Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Royal Biscuits Pvt. Ltd. v. Sethi Bakers & Confectioners

Delhi High Court
Aug 30, 1991
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Mr. P.K. Bahri, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff instituted a suit seeking permanent injunction restraining the defendant from manufacturing, selling, offering for sale, advertising and displaying biscuits and allied goods under the trade mark "ROYALTY" and similar labels, alleging infringement of the plaintiff's registered trade mark "ROYAL" and of copyright in the plaintiff's labels. The plaintiff alleged adoption and continuous use of "ROYAL" since 1982, registration of the trade mark under the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958 (since 16 February 1982), and registration of the label artwork under the Indian Copyright Act, 1957. Specimen labels were filed as Annexures 'A' and 'B'. The plaintiff also alleged substantial sales and widespread distribution and advertising.

At the suit's admission stage a temporary injunction was granted restraining the defendant from distributing, selling or advertising biscuits under the "ROYALTY" mark and similar labels. The defendant filed an application under Order 39 Rule 4 C.P.C. (seeking vacation of the stay/injunction), contending lack of territorial jurisdiction of the Delhi Courts and denying similarity and originality of the plaintiff's labels; the defendant said it carried on business from Chandigarh and had used "ROYALTY" since July 1989. The court heard arguments on both the defendant's application (LA. 6743/91) and the plaintiff's interlocutory application for continuance of injunction (I.A. 3445/91).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, prima facie, the Delhi Courts have territorial jurisdiction to try the suit (particularly in view of Section 62(2) of the Copyright Act and the plaintiff's averment that the defendant marketed goods in Delhi).
  2. Whether, on a prima facie examination of labels and trade marks, the defendant has infringed the plaintiff's copyright in its labels and the plaintiff's registered trade mark "ROYAL".
  3. Whether the interim injunction previously granted should be continued (i.e., whether the defendant's application under Order 39 Rule 4 C.P.C. seeking vacation of the injunction merits relief).

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The plaintiff is the proprietor of the trade mark "ROYAL" by adoption and continuous use since 1982 and is the registered proprietor under the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958 (registration dated 16-02-1982).
  • The plaintiff owns copyright in the label artwork (registered under the Indian Copyright Act, 1957) which has distinctive get up, colour scheme, lettering style and a bust portrait of a Prince wearing a crown inside circles; specimen labels were filed as Annexures.
  • The plaintiff's goods bearing the mark and labels have been extensively sold and advertised across many states, including Delhi; therefore the plaintiff can sue in Delhi and Delhi Courts have territorial jurisdiction.
  • The defendant has adopted the mark "ROYALTY" and similar labels to take undue advantage of the plaintiff's reputation and is guilty of infringement and passing off.

Defendant's Arguments

  • The cause of action did not accrue within the territorial jurisdiction of the Delhi Court and therefore the Delhi Court lacks jurisdiction; the defendant does business from Chandigarh and has carried on business for about 20 years from there.
  • The defendant contended there was no similarity between the marks and labels and that the plaintiff's artwork lacked originality so no copyright could subsist in it.
  • The defendant asserted bona fide adoption of its trade mark and that it had obtained a report from the Registrar of Trade Marks; it also noted that its logo uses a bust portrait of a woman (as opposed to the plaintiff's Prince).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Brooke Bond India Ltd. v. Balaji Tea (India) Pvt. Ltd., 1990 (2) Arbitration Law Reporter 35 Expressed the view (by a single Judge of the Madras High Court) that Section 62(2) of the Copyright Act should be sparingly resorted to so that small traders are not put to hardship by being dragged to distant places. The judgment was noticed by the court but not followed; the court observed the view but preferred other authority (Glaxo) and nonetheless noted that Chandigarh was not so distant from Delhi as to cause hardship to the defendant.
Glaxo Operations UK Ltd. v. Samrat Pharmaceuticals, AIR 1984 Delhi 265 Held that Section 62(2) of the Copyright Act enables a plaintiff to bring a suit at the place where the plaintiff is carrying on business. The court respectfully followed the view in Glaxo and held that Section 62(2) admits of no two interpretations and supports the plaintiff's ability to sue where the plaintiff carries on business.
The Tata Oil Mills Company Ltd. v. Reward Soap Works, AIR 1983 Delhi 286 Held that under Section 62 of the Copyright Act a suit could be brought at a place where the plaintiff is carrying on business; in that case an averment that the defendant sold goods within the court's jurisdiction was accepted for granting interim relief. The court cited this authority to reinforce the proposition that a plaintiff may sue where it carries on business and that specific averments of sales in the court's territory can be accepted for interim relief purposes.
Smith and Wellstood v. The Carron Company, 1896 (13) R.P.C. 108 Illustrated that adoption of a mark such as "New Mistress" where "Mistress" was registered, or "Fort" where "Fortress" was registered, amounted to infringement and injunctions were granted. The court relied on this principle to support the finding that use of "ROYALTY" in the same style as "ROYAL" is capable of deceiving consumers and amounts prima facie to trademark infringement.
Metro Playing Card Co. v. Wazir Chand Kapoor, AIR 1972 Delhi 248 Held that although registration may be granted for concurrent uses under Section 12(3), until registration is granted the plaintiff's registered trade mark cannot be allowed to be infringed; registration is prima facie evidence of validity under Section 28 of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act. The court invoked this authority to reject the defendant's contention that steps to obtain registration entitle it to infringe the plaintiff's registered mark; until registration, infringement cannot be permitted.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in distinct steps:

  1. Jurisdictional inquiry: The court examined whether the Delhi Courts had territorial jurisdiction. The plaintiff had served a legal notice alleging that the defendant marketed and sold goods in Delhi; the defendant did not controvert that averment in its reply to the notice. The court treated that non-controversion as sufficient, prima facie, to establish that the Delhi Courts had territorial jurisdiction to try the suit. The court considered Section 62(2) of the Copyright Act and relevant precedent: it noted a cautionary view in Brooke Bond but followed Glaxo Operations (AIR 1984 Delhi 265) which supports a plaintiff suing where it carries on business. The court also referenced The Tata Oil Mills Co. to show that specific averments of sales within jurisdiction justify injunctive relief at an interim stage. The court added that Chandigarh was not so distant from Delhi as to impose undue hardship on the defendant.
  2. Prima facie infringement analysis: The court compared the specimen labels of the plaintiff and defendant. On prima facie examination the court found that the defendant had adopted the plaintiff's colour scheme, the style of lettering and had placed a bust portrait of a Prince with a crown within a circle, resembling the plaintiff's labels. The court concluded there was prima facie copyright infringement of the plaintiff's labels.
  3. Trademark infringement analysis: On the trademark issue, the court held that the defendant, by using "ROYALTY" written in much the same way as "ROYAL", appeared to have infringed the plaintiff's registered trade mark. The court found that an ordinary consumer might be deceived into purchasing the defendant's goods believing them to be the plaintiff's. It relied on Smith and Wellstood to illustrate that additions like "New" to a registered mark can still constitute infringement.
  4. Effect of defendant's registration efforts: The court addressed the defendant's contention that steps to register its own mark warranted permissive use. Relying on Metro Playing Card Co., the court held that concurrent registration possibilities under Section 12(3) do not permit infringement while registration is pending; a registered proprietor's statutory rights under Section 28 must be respected.
  5. Conclusion on applications: Considering the above, the court found no merit in the defendant's Order 39 Rule 4 application to vacate the injunction and held that the interlocutory injunction previously granted should be continued until the suit's disposal.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court's dispositive rulings were as follows:

  • The defendant's application (LA. 6743/91) to vacate the interim injunction is dismissed.
  • The plaintiff's application (I.A. 3445/91) is allowed and the interim injunction already granted is confirmed until the disposal of the suit.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the defendant is restrained (by the confirmed injunction) from distributing, selling or advertising biscuits or allied goods under the trade mark "ROYALTY" or under labels similar or deceptively similar to the plaintiff's labels until the suit is finally decided.
  • The court's decision was based on prima facie findings at the interlocutory stage: prima facie territorial jurisdiction of the Delhi Courts (in view of the plaintiff's averments and non-controversion), prima facie copyright infringement of the labels and prima facie trademark infringement. The matter will proceed to trial for final determination.
  • The opinion does not purport to lay down any newly declared, binding precedent beyond applying and following the cited authorities (notably Glaxo Operations and Metro Playing Card Co.); the court applied existing principles to reach the interlocutory conclusion and did not indicate that it was establishing a novel rule of law.

Additional procedural note from the opinion: Suit No. 1024/91 was directed to be put up before the Deputy Registrar on September 16, 1991 for further proceedings. (Injunction granted.)

Show all summary ...

Mr. P.K Bahri, J.— At the outset, I may mention that Counsel for defendant has stated that the application filed under Order 39 Rule 4 C.P.C by the defendant be treated as a reply to the application filed by the plaintiff (I.A 3445/91) and both the applications may be disposed of together.

2. I have heard arguments for deciding these two applications.

3. Plaintiff has instituted the present suit seeking permanent injunction restraining the defendant from manufacturing selling, offering for sale, advertising and displaying directly or indirectly dealing in biscuits and other allied goods under the trade mark “ROYALTY” logo, packing labels or any other trade mark or packing label identical with or deceptively similar to the plaintiff's trade mark “ROYAL” logo and its label and for other reliefs flowing from the same cause of action. The case set up by the plaintiff, in brief, is that plaintiff company is the proprietor of trade mark ‘ROYAL’ on account of its adoption and continuous user since 1982 in respect of manufacture and sale of biscuits. The plaintiff also claims to be the owner and proprietor of “ROYAL” labels being used by the plaintiff for the purpose of packing the biscuits and the said labels are stated to have a distinctive get up, make up, colour scheme and lettering style. It is pleaded that the plaintiff has been invariably using the devise of bust portrait of the Prince wearing a crown inside the circles in those labels and plaintiff pleaded that the art work involved in the said labels together with the composition of the colour scheme are original in character and a copyright has been obtained in respect of the same by getting it registered under the Indian Copyright Act, 1957. The specimen of the plaintiff's labels were filed as Annexure ‘A’ and ‘B’ with the plaint. The plaintiff claimed that its business has been very extensive one and the goods of the plaintiff under the said trade mark packed in the said labels have been sold and distributed in major parts of the country including the States of Jammu & Kashmir, Himachal Pradesh, Punjab, Haryana, U.P, Rajasthan and Union Territories of Delhi and Chandigarh. It is also pleaded that the plaintiff's trade mark “ROYAL” has been duly registered under the Trade and Merchandise Marks-Act, 1958, since February 16, 1982.

4. So, plaintiff pleaded that the said trade mark as well as the get up, make up, colour scheme and lettering style of the labels have already become distinctive and associated with the aforesaid goods of the plaintiff on account of their long, continuous, exclusive and extensive user of the goods bearing the said trade mark packed in said labels stand associated with the name of the plaintiff as coming from the source of the plaintiff and have achieved lot of reputation in the market as standard quality goods. The plaintiff has then given the figures of the sales of the year 1982 to 1990 in para 7 which are substantial. Presently, the sales of the plaintiff are to the tune of Rs. 2,63,18,012.49 paise for the year 1989-1990. The plaintiff also claims to have widely advertised said trade mark and lables in different newspapers, trade magazines and thus, the said trade mark and the labels are stated to have become synonym with the business of the plaintiff.

5. It is pleaded that the defendant has recently set up his business of manufacturing and selling the biscuits and defendant has deliberately adopted the trade mark “ROYALTY” and had also adopted the similar labels as that of the labels of the plaintiff with a view to take undue advantage of the reputation of the plaintiff earned in the trade, by using the trade mark “ROYALTY” and the said labels. It is pleaded that the defendant's trade mark “ROYALTY” is phonetically and visually similar to the trade mark “ROYAL” of the plaintiff and similarly, the labels of the defendant are also similar to the labels of the plaintiff in its get up, make up, colour scheme and lettering style and also in the depiction of the bust portrait of a Prince wearing a crown inside the circle. So, it is pleaded that the unwary customers, who are ordinary persons, are bound to be misled in purchasing the goods of the defendant under the said trade mark and the labels thinking them to be the goods of the plaintiff which are of high quality, and thus, it is pleaded that the defendant had not only infringed the registered trade mark and the copyrights of the plaintiff by adopting the said trade mark “ROYALTY” and having the similar labels but is also guilty of passing off his goods as those of the plaintiffs with a view to earn high profits for defendant's goods.

6. Alongwith the suit, an application was given for grant of temporary injunction and at the time of the admission of the suit, a temporary injunction was granted restraining the defendant from distributing, selling or advertising its biscuits or other allied goods under the trade mark “ROYALTY” logo and under the labels which are similar to the trade mark and labels of the plaintiff or which are deceptively similar to the plaintiff's trade mark and the labels.

7. The defendant filed the application under Order 39 Rules 4 seeking vacation of the stay order. It is pleaded by the defendant that no part of the cause of action has accrued within the territorial jurisdiction of Delhi Court, so this Court has no jurisdiction to deal with the matter and that plaintiff is guilty of concealing material facts and thus, the Court should vacate the ex-parte injunction. It is pleaded that defendant firm is a partnership firm having its business from Chandigarh and defendant is carrying on the said business for the last 20 years and that the plaintiff's trade mark “ROYAL” is not registered with any device of bust portrait of a Prince wearing a crown inside the circle whereas the defendant has been using the logo “ROYALTY” with the bust portrait of a woman from July 1989. It is controverted by the defendant that there was any similarity of the trade mark and the labels of the defendant with the trade mark and labels of the plaintiff. It is also pleaded that there was n'o originality in the art work of the label of the plaintiff and no copyright could be obtained by the plaintiff in respect of the said lable. Plea is taken that defendant has adopted its trade mark under the bona fide belief that its trade mark does not violate the registered trade mark of the plaintiff and a report was also obtained in this respect from the Registrar of the Trade Mark.

8. Now the first question to be decided is whether the plaintiff has a prima facie case to show that Delhi Courts have territorial jurisdiction to try the suit. The Counsel for plaintiff has pointed out that before filing the suit, a legal notice was served on the defendant in which plaintiff had clearly averred that the defendant is marketing and selling its goods in Delhi and this fact was not controverted by the defendant in its reply given to the notice. So, he has argued that keeping in view these facts and also the averments of the plaintiff in the plaint that defendant is carrying on business in Delhi by marketing the goods in Delhi, the Delhi Courts have territorial jurisdiction to try the suit.

9. Learned Counsel for defendant, on the other hand, has argued that plaintiff has not placed any material on the record which could” show that defendant had ever marketed its goods in Delhi and he has argued that mere fact in reply to the notice the defendant did not controvert the averments of plaintiff made in the notice that defendant was selling the biscuits in Delhi, does not mean that defendant is estopped from asserting this fact now. It is not the question of defendant being estopped from taking any plea in the pleadings. The question is of deciding the point at the initial stages in order to see that the plaintiff has prima facie case. So, keeping in view these facts, I hold that plaintiff has been able to show prima facie that Delhi Courts have territorial jurisdiction to try the suit in view of defendant not controverting this fact in reply to the notice that defendant is carrying on business at Delhi. It has also been argued by learned Counsel for plaintiff that under Section 62(2) of the Copyright Act, the plaintiff, who is carrying on business at Delhi, can bring the suit for infringement of the copyright at Delhi. The learned Counsel for defendant placed reliance on Brooke Bond India Ltd. v. Balaji Tea (India) Pvt. Ltd., 1990 (2) Arbitration Law Reporter 35 wherein a single Hon'ble Judge of the Madras High Court expressed the view that although Section 62(2) of the Copyright Act entitles that plaintiff to file a suit in the District Court having jurisdiction at the place of the business of the plaintiff, yet this provision should be sparingly resorted so that a small trader is not put to unnecessary hardship and disadvantage by being dragged to a distant place. In the said case, the defendant was resident of Raipur. Further, in Glaxo Operations UK Ltd. v. Samrat Pharmaceuticals, AIR 1984 Delhi 265, this Court has taken the view that Section 62(2) of the Copyright Act enables the plaintiff to bring the suit at a place where plaintiff is carrying on business. In the said case also, the suit was brought for infringement of the trade mark as well as the copyright of the plaintiff. This judgment was noticed in case of Brooke Bond India Ltd. but was not followed. However, I respectfully follow the view expressed in the case of Glaxo Operations (supra). The provisions of Section 62(2) of the Copyright Act admit of no two interpretations. This provision gives the right to the plaintiff to institute a suit under the Copyright Act at a place where plaintiff is carrying on business. However, it may also be mentioned that Chandigarh is not at a distance from Delhi so that it could be said that by facing trial in this suit at Delhi, defendant would be suffering any hardship. I may also refer to The Tata Oil Mills Company Ltd.…Plaintiff; v. Reward Soap Works…Defendant., AIR 1983 Delhi 286, where also the suit was brought for infringement of the Copyright and the trade mark. In the said case, the Court held that under Section 62 of the Copyright Act, suit could be brought at a place where the plaintiff is carrying on business and in that case also, there was a specific averment in the plaint that the defendant was selling his goods within the territorial jurisdiction of the Court and that averment was accepted for granting the temporary injunction. In view of above discussion, I, prima facie, hold that the Delhi Courts have territorial jurisdiction to try this suit.

10. I have examined the specimen labels of the plaintiff and the labels of the defendant. It is evident that defendant has, prima facie, adopted the colour scheme of the plaintiff's label and as also the way of writing the letters and has also put a bust portrait of a Prince with a crown in a circle as it appears in the labels of the plaintiff. The defendant has definitely, prima facie infringed the Copyright of plaintiff in the said labels.

11. As far as the registered trade mark of the plaintiffs concerned, by writing the trade mark “ROYALTY” in the same way as the trade mark “ROYAL” of the plaintiff is being written, the defendant appears to have also infringed the trade mark logo of the plaintiff. An unwary customer, while going in the market to purchase the biscuits of the plaintiff under the trade mark “ROYAL” can be easily deceived in purchasing the goods of the defendant under the trade mark “ROYALTY” treating the defendant's goods as those of the plaintiff. In Smith and Wellstood v. The Carron Company, 1896 (13) R.P.C 108, one of the registered trade marks was “Mistress” and the opposite party adopted the trade mark “New Mistress”. It was held that there is an infringement of the registered trade mark. In the said case also, one of the registered trade marks was “Fortress”. The opposite party started using the trade mark “Fort”. It was held that it again amounts to infringement of the trade mark of the plaintiff and the injunctions were granted.

12. So, prima facie, I hold that defendant infringed the registered trade mark and copyright of the plaintiff. The defendant's trade mark is not registered. Mere fact that defendant is taking steps to get its trade mark registered does not entitle the defendant to infringe the registered trade mark of the plaintiff. In Metro Playing Card Co. v. Wazir Chand Kapoor, AIR 1972 Delhi 248, it was held that no doubt registration may be granted for concurrent uses as provided by Section 12(3) of the Act but till registration is granted, the plaintiff's trade mark cannot be allowed to be infringed by the defendant as otherwise a statutory right which plaintiff has as a registered proprietor under Section 28 of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958 would be violated, as registration of a trade mark is & prima facie evidence of its validity.

13. So, I hold that there is no merit in the application of defendant and the injunction already granted in favour of the plaintiff is liable to be confirmed till the disposal of the suit. I dismiss the application of the defendant (LA. 6743/91) whereas I allow the application of the plaintiff (I.A 3445/91) and confirm the injunction order already granted till the disposal of the suit.

Suit No. 1024/91.

14. Put up before the Deputy Registrar on September 16, 1991, for further proceedings.

Injunction granted.