- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
D.D.A v. Sudhir Brothers..
Factual and Procedural Background
This opinion arises from a dispute involving the recovery of Rs. 5,69,473 as compensation from a contractor for delay. The concerned engineer had originally decided that the contractor was liable to pay this compensation. However, the Delhi Development Authority (D.D.A) requested the Arbitrator to include this amount in the arbitration award, despite the engineer’s decision being final on this matter. The contractor argued on merits before the Arbitrator, who then held that the compensation was not payable. The D.D.A filed objections to this, contending that the Arbitrator lacked jurisdiction to decide on the merits of the compensation levy. The learned Single Judge did not address this jurisdictional issue and made the Award a Rule of the Court, with the compensation amount deleted by the Arbitrator.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Arbitrator had jurisdiction to go into the merits of the levy of compensation decided by the engineer, whose decision was final under the arbitration agreement.
- Whether the part of the arbitration award deleting the compensation amount should be set aside on the ground of lack of jurisdiction.
- The procedural propriety of including an excluded item, on which the engineer’s decision is final, in the arbitration award.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments (D.D.A)
- The Arbitrator could not have gone into the merits of the compensation levy as it was an excluded item under the arbitration clause, with the engineer’s decision being final.
- The D.D.A requested the Arbitrator to include the compensation amount in the award, but this was a procedural error.
- The Arbitrator was informed that he lacked jurisdiction to decide on the merits of this issue.
Respondent's Arguments (Contractor)
- Upon the D.D.A’s request to include the compensation claim in the award, the contractor argued on merits before the Arbitrator that the compensation was not payable.
- The contractor relied on the Arbitrator’s jurisdiction to decide the merits of the compensation claim.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Vishwanath Sood v. Union of India and Another, AIR 1989 S.C 952 | The Arbitrator cannot go into merits of matters expressly excluded from arbitration, especially where the engineer’s decision is final. | The Court relied on this precedent to hold that the Arbitrator lacked jurisdiction to decide the compensation claim which was excluded from arbitration. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the arbitration clause and the exclusion clause related to compensation, which stated that the engineer’s decision on compensation was final and binding. The arbitration clause began with "Unless otherwise provided," but no provision allowed the Arbitrator to decide on compensation. The Court referred to the Supreme Court decision in Vishwanath Sood, which established that the Arbitrator cannot decide on matters excluded from arbitration. Since the D.D.A requested the Arbitrator to include the compensation amount in the award, the contractor seized the opportunity to argue on merits, leading the Arbitrator to rule in his favor. The Court found this procedure unwarranted and held that the Arbitrator acted without jurisdiction in deleting the compensation amount from the award. Consequently, the Court set aside that part of the award and removed the compensation issue from arbitration, leaving recovery to be pursued outside arbitration. The Court also clarified that the parties cannot raise limitation as a defense due to the procedural irregularity.
Holding and Implications
The Court set aside the part of the arbitration award dealing with the compensation of Rs. 5,69,473, holding that the Arbitrator lacked jurisdiction to decide on the merits of this claim.
As a result, the compensation claim is excluded from the arbitration award and must be pursued by the D.D.A outside arbitration. The contractor may raise all legal defenses, including filing a suit if necessary. The Court also allowed the D.D.A to raise other issues not specifically challenged in the appeal. No new precedent was established beyond the reaffirmation of the principle that excluded matters cannot be arbitrated.
M. Jagannadha Rao, C.J (Oral)— Admitted.
2. So far as the claim relating to the levy of Rs. 5,69,473 towards compensation against the contractor is concerned, the contention of the appellant is that the Arbitrator could not have gone into the said question on merits as it was an excluded item on which the decision of the Engineer is final, and, therefore, that part of the award has to be set aside. The item relates to recovery of compensation from the contractor on account of delay.
3. In this case the point arises in a novel fashion. The concerned engineer authorised to determine the question whether the contractor was liable to pay compensation had, in fact, decided that such compensation was payable by the contractor. That was a decision of the officer in favour of the D.D.A This appears to be borne out by the decision contained in the officer's letter dated 20.5.1985 (referred to under Counter Claim No. 1 of the appellant/D.D.A). There was no need for D.D.A to ask the Arbitrator to include it in the award. But unfortunately, the D.D.A applied before the Arbitrator to have the said amount included in the award. If the D.D.A tried to recover it outside the award, there would have been no difficulty. Instead the D.D.A included the said amount in their Counter Claim No. 1 and requested the Arbitrator to make it part of the award.
4. The D.D.A stated in its counter-claim”… It is prayed that the learned Arbitrator may kindly award the same amount in favour of the respondent.” When such a request was made on behalf of the D.D.A, the contractor took advantage of the same and submitted an arguments on merits before the Arbitrator that the compensation could not be levied at all and the concerned engineer was wrong in finding the contractor guilty and liable to pay compensation. The Arbitrator, who thought he had jurisdiction to go into merits of the question, then decided that the contractor was not at fault and the compensation was not payable. Thereafter the D.D.A filed objections stating that the Arbitrator could not have gone into the merits of the levy of compensation by the concerned engineer. The learned Single Judge did not go into this question at all, but made the Award a Rule of the Court the Arbitrator having already deleted the above amount of Rs. 5,69,473 on merits.
5. Our attention has been drawn to the arbitration clause and also the relevant clause which relates to exclusion of certain matters from the purview of arbitration. The relevant clause 2 in the arbitration agreement deals with the question of compensation and directs that the concerned engineer should decide this question and his decision is final. The arbitration clause opens with the words “Unless otherwise provided”. In view of this language, it is obvious from the decision of the Supreme Court in Vishwanath Sood v. Union of India and Another (AIR 1989 S.C 952) that the Arbitrator could not have gone into the merits of the levy of compensation by the engineer. In that view of the matter, the D.D.A ought not to have requested the Arbitrator to include the said amount in the arbitration award. We are told by the counsel for the appellant/D.D.A the Arbitrator was in fact informed that he could not go into the matter on merits. In any event, the D.D.A committed a blunder in requesting the Arbitrator to formally include the above said amount as part of the award. Taking advantage of the said request, the contractor argued the question of levy on merits and obtained a decision from the Arbitrator in his favour.
6. We, therefore, find that the entire procedure adopted by both the parties was totally unwarranted. If the D.D.A considered that it was entitled to the recovery of Rs. 5,69,473 outside the arbitration, it could have taken such steps as it thought necessary instead of asking the Arbitrator to include the said amount in the award. The contractor was also wrong in taking advantage of the same and asking the Arbitrator to give a finding on the merits of the claim. The Arbitrator acted totally without jurisdiction in going into the said question and deleting the said item of counter claim for Rs. 5,69,473 and holding that the contractor not liable for payment of compensation. That was not within the power of the Arbitrator. In view of the said unfortunate events, we have no option but to set aside that part of the award of the Arbitrator where in he has gone into the merits of the decision of the Superintending Engineer and had come to the conclusion that the sum of Rs. 5,69,743 was not payable by the contractor. The validity of the levy of compensation is therefore taken out from the award.
7. It will, therefore, be for the D.D.A to seek to recover the said amount of Rs. 5,69,743 in whatever manner it is open to it and in case any such proceedings are taken, it will be open to the contractor to raise all defences that may be open to him in law to contend that the levy is bad. In case, the D.D.A seeks to recover the said amount of compensation from the contractor it will be open to the contractor to file a suit and raise all such contentions as he may deem fit. We make it clear that the question of limitation will not be raised by either of the parties, in view of the above unfortunate procedure adopted by both parties.
8. Learned counsel for the appellant wanted to contend that the learned Arbitrator had not gone into the other objections filed by the D.D.A in detail. We find from the grounds of appeal preferred by the D.D.A that except for the question of compensation of Rs. 5,69,743, there is no specific ground in regard to any other ground mentioned in the objections.
9. In view of the absence of specific grounds in the ground of appeal, we are inclined to permit the appellant/D.D.A to rake up all other issues.
10. The appeal fails and is dismissed except to the extent indicated above.
Alert