Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Anil Kumar Malik v. Delhi Administration, Delhi .

Delhi High Court
May 12, 1993
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judicial Opinion Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition concerns an application for bail under section 439 of the Criminal Procedure Code (the Code) filed by the accused, Anil Kumar Malik. During the pendency of the bail petition an application (Cr.M.508/93) was filed by the complainant, Mrs. Kusum Malik, seeking to be impleaded among the respondents and to be heard in opposition to the bail application.

The First Information Report (FIR) against the petitioner was registered under sections 376, 384, 506 and 34 of the Indian Penal Code. The complaint alleges that the complainant, who was married to Om Prakash Malik (a cousin of the petitioner) in January 1981, had prior correspondence (letters) with the petitioner. In May 1986 the petitioner is alleged to have shown those letters to the complainant, threatened to show them to her husband, compelled her to submit to sexual acts, repeatedly extorted money (Rs. 50,000 three times), brought other persons to sexually assault her and continued to blackmail and rape her until August 1992. The complainant later revealed these events to her husband, who became unconscious and required hospitalization. The complainant then attempted, unsuccessfully, to kill the petitioner and commit suicide. She lodged a report with the police on 10 January 1993 and the FIR was registered.

Procedurally, the core issue for the Court was whether the complainant has a right to intervene and be heard in opposition to the accused's petition for bail. The petitioner opposed impleadment. Counsel for the State supported the petitioner's position that the complainant should not be allowed to intervene where the State is represented. The Court dismissed the impleadment application (Cr.M.508/93) and listed the main bail petition (Cr.M(M)248/93) for arguments on merits.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a complainant (private party/informant) has the right to intervene and be heard in opposition to an accused's petition for bail under section 439 of the Code, particularly when the State is represented by counsel.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant / Petitioner (represented by Mr. Grover)

  • Submitted that the complainant has no right to be heard in a petition filed by an accused for release on bail.
  • Argued that an aggrieved/private party can approach the High Court for cancellation of bail, but does not have a right to intervene in the bail application itself where the State is represented.
  • Relied on sections 301(2) and 302 of the Code to suggest that the complainant party may bring facts to the notice of the State counsel and otherwise has no independent right to be heard when the State is duly represented.
  • Placed reliance on several judicial decisions (listed to support his contention that private parties cannot independently intervene in bail applications).

Complainant / Applicant to Intervene (represented by Mr. Mathur)

  • Contended that sections 300 and 301 of the Code apply only when a case is under inquiry, trial or appeal and are not applicable to High Court bail proceedings.
  • Invoked statutory provisions (section 198A; sections 154(2), 157(2) and section 173(2)(ii) of the Code) to argue that the informant/aggrieved party has certain rights under the Code and therefore a right to be heard in the present proceedings.
  • Placed reliance on the Supreme Court decision in Bhagwant Singh v. Commissioner of Police (AIR 1985 SC 1285) to support the proposition that an informant has a right to notice and an opportunity to be heard where a magistrate considers not taking cognizance under section 173(2) of the Code, and argued by analogy that complainant should be heard in bail proceedings.
  • Distinguished some earlier High Court decisions by arguing certain authorities did not consider Bhagwant Singh; and relied on the contention that the present application seeks only permission to intervene where jurisdiction has already been invoked by the accused.

State (represented by Mr. Bahri)

  • Supported the petitioner's submissions that private parties should not be permitted to intervene when the State is properly represented.
  • Specifically submitted there is no allegation that the State counsel has abdicated functions; therefore, the private party should not be allowed to intervene.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kuldip Singh v. State of Haryana (1980 Crl.L.J 1159) Authority from Punjab & Haryana High Court relied upon to support that complainant cannot independently intervene in bail applications. Referenced as one of the authorities relied upon by the Single Judge in Indu Bala; treated as persuasive support that complainants have no statutory right to independently address bail applications.
Sarwar Kumar v. State of Haryana, 1989 (2) RCR 469 Punjab & Haryana High Court decision considered relevant to the question of complainant's right to intervene in bail proceedings. Used by the Single Judge in Indu Bala and treated as precedent that the ratio of Bhagwant Singh is not applicable to bail/anticipatory bail under s.438; court relied on its reasoning to deny complainant's right to intervene.
Indu Bala, Ajesh Kumar v. State, 1990 RLR 131 Held that there is no provision in the Criminal Procedure Code allowing a complainant to intervene and make independent submissions in opposition to bail/anticipatory bail applications; counsel for complainant may brief State counsel but only State counsel is to be heard. The Court expressly agreed "with respect" and followed the law laid down in Indu Bala as directly on point for the present matter.
Praveen Malhotra v. State (Delhi Administration), 41 (1990) DLT 418 (also reported 41 (1990) DLT 30 on merits) Applied Indu Bala's principle that private parties have no independent right to intervene in bail applications; record shows complainant's counsel was allowed to address only after the Public Prosecutor consented. Cited as a later decision following Indu Bala; Court noted that in Praveen Malhotra the intervener was allowed to assist the Court only after the Public Prosecutor gave no objection—used to support the proposition complainant's counsel can assist only with State's consent.
In Re: Rakhaan Ojha alias Rakhal Chandra Ojha, 1988 Crl.L.J 278 Listed among authorities relied upon by the petitioner in support of the proposition that complainants cannot independently intervene in bail applications. Referenced by petitioner; the opinion does not elaborate a specific rule from this decision in its reasoning beyond listing it among relied authorities.
Thakur Ram and others v. The State of Bihar, AIR 1966 SC 911 Supreme Court decision cited for the proposition that a private party cannot invoke jurisdiction under the provisions of the Code. Cited by petitioner and discussed by counsel; the Court noted counsel's submission that Thakur Ram held private parties cannot invoke jurisdiction under the Code, but also noted the factual distinction argued by the complainant’s counsel that here jurisdiction had already been invoked by the accused.
Bhagwant Singh v. Commissioner of Police, AIR 1985 SC 1285 Held that when a magistrate decides not to take cognizance under section 173(2) of the Code, the magistrate must give notice to the informant and provide an opportunity to be heard; recognizes certain statutory rights of the informant under section 173(2)(ii). Placed reliance upon by the complainant. The Court distinguished this authority as inapplicable to bail proceedings under section 439/438 because Bhagwant Singh concerned statutory rights of informants under section 173(2) and communication by police, not the question of an aggrieved party's right to be heard in bail applications where the State is represented.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court addressed whether section 439 of the Code, under which the accused sought bail, contemplates any independent right for a complainant to be heard in the bail proceedings. The Court proceeded through the following analytical steps, reflecting only the reasoning set out in the opinion:

  1. The Court observed that section 439 by itself does not contemplate any hearing to be given to the complainant party in a police case.
  2. The Court reviewed relevant High Court authority, particularly the Single Judge decision in Indu Bala, which relied on Punjab & Haryana High Court decisions (Kuldip Singh and Sarwan Kumar) and held that there is no provision in the Code permitting a complainant to intervene and make independent submissions in opposition to bail applications; rather, the complainant's counsel can brief the State counsel and it is the State counsel who is to be heard.
  3. The Court noted that the ratio in Indu Bala was followed in Praveen Malhotra. The Court expressly stated its agreement with Indu Bala and adopted that principle for the present case.
  4. The Court considered the complainant's reliance on the Supreme Court judgment in Bhagwant Singh, which requires the magistrate to give notice and an opportunity to be heard to an informant when a report under section 173(2) is not acted upon by the magistrate. The Court examined and distinguished Bhagwant Singh on its facts and statutory basis: Bhagwant Singh deals with statutory rights of the informant under section 173(2)(ii) (communication of action taken by the police and the forwarding of report to a magistrate) and concerns the magistrate's consideration of the police report, not the question of intervention in a bail hearing.
  5. On this distinction the Court concluded that the ratio of Bhagwant Singh cannot be applied where an application for bail is being considered; the statutory position and interest of an informant in section 173(2) does not translate into a right for an aggrieved party to be heard in bail proceedings under section 439 (or 438) when the State is represented.
  6. The Court also observed that in Praveen Malhotra the complainant's counsel was permitted to address the Court only after the Public Prosecutor gave his no objection—showing that any participation by a private party in such a hearing is conditional on the State's representation and consent.
  7. Accordingly, the Court concluded that where the State counsel is properly representing the prosecution and there is no allegation of abdication of functions by the State counsel, a private complainant has no independent right to be heard in a petition for grant of bail. The complainant's counsel may, however, brief the State counsel, who alone will be heard in opposition.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court held that the complainant has no right to be heard in a petition for grant of bail when the State is properly represented and there is no allegation that the State counsel has abdicated his functions. The application for impleadment and to be heard (Cr.M.508/93) was dismissed.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The complainant (Mrs. Kusum Malik) was not permitted to be heard separately in opposition to the accused's bail petition; the impleadment application (Cr.M.508/93) was dismissed.
  • Practical guidance: A complainant's counsel may brief the State counsel, and any assistance by a complainant's counsel in Court on a bail application is permissible only in circumstances such as where the Public Prosecutor gives consent or where there is an allegation that the State counsel has abdicated duties.
  • Broader precedent: The Court applied and followed earlier High Court decisions (e.g., Indu Bala, Praveen Malhotra) and distinguished Bhagwant Singh; the opinion does not purport to create any broader new legal principle beyond applying and following existing authority on the limited question of participation in bail hearings.

Order: Cr.M.508/93 is dismissed. The main bail matter Cr.M(M)248/93 was listed for arguments on merits on 19th May, 1993.

Show all summary ...

Sat Pal, J.:— This petition for grant of bail under section 439 Criminal Procedure Code (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Code’) has been filed by Anil Kumar Malik. During the pendency of the bail petition an application being Cr.M.508/93 has been filed on behalf of the complainant Mrs. Kusum Malik for impleading her in the array of respondents. The aforesaid application has been strongly opposed on behalf of the petitioner, It has, therefore, become necessary to decide the question; whether applicant has a right to intervene and be heard in opposition to the petition for bail.

2. First Information Report in the present case has been registered against the petitioner under sections 376/384/506/34 IPC at the instance of the complainant Mrs. Kusum Malik. It has been alleged in the complaint that the complainant was married to one Om Prakash Malik, who happens to be a counsin of the petitioner Anil Kumar Malik, in January, 1981. It is further stated in the complaint that before marriage the complainant wrote some letters to the petitioner and after her marrige with Om Prakash Malik had forgotton all about these letters written to Anil Kumar Malik. It is alleged that in May 1986 when there was no one else at the house of the complainant, the petitioner came to the house and showed her the letters and compelled her to submit to his lust under threat of showing these letters to her husband. It is also alleged that the complainant paid Rs. 50,000/- thrice to the petitionerout of fear of the threats beinggiven to her. It is further alleged that the petitioner even brought some other persons along with him and made the complainant to submit herself to satisfy the lust of those persons and he continued black mailing her and raping her against her consent upto August 1992.

3. It is further alleged that finally the complainant decided to tell her husband all these facts and on hearing these facts, her husband became unconscious and had to be taken to a hospital. Thereafter, the complainant decided to murder the petitioner and then to commit suicide but she was not successful. Finally the complainant lodged a report with the police against the petitioner on 10th January, 1993 and the First Information Report was registered against the petitioner.

4. Mr. Grover, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitoiner has strongly objected to give any hearing to the learned counsel for the complainant and submitted that the complainant has no right to be heard in a petition filed by an accused for his release on bail. Learned counsel, however, submitted that an aggrieved party can approach the High Court for cancellation of bail. He drew my attention to sections 301(2) and 302 of the code and contended that the complainant party may bring facts to the notice of the State counsel and apart from that, the complainant party has got no right to be heard particularly when the State is duly represented. In support of his contentions he placed reliance on the following judgments:

1.) Kuldip Singh v. State of Haryana, 1980 Crl.L.J 1159.

2.) Sarwar Kumar v. State of Haryana, 1989 (2) Recent Crime Reporter 469.

3.) Indu Bala, Ajesh Kumar v. State, 1990 RLR 131.

4.) Praveen Malhotra v. State (Delhi Administration), 41 (1990) DLT 418.

5) In Re: Rakhaan Ojha alias Rakhal Chandra Ojha, 1988 Crl.L.J 278. and

6) Thakur Ram and others v. The State of Bihar, AIR 1966 SC 911.

5. Mr. Mathur, learned Senior Advocate, appearing on behlaf of the complainant, however, submitted that sections 300 and 301 of the code are applicable only when the case is under inqury, trial or appeal and the aforesaid provisions are not applicable to the proceedings before the High Court for grant of bail because High Court is not a court of original jurisdiction in criminal matters. Learned counsel also drew my attention to section 198a of the code and contended that in a case of an offence punishable under section 498-A, IPC a Court can take cognizance only on a police report or upon a complaint made by the person aggrieved by the offence or by her father, mother and other relations. He also drew my attention to Sections 154(2), 157(2) and sub-section (2)(ii) of section 173 of the Code in terms of which informant has been given certain rights under the Code. He, therefore, contended that the aggrieved party has a right to be heard in the present case.

6. In support of his contention Mr. Mathur placed reliance on a Supreme Court judgment in Bhagwant Singh v. Commissioner of Police, AIR 1985 SC 1285. In this case it was held by the Supreme Court that in a case where the magistrate to whom a report is forwarded under sub-section (2) of Section 173 of the Code decides not to take cognizance of the offence and drop the proceedings, the magistrate must give notice to the informant and provide him an opportunity to be heard at the time of consideration of the report. It was further held that though under the provision of the Code or from the principle of natural justice, no obligation is cast on the magistrate to issue notice to the injured person or relation of the deceased (other than the informant) for providing such person an opportunity to be heard but such person can appear before the magistrate and make his submission when the report is considered by the magistrate for the purpose of deciding of the action he should take on the report. Relying on this judgment Mr. Mathur contended that in case the informant or other relations appear before the Court of Sessions or High Court when an application of the accused for grant of bail is being considered, he should be allowed to make his submissions before the Court. The learned counsel further submitted that in case of Indu Bala (Supra) the judgment in the case of Bhagwant Singh (supra) was not brought to the notice of the learned Single Judge of this Court. Learned counsel further submitted that though in the case of Praveen Malhotra (supra) it was held that the private parties have got no right to intervene and make oral arguments on the bail application filed by the accused but when the petition for bail was heard on merits, the learned Judge allowed the learned counsel for intervener to address the arguments and this is clear from the decision on merits reported in 41 (1990) DLT 30. As regards the case of Thakur Ram (supra) learned counsel submitted that in that case the Supreme Court held that a parivate party cannot invoke the jurisdiction under the provisions of the Code but in the present case the jurisdiction has already been invoked by the accused and the applicant is only seeking permission of the Court to intervene in the matter.

7. Mr. Bahri, learned counsel, appearing on behalf of the State reiterated the submissions made by Mr. Grover. He submitted that in the present case there is no allegation that the State counsel has abdicated his function and as such the private party should not be permitted to intervene into the matter.

8. I have given my thoughtful consideration to the submissions made by the learned counsel for the parties. section 439 of the code does not contemplate by itself any hearing to be given to the complainant party in a police case. This question was examined by a learned Single Judge of this Court in the case of Indu Bala (supra). Relying on two judgments of Punjab & Haryana High Court in the case of Kuldip Singh (supra) and Sarwan Kumar (supra) the learned Judge of this Court held that, “as far as the application for grant of bail is concerned there is no provision made in the Criminal Procedure Code that a complainant can intervene and make any submissions independently in opposing the application for grant of bail or anticipatory bail.” It was further held in this case that the counsel for the complainant can brief the State counsel and it is only the State counsel who can be heard in opposition to these applications seeking bail. The ratio of this judgment was followed by another learned Single Judge of this Court in the case of Praveen Malhotra (supra). With respect, I am in full agreement with the law laid down in the case of Indu Bala (supra).

9. As regards the contention of Mr. Mathur, learned counsel for the applicant, that the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Bhagwant Singh (supra) was not brought to the notice of the learned Judges in the case of Indu Bala (supra) and Praveen Malhotra (supra), it may be pointed out that in the case of Indu Bala (supra) the learned Judge has placed reliance on the judgment of Punjab and Haryana High Court in the case of Sarwan Kumar (supra) and in the case of Sarwan Kumar (supra) the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Bhagwant Singh (supra) has been considered and it was held that the ratio of this judgment was not applicable in the case pertaining to grant of bail under section 438 of the Code as the case was not of cancellation of bail or consideration of a report under section 173(2) of the Code. It may be pointed out here that the decision in the case of Bhagwant Singh (supra) cannot be made applicable to the facts of the present case as in the case of Bhagwant Singh (supra) the Supreme Court while dealing with the statutory rights of the informant under section 173(2(ii) of the Code has held that since the officer incharge of the Police Station is required to communicate to the informant the action taken by the police and the report forwarded by him to the magistrate, it must be presumed that the informant would equally be interested in seeing mat the magistrate takes cognizance of the offence and issues process, because that would be culmination of the First Information Report lodged by him. But no such right vests in the aggrieved party when an application for grant of bail is to be considered.

10. As regards the contention of Mr. Mathur that even in the case of Praveen Malhotra (supra), the learned counsel for the complainant was allowed to address the arguments, it may be pointed out that it was only after the learned Public Prosecutor had given his no objection for the learned counsel of the complainant to assist the Court, such permission was granted.

11. In view of the above discussion I hold that the complainant has no right to be heard in a petition for grant of bail particularly when there is no allegation that the State counsel has abdicated his functions. Learned counsel for the counsel, however, can brief the State counsel to oppose the petition for grant of bail. Accordingly, Cr.M 508/93 is dismissed.

12. List Cr.M(M) 248/93 for arguments on merits on 19th May, 1993.