Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

New Bank Of India v. Master Steel Marketing Co.

Delhi High Court
Aug 8, 1995
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff filed a suit for recovery of Rs. 2,68,791.77 against the defendants under Order XXXVII of the Code of Civil Procedure (C.P.C). The defendants were served summons by publication in “The Statesman” on 28th July, 1988 and appeared on 17th August, 1988. The plaintiff moved an application alleging delay in the defendants' appearance, which was dismissed on 23rd October, 1989, with the Court condoning the delay and holding that service by mere publication was incomplete as per the precedent in Punjab & Sind Bank v. Ramji Dass Khanna. Subsequently, the plaintiff sought issuance of summons for judgment, and on 8th July, 1991, the Court noted that summons for judgment had been duly served on the defendants, who failed to apply for leave to defend within the statutory period. The defendants moved an application to condone delay in filing leave to defend and sought supply of plaint and documents, which was rejected on 22nd August, 1991, leading to the passing of the decree on the same day. The defendants then applied on 24th September, 1991 to set aside the decree, alleging non-supply of plaint and documents handicapped their ability to defend. The plaintiff opposed this application, asserting the decree was rightly passed due to defendants' failure to file leave to defend timely.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the decree passed against the defendants under Order XXXVII C.P.C. can be set aside on the ground that the defendants were not supplied copies of the plaint and documents necessary to apply for leave to defend.
  2. Whether the defendants are entitled to unconditional leave to defend the suit despite delay in filing the application for leave to defend, given the non-supply of documents by the plaintiff.

Arguments of the Parties

Defendants' Arguments

  • Defendants were served only through publication and were not supplied copies of plaint, annexures, affidavit, and documents.
  • This lack of supply of documents handicapped their ability to apply for leave to defend within the statutory period.
  • They sought condonation of delay and requested the Court to direct the plaintiff to supply the necessary documents.

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The application for leave to defend was not filed within the statutory period.
  • The Court rightly dismissed the application for condonation of delay.
  • The decree passed on 22nd August, 1991 was valid and should not be set aside.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Punjab & Sind Bank v. Ramji Dass Khanna, A.I.R 1984 Delhi 175 Service by publication is not complete if the publication does not contain copies of documents relied upon by the plaintiff. The Court relied on this precedent to hold that service on the defendants by mere publication without supplying plaint and documents was incomplete and invalid for the purpose of initiating leave to defend.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court noted that the defendants were never supplied copies of the plaint, annexures, and documents despite the plaintiff being ordered to do so. The earlier order dated 23rd October, 1989, and subsequent proceedings confirmed this non-supply. The plaintiff only served a copy of the application for issuance of summons for judgment, which did not contain the plaint or documents. The defendants were thus unable to apply for leave to defend within the statutory period due to lack of necessary documents. The application for condonation of delay was rejected on a technical ground that the defendants had not filed a separate application for leave to defend. However, the Court found these facts cogent enough to justify setting aside the decree and granting unconditional leave to defend. The Court emphasized the defendants' right to contest the suit on merits in light of the plaintiff's failure to supply documents, which was a fundamental procedural lapse.

Holding and Implications

The Court allowed the defendants' application, set aside the decree passed on 22nd August, 1991, and granted unconditional leave to the defendants to contest the suit on merits.

The plaintiff was directed to supply copies of the plaint and documents within two weeks, and the defendants were given four weeks thereafter to file their written statement, with no further extension allowed. The Court's decision restored the defendants' procedural rights due to the plaintiff's failure to comply with service requirements. No new precedent was established; the ruling primarily rectified procedural injustice in this case.

Show all summary ...

Mr. Devinder Gupta, J.— This is defendant's application under Section XXXVII Rule 4 of the Code of Civil Procedure (for short “C.P.C”) for setting aside the decree passed on 22nd August, 1991 and for grant of leave to defend the suit.

2. Plaintiff filed the suit for recovery of Rs. 2,68,791.77 against the defendants under Order XXXVII C.P.C It is not in dispute that defendants were served with the summons in the suit by publicaton in “The Statesman” in its issue dated 28th July, 1988 and that the defendants had put in appearance on 17th August, 1988. After the defendants had put in appearance, plainitff moved an application (I.A 2241/89) for judgment alleging that appearance had not been put in by the defendants within the statutory period of limitation. The said application of the plaintiff was dismissed on 23rd October, 1989 when the Court condoned the delay for entering appearance. While deciding the application, it was held that the defendants had been served through publication in “The Statesman” and since the said publication did not contain the copies of the documents relied upon by the plaintiff, therefore, in view of the decision in Punjab & Sind Bank v. Ramji Dass Khanna, A.I.R 1984 Delhi 175, service on the defendant was not complete by mere publication.

3. Plaintiff moved an application (I.A 4790/90) under Order XXXVII read with Section 151 C.P.C for issuance of summons for judgment. On 8th July, 1991, it was noticed that summons for judgment in the prescribed form for 12th September, 1990 had been received back duly served and despite service defendants had failed to move any application for leave to defend within the stipulated period. The case was directed to be posted in Court.

4. In the meanwhile, application (I.A 8298/91) was moved by the defendants seeking condonation of delay in filing application for leave to defend praying that since defendants had not been supplied with copies of the plaint, annexures, affidavit and documents, therefore, the plaintiff be directed to supply the said documents to enable the defendants to apply for leave to defend. The said application was rejected on 22nd August, 1991 and consequently the suit was decreed on the same day.

5. The defendants on 24th September, 1991, moved the instant application for setting aside the decree. It is alleged in the application that admittedly the defendants were served through publication and as per the Court's order the plaintiff had not supplied to the defendants copies of plaint, documents, annexures to the plaint and affidavit, therefore, defendants were handicapped in seekng leave to defend. Since defendants were served only with a copy of the application, which did not contain the particulars of the suit, therefore, defendants had also sought condonation of delay in moving the application and has also prayed for directions for supplying the documents.

6. Plaintiff has opposed the application on the ground that application for leave to defend, was not filed within the statutory period and the Court rightly dismissed the application for condonation of delay and rightly passed the decree, which cannot be set aside.

7. I have heard learned Counsel for the parties who have taken me through the record.

8. From the facts, as noticed above, and from the order sheet, it has to be inferred that defendants were never supplied copies of the plaint, annexures and documents. The order passed on 23rd October, 1989 is clear in that regard. Court proceedings, as recorded thereafter, also suggest that neither copies of the plaint nor documents were ever supplied by the plaintiff to the defendants. Plaintiff only moved an application for issuance of summons for judgment (I.A 4790/90) and only a copy of this application was served on the defendants along with summons for judgment. Defendants could not have, in the absence of plaint and documents, applied for leave to defend and for that reason alone, while moving application (I.A 8298/91), had prayed that plaintiff be directed to supply copies of the plaint and documents. Despite service of the copy of this application on the plaintiff, no effort was made by the plaintiff to supply such copies to the defendants. The Court rejected the application on a technical ground that since this was an application for condonation of delay in moving application for leave to defend and since there was no separate application moved seeking leave to defend, therefore, the application was not maintainable. Facts, as noticed above, are not sufficient but cogent enough to set aside the decree passed in plaintiff's favour and for the self same reasons also defendants are entitled to contest the suit on merits. The application is accordingly allowed, judgment and decree is set aside and unconditional leave is granted to the defendants to contest the suit.

S.1144.86

9. Let the plaintiff supply copies of the plaint and documents to the defendants within a period of two weeks from today. Defendants to file their written statement within a period of four weeks thereafter.

10. It is, however, made clear that no further time will be granted to the defendants for filing the written statement and in case the written statement is not filed within the period allowed, right to file the same shall stand closed.

11. List before the Deputy Registrar on 12th September, 1995 for admission/detail of documents and in Court on 18.9.1995 for issues.

Petition allowed.