the reference to BIFR, the number of workers was fifty or more (i.e., the statutory threshold was satisfied at the time of reference), subsequent closure or reduction in the number of workers does not defeat the reference. The court emphasized that the right of workers to wages and other dues continues and that allowing the reference to be struck off would defeat the legislative purpose of SICA. On this basis the court rejected the petitioner's contention that SSL ceased to be an industrial undertaking and therefore outside SICA.

  2. Evaluation of the bidding/rehabilitation process:

    The court reviewed the procedural steps taken by BIFR: appointment of ICICI as operating agency, wide publicity inviting bids, stipulation of a Rs. 2.5 crore bank guarantee to ensure serious bids, evaluation of bids, and circulation of a draft scheme with invitation for objections. The court found that the BIFR had taken all reasonable steps to explore revival options and that the selection of Gabriel India Ltd.'s offer was justified by objective factors (higher NPV of payments to institutions, lower sacrifices, and a substantial package to meet liabilities and inject capital).

  3. Treatment of unsecured creditors and shareholders:

    The court observed that when accumulated losses exceed net worth, unsecured creditors and shareholders ordinarily receive nothing on winding up; therefore the question of compensation for deprivation of property (shares or claims) is limited in such a financial scenario. The court accepted that in such circumstances shareholders and unsecured creditors effectively have no real property in respect of their investments or dues.

  4. Specific objections (Monroe royalty and differential treatment):

    The court accepted BIFR's justification for making provision for Rs. 72 lakhs for Monroe (royalty) despite Monroe not having consented to waive dues. The reasoning given — accepted by AAIFR and the court — was that public policy required protection of confidence of foreign technical collaborators; ensuring payment or provision for legitimate dues to foreign collaborators would prevent a chilling effect on foreign technical supply and collaboration. The court found no serious lacuna in this approach.

  5. Overall reasonableness and conformity with law:

    After reviewing submissions and the record, the court concluded AAIFR's approval (with modifications) was not unreasonable or contrary to settled legal principles. The court emphasized that the BIFR/AAIFR had heard concerned parties, considered objections, and sanctioned a scheme after thorough inquiry; modifications made by AAIFR (including options for shareholders, interest payments by GIL, and sales tax payment timetable) were reasonable refinements consistent with the aims of rehabilitation.

Holding and Implications

Holding: DISMISSED — The writ petition was dismissed as devoid of merit.

Direct implications and consequences:

  • The BIFR's sanctioned rehabilitation scheme for M/s Stallion Shox Ltd., as modified and approved by AAIFR, stands upheld by the court.
  • The petitioner's jurisdictional challenge under SICA and the challenge to particular features of the scheme (waiver/write-down of unsecured loans, compulsory transfer of shares at reduced value, and treatment of Monroe's royalty) were rejected by the court on the factual and policy grounds outlined above.
  • Specific modifications approved by AAIFR (as recorded in the opinion) remain part of the sanctioned scheme, including: (a) an option mechanism for existing shareholders to accept/decline transfer to the new promoter (GIL); (b) payment of simple interest @15% by GIL on Rs. 23.23 crores for a specified period, to be distributed pro rata among institutions/banks; (c) payment schedule for sales tax dues to the Government of U.P. (Rs. 32 lakhs by 31.5.1996) with stated consequences for default; and (d) addition of these amounts to the cost of the scheme to be brought in by GIL as unsecured loan/interest.
  • The court ordered that parties bear their own costs.

Broader implications / precedent:

The opinion does not state or purport to lay down any new legal precedent beyond applying established principles — it upholds the administrative process followed by BIFR/AAIFR in this particular factual matrix and confirms that subsequent reduction in workforce after a valid reference will not defeat the jurisdiction of SICA. The court expressly found the AAIFR's approach reasonable but did not indicate that it was announcing new legal rules beyond its application to these facts.

Show all summary ...

Dalveer Bhandari, J.:— This writ petition has been filed against the order dated 30th April, 1996, passed by the Appellate Authority for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction, (for Short AAIFR) confirming the order dated 22nd/29th December, 1995 passed by the Board of Industrial and Financial Reconstruction sanctioning a rehabilitation scheme for revival of M/s Stallion Shox Limited, for short, S.S.L with some modification.

2. The Appellate Authority for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction, by its impugned order dated 16.4.96 disposed of Appeal no. 23/96 filed by M/s Stallion Shox Ltd. and three others against the said orders of the BIFR in case No. 9/94. The AAIFR also disposed of Appeal no. 24/96, filed by the Punjab National Bank, and Appeal No. 54/96 by the S.S.L and two others against the order of the BIFR in the same case No. 9/94.

3. The Stallion Shox Ltd., was promoted by Mr. Ajit Sarin of Sarin International Private Limited and their associates in technical collaboration with Monroe Auto Equipment company (Monroe), a leading manufacturer of shock absorbers in the U.S.A

4. The financial condition of the said company deteriorated very rapidly. The said company did not pay large amounts to the Provident Fund Commissioner collected from the workers. The said company did not pay even insurance premium collected from the workers. On account of the continued unsatisfactory performance and crumbling financial conditions of the Stallion Shox Ltd., the institutions and banks took in principle a decision to recall their term loans/working capital assistance in the month of January, 1993. Consequently recall notices were sent and suits were filed for the sale of assets in March, 1993. The company thereafter approached the Bombay High Court and contended that the SSL was a sick company under the purview of Section 15 of the Board of Financial and Industrial Reconstruction, and represented that the order appointing the receiver be quashed. The High Court did not rescind its earlier order, but stayed the sale of assets by the receiver. The existing promoter (Mr. Ajit Sarin and Associates) “submitted a proposal for revival of the company entailing a ‘One Time Settlement’ of institutional and bank dues. The proposal of other promoters were also discussed in the meeting of September 22, 1994. The banks and institutions agreed in principle to the proposal, subject to the confirmation from their respective managements. However, Mr. Ajit Sarin requested the institutions/banks to put his ‘One Time Settlement’ proposal on hold, in view of Monroe (the collaborators of SSL and a division of Tenneco Automotive, USA) expressing interest in taking over the unit. The number of opportunities were given to the existing promoter but no viable proposal was placed by the existing promoter. Ultimately the BIFR in its meeting held on 6.2.1995 appointed the ICICI as operating agency. The ICICI was directed to advertise and invite bids to take over/change in management. The operating agency received two bids:

i) A joint venture of Tenneco Automotive of U.S.A and Hydraulics Limited, (Tenneco-HL);

ii) The Gabriel India Limited (for short G.I.L) both of which, inter-alia, proposed a one time settlement with the institutions and banks. The two bids were discussed in the joint meeting held on July 28, 1995 where the institutions and banks felt that while both bidders are equally strong in terms of capability to revive the SSL, the Gabriel bid is better on account of higher NPV of payments to institutions, lower sacrifices, etc. The BIFR in its hearing on August 25, 1995, felt that considering the material on record and the submissions made by the representatives of the bidders, banks, workers' union and institutions, the proposal submitted by the Gabriel may be circulated as a draft scheme. The BIFR also directed that Rs. 72 lacs of royalty payment be made to Monroe for which the Gabriel was seeking a waiver, because there was no agreement with Monroe to waive this royalty.

5. It may be pertinent to mention that despite number of opportunities, the existing promoters had expressed their inability to put any funds upfront in a no lien account. They had also deducted the funds from one time settlement obtained through companies outside India. however, the prospective sources of funds from outside were never indicated. In these circumstances, the BIFR had no option but to appoint an operating agency for finding out an alternate suitable promoter. The ICICI was consequently appointed an operating agency. The ICICI gave advertisement for getting alternate promoters. The intending bidders were given four months' time to give their proposals for rehabilitation of the company. In order to keep the bidding within the parties serious it was stipulated that the intending bidders should give a bank guarantee of Rs. 2.5 crores as a condition for considering their offer. The existing promoter did not bid, perhaps for the reason that he could not arrange the said amount of Rs. 2.5 crores.

6. The President of Stallion Shramic Sangh (Workers' Union) explained the difficulties faced by the workers on account of lock out of the company. He has even gone to the extent of saying that the company has not paid a large amount to the Provident Fund Commissioner towards contribution collected from the workers. The company had also not paid any insurance premium collected from the workers. To protect the interest of all concerned, the BIFR had to look for an alternate promoter for reviving or rehabilitating the said unit. The offer which has been given by the Gabriel was the best offer received by the BIFR. The Gabriel India Limited, had agreed to pay the amount of Rs. 26.95 crores to defray the liability of all the creditors/statutory dues/workers dues, etc. The GIL also agreed to make capital investment of Rs. 9 crores to revive the SSL. Therefore, the total investment of the GIL would be to the tune of Rs. 35.95 crores. In contrast to this, the existing promoter could not even arrange to get a bank guarantee of Rs. 2.5 crores as a condition for considering his offer. The BIFR has passed this order after hearing all the concerned parties. Therefore, this is not the case where the appellant had offered higher amount to revive and rehabilitate the SSL in comparison to the GIL. This is also not the case that any other promoter had given higher or better offer, than the GIL. The offer given by the GIL was the best available offer and the BIFR was justified in accepting the same.

7. The order passed by the BIFR was challenged before the Appellant Authority of Industrial and Financial Reconstruction (AAIFR). The AAIFR also heard the counsel and the representative of all the parties at length. The AAIFR disposed of these appeals by modifying the order passed by the BIFR on 22.12.1995 and 26.3.1996, sanctioning the same.

8. The learned counsel for the petitioner has reiterated the arguments which were advanced before the AAIFR, that the BIFR had no jurisdiction to proceed under the provisions of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provision) Act, 1985 with regard to the SSL, because the SSL ceased to be a sick industrial company under the provisions of the Sick Industrial companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985 (hereinafter referred to as the said act).

9. Mr. Ajit Sarin, Managing Director of the SSL had stated before the BIFR on 27.4.1994 that the industrial unit, was closed since October, 1992 due to lock out. The SSL had a strength of 370 workers prior to the lockout. It was also submitted by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the number of workers as on date is only seven. Therefore, it ceased to be an industrial undertaking within the meaning of section 3(1)(f) of the said Act read with Section 3(c) of industries (Development & Regulation) Act, 1951. This argument was rejected by the Appellate Authority for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction in its order dated 30th April, 1996 on the ground that at the time of making the reference, if the number of workers were 50 or more, the reference cannot be subsequently struck off on the ground that the industrial undertaking is closed and the number of workers engaged in ‘manufacturing’ has been reduced to less than 50; The right of workers' wages continue and their dues have to be settled either by negotiations, or revival or by winding up of the company. The AAIFR was quite justified in rejecting the arguments of the appellant because otherwise the whole purpose of enacting the Act would be defeated. The AAIFR was also quite justified in arriving at a conclusion that the existing promoter lacks financial capability, and competence of rehabilitating or reviving the said unit.

10. The petitioner submitted that the scheme as approved, is bad in law because dues of some unsecured creditors have been waived wholly or partially without their consent. The shareholding of the existing shareholders has been written down by 90 per cent and their shares have been compulso-rily transferred to the GIL at 10% of their face value. These creditors and shareholders have been deprived of their property without their consent and without fair compensation.

11. In the case of a Sick Industrial Company where the accumulated losses are more than the net worth, the unsecured creditors and shareholders ordinarily do not get anything in the event of winding up. The question of compensation for deprivation of property could only arise if there is any real property. In these circumstances, the shareholders and creditors can be assumed to have no property in respect of the investment or dues from a sick industrial company whose accumulated losses are more than the net worth.

12. In the instant case a draft scheme was circulated to all parties and a gist was publlished in newspapers inviting objections and suggestions from all the parties and every one was given sufficient opportunity to file objections and suggestions which were duly considered by the BIFR before sanctioning the scheme.

13. The petitioner also challenged that part of the scheme by which the unsecured loan of existing promoters were totally written off and the unsecured loan of M/s Monroe Auto Equipment Ltd. to the extent of 72 lacs have been provided for on the ground that they have not consented to waive the dues. The dues of Sundry creditors have also been settled at Rs. 94 lacs. It was submitted that there has been unequal treatment to persons equally placed. The BIFR has provided justification for making provision for Rs. 72 lacs for Monroe Auto Equipment Limited because it would not be appropriate to public policy to give an impression to foreign technical suppliers that their legitimate dues on account of supplies made shall not be paid because of our administrative and judicial processes. The full payment of this amount of royalty was accepted in this scheme so that wave of confidence amongst foreign technical collaboration be sustained. This submission was accepted by the AAIFR. We do not see any serious lacuna or infirmity in this approach.

14. We have also carefully considered submissions advanced by the learned counsel for the parties and the basis on which the scheme has been sanctioned by the BIFR. According to our view the approach adopted by the AAIFR of approving the scheme with some modifications cannot be said to be unreasonable or contrary to the settled principles of law.

15. The BIFR while sanctioning the scheme has considered various factors and possibilities. The scheme was approved with certain modifications after hearing all concerned parties and has received the approval of the AAIFR in following terms.

“a) The existing shareholders shall have an option to hold your transfer to the new promotor (GIL). Their shareholding is reduced under the sanctioned scheme. The new promotor (GIL) shall send a suitably devised option form to all the existing shareholders for exercising their option within a specified time to be determined by the BIFR.

b) The new promotor (GIL) shall pay simple interest @ 15 per cent from 1.4.1995 to 29.3.1996 on the amount of Rs. 23.23 crores (the negotiated amount of OTS in respect of the dues of financial institutions and banks as on 31.3.1995). This amount of interest shall be paid by the GIL as per the agreed schedule of payment to be incorporated by BIFR in the sanctioned scheme. This amount shall be distributed amongst the financial institutions and banks in proportion to their OTS amount as 31.3.1995

c) The sales tax dues of the Government of U.P to the extent of Rs. 32 lakhs shall be paid by the new promotor (GIL) by 31.5.1996 (without any interest) failing which it shall be competent for the State Government to recover this amount along with the interest from the S.S.L

d) The amounts referred to in (b) and (c) above shall be added to the cost of the scheme and shall be brought in by the new promotor (GIL) as additional interest from unsecured loan.”

16. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties at length. We have carefully gone through the scheme as sanctioned by the BIFR and later modified by the AAIFR. We are clearly of the opinion that the BIFR was justified in inviting new promoter to revive or rehabilitate the sick company. We are also of the opinion that the BIFR had made all serious efforts of reviving the said company (the S.S.L). The BIFR has also appointed the ICICI as the operating agency and directed the said agency to give vide publicity in newspapers and thereafter accepted the best available offer after hearing all concerned parties before sanctioning the scheme with certain modifications.

17. Looking to the totality of the facts and circumstances of this case, we do not find any merit in the writ petition. The writ petition is devoid of any merit and is accordingly dismissed. In the facts and circumstances of this case, parties are directed to bear their own costs.