Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Lok Nath Prasad Gupta. v. Bijay Kumar Gupta.

Delhi High Court
Jan 20, 1995
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff, engaged in the manufacture and sale of chewing tobacco under the trademark RAJA, claims copyright in the artistic work constituting the pouch design and alleges that the defendant infringed this copyright by reproducing the plaintiff's artistic work on his own pouch for RATAN Khaini. Both parties are residents of Calcutta. The plaintiff filed suit in the present Court claiming territorial jurisdiction under Section 62(2) of the Copyright Act, 1957, and Section 20 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC). The defendant contests the Court's jurisdiction, asserting that neither party sells the product within the Court's territorial jurisdiction and alleges the suit is filed to harass. The Court is tasked with determining the proper forum for the suit concerning copyright infringement.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Which forum or Court has jurisdiction to entertain a suit for infringement of copyright or any other right conferred by the Copyright Act, 1957?
  2. Whether the plaintiff has sufficiently pleaded facts to establish territorial jurisdiction of the Court under Section 62 of the Copyright Act read with Section 20 of the CPC?

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The Court has jurisdiction as the defendant sells the infringing products within the territorial jurisdiction of this Court.
  • The Court has jurisdiction under Section 62(2) of the Copyright Act since the plaintiff carries on business within this Court’s territorial jurisdiction.

Defendant's Arguments

  • The Court lacks jurisdiction as both parties manufacture in 24 Pargana (North), West Bengal, and the defendant has never sold the infringing product within this Court's jurisdiction.
  • The suit is filed with an intent to harass the defendant due to strained personal relations.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Smt. Fula Devi v. Mangtu Maharaj & Ors., AIR 1969 Patna 294 Plaintiff must plead facts to prima facie establish jurisdiction as required by Order 7 Rule 1(f) of CPC. Used to emphasize that bald assertions without factual particulars do not satisfy jurisdictional pleading requirements.
Brady v. Chemical Process Equipment FSR (1988) 457 Jurisdictional principles concerning civil suits. Cited by plaintiff’s counsel but found not detrimental to the Court’s view on jurisdiction.
Amar Soap Factory v. Public Gram, I.L.R (1985) 1 DEL 960 Jurisdiction over copyright infringement suits. Cited in support of plaintiff’s jurisdictional claim but not found persuasive.
Glaxo v. Samrat Pharmaceuticals, AIR 1984 DEL 265 Interpretation of jurisdiction under Copyright Act and CPC. Considered by both parties; court found no conflict with its jurisdictional analysis.
Kissan Industries v. Panjab Food, 1984 IPLR 131 Jurisdictional principles in infringement suits. Referenced but did not alter the Court's conclusion.
Nirex Industries v. Manchand Footwears, 1984 IPLR 70 Jurisdictional considerations in intellectual property disputes. Cited but not determinative against the Court’s ruling.
Tobu Enterprises v. Toho Cyles, 1983 IPLR 150 Jurisdiction in civil suits involving intellectual property. Considered but not found to contradict the Court’s view.
TOMCO Ltd. v. Reward Soap, 1983 IPLR 91 Forum jurisdiction in infringement actions. Reviewed and found consistent with Court’s reasoning.
Deep Chand Arya v. Kiron Soap, 1981 PTC 108 Jurisdictional rules under CPC and Copyright Act. Cited in support of jurisdictional analysis.
TOMCO Ltd. v. Hansa Chemical, ILR (1979) II DEL 236 Jurisdiction over intellectual property suits. Considered relevant to jurisdiction issue.
Tata Oil Mills Co. Ltd. v. Dr. Gajra's Monochem Industries, 1988 (1) TMC 1 Section 62(2) of Copyright Act is an exception altering Section 20 CPC jurisdiction principles. Affirmed that Section 62(2) extends jurisdiction beyond traditional CPC limits.
Tata Oil Mills Company Ltd., Delhi v. Reward Soap Works, AIR 1983 Delhi 236 Jurisdiction under Copyright Act and CPC. Relied upon by defendant’s counsel; court considered but did not find it decisive against its ruling.
Everest Pictures Circuit, Salem v. S. Karuppannan, AIR 1982 Madras 244 Jurisdictional principles in intellectual property matters. Referenced in defendant’s submissions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the jurisdictional provisions under Section 62 of the Copyright Act, 1957, particularly sub-sections (1) and (2), in conjunction with Section 20 of the CPC. Section 62(1) mandates that suits for copyright infringement be instituted only in District Courts, overriding CPC provisions to that extent. Section 62(2) extends the meaning of "District Court having jurisdiction" to include courts where the plaintiff or any of multiple plaintiffs actually and voluntarily resides, carries on business, or personally works for gain, even if such courts would not have jurisdiction under the CPC alone.

The Court emphasized that terms like "actually and voluntarily resides" and "carries on business" in Section 62(2) must be interpreted consistently with their meaning in Section 20 CPC. The Court underscored the requirement under Order 7 Rule 1 of CPC that a plaint must plead facts showing the Court's jurisdiction. Mere bald assertions without factual particulars, such as the plaintiff’s claim of carrying on business within the Court’s jurisdiction or defendant’s sale of infringing goods there, are insufficient.

Upon reviewing the plaint, the Court found no specific factual allegations demonstrating that the plaintiff carries on business within the Court’s jurisdiction or that the defendant sells infringing products there. The Court rejected the plaintiff’s jurisdictional claim based on unsupported assertions and held that the suit was not maintainable in the present Court. The Court also reviewed several precedents cited by both parties and found none that undermined its conclusion.

Holding and Implications

The Court held that the suit does not lie within the territorial jurisdiction of this Court due to the failure of the plaintiff to plead sufficient facts to establish jurisdiction under Section 62 of the Copyright Act read with Section 20 of the CPC.

The plaint was directed to be returned to the plaintiff for presentation to the proper court having territorial jurisdiction. The suit and interlocutory application were treated as disposed of. This decision does not create new precedent but clarifies the necessity for plaintiffs to plead jurisdictional facts adequately and adhere to the territorial limits prescribed under the Copyright Act and CPC.

Show all summary ...

R.C Lahoti, J.— Section 62 of the Copy Right Act, 1957 read in juxtaposition with Section 20 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, which forum can a plaintiff invoke complaining of infringement of copy right or infringement of any other right conferred by the Copy Right Act, is the question arising for decision.

2. On the plaintiff's own showing, and admittedly, the plaintiff and the defendant are both residents of Calcutta. Plaintiff who is engaged in the manufacture and sale of chewing tobacco known as khaini under the trade mark RAJA, claims copy right in the pouch which according to him coupled with distinctive colour combination get-up and lay-out constitutes an ‘original artistic work’ within the meaning of Section 2(c) of the Copy Right Act (hereinafter ‘Act’, for short) and the plaintiff is the owner thereof. He complains of the defendant having reproduced the plainiff's artistic work in his own pouch wherein he sells RATAN Khaini and is thereby committing infringement of the plaintiff's copy right. Vide para 13 the plaintiff states, “the Court has jurisdiction to entertain and try the present suit as the defendant is selling its products within the territorial jurisidiction of this Court. Moreover, this Court has jurisdiction under Section 62 (2) of the Copy Right Act, 1957 as the plaintiffs carry on their business within the territorial jurisdiction of this Hon'ble Court.”

3. Apart from the abovesaid statement in para 13, which is the jurisdiction clause in the plaint, it is nowhere mentioned in the plaint as to how and in what manner, the plaintiff carries on his business within the jurisdiction of this Court. Nor is it stated as to how and in what manner, the defendant is selling its products within the territorial jurisdiction of this Court. The plaintiff has not alleged a single transaction of any sale of his product by the defendant himself or anyone else on his behalf in the infringing pouch within the territorial jurisdiction of this Court.

4. The defendant has specifically pleaded in the written statement that this Court does not have jurisdiction to try the suit as both the parties are manufacturing chewing tobacco (khaini) in Distt. 24 Pargana (North) West Bengal and the defendant has never sold his khaini in the jurisdiction of this Court at any point of time. It is further alleged that the plaintiff has filed the present suit before this Court with a view to harass the defendant. The defendant lives jointly with his elder brother Shri Rakesh Kumar Gupta. Plaintiff's sister is married with the defendant's brother. Their relations are strained.

5. It is well settled that the question of jurisdiction has to be decided, prima facie, by looking into averments made in the plaint and not by the plea taken in the written statement.

6. Section 20 of the Code of Civil Procedure (hereinafter ‘Code’, for short) provides for a suit being instituted in a Court within the local limits of whose jurisdiction, the defendant or each of the defendants or one of the defendants actually and voluntarily resides or carries on business or personally works for gain (subject to leave of the Court where one of the defendants only resides within the jurisdiction of the Court) or where the cause of action wholly or in part arise.

7. Section 62 of the Act reads as under:—

“62. Jurisdiction of Court over matters arising under this Chapter—

(1) Every suit or other civil proceedings arising under this Chapter in respect of the infringement of copyright in any work or the infringement of any other right conferred by this Act shall be instituted in the District Court having jurisdiction.

(2) For the purpose of sub-section (1), a “District Court having jurisdiction” shall, notwithstanding anything contained in the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, or any other law for the time being in force, include a District Court within the local limits of whose jurisdiction, at the time of the institution of the suit or other proceeding, the person instituting the suit or other proceeding or, where there are more than one such person, any of them actually and voluntarily resides or carries on business or personally works for gain.”

A bare reading of Section 62 of the Act makes it clear that sub-Section 1 of Section 62 over-rides the provisions or CPC relating to jurisdiction of the Court to the limited extent that the suit has to be instituted only in a District Court. Sub-Section (2) of Section 62, as the use of the word ‘includes’ therein suggests, gives an extended meaning to the phrase “District Court having jurisdiction”. The use of the word ‘includes’ in a legislative expression by the draftsman assigns an extended meaning to the word or expression in relation to which it is used. Artificially it is made to include what would otherwise have been excluded. If there would not have been sub-Section (2) and only Sub-Section (1) in Section 62 of the Act then the suits relating to infringement of copy right in any work or the infringement of any other right conferred by the Act shall have been required to be instituted in a District Court having jurisdiction determinable by reference to sections 15 to 20 of the code. The effect of Sub-Section (2) is that a suit in respect of infringement of a right referred to in sub-Section (1) can be filed not only in a District Court having jurisdiction by reference to the Code but also in a District Court within the local limits of whose jurisdiction at the time of institution of the suit or the proceeding, the person instituting the suit or the proceeding or where there are more than one such person, any of them actually and voluntarily resides or carries on business or personally works for gain, though such a District Court would not have had jurisdiction but for the provisions of Section 62 (2) of the Act.

8. “Actually and voluntarily resides”, “carries on business” and “personally works for gain” have the same meaning to be assigned in Section 20 of the Code or in Section 62(2) of the Act.

9. Order 7 Rule 1 of CPC enjoins a plaint to contain particulars as to the facts showing that the Court has jurisdiction. Order 6 Rules 2 and 4 require all material facts and particulars with dates and items, if necessary, to be stated in the pleadings. A Full Bench of Patna High Court has held in Smt. Fula Devi v. Mangtu Maharaj & Ors., AIR 1969 Patna 294:—

“unless a plaintiff pleads in his plaint facts which would make the suit prima facie entertainable by the Courts it cannot be said that the plaintiff has discharged the duty put upon him by Order 7 Rule 1(f) of the Code.”

10. A bald assertion, as has been made in para 13 of the plaint referred to hereinabove, without giving further facts or particulars is not enough to confer this Court with a territorial jurisdiction over the suit. The plaitiff does not allege having any shop, branch or office of his own in Delhi. The plaint also does not allege any instance of the defendant having sold the infringing goods in Delhi or having any office, branch or shop of his own in Delhi.

11. Learned counsel for the plaintiff has cited number of judgements given below in defence of his plea of territorial jurisdiction vesting in this Court:

1. Brady v. Chemical Process Equipment FSR (1988) 457.

2. Amar Soap Factory v. Public Gram I.L.R(1985) 1 DEL 960.

3. Glaxo v. Samrat Pharmaceuticals AIR 1984 DEL 265.

4. Kissan Industries v. Panjab Food 1984 IPLR 131.

5. Nirex Industries v. Manchand Footwears 1984 IPLR 70.

6. Tobu Enterprises v. Toho Cyles 1983 IPLR 150.

7. TOMCO Ltd. v. Reward Soap 1983 IPLR 91

8. Deep Chand Arya v. Kiron Soap 1981 PTC 108

9. TOMCO Ltd. v. Hansa Chemical ILR (1979) II DEL 236

I have gone through the decisions cited. I find nothing therein deterimental to the view taken by me hereinabove.

12. Learned counsel for the defendant has placed reliance on the cases of Glaxo v. Samrat (supra), Tata Oil Mills Company Ltd., Delhi v. Reward Soap Works AIR 1983 Delhi 236 and Everest Pictures Cicuit, Salem v. S. Karuppannan, AIR 1982 Madras 244.

13. I am referring only to one case which is The Tata Oil Mills Co. Ltd. v. Dr. Gajra's Monochem Industries 1988 (1) TMC 1. The plaintiff company had its registered office in Bombay and Branch Office in Delhi. The suit was filed in Delhi. Shri M.K Chawla, J. has held vide para 8 that Section 62(2) of the Act is an ‘exception’ and to that extent ‘altering the principles laid down in Section 20 of the Code.’

14. The averments made in the plaint, as it stands, fail in conferring territorial jurisdiction on this Court. It is held that the suit does not lie within the territorial jurisdiction of this Court.

15. The plaint is directed to be returned to the plaintiff for presentation to proper court. The suit and IA be treated as stand disposed of.