Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Punjab & Sind Bank v. New India Knitting Mills.'.

Delhi High Court
Jan 1, 1996
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff bank filed a suit on 2nd April 1988 seeking recovery of Rs. 2,38,958.42 from defendant No. 1 and defendants Nos. 2-4. The plaintiff alleged that defendant No. 2, who maintained an account with the plaintiff bank, represented that M/s. Batus Retail Group had obtained a Letter of Credit from First Chicago International, New York, and requested the plaintiff to purchase or negotiate documents of defendant No. 1, crediting the amount to defendant No. 2's account since defendant No. 1 did not have an account with the plaintiff.

The plaintiff claimed that a bill drawn by defendant No. 1 on M/s. Batus Retail Group for U.S. $14,879.72 was negotiated under the Letter of Credit but was returned unpaid for non-compliance with the Letter of Credit. Defendant No. 2 and partners (defendant Nos. 3 and 4) admitted liability partially by paying Rs. 25,000, with the balance remaining due. The plaintiff asserted joint and several liability of all defendants.

Defendant No. 1 filed a written statement denying any privity of contract or dealings with the plaintiff bank, claiming entitlement to a quota transferred to defendant No. 2, and denying representation to the plaintiff for purchase or advance against the documents.

The defendant filed an application under Order VI Rule 17 CPG seeking to amend paragraph 7 of the written statement to aver that the documents filed by the plaintiff and purportedly executed by defendant No. 1 were forged and fabricated, and that none of the documents were signed by any of the partners of defendant No. 1. The plaintiff opposed the amendment as malafide, highly belated, and an attempt to resile from prior admissions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the defendant is entitled to amend the written statement to include a plea that the documents filed by the plaintiff are forged and fabricated, despite the amendment being sought belatedly.
  2. Whether the amendment should be allowed given the procedural history, including the timing of document filings and prior admissions or denials by the defendant.

Arguments of the Parties

Defendant's Arguments

  • The defendant No. 1 had no privity of contract or dealings with the plaintiff bank.
  • The plea that the documents are forged and fabricated was not taken earlier because the documents were filed after the written statement was submitted.
  • The defendant was not supplied copies of the first set of documents at the time of filing the written statement.
  • The defendant denied all documents at the admission/denial stage as soon as they became available.

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The amendment is malafide, highly belated, and an attempt to resile from admissions made in the written statement.
  • The defendant did not deny the existence of documents prepared under the Letter of Credit earlier and had admitted that the bill was drawn by defendant No. 1.
  • Copies of documents were not required to be supplied at the time under the Original Side's Rules.
  • Allowing the amendment would permit a false and inconsistent plea.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court observed that the second set of documents, which are the subject of the proposed amendment, were filed only after the defendant had filed the written statement. The defendant did not have the opportunity to take the plea of forgery and fabrication at the time of filing the written statement. Although some references were made to documents in the first set, the defendant did not specifically plead forgery then. The court noted that the defendant denied all documents at the admission/denial stage as soon as the documents were supplied.

The court acknowledged the application was belated but found that the trial had not yet commenced, and the plaintiff could be compensated with costs. The court rejected the plaintiff's contention that the amendment would set up a false and inconsistent plea, highlighting that there was no specific admission from which the defendant was resiling. The court emphasized that the merits or falsity of the amendment are not to be considered at the stage of an amendment application. The court also noted it was unnecessary to delve into the various authorities cited by the parties.

Holding and Implications

The court allowed the amendment to paragraph 7 of the written statement subject to the payment of costs of Rs. 3,000. The amended written statement was taken on record, and the interlocutory application was disposed of accordingly.

This decision permits the defendant to raise the plea of forgery and fabrication of documents despite the belated application, ensuring procedural fairness as the trial had not commenced. The plaintiff is compensated by the imposition of costs. No new precedent was established beyond the direct effect on the parties.

Show all summary ...

Manmohan Sarin, J.— This is an application filed by the defendant under Order VI Rule 17 CPG seeking an amendment in para 7 of the written statement. The defendant by the amendment seeks to aver that the documents filed by plaintiff and purported to have been executed by the defendant are forged and fabricated and that none of the documents produced by the plaintiff bank are signed by any of the partners of the defendant No. 1.

2. The amendment sought is opposed by the plaintiff, as being a malafide one, highly belated and for resiling from the admissions made.

3. The facts in brief leading to the filing of this application are:

(i) The plaintiff had filed a suit for recovery on 2nd April, 1988 for Rs. 2,38,958.42 against the defendant No. 1 and defendant Nos. 2-4. The case of the plaintiff is that defendant No. 2, who had an account with the plaintiff bank had represented that M/s. Batus Retail Group had got a Letter of Credit from the first Chicago International, New York and that the doucments of defendant No. 1 be purchased and or negotiated. Further that since defendant No. 1 did not have any account with the plaintiff bank, the amount to be advanced be credited to the account of defendant No. 2.

(ii) The plaintiff claims that the bill drawn on M/S. Batus Retail Group by defendant No. 1 for U.S $ 14879.72 was negotiated under the Letter of Credit and presented to the bank of detendant No. 1. The documents had been negotiated “under reserve. The bill on presentation was returned unpaid as the documents were said to be not in accordance with the Letter of Credit. It is further claimed that defendant No. 2 i.e M/S. Diana Exports and partners i.e defendant No. 3 and 4, admitted their liability and paid the sum of Rs. 25,000/- and the balance amount was due from them. The plaintiff claims that defendants are jointly and severally liable to pay the amount.

(iii) The defendant No. 1 had filed its written statement averring that it was entitled to quota for past performance, which was transferable and infact had been transferred to defendant No. 2. Defendant No. 1, claimed that it had neither claimed any amount from plaintiff nor any amount was paid by the plaintiff bank to it. Further that it did not represent to the plaintiff to purchase the bill or advance a sum of Rs. 1,80,000/- against the said documents. There was no privity of contract or relationship between the plaintiff bank and defendant No. 1.

4. The above background is sufficient for the purpose of the present application and the merits of the matter need not detain me any further.

5. As stated the suit was filed on 2-4-1988. The written statement though dated 14-11-1988 was filed on 1-3-1989. It is the defendant's case that the plaintiff filed the first set of documments on 4-7-1988. Copies of the said documents were, however, supplied to defendant No. 1, only on 14-3-1990. The written statement had been filed prior to the said date. The plaintiff admittedly filed the second set of documents on 22-10-1990. The admission/denial of documents was done on 5-2-1991, when all the documents including those in respect of which the defendant wishes to make an additional averment that the same were forged and fabricated were denied.

6. Mr. Chandhiok, learned counsel for the defendant submitted that the plea of the defendant No. 1 has been that there was no privity of contract with the plaintiff and there were no dealings between the plaintiff and defendant No. 1. It is by the proposed amendment that defendant No. 1 wants to take up the plea of documents, being forged and fabricaated. Learned counsel for the plaintiff has been at pains, to point out that the defendant No. 1 had not earlier denied the averments in the plaint that a request had been made by the defendants to the plaintiff bank to purchase and or negotiate the documents of the defendant No. 1. It is urged that the defendant No. 1 had not denied the existence of documents prepared in terms of the Letter of Credit. It is stated that the defence was that the bills of defendant No. 1 though in existence and purchased by the plaintiff, defendant No. 1 was not liable since no benefit has been received by defendant No. 1. The plea, however, now sought to be taken is that the documents are forged. Plaintiff claims that there was an admission of the defendant that the bill was drawn by defendant No. 1, from which it seeks to resile. Counsel submits that few of the documents in the first set of documents filed, referred to the documents which were filed later, yet the defendant No. 1 did not claim them to be forged and fabricated in the written statement.

7. On perusal of the plaint, it is seen that the second set of documents which form the subject matter of the amendment sought in para 7 had not been filed at the time when the defendant filed its written statement. In fact the plaintiff's case is that the said documents were filed after seeing the stand taken by the defendant No. 1. It also cannot be lost sight of that the defendant No. 1 during the admission/denial has denied all the documents. The defendant's basic plea appears to be that the quota had been transferred to defendant No. 2 and he had no dealings with plaintiff.

8. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case and the well settled priciples for allowing amendment in the written statement, I am of the view that the amendment in the written statement deserves to be allowed. The defendant did not have the opportunity to take the plea that the said documents are forged and fabricated when the written statement was filed since these documents were filed subsequently on 22-10-1990. Merely because a reference was made to some of these documents in the first set of documents and the defendant failed to take the plea of these documents being fabricated and forged is not sufficient to shut out the pleas of the defendant No. 1. The defendant No. 1 explains that copies of the first set of documents were not supplied to him and were not referred to in the plaint. Counsel for the plaiantiff submitted that at the relevant time under the Original Side's Rule copies of documents were not required to be supplied. On the first opportunity, these documents had been denied by defendant No. 1 during the admission/denial. The application, no doubt, is belated. However, the trial is yet to commence and the plaintiff can be compensated with costs. The plea of the plaintiff that if the amendment is allowed a false and inconsistent plea would be set up is not correct in as much as there was no specific admission of the defendant from which he can be said to be resiling. Besides the falsity or the merits of the amendment sought are not to be considered at the stage of the amendment application. It is not necessary to advert to the various authorties cited by either of the parties.

9. In view of the foregoing discussion, the amendment is allowed subject to costs of Rs. 3000/-. The amended written statement is taken on record. The I.A stands disposed of.