- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
M.T.N.L. v. Tata Press
Judicial Opinion Summary — J.K. Mehra, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
The plaintiff initiated Suit No. 759/93 alleging that the defendant Tara Press (publisher of the "Tata Press Yellow Pages") intended to publish a yellow-pages style directory in violation of Rule 458 of the Indian Telegraph Rules, 1951. The plaintiff applied for interim relief under Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 CPC (I.A. 3592/93) seeking an injunction restraining the defendants from printing, publishing, advertising or distributing the Yellow Pages booklet. No ex parte injunction was granted; notices were issued and the defendants filed replies.
The defendants opposed the injunction and raised multiple defenses including (a) that the publication is not a "telephone directory" within the meaning of Rule 458, (b) that Rule 458 is ultra vires Section 7 of the Indian Telegraph Act and violative of Articles 14 and 19(1)(a) and 19(1)(g) of the Constitution, and (c) that prior litigation and orders in other fora barred or limited the plaintiff's relief. The defendants also moved under Section 10 CPC (I.A. 6466/93) to stay the present suit, asserting that a previously instituted suit in Bombay (identified in the record by reference to earlier proceedings and Suit No. 6026/92) raised the same substantive issues.
The Court first considered and allowed the Section 10 CPC application, holding that the matter was directly and substantially in issue in the previously instituted Bombay suit and therefore stayed the suit pending final disposal of the Bombay proceedings. The Court rejected a res judicata plea because an appeal against the Bombay judgment remained pending. The Court nevertheless heard the interlocutory injunction application and, applying a balance-of-convenience analysis, declined to grant an injunction but imposed specific interim terms on the defendants. Both interlocutory applications (I.A. Nos. 3592/93 and 6466/93) were disposed of in the terms recorded in the order. The suit was adjourned sine die to be revived, if required, after final disposal of the Bombay suit.
Legal Issues Presented
- Does Rule 458 of the Indian Telegraph Rules, 1951 apply to the defendant's publication of a yellow-pages style directory (i.e., can such a publication be treated as a "telephone directory" within the meaning of Rule 458)?
- Whether an interim injunction should be granted restraining the publication, printing, advertising or distribution of the Yellow Pages (application under Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 CPC).
- Whether the present suit should be stayed under Section 10 CPC because the same matter is directly and substantially in issue in an earlier suit before the Bombay courts (including Suit No. 6026/92 and related proceedings).
- Whether the challenge to Rule 458 (as being ultra vires Section 7 of the Indian Telegraph Act and violative of Articles 14 and 19(1)(a) & 19(1)(g) of the Constitution) ought to be adjudicated in these proceedings given parallel litigation.
- Whether the plea of res judicata applies in view of prior final orders in the Bombay suit (and whether pending appeal affects that plea).
Arguments of the Parties
Plaintiff's Arguments
- The defendant's Yellow Pages is, in substance, a telephone directory or a parallel/abridged telephone directory and thus falls within Rule 458 of the Indian Telegraph Rules, 1951.
- Bulk of the entries are lists of telephone subscribers organized trade-wise and provided free of charge; only a small number are paid advertisements—this supports classifying the publication as a telephone directory.
- Rule 458 should receive a broad interpretation to effectuate its purpose and prevent its redundancy; dictionary definitions (Webster, New Oxford) were cited to show that "yellow pages" and "telephone directory" encompass classified listings of subscribers by business type.
- The plaintiff sought an interim injunction under Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 CPC to restrain publication pending trial.
Defendant's Arguments
- The publication is a commercial/trade/classified directory distinct from a "telephone directory"; reliance was placed on dictionary definitions (Collins, Black's Law Dictionary) distinguishing "commercial/trade directory" from "telephone directory".
- Rule 458's title refers to "Publishing of telephone directory" and the body of the rule refers to "telephone subscriber[s]"; thus the rule should be read narrowly as applying to lists of telephone subscribers only.
- Rule 458 is ultra vires Section 7 of the Indian Telegraph Act and violative of Articles 14 and 19(1)(a) and 19(1)(g) of the Constitution.
- The plaintiff had earlier pursued relief in other fora (City Civil Court, Bombay High Court, and Supreme Court) and failed; the defendants argued that prior failures, long-standing publications by others, and the plaintiff's inaction against other publishers amounted to waiver/estoppel.
- The defendants had incurred substantial expenditure (initially stated at Rs. 1.7 crores, later referenced as about Rs. 4 crores) and would suffer irreparable loss if an injunction were granted; they also asserted that the Bombay suit dealt with substantially the same issues, invoking Section 10 CPC to stay the Delhi proceedings.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| MTNL v. ABI Overseas Ltd., Suit No. 127/88 (Single Bench order referred to; observations by B.N. Kirpal, J.) | The Single Bench order addressed a similar interim application concerning publication of directories. It held that Rule 458 can apply to publications similar to "yellow pages" but also indicated that the rule does not preclude permission being granted to more than one publisher; in that earlier order the injunction was declined (on a different ground, non-impleadment of telegraph authorities) and the court observed that business loss alone did not justify an injunction. | The present Court relied on and discussed the earlier Single Bench order. It noted that the Supreme Court was aware of that order when it rejected the plaintiff's contentions on two occasions. The present Court treated the prior order as persuasive background but did not rely on it as determinative; instead it conducted a balance-of-convenience analysis without pronouncing finally on Rule 458's validity. |
| Supreme Court — dismissal(s) of Special Leave Petitions (SLPs); reference to an SLP dismissal on 15.3.93 | The Supreme Court (in dismissing SLP(s) brought by the plaintiff) observed that no interim injunction should be granted, particularly noting that such publications had been in vogue for a long time. | The Court recorded that the Supreme Court had rejected the plaintiff's contentions with full awareness of the Single Bench order. This influenced the Court's caution in granting interlocutory relief and formed part of the contextual background for refusing an injunction in the present case. |
| Judgment of the Bombay City Civil Court (as referred to in the record; rule struck down) | The Bombay City Civil Court had declared Rule 458 "ultra vires" the Indian Telegraph Act and the Constitution of India and consequently struck down the rule in the proceedings before it. | The present Court noted that the Bombay judgment had struck down Rule 458 and that final adjudication on the legal validity of the rule was pending on appeal in the Bombay High Court. Because the Bombay controversy awaited final determination, the present Court refrained from pronouncing on the legal validity or applicability of Rule 458 in these proceedings. |
| Suit No. 6026/92 (Bombay) and related earlier Bombay proceedings | These prior proceedings raised substantially the same issues between the same parties concerning publication of yellow pages; they were relied upon as a previously instituted suit for the purpose of Section 10 CPC. | The Court compared the plaints and materials and held that the matter in issue was directly and substantially the same as that in the previously instituted Bombay suit. Consequently, the Court applied the bar under Section 10 CPC and stayed the present suit pending the final disposal of the Bombay suit. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded in a structured fashion, addressing the Section 10 CPC application before the injunction application:
- Section 10 CPC application: The judge compared the plaints and annexures in the Delhi and Bombay proceedings and found that the issues in the present suit were "directly and substantially in issue" in the earlier Bombay suit. The Bombay plaint referred to publications both at Bombay and Delhi and its prayers were not limited to Bombay. On this factual and legal comparison, the Court held that Section 10 CPC applied and therefore the suit had to be stayed. The Section 10 stay was accordingly allowed.
- Res judicata plea: The defendants also argued res judicata based on the Bombay decision. The Court rejected this contention because an appeal against the Bombay judgment was still pending; therefore the matter had not been finally adjudicated for purposes of res judicata.
- Interim jurisdiction despite stay: The Court explained that a stay under Section 10 does not deprive it of jurisdiction to hear interlocutory applications. On that basis, the Court proceeded to hear the injunction application.
- Consideration of prior orders and rule interpretation: The Court examined earlier judicial material (including the Single Bench order in MTNL v. ABI Overseas Ltd. and the fact that the Supreme Court had dismissed SLP(s) with awareness of that order). The Court also reviewed administrative guidelines of 1971 relating to directory publication and inferred that the rule's intention included raising revenue for the department and securing indemnity against claims. It noted the absence of penalty provisions in Rule 458 itself.
- Declining to rule on validity of Rule 458: Recognising that the Bombay City Civil Court had declared Rule 458 ultra vires and that final adjudication was pending, the Court declined to pronounce finally on the legal validity or applicability of Rule 458 in this suit.
-
Balance of convenience: Because the Court avoided addressing the merits of Rule 458, the decisive test for the interlocutory relief was the balance of convenience. The Court weighed:
- Plaintiff's position: the plaintiff had a contractual arrangement with a contractor to publish directories for five years and a committed royalty of Rs. 80 crores; therefore the plaintiff alleged potential commercial loss but no imminent loss was shown.
- Defendant's position: the defendants had already incurred substantial expenditure (initially stated at Rs. 1.7 crores and later mentioned as having increased to Rs. 4 crores) in compiling and preparing the Tata Press Yellow Pages; an injunction would render that expense wasted.
- Nature of the publication: the defendant's publication was a compilation of businesses and professions; it contained numerous free entries included to make the publication comprehensive, and conceded that it did not list persons outside business categories (e.g., housewives or students).
- Protective terms: Although the injunction was refused, the Court imposed interim terms to protect the plaintiff's position pending final adjudication: (a) deposit in Court of a sum equal to the royalty provided in the administrative Guideline No. VI(c), and filing within two weeks of an indemnity bond in terms of Guideline No. III (to keep the P & T Department indemnified against actions arising from the directory); and (b) a prohibition on the defendant using the plaintiff's software for publishing or printing their Yellow Pages.
- Limitation and costs: The order was expressly limited to "Tata Press Yellow Pages, Delhi-1994" and stated it was without prejudice to the parties' rights in the pending Bombay proceedings. Parties were directed to bear their own costs.
Holding and Implications
Holding (core ruling):
The applications I.A. Nos. 3592/93 and 6466/93 are disposed of in the terms recorded by the Court.
More specifically:
- The suit was stayed under Section 10 CPC pending final disposal of the previously instituted Bombay suit (the matter being directly and substantially in issue there).
- The Court refused to grant the interlocutory injunction sought by the plaintiff but imposed interim protective terms on the defendants (deposit of a sum equal to the guideline royalty, filing of an indemnity bond, and prohibition on using the plaintiff's software).
- The order was limited in its application to the Tata Press Yellow Pages, Delhi-1994 and was made without prejudice to the parties' respective rights and contentions in the ongoing Bombay proceedings.
Implications:
- The direct effect on the parties is that the Delhi suit cannot proceed substantively while the related Bombay proceedings remain pending; interim relief in the Delhi forum was denied subject to the protective terms imposed.
- The Court expressly refrained from resolving the larger constitutional and statutory challenges to Rule 458, noting that the Bombay Court had already struck down the rule and that final adjudication was pending; consequently this decision does not constitute a definitive ruling on the validity or applicability of Rule 458.
- No new binding precedent on the validity of Rule 458 or on the central legal questions was established by this order; the Court limited itself to procedural disposition and interim protective measures.
Disposition: Both interlocutory applications (I.A. Nos. 3592/93 and 6466/93) were disposed of in the terms recorded; the substantive suit was stayed sine die to be revived, if required, after final disposal of the Bombay suit.
J.K Mehra, J.— The plaintiff has filed this suit, alleging that the defendant in intending to publish yellow pages the defendant known as Tara Press Yellow Pages (hereinafter referred to as the “yellow pages”) is in violation of the Rule 458 of the Indian Telegraph Rules, 1951. The plaintiff has also filed with the plaint aforesaid application under Order 39 Rules land 2 of CPC being I.A 3592/93 seeking an interim injunction restraining the defendants from printing and/or publishing and/or advertising and/or distributing the “Yellow Pages” booklet to anyone. No ex-parte interim injunction was granted in this case and notices were issued to the defendants who have since filed reply to the injunction application. The case of the plaintiff mainly is that the publication and printing of the said yellow pages in the form sought to be published by the defendant is nothing but publication of a parallel directory in an abridged form on the line of the yellow pages which are at present forming a supplement to the directory of the telephone subscribers being got printed by the plaintiff. It is further contended by the plaintiff that bulk of the entries of the “yellow pages” are mere list of telephone subscribers listed Trade-wise free of charge and only a small number of such parties are coming forward with advertisements in the said “yellow pages” and to the extent that the “yellow pages” can be described as a list of telephone subscribers and that would be deemed to be publication of a telephone directory as contemplated by the aforesaid Rule 458 of Indian Telegraph Rules. Counsel for the plaintiff has contended that the aforesaid rule should receive widest possible interpretation and that any limited interpretation would only defeat the intention of the rule and make it redundant. Counsel has cited the meaning given to telephone directory in certain dictionaries such as Webster wherein it has been given the following meaning:—
“classified section of telephone directory listing subscribers by the type of business or service they offer”.
And new Oxford English Dictionary wherein directory is defined as under:—
“A book containing an alphabetical or classified, list of the people in some category, e.g telephone subscribers or clergy with information about them.”
2. In the same dictionary yellow pages have also been separately dealt with which is as under:—
“(proprietory name for) the classified section of or supplement to a telephone directory, printed on yellow paper and listing firms, products and services.”
3. The claim of the plaintiff both in suit as also injunction application has been contested by the defendants. Counsel for defendants has cited Collin dictionary wherein the expressions “Directory”, “Classified Directory”, “Commercial Directory or Trade Directory” and “Telephone Directory” are explained as under:—
“Directory” noun list of people or businesses with information about their addresses and telephone numbers:
“Classified Directory” list of businesses grouped under various headings, such as computer shopes or newsagents:
“Commercial Directory or trade Directory” book which lists all the businesses and business people in a town;
“Telephone Directory” book which lists all people and business who have telephones, in alphabetical order with their phone numbers.
4. He has argued that the expressions “Commercial Directory or Trade Directory” convey quite distinct and different meaning from “Telephone Directory” and they cannot be deemed to be the same. He also cited Black's Law Dictionary wherein word “Directory” is explained as under:—
“Directory”, Book containing names, addresses, and occupations of inhabitants of city. Also any list or compilation, usually in book or pamphlet form, or persons, professional organisations, firms or corporations forming some class separate and distinct from others, e.g telephone directory, lawyer's directory, hotel directory etc.”
It is further contended that the order on the interim injunction application which was passed against the plaintiff was also challenged both before the City Civil Court and Bombay High Court as well as Supreme Court and in all these for a the plaintiffs failed and to that extent the Court here should also stay its hands from granting any injunction. They have been to the Supreme Court twice, once against the interlocutary order being revised by the Trial court as also the High Court and second time when the appeal against the final judgment was admitted but no interlocutary order was granted to the plaintiff and on each occasion, Supreme Court dismissed the SLP. Secondly, it is alleged that not only a similar injunciton application had failed at Bombay but the publication of yellow pages by different publishers has gone on for quite some time and that even recenlty another publication, which is not even on yellow pages but is on while pages, published by Business India known as “Business Pages”, has been published known “Exporter's Yellow Pages”. It has also been published recently and the plaintiffs have not taken any action against any of those thereby by their own conduct they are deemed to have waived their right and are estopped from challenging or objecting to any such publication. They have also cited instances of “Sell Pages” which has been published for the past server years (since 1984) and in that particular publication even plaintiffs dvertisements have appeared in the 1990 Edition of Sell pages.
5. The defendant has also contested the applicability of Rule 458 on various grounds. Firstly they contended that the rule itself has no application to their publication because the title of the rule which reads “Publishing of telephone directory (emphasis supplied), but the rule in its body does not repeat the expression telephone directory but merely states “except with the permission of telegraph authority no person shall publish any of telephone subscriber” which would suggest the words “telephone directory” in the title of the rule and intended to mean list of telephone subscribers only. It is further contended that no such restriction could have been imposed under the Rules as such the rule was ultra vires Section 7 of the Indian Telegraph Act which lays down the rule making powers of the Telegraph authority. They have further contended that the said Rule 458 is also ultra vires the Constitution of India being violative of Article 14,19(I)(a) and 19(1)(g), and lastly counsel of the defendant contended that the Supreme Court while dismissing the SLP on 15.3.93 observed that no interim injunction should be granted particularly in the light of the such publications having been in vogue for a long time.
6. The defendant also moved a substantive application u/Sec. 10 of CPC being I.A No. 6466/93 praying for the stay of the present suit pending hearing and final disposal of the suit No. 6026/92 at Bombay. It has been pointed out that the suit has since been disposed of by a judgment of the City Civil Court which has been decided against the plaintiff and an appeal against the said judgment is still pending before Bomby High Court. The Bombay Suit was also for the stay of publication of similar yellow pages of this very defendant at Bombay and the issues raised by the plaintiff before the Court at Bomaby were substantially the same. The other ground of opposition also which had been taken before the Court at the time of arguments apart from the matter being directly covered by the judgment of Bomaby Court, are it has been further urged on behalf of the defendant that the controversy in the present suit itself would be barred by the principle of res judicate inasmuch as Bombay City Civil Court has finally disposed of the suit and it is now only an appeal which is pending before the High Court of Bombay.
7. In support of its application u/Sec. 10 the defendant has filed copies of the plaint at Bombay apart from the various orders passed in the proceedings at Bombay which I have perused in support of their contention that the Court should not proceed with the trial of this suit as the matter in issue in the present suit is directly and substantially in issue in the Bombay suit which happens to be previously instituted suit between the same parties. They have, however, not challenged the jurisdiction of this Court to deal with the interim relief applications even if the provisions of section 10 of cpc impose a bar to the trial of a particular suit. The Counsel for the defendant however, states that in the light of their contention that the suit itself is not maintainable the suit in any event should not be proceeded with and even the interlocutary applications should not be entertained.
8. I have considered the various contentions and would like to deal with the second application first. I have compared the plaint before the Bombay Court as also before this Court and also the other annexures filed with the application. I find that the matter in issue before this Court in the suit is in fact directly and substantially in issue in the previously instituted suit at Bombay. Not only that I find that in the body of the suit before Bombay Court the venue of the publication of yellow pages both at Bombay and Delhi have been referred to and the prayer also is not limited only to the publication of yellow pages at Bombay. In that view of the matter I hold that the bar of Section 10 CPC would be attracted in and as such the proceedings in the suit have to be stayed. Therefore, I allow this application and stay the suit pending final disposal of the suit at Bombay.
9. Counsel for the defendant also raised the plea of the present suit being barred by the principle of res-judicata. On their own showing appeal against the final judgment of the Court at Bombay is still pending. As such it cannot be said that any matter in issue before the Bombay Court stands finally adjudicated upon and for that reason I cannot entertain the plea of res-judicata. This plea is therefore rejected.
10. By the stay of the suit under section 10 of cpc the jurisdiction of Court to entertain and deal with interim applications seeking urgent relief in the interest of justice is not taken away. The Court can hear such applications and pass such interim orders as may be deemed appropriate and it is in the light of this legal position that I proceeded to hear both the parties in respect of the injunction application.
11. In support of his contention Mr. Sikri has strongly relie upon the observations by B.N Kirpal, J. on a similar application in an earlier suit against another party namely MTNL v. ABI Overseas Ltd, Suit No. 127/88. I may point out that this particular order of the Single Bench of this Court while disposing of that interim application was brought to the notice of the Hon'ble Supreme Court and that with full awareness of what had been held in this order, the Supreme Court rejected the contentions of the plaintiff on both the occasions. Furthermore, I may point out that while disposing of the application the Court had declined the injunction though on a different ground i.e of non-impleadment of telegraph authorities and since relief had been declined the defendant in that suit did not take the matters any further by filing any appeal against the reasons given in such an order, as there was no occasion for challenging the said order and testing it in appeal. In that order, however, this Court had held that Rule 458 does apply to cases similar to defendants yellow pages though it also states that said rule does not preclude permission to be granted to more than one person to publish telephone directory. The Court in that very order had held “merely because business of the plaintiff may be adversely affected by the defendant publishing yellow pages is not sufficient to enable the plaintiff in this case to ask for an injunction against the defendant”. The intention of the rules has to be drawn from the context in which those were framed. In 1951, there was no publication like the yellow pages in vogue. My attention is drawn to the certain guidelines which the department had come out within the year 1971 for allowing publication of directories. A perusal of the said guidelines shows that the intention of the rule as reflected in the guidelines is primarily to avail of some revenue for publication of such telephone directories by other parties as certain rates had been prescribed as the free for permission and that to secure indemnity for the department against any action or adverse claim that the Department may be exposed to on account of such publication. Nothing further has been indicated to me as the intention behind the rule. Furthermore, no penalties have been provided for any violation of this rule, though there does exist authority for making such rules laying down penalty or fines etc. In the Bombay suit the Court has already declared Rule 458 as ultra vires the Act as also Constitution of India and the said rule has consequently been struck down. In the light of such controversy awaiting final adjudication at Bombay it will not be appropriate for me to pronounce either way in respect of the legal validity or applicability of the said rule. I have compared the publications of the defendant with that of the “Business Pages” and “Exporters' Yellow Pages”. The defendants yellow pages are a compilation of various persons in different businesses and professions and they do not include the name of any person who does not belong to any particular business or class of business or profession such as housewives or students. It is conceded by the defendants Counsel that there are a large number of free entries in their publication which have been included primarily with the object of making a publication more comprehensive and informative for information of the various businesses. In the light of the above I think the main consideration befoe Court in dealing with the present applications should be that of balance of convenience as I do not wish to pronounce on the merits of the plaintiffs case due to pendency before Bombay Court. The main contention of the plaintiff is that they at present are getting the directories published through a contractor who has been conceded the benefit of revenue that he may earn from the yellow pages which appear as a supplement to the plaintiff's telephone directory and it is on account of possiblity of earning adequate profit that the contractors can be lured not only to print the directories for the plaintiff free of charge which otherwise would have cost the plaintiff about Rs. 600/- per set of directory which would cost the plaintiff an enormous amount but have come forward to pay royalty to the plaintiff. It is further conceded that at present there is no imminent danger of any loss as the present contractor has contracted to publish directory for the next five years and has also committed to pay to the plaintiff a royalty of Rs. 80 crores. On the other hand, the defendants have alleged that they had already committed Rs. 1.7 crores which at the time of arguments was mentioned as having swelled to Rs. 4 crores by way of expense which has already been incurred in compiling the Tata Press Yellow Pages, Delhi, proof copy and arranging for the paper required to turn out the final prints and if injunction is granted all this expense and effort will go waste. In the light of these facts and keeping in view the totality of circumstances I am of the view that balance of convenience is in favour of the defendant and as such, am not inclined to grant an injunction against defendant, I, however, think that it will be in the interest of justice if the defendants are put to certain terms which are as under:—
(1) The defendant shall deposit in this Court a sum equal to the royality provided in the Guideline No. VI(c) and also the defendant should file in this Court within two weeks from today an indemnity bond in terms of Guideline No. III which reads as under:—
“The publishers shall keep the P & T Department indemnified against all actions, proceedings, claims and demands whatsoever made against the department by reason of anything contained in the directory, so published.”
(2) The defendant shall not make use of the plaintiffs software for publishing or printing their Yellow Pages.
This order shall apply only to the Tata Press Yellow Pages, Delhi-1994 and will be without prejudice to the respective rights and contentions of the parties either in this suit or in the proceedings before the Bombay Court, nor will it be treated as an expression of opinion on the merits of either party's case in the suit.
In the circumstances of the case, parties are left to bear their own costs.
Both I. As. No. 3592/93 and 6466/93 are disposed of in the above terms.
Suit No 759/93.
In the light of the order passe on I.A 6466/93 application today, the suit is adjourned sine die to be revived, if required, after the final disposal of the suit filed in Bombay Court.
Alert