- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
S.K Enterprises v. Delhi Development Authority .
Factual and Procedural Background
The respondent Delhi Development Authority (DDA) filed an application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act seeking condonation of delay in filing objections to an award. The DDA's application stated that the notice of filing of the award was received on 1 October 1992, that internal approvals were obtained by 18 November 1992, but that the file was subsequently mixed up with another file and only came to the concerned officer's notice on 5 February 1993; objections were filed on 18 February 1993. The petitioner filed a reply contesting the sufficiency of this explanation. The court considered documentary timing (including court service and inspection dates) and made a final order dismissing the DDA's application and the objections, making the award dated 30 June 1992 a rule of the Court and directing a decree in terms of that award.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the delay in filing objections by the DDA can be condoned under Section 5 of the Limitation Act given the explanation that the file was misplaced and internal approvals took time.
- Whether, if the delay is not condoned, the objections filed by the DDA are time-barred and the award should be made a rule of the Court.
Arguments of the Parties
DDA's Arguments
- The delay in filing objections is explained by internal processing: the Executive Engineer prepared comments on 15 October 1992, the Chief Engineer approved on 4 November 1992, and the legal cell approved on 18 November 1992.
- The file was misplaced (mixed up with another file) and only came to the concerned officer's notice on 5 February 1993, after which a panel lawyer was briefed and objections filed on 18 February 1993.
- Because the DDA is a government department and the delay arose from administrative mishap, a liberal view should be taken and the delay condoned; reliance was placed on G. Ramegowde Major v. Special Land Acquisition Officer Bangalore (1988) 2 SCC 142 in support of condonation.
Petitioner's Arguments
- The DDA's explanation is unsatisfactory and the delay should not be condoned.
- Court records show the notice was served earlier than stated in the DDA's application; specifically, the notice was served on the DDA on 24 September 1992 (not 1 October 1992 as claimed), and the Senior Law Officer had applied for inspection of the Court record on 25 September 1992 with inspection on 28 September 1992—facts inconsistent with the DDA's account.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| G. Ramegowde Major v. Special Land Acquisition Officer Bangalore, (1988) 2 SCC 142 | Relied upon by DDA's counsel to support a submission that a liberal view should be taken to condone delay arising from administrative mishap. | The court recorded that the DDA's counsel placed reliance on this Supreme Court judgment, but proceeded to examine the factual record and found inconsistencies in the DDA's account. The precedent was not held sufficient to justify condonation given the factual deficiencies identified. |
| Food Corporation of India v. E. Kuttappan, JT 1993 (4) SC 90 | Illustrates that objections filed after the prescribed date were held to be time-barred (specific example: objections due by 25 October 1988 were filed on 6 December 1988 and held time-barred). | The court referred to this decision to support the proposition that delay which is not satisfactorily explained results in objections being time-barred; it was applied to underscore that the DDA's delay, similarly unexplained in material respects, could not be condoned. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded by comparing the DDA's asserted timeline with the court's own record. The DDA's application asserted service of the notice on 1 October 1992, but the court's record showed service on 24 September 1992. The court also noted that the Senior Law Officer of the DDA had sought and obtained inspection of the court record on 25 and 28 September 1992 respectively, which contradicted the DDA's stated chronology.
The court found the factual statements in the DDA's affidavit-based application to be incorrect and therefore unreliable. The court further observed that the DDA had not placed an affidavit from the concerned officer to explain the asserted file-misplacement (the application alleged the file came to notice only on 5/15 February 1993), nor had it satisfactorily explained the time taken by the Chief Engineer to record approval. Because material aspects of the delay remained unexplained or contradicted by court records, the court concluded the delay was not properly explained.
The court also invoked a recent Supreme Court decision (Food Corporation of India v. E. Kuttappan) as a precedent where belated objections were held to be time-barred, applying that authority by analogy to reinforce that unexplained delay cannot be condoned.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: Application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act dismissed.
Implications and direct effects:
- The DDA's application for condonation of delay is dismissed.
- Consequently, the objections filed on behalf of the DDA are held to be time-barred and are dismissed.
- The award dated 30 June 1992 is made a rule of the Court and a decree is to be drawn in terms of that award; the award shall form part of the decree.
- The parties are to bear their own costs.
- The petitioner is entitled to interest at the rate of 12% per annum from the date of the award until the date of the decree; if the decretal amount is not paid within two months from the date of the decree, the petitioner is entitled to interest at 12% per annum from the date of the decree until realisation.
- No broader precedent was created by the court's order beyond applying established principles that unexplained delay will not be condoned and late objections will be time-barred (as illustrated by citation to Food Corporation of India v. E. Kuttappan).
Petition dismissed
Mr. Sat Pal, J.— This application has been field on behalf of the respondent Delhi Development Authority (hereinafter referred to as ‘the, DDA’) under Section 5 of the Limitation Act. In this application it has been prayed that the delay in filing the objections be condoned.
2. In para 3 of the application it has been stated that the notice of filing of the award was received by the DDA on 1st October, 1992. It is further stated that the Executive Engineer of the Division concerned prepared his comments on the award on 15th October, 1992 and the same were sent to the Chief Engineer for approval on the same date. Thereafter the Chief Engineer gave his approval on 4th November, 1992 and the file was sent to the legal cell of DDA. On 18th November, 1992 the legal cell of DDA is stated to have given its approval. It is then stated in the application that the file was mixed up with some other file and came to the notice of the concerned officer only on 5th February, 1993 and thereafter a panel lawyer was briefed and objections were filed on 18th February, 1993. Reply to this application has been filed on behalf of the petitioner and it has been stated in the reply that the explanation given by the DDA is not satisfactory and as such the delay should not be condoned.
3. Ms. Ansuya Salwan, learned Counsel for the DDA submitted that the delay has been explained in the application and the DDA being a Government department and the file having been misplaced, a liberal view should be taken and the delay should be condoned. In support of her contention she has placed reliance on a Supreme Court judgment in G. Ramegowde Major v. Special Land Acquisition Officer Bangalore, (1988) 2 SCC 142.
4. Mr. Rajiv Sharma, learned Counsel for the petitioner, however, drew my attention to the notice sent by this Court regarding filing of the award and from the notice I find that the notice in fact was served on the DDA on 24th September, 1992 and not on 1st October, 1992 as stated in the application. From the Court record I further find that the Senior Law Officer of the DDA after the receipt of the notice, had even moved an application for inspection of the Court record on 25th September, 1992 and the records were inspected on 28th September, 1992. Since the facts were not stated correctly in the application which is duly supported by an affidavit of an officer of the DDA, I find no reason to allow this application. Even otherwise the delay has not been properly explained. In para 7 of the application it has been stated that the file was not available and got mixed up with some other files and came to the notice of the concerned officer only on 15th February, 1993 but no affidavit of the concerned officer has been filed to explain the delay. The time taken by the Chief Engineer for recording approval has also not been properly explained. In this connection I may refer to a recent judgment of the Supreme Court in Food Corporation of India v. E. Kuttappan, JT 1993 (4) SC 90. In this case the objections which were required to be filled on or before 25th October, 1988 were filed on 6th December, 1988 and the objections were held to be time barred.
5. In view of the above discussion the application is dismissed.
IA 2226/93
6. Since I have dismissed the application field on behalf of the DDA under Section 5 of the Limitation Act for condonation of delay in filing the objections, the objections being time barred are also dismissed.
S. No. 2980-A/92
7. The objections filed on behalf of the DDA having been dismissed, the award dated 30th June, 1992 is made a rule of the Court. Let a decree be drawn in terms of the award. The award shall form part of the decree. However, the parties are left to bear their own costs. The petitioner will also be entitled to interest at the rate of 12 per cent per annum from the date of the award till the date of the decree. In case the decretal amount is not paid within two months from the date of the decree, the petitioner will also be entitled to interest at the rate of 12 percent per annum from the date of the decree till realisation.
Petition dismissed
Alert