- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Chandan & Others v. Union Of India
Factual and Procedural Background
These consolidated proceedings comprise 32 appeals under section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 concerning land situated in Village Tughlakabad. A notification under section 4 of the Act was issued on 23 January 1965 and a declaration under section 6 on 30 October 1969. The Collector's award was dated 4 November 1981.
The Land Acquisition Collector originally assessed compensation generally at Rs. 4,000 per bigha; in one appeal (RFA 468/89) the Collector's assessment was Rs. 1,000 per bigha, that valuation being explained by the presence of deep pits and alleged inability to use the land for agriculture.
On reference under section 18, the Additional District Judge enhanced the compensation, assessing market value at Rs. 23,000 per bigha in most matters; RFA 468/89 was assessed at Rs. 4,000 per bigha by the court below.
Of the 32 appeals, 28 were filed by the Union of India challenging the enhancements by the court below. Respondents filed cross-objections seeking further enhancement of compensation. During pendency respondents filed applications under Order 6 Rule 17 and section 151 CPC to amend grounds of cross-objections and claim yet further enhanced compensation (after making up any deficiency in court fee); those applications were kept pending and ordered to be heard with the appeals (except in a listed set of RFAs where no such applications were filed).
The matter involved consideration of a prior judgment (RFA 299/84 — Virender Singh v. Union of India, decided 23 April 1991) that had fixed market value for land in the same village based on a Central Government circular of 28 March 1966. The court considered whether and how to apply those observations and other authorities to fix market value in these appeals and finally determined compensation adjustments, interest, solatium and related relief as set out in the judgment.
Legal Issues Presented
- What is the appropriate basis and rate for fixing the market value of the acquired land in Village Tughlakabad (whether to adopt the Central Government circular of 28 March 1966 and, if so, how to apply it)?
- Whether one-third of the market value should be deducted for development (roads, drainage and other amenities) when fixing compensation, as reflected in Supreme Court decisions.
- Whether the benchmark/finding in RFA 299/84 (Virender Singh v. Union of India) should be followed for the present cases given differences in notification dates and other circumstances.
- Whether a parcel of land (RFA 468/89) with deep pits and alleged non-usability for agriculture should be valued at the same rate as other lands in the village or at a distinct rate.
- Procedural: Whether the respondents' applications under Order 6 Rule 17 and section 151 CPC to amend cross-objections and claim higher compensation should be allowed and to what extent (including the consequences for court fee deficiency).
Arguments of the Parties
Union of India (Appellant)
- Appealed against the judgments below that enhanced compensation — seeking to set aside or reduce the enhanced awards made by the Court below.
- Implicitly resisted application of higher market values argued by respondents (including reliance on RFA 299/84) for the purpose of fixing compensation in these appeals.
Respondents (Cross-Objectors)
- Sought enhancement of compensation; filed cross-objections to obtain higher amounts than those awarded by the trial court.
- Filed applications under Order 6 Rule 17 and section 151 CPC (during pendency) to amend grounds of cross-objections and claim still higher compensation after paying any deficiency in court fee.
- Relied on the Court's earlier decision in RFA 299/84 (Virender Singh v. Union of India) — which used the Central Government circular of 1966 fixing plot value at Rs. 60 per square yard for Kalkaji — to support a much higher valuation (respondents claimed up to Rs. 60,000 per bigha after amendment, and argued market value would work out to Rs. 42,000 per bigha on that basis).
- With respect to RFA 468/89, respondents (or parties) explained the lower Collector valuation by pointing to 8–10 deep pits in the land that affected its usability; some respondents argued no distinction should be made across parcels (relying on decisions such as Sham Krishan Chandiwala), i.e., the potentiality of contiguous acquired land is the same.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Virender Singh v. Union of India (RFA 299/84, decided 23 April 1991) | Used a Central Government circular (28 March 1966) as a reasonable basis to determine market value for Kalkaji area; fixed market value for 1973 in that case. | The court declined to follow the judgment in RFA 299/84 as a binding norm for these appeals because the notification under section 4 differed (5 July 1973 in RFA 299/84 vs. 23 January 1965 here) and because certain Supreme Court authorities had not been brought to the Bench in RFA 299/84. Nonetheless, the court accepted the observation in RFA 299/84 that the 1966 circular forms a reasonable basis for determining 1965 market value. |
| Spl. Tehsildar, Land Acquisition, Vishakapatnam v. Smt. A. Mangala Gowri, AIR 1992 SC 666 | Latest Supreme Court decision cited on the question that 1/3rd of market value should be deducted for development of acquired land (roads, drainage, amenities). | The court relied on this decision (and earlier decisions referred therein) to hold that 1/3rd of the market value must be deducted when fixing market value for compensation in these appeals. |
| Tribeni Devi v. Collector of Ranchi, AIR 1972 SC 1417 | Authority indicating that one-third of market value will have to be deducted for roads, drainage and other amenities. | The court cited this decision to support the deduction of one-third of the market value for development when calculating compensation. |
| DLF Housing and Construction (P) Ltd. v. Union of India, AIR 1967 Punjab 325 (DB) | Illustrative precedent where evidence showed developed plot sale price and deductions for roads/open spaces/ development charges reduced effective developed-plot price to about half of sale price. | The court noted that, unlike the DLF case, there was no such specific evidence here to compute an itemized deduction and therefore the court adopted the “rough and ready” method (i.e., applying the 1/3rd deduction) as guided by higher authority. |
| Sham Krishan Chandiwala & another v. Union of India, (1978) 14 D.L.T. 83 | Held that where acquisition is for planned development it may be unnecessary to distinguish chahi/aabi/rosli — potentiality of contiguous land may be same. | The court observed that such a principle depended on the facts of each case and could not be applied as a universal rule; it therefore did not apply that reasoning to value RFA 468/89 identically with other parcels given factual differences (deep pits). |
| Harcharan v. State of Haryana, AIR 1983 SC 43 | Principle that the award of the court is the best evidence for evaluation of land price, subject to area-wise, topography-wise and use-wise comparison. | The court referenced this as a settled principle recognising that comparison of awards requires factual matching; it used this principle in explaining why uniform valuation cannot automatically be applied to all parcels (noting the need for factual comparisons). |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded by examining the factual matrix (dates of notification, nature of the locality, the Central Government circular of 28 March 1966 regarding Kalkaji, and prior judicial decisions) and applying established legal principles about valuation and deductions for development.
Key steps in the court's analysis:
- The court accepted that Kalkaji colony had been carved out of Tughlakabad and that the Central Government circular (28 March 1966) fixed residential plot value in Kalkaji at Rs. 60 per square yard, noting the circular stated the value was determined some time in 1965 and that the circular was not a statutory rule but provided reasonable guidance. The court treated the circular as a reasonable basis to determine market value for the year relevant to these acquisitions.
- The court declined to follow RFA 299/84 in full because that case involved a different notification date (5 July 1973) and because certain Supreme Court judgments concerning deduction of one-third were not placed before the Bench in RFA 299/84. Nonetheless, the court accepted the underlying proposition from the circular (i.e., Rs. 60/sq yd as a reasonable 1965 baseline).
- Applying Supreme Court authority (including Vishakapatnam v. Mangala Gowri and Tribeni Devi), the court held that one-third of that market value must be deducted to account for development (roads, drainage and other amenities). The court therefore reduced Rs. 60/sq yd by one-third to arrive at Rs. 40 per square yard as the market value to be used for these appeals; expressed equivalently as Rs. 40,000 per bigha.
- For RFA 468/89 the court analysed factual differences: the presence of deep pits and diminished potential. It concluded that uniform valuation across all parcels could not be rigidly applied; while the valuation for RFA 468/89 could not be fixed identically with others, it should nonetheless receive a proportionate enhancement. On that basis the court fixed market value for RFA 468/89 at Rs. 7,000 per bigha.
- The court addressed the respondents' pending amendment applications under Order 6 Rule 17 and section 151 CPC and allowed those applications to the extent of the market value as fixed by the court, subject to payment of any deficiency in court fee within one month.
- The court calculated and awarded statutory additional amounts and interest as provided under various sections of the Act, specifying different rates or treatments for RFA 212/81 as compared to the other appeals (details reproduced from the opinion below).
Holding and Implications
Core Holding: All appeals filed by the Union of India are dismissed and the cross-objections filed by the respondents are allowed.
Direct consequences and orders as stated in the opinion:
- Market value fixed at Rs. 60 per square yard less one-third for development, resulting in Rs. 40 per square yard (stated equivalently in the judgment as Rs. 40,000 per bigha). Accordingly, compensation is enhanced by Rs. 17,000 per bigha in all appeals except RFA 468/89.
- In RFA 468/89 the court fixed market value at Rs. 7,000 per bigha, which results in an enhancement of Rs. 3,000 per bigha (as stated in the opinion).
- The respondents' applications to amend cross-objections (Order 6 Rule 17 / section 151 CPC) are allowed to the extent of the market values fixed by the court. Respondents must make up any deficiency in court fee within one month; no further time will be granted.
- Appeals filed against Union of India where there were no applications for enhancement will stand allowed to the extent of the compensation claimed therein, because those claims were lower than the amounts fixed by this judgment.
-
Except in RFA 212/81, respondents are entitled to:
- (a) 12% additional amount under section 23(1-A) of the Act from the date of notification under section 4 to the date of the Collector's award or date of taking possession, whichever is earlier;
- (b) "305 solatium" on the market value as provided by section 23(2) of the Act (language in the opinion is reproduced as stated);
- (c) interest under section 28 of the Act: stated in the opinion as "9% per annum for the first year from the date of taking of the possession and per 155 per annum till the payment is made;" (rates quoted as in the opinion);
- (d) 6% interest under section 4(3) of the Land Acquisition (Amendment & Validation) Act, 1967 because there is a difference of more than three years between the section 4 notification and section 6 declaration (dated 23 January 1965 and 13 January 1969 respectively in the opinion).
- In RFA 212/81 the respondents are entitled to solatium at the rate of 15% on market value as provided in section 23(2) and interest at 6% per annum on the enhanced amount of compensation from the date of possession till payment as per section 28; and also to 6% interest under section 4(3) as allowed in other appeals.
- Respondents are also entitled to proportionate costs limited to court fee only.
Broader implications: The court applied existing precedents (including Supreme Court decisions) concerning deduction of one-third of market value for development and used the Central Government circular of 1966 as a reasonable basis for fixing 1965 values for Kalkaji. The opinion does not purport to establish a new legal principle beyond application of these authorities to the specific facts before the court.
D. P. WADHWA, J. (Oral)— In all these 32 appeals filed under section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (the Act for short) the award is same. The land which is subject-matter of the acquisition proceedings is situated in Village Tughlakabad. Notification under section 4 of the Act was issued on 23 January 1965 and declaration under section 6 on 30 October 1969. The award was given on 4 November 1981. The Land Acquisition Collector assessed the compensation payable at the rate of Rs. 4,000/- per bigha. In respect of the land subject-matter of one appeal (RFA 468/89) the compensation was assessed at Rs. 1,000/- per bigha. In this case it was submitted that there were 10 to 8 deep pits in the land and also it could not be put to agriculture use.
On a reference made under section 18 of the Act the learned Additional District Judge enhanced the compensation payable and assessed the market value at Rs. 23,000/ per bigha. In the case of land in RFA 468/89 the market value was assessed at Rs. 4,000/- per bigha.
Of the 32 appeals, 28 have been filed by Union of India against different judgments of the Court below enhancing the amount of compensation as aforesaid. The respondents filed their cross-objections seeking enhancement of the compensation. Then during the pendency of these appeals the respondents filed applications under Order 6 Rule 17 and section 151 of the Code Civil Procedure seeking to amend the grounds of appeal and claiming yet further enhanced amount of compensation after making the deficiency in court fee payable on that account. These applications have been kept pending and were ordered to be heard along with appeals. There are, however, no such applications in RFAs. 212/81, 187/88, 199/88, 347/88, 462/87, 2/88 and 249/88. The respondents, it appered, did not feel it necessary to file any such applications for enhancement of compensation in RFAs 344/90 and 166/92 inasmuch as they had already claimed compensation at a much higher rate. The applications for enhancement of comensation were filed after judgment of this Court in RFA 299/84 (Virender Singh v. Union of India, decided on 23 April 1991) In that case land also pertam to Village Tughlakabad but a notification under section 4 of the Act was issued on 5 July 1993 and a declaration under section 6 on 12 August 1975. This Court assessed the market value of the acquired land at the rate of Rs. 68,000- per bigha. On the basis of this judgment it was submitted before us that the market value of the land subject matter of all these appeals would work out to be at the rate of Rs. 42,000/- per bigha though compensation after amendment was claimed at Rs. 60,000/- per bigha. In RFA 299/84 the Court observed that it was not disputed that the land in that village was in Kalkaji area, a developed residential colony. Reference was made to a circular dated 28 March 1966 issued by the Central Government in the Ministry of Works, Housing and Development fixing the market value of the plots for residential use in Kalkaji Colony at the rate of Rs. 60/- per square yard. The court further observed that this circular was quite relevant and would form reasonable and fair basis to determine the market value of the land for the year 1973. The court, thererfoere, accepted the contention of the appellant in that appeal that the market value of the land had since enhanced from 1966 when the circular was issued and accepted the calim of the appelant and fixed the market value at the rate of Rs. 68/- per square yard. We do not think we have to follow the judgment of this Court in RFA 299/84 for fixing the market value of the land in the appeals before us. There are two principal reasons for this. (1) Notification under section 4 of the Act in RFA 299/84 was issued on 5 July 1973 while in the present case it was on 23 January 1965, and (2) the judgments of the Supreme Court, wherein it had said that 1/3rd of the market value should be deducted for development of the acqquired land, were not brought to the notice of the Bench. However, we feel bound by the observations made by the Bench that the market value of the land as fixed by the Central Government in 1966 as per circular dated 28 March 1966 would form a reasonable and fair basis to determine the market value of the land subject-matter of the present appeals.
It is not disputed before us that colony of Kalkaji was carved out of the land of the village Tughlakabad. The colony is developed with roads, parks schools and having other civil amenities. The circular of the Central Government containing information for guidance of leaseholders fixes the market value of the residential plots in Kalkaji at the rate of Rs. 60/- per square yard. It is mentioned in the circular that the land value indicated in it was determined some time in 1965 and though issued in 1966 would not purport to indicate current market value of any particular plot for the purpose of Direct Taxes Act which would depend not only on the exact location of the plot within the specified area but also on the date as on which the valuation had to be made under the respective Acts. The circular also states that the instructions contained therein were for the limited purpose of providing assistance to the lessees in the matter of assessment of charges by the lessor and were, in no way, to be construed as statutory rules and regulations on the subject. Nevertheless, as held in RFA 299/84 the circular does give reasonable basis of the market value of the land in the colony of kalkaji in the year 1965. It is, therefore, not necessary to refer to any judgment fixing the market value of the adjacent land to the lands subject-matter of these appeals when sufficient guidelines could be obtained from the Central Government Circular of 1966 it self. The market value of the land in all these appeals has, therefore, to be fixed at Rs. 60/- per square yard less 1/3rd of the same deducted for the purpose of development of lands. The latest decision of the Supreme Court on the question of deduction of 1/3rd of the market value is reported in Spl. Tehsildar, land Acquisition, Vishakapatnam v. Smt. A. Mangala Gowri, AIR 1992 Supreme Court 666. Reference in this case was made to many earlier decisions of the Supreme Court and one of such decisions is in the case of Tribeni Devi v. Collector of Ranchi, AIR 1972 S.C 1417, where the value of 1/3 of the land will have to be deducted for roads, drainage and other amenities”. In DLF Housing and Construction (P) Ltd. v. Union of India. AIR 1967 Punjab 325 (DB), the court found that the acquired land was acrose the road of a developed colony Rajouri Garden. The evidence showed that the sale price of development plots in the Rajouri Garden came to Rs. 23/- per square yard. After taking into account the land set apart for roads, open spaces and other facilities and the development charges including the brokerage and administrative expenses, the court found the price of the developed land would work out to Rs. 11.56 per square yard. That would be about half of the price for a developed plot. In the present case, however, we find the there is no such evidence and we have to adopt the rough and ready method laid by the Supreme Court. Accordingly, we will hold that 1/3rd of the market value be deducted for the development of lands acqquired and, thus, the market value would come to Rs. 40/- per square yard or Rs. 40,000/- per bigha.
Then the question arises as to what should be the market value of the land subject-matter of RFA 468/89. It was submitted before us that no distinction should be made between this land and the other lands and in this connection reference was made to a Bench decision of this Court in Sham Krishan Chandiwala and another v. Union of India, (1978) 14 D.L.t 83, wherein it was held that where the acquistition of the land was for the planned development of Delhi it was unnecessary to consider whether the land was chahi, Aabi or rosli, for in such a case, the potentiality of the land would be the same. Some other cases of this Court were also referred to where it was said that no distinction be made when a big chunk of land in any particular village had been acquired and that market value should be the same of all the lands. All those cases in our view depend upon the facts of those cases. This cannot be a universal rule. In Harcharan v. State Of Haryana, AIR 1983 Supreme Court 43, the could held that it was a well settled principle that the best evidence with regard to evaluation of price of land in a proceeding for ascertainment of compensation for land acquired under the Act was the Award of the Court, subject of course, to the comparison of the land areawise, topographywisse and usewise. It was also submitted before us that the acquired land could be developed into residential colony and for that purpose strenght was drawn from the circular of the Central Government of the year 1966. That being so, it cannot be said that the land which has deep pits should be valued at the same rate. Of course, it would bot be material whether any particular piece of land can be used for agricultural purposes or not. We, therefore, cannot determine market value of the land in RFA 468/89 as in other appeals. But then the valuation of the land in RFA 468/89 will have also to be proportionately enhanced. As observed by the Supreme Court certain amount of guese is involved in all these cases. We will, therefore, fix the market value of this land at the rate of Rs. 7,000/- per bigha.
Thus, in all the appeals except in RFA 468/89 compensation is, thus, enhanced by Rs. 17,000/- per bigha and in RFA 468/89 by Rs, 3,000/- per bigha.
Accordingly, all appeals filed by Union of India are dismissed and corss-objections are allowed. The applications filed by the respondents for amendment of the memorandum of Cross-objections seeking higher compensation are allowed to the extent of the market value as fixed by us. All these respondents shall make up deficiency in court fee within one month and no further time for this purpose will be granted. In appeals filed against Union of India where there are no applications for enhancement of compensation, those appeals shall stand allowed to the extent compensation is claimed therein as in all these appeals compensation has been claimed at a rate less than what has been fixed by the us by this judgment. In all the appeals except RFA 212/81 the respondents shall also be entitled to: (a) 12% additional amount under section 23(1-A) of the Act from the date of the notification under section 4 of the Act to the date of the award of the Collector or the date of taking possession of the land, whichever is earlier; (b) 305 solatium on the market value of the land as provided by section 23(2) of the Act; (c) interest under section 28 of the Act, i.e, 9% per annum for the first year from the date of taking of the possession and per 155 per annum till the payment is made; and (d) 6% interest under section 4(3) of the land acquisition (amendment & validation) act, 1967, as there is a difference of more than three years between the notification under section 4 and declaration under section 6 of the Act which are dated 23 January 1965 and 13 January 1969 respectively. In R.F.A 212/81 the respondents shall, however, be entitled to solatium at the rate of 15% on the market value as provided in section 23(2) of the Act and interest at the rate of 6% per annum on the enhanced amount of compensation from the date of possession of the land till the payment of the enhanced compensation as per section 28 of the Act, and also to 6% interest under section 4(3) of the land acquisition (amendment & validation) act, 1967, as allowed in other appeals. Respondents will also be entitled to proportionate costs limited to court fee only.
Alert