- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Shri O.P Sethi Petitioner v. The Lt. Governor & Others S
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner applied for membership in the Raj Nagar Co-operative House Building Society Ltd. in 1966 and was admitted as a member. At that time, the petitioner’s wife owned a residential property in Delhi. In 1967, the petitioner transferred his membership to his mother-in-law, Smt. Partavati Devi, who made nominations in favor of her daughter and later the petitioner’s daughter. After Smt. Partavati’s death in 1982, the petitioner sought transfer of the plot to himself based on her Will and a no objection certificate from the nominee. The Society’s Managing Committee conditionally approved the transfer, and the Delhi Development Authority (DDA) mutated the property in the petitioner’s name in 1984.
In 1987, the Assistant Registrar issued a show cause notice to the petitioner to explain why his membership should not be cancelled under Rule 25(1)(c)(i) of the Delhi Co-operative Society Rules, 1973, on the ground that his wife owned a property. The petitioner replied that the Rule did not apply to succession by Will. The Deputy Registrar declared the petitioner’s membership transfer invalid in December 1987. The petitioner’s appeal to the Lt. Governor was dismissed, leading to the present writ petition under Article 226 challenging the orders of the Lt. Governor, the Registrar, and the show cause notice issued by the DDA.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether Rule 25(1)(c)(i) of the Delhi Co-operative Society Rules, 1973, which disqualifies a person from membership if he or his spouse owns residential property in Delhi, applies to cases of succession by Will.
- Whether the petitioner’s membership was validly cancelled under the said Rule given that his wife owned the property prior to his membership application.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- Rule 25(1)(c)(i) does not apply to acquisition of membership by succession through a Will.
- The Rule is intended to prevent benami holdings of property in the name of spouse or dependents, not to disqualify successors who acquire membership by legal transmission.
- Relied on Rule 35 and bye-law 9 of the Society’s bye-laws to support the distinction between acquisition by succession and benami holdings.
Respondent Society's Arguments
- The petitioner was disqualified under Rule 25(1)(c) because his wife owned a residential house prior to his membership application, making his initial membership illegal.
- Consequently, the transfer of membership to Smt. Partavati Devi and subsequent nominations were invalid.
- This plea was not raised before the Deputy Registrar and was therefore considered belated and without merit by the court.
Lt. Governor's Counsel's Arguments
- The Lt. Governor upheld the Deputy Registrar’s order based on the ground that the petitioner acquired property during membership, disqualifying him under Rule 25(1)(c)(i).
- The actual reasoning of the Lt. Governor’s order was not communicated, but reliance was placed on the Deputy Registrar’s letter stating disqualification due to property acquisition during membership.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined the application of Rule 25(1)(c)(i) and distinguished between acquisition of membership by succession and benami holdings of property. The Rule disqualifies persons owning residential property either in their own name or in the name of spouse or dependents to prevent benami transactions. However, the court found that the Rule does not apply to cases where membership is acquired by transmission or succession under a Will, as governed by Section 26 of the Delhi Co-operative Societies Act, 1972, and Rule 35 concerning nomination and transfer of shares after death.
The court analyzed the Society’s bye-laws, particularly bye-law 5 which sets eligibility conditions excluding persons owning property, and bye-law 9 which exempts nominees or legal heirs of deceased members from such disqualifications. This indicated legislative intent to allow succession and nomination transfers without triggering disqualification under Rule 25.
The court rejected the society’s belated argument that the petitioner’s initial membership was invalid due to his wife’s ownership of property prior to his application, noting it was not raised earlier and lacked merit given the Society had admitted new members after the transfer and had approved the petitioner’s mother-in-law’s membership.
Accordingly, the court concluded that the Deputy Registrar exceeded jurisdiction in declaring the petitioner disqualified under Rule 25(1)(c)(i) and invalidating his membership transfer.
Holding and Implications
The court issued the following ruling:
- The writ petition is allowed and the rule is made absolute.
- The orders of the Lt. Governor dismissing the petitioner’s appeal, the Registrar’s order declaring disqualification, and the DDA’s show cause notice are quashed.
The direct effect of this decision is the restoration of the petitioner’s membership rights in the Co-operative Society. The court’s interpretation clarifies that Rule 25(1)(c)(i) does not apply to membership acquired by succession through a Will, thereby preventing misapplication of disqualification rules in such contexts. No new precedent beyond the parties involved was explicitly established.
D.K Jain, J.:— This petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India seeks to challenge the order passed by the Lt. Governor, Delhi, dismissing the petitioners appeal, filed against the order of the Deputy Registrar (HB), disqualifying him from the membership of Co-operative Society, namely, Raj Nagar Co-operative House Building Society Ltd. A writ of certiorari or any other appropriate order or defection has been sought to quash the orders passed by: (i) the Lt. Governor, communicated to petitioner on 20-12-1988. (ii) the Registrar, Co-operative Societies, communicated on 3-12-1987 and (iii) the show cause notice issued by Delhi Development Authority on 5-1-1988.
2. Briefly stated the facts are that in the year 1966 the petitioner made an application for membership of the said society and vide resolution dated 6th April, 1966 he was admitted as a member. It may be noted here that at the time when the petitioner filed the application for getting membership of the society his wife was the owner of a house property No. 24|56, Shakti Nagar, Delhi. Thereafter, in July, 1967 the petitioner applied to the society for transfer of his all rights, privileges and benefits arising out of this membership in favour of his mother-in-law, namely, Smt. Partavati Devi. An admission form was also filed by Smt. Partavati Devi with the society. Vide resolution dated 18th July, 1967, petitioner's membership was transferred in favour of Smt. Partavati and she was admitted as a member. In her admission form, Smt. Partavati had made a nomination in favour of her daughter, namely. Dr. (Mrs.) Shanta Sethi, wife of the petitioner, which was subsequently changed in favour of Miss Rachna Sethi, daughter of the petitioner. Once again, in the year 1979 Smt. Partavati requested the society for a change in nomination in favour of the petitioner and it appears that the said change was recorded by the society in its records.
3. Smt. Partavati died on 20th August, 1982 and in November, 1982, the petitioner informed the society about her death. On the strength of a Will left by the said Smt. Partavati in his favour and no objection certificate from the said Miss, Rachna Sethi, he requested the society to transfer the plot in question in his favour and make necessary changes in its records in this behalf. The Managing Committee of the Society in its meeting held on 19th December, 1982 resolved as under: —
“Discussed and resolved that the society has no objection to the transfer subject to the necessary permission of the competent minority.”
The petitioner accordingly, submitted an application to the Delhi Development Authority requesting for mutation of the plot in question in his name. On the requisite documents, as demanded by the DDA, including a certificate issued by the society to the effect that the petitioner was the nominee of Smt. Partavati being submitted, the DDA effected the mutation in favour of the petitioner and communicated the said decision to the society vide their letter dated 27th January, 1984. Thereafter various charges were demanded from the petitioner by the DDA and were paid.
4. In September, 1987, a notice (Annexure ‘R’) was issued by the Asst. Registrar (HB) lo the petitioner to appear before the Registrar, Co-operative Societies and show cause as to why his membership in the said society may not be cancelled under Rule 25 (1) (c) (i) of the Delhi Co-operative Society Rules, 1973 as his wife was owning a property. A copy of the said notice was also endorsed to the President/Secretary of the Society with a request to appear before the Registrar, Co-operative Societies along with all relevant documents relating to the members concerned.
5. The petitioner filed reply to the said notice, contending that he having acquired the plot in question under a Will, the said Rule, under which the proposed action was sought to be taken, was not applicable in his case. Another registered notice was issued to the society to produce the complete records of Smt. Partavati and the petitioner. It appears that none attended before the Registrar on behalf of the society. On 3rd December, 1987, an order was made and the transfer of the membership in favour of the petitioner in the year 1984 was declared to be invalid. The petitioner appealed to the Lt. Governor but with no success. Hence the present writ petition.
6. The actual terms of the order passed by the learned Lt. Governor have neither been communicated to the petitioner, nor have been filed before us. The order impugned before us is an intimation to the petitioner that his appeal has been dismissed by the Lt. Governor and does not give even at indication as to what weighed with the Lt. Governor to uphold the order of the Deputy Registrar. Mr. S.K Mahajan, the learned counsel appearing for the Lt. Governor submits that the reason given by the Deputy Registrar in his letter dated 3-12-1987 has found favour with the Lt. Governor and we may examine the matter in the light of the said letter. The letter of the Deputy Registrar is as under: —
“I am directed to inform you that you are disqualified to be a member of Raj Nagar Co-op. H.B Society Ltd. due to the reason that you have acquired a property No. 24/56 during your membership with the society. Hence you ceased to be a member of the society under Rule 25 (1) (c) (i) of the Delhi Co-op. Societies Rules 1973 and Regd. bye-laws of the said Society. Therefore, the subsequent transfer of membership is also accordingly held to be invalid.”
It is not in dispute that the wife of the petitioner was the owner of a house property No. 24/56, Shakti Nagar, Delhi even prior to the petitioner's filing of the application for membership. This being so, the only ground, namely, the petitioner had acquired property No. 24/56, Shakti Nagar, Delhi during his membership with the respondent-society, on the basis whereof petitioner's membership was declared to be invalid, is on the lace of it unsustainable and the impugned order could be quashed on this short ground alone, if not on live ground that the impugned order is otherwise absolutely non-speaking. But since, we have been addressed on the legal issue, namely, as to whether Rule 25 of the said Rules is at all applicable to a case of succession by will and this issue is likely to arise in other cases as well, we propose to deal with this issue.
7. Mr. S.C Gupta, Sr. Advocate, appearing for the petitioner, submits that Rule 25 (1) (c) (i) is not attracted in the instant case. His contention in this behalf is two fold, namely; (i) the said Rule is not attracted at all in the case of an acquisition of membership in a co-operative society by succession and (ii) the said Rule is intended to apply to those cases where the properties are held ‘benami’ in the name of wife or dependent children. In support of his contentions, the learned counsel has heavily relied on Rule 35 and bye-law 9 of the Society's bye-laws.
8. Before dealing with the contentions of Mr. Gupta, it would be appropriate to refer to some of the provisions of the Delhi Co-operative Societies Act, 1972 for short, “the Act” and the Rules made thereunder, which are relevant for the purposes of this case.
9. Chapter III of the Act as also of the Rules made there under deals with “members of Co-operative Societies and their rights and duties.” Broadly speaking, these inter alia, prescribe the conditions for eligibility and disqualifications for admission to membership. (Section 20 read with Rules 24 to 26), restrictions on and transfer of membership by a person during his life time or on his death (sections 25 & 26.) Rule 25 of the said Rules deals with “Disqualifications for membership”. Relevant portion whereof is extracted below:
Rule 25:
(1) No person shall be eligible for admission as a member of a co-operative society if he —
(a) . . . . . . .
(b) . . . . . . .
(c) in the case of membership of a housing society: —
(i) he owns a residential house or a plot of land for the construction of a residential house in any of the approved or unapproved colonies or other localities in the Union Territory of Delhi, in his own name or in the name of his spouse or any of his dependent children, on lease hold or freehold basis provided that disqualification as laid down in sub-rule (1) (c) (1) shall not be applicable in case of persons who are only co-sharers of joint ancestral properties in congested localities (slum areas) whose share is less than 65.72 Sq. meters (80 Sq. yards) of land;
(ii) he deals in purchase or sale of immovable properties either as principal or as agent in the Union Territory of Delhi; or
(iii) he or his spouse or any of his dependent children is a member of any other housing society except otherwise permitted by the Registrar.
(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in the rules or the bye-laws of the co-operative society, if a member becomes, or has already become, subject to any disqualifications specified in sub-rule (1), he shall be deemed to have ceased to be a member from the date when the disqualifications were incurred.
(3) . . . . . . . .
(4) . . . . . . . .
10. Rule 25 of the said Rules stipulates, inter alia, that no person shall be eligible for admission as member of the co-operative society, if in the case of membership of a Housing Society: (i) he owns a residential house or a plot of land for construction of the residential house in any of the approved or un-approved colonies or other localities in the Union Territory of Delhi, in his own name or in the name of his spouse or any of his dependent children on base hold or free hold basis; or (ii) he deals in purchase or sale of immovable property either as member or as agent in the Union Territory of Delhi; or (iii) he or his spouse or any of his dependent children is a member of any other Housing Society except otherwise permitted by the Registrar. Rule 25 (2) provides that if a member becomes or has already become subject to any disqualifications specified in Rule 1 he shall be deemed to have ceased to be a member from the date when the disqualifications were incurred.
11. Section 26 of the Act deals with transfer of interest on death of members. It lays down:
Section 26:
(1) On the death of a member a co-operative society may transfer the share or interest of the deceased member to the person nominated in accordance with the rules made in this behalf, or, if there is no person so nominated, to such person as may appear to the committee to be the heir or legal representative of the deceased member, or pay to such nominee, heir or legal representative, as the case may be, a sum representing the value of such member's share or interest as ascertained in accordance with the rules or bye-laws:
provided that —
(i) in the case of a co-operative society with unlimited liability, such nominee, heir or legal representative, as the case may be, may require payment by the society or the value of the share or interest of the deceased member ascertained as aforesaid;
(ii) in the case of a co-operative society with limited liability, the society shall transfer the share or interest of the deceased member to such nominee, heir or legal representative, as the case may be being qualified in accordance with the rules and bye-laws for membership of the society or on his application within one month of the death of the deceased member to any person specified in the application who is so qualified;
(iii) no such transfer or payment shall be made except with the consent of the nominee, heir or legal representative, as the case may be.
(2) A co-operative society shall, subject to the provisions of section 36 and unless within six months of the death of member prevented by an order of a competent court, pay to such nominee, heir or legal representative, as the case may be, all other moneys due to the deceased member from the society.
(3) All transfers and payments made by a co-operative society in accordance with the provisions of this section shall be valid and effectual against any demand made upon the society by any other person.
12. Rule 35 of the said Rules, dealing with nomination by a member, inter alia, provides:
Rule 35:
(1) For the purpose of transfer of his share or interest under sub-section (1) of section 26 a member of a co-operative society may, by a document sighed by him or by making a statement in any book kept for the purpose by the society, nominate any person or persons. Where the nomination is made by a document, such document shall be deposited with the society during the member's life time and where the nomination is made by a statement, such statement shall be signed by the member and attested by one witness.
(2) The nomination made under sub-rule (1) may be revoked or varied by any other nomination made in accordance with that sub-rule
(3) The record of nomination shall be kept by a co-operative society in such manner as may be laid down in the bye-laws.
(4) When a member of a co-operative society nominates more than one person, he shall, as far as practicable, specify the amount to be paid or transferred to each nominee in terms of whole share and the interest accrued in the society.
(5) The value of the share or interest transferred or paid to a nominee or nominees shall be determined on the basis of the sum actually paid by the member to acquire such share or interest unless the bye-laws provided for calculation on a different basis.
(6) (i) Where a member of a co-operative society has not made any nomination, the society shall, on the member's death, by a public notice exhibited at the office of the society invite claims or objections for the proposed transfer of the share or interest of the deceased within the time specified in the notice.
(ii) After taking into consideration the claim or objections received in reply to the notice or otherwise, and after making such inquiries as the committee considers proper in the circumstances prevailing, the Committee shall decide as to the person who in its opinion is the heir or the legal representative of the deceased member and proceed to take action under section 26, subject to any appeal which may be filed to the Registrar by any person claiming the share or interest of deceased member within 30 days of the decision of the committee. The orders of the Registrar on such appeal shall be final and binding upon all concerned.
(7) If the committee refuses to transfer the share or interest of the deceased member to his nominee or his successor-in-interest, or fails to take a decision on the application of such nominee or the successor-in-interest as the case may be within 30 days of the date of such refusal or the date of such application, a nominee or any person claiming to be a successor-in-interest of the deceased member shall file an appeal to the Registrar, who after hearing the society and the applicant or any other person interested, shall pass such order as he may deem fit and on such condition as he may impose and order made by the Registrar shall be final and binding on all concerned.
Section 26 stipulates that on the death of a member of a co-operative society, the society may transfer the share of the deceased to the nominated person or the legal heir or representative, as the case may be, in accordance with law or such person may be paid a sum representing the value of the share or interest ascertained in accordance with the rules and bye-laws governing a society. Thus, on the death of a member, the said section gives two options to the society (i) the society may transfer the share of a deceased to the nominated person or the legal heir or representative in accordance with law or (ii) pay such person a sum, representing value of share or interest ascertained in accordance with the rules or bye-laws. Rule 35 of the said rules provides for nomination of persons and the procedure therefor for the purpose of sub section (1) of Section 26 of the said Act.
13. From a conjoint reading of Section 26 and Rule 35 it appears that if a proper nomination has been made in accordance with Rule 35, the society has no option but to transfer the share of the deceased in favour of the nominated person, if he so desires.
14. In this context it is also necessary to notice the bye-laws of the respondent-society, which were adopted on 15-8-1965. Bye-laws 5 and 9, which are relevant for the instant case, are under:
Bye-law 5:
(i) Any person shall be eligible to be a member of society provided: —
(a) he is a resident in Delhi or New Delhi.
(b) his written application for membership has approved by a majority of the Managing Committee;
(c) his age is more than 18 years, except in the case of minor heir of a deceased member;
(d) he is not a member of any other house building society;
(e) he or his wife (she or her husband in case of woman) or any of his/her dependents does not own a dwelling house or a plot for building and house in Delhi;
(f) directly or indirectly he does not deal in purchase or sale of house or land for construction of houses either himself or through any of his dependants.
(g) he has carried out the provisions of bye-law 11.
Bye law 9:
(1) A member or the nominee or successor of an ex-member may transfer his shares to another member or applicant qualified under bye-law 5 and approved by the committee or to a share transfer fund created by the society out of its profits and shall then be paid the value of his shares, less any sum due from him to the society. No transfer of share or interest shall, however, be made unless a member has held such shares for not less than one year but the condition of bye-law 5 will not be applicable to the nominee or legal heir of the deceased member.
(2) The value of the share shall be in no case be more than the sum received by the society in payment thereof.
(3) A member on withdrawal, whether voluntarily or through the action of the society shall subject however to the rules of the society, have no claim on the provident fund or on any other funds or property of the society of any kind.
15. Bye-law 5 stipulates that any person shall be eligible to be a member of the society provided he is not a member of any other house building group housing society or he or his wife does not own a dwelling house or a plot for building a house in Delhi.
16. Bye-law 9 provides that a member or the nominee or successor of an ex-member may transfer his shares to another member or applicant qualified under bye-law 5 and approved by the committee. It further provides that no transfer of shares or interest shall be made unless a member has held such shares for not less than one year but the condition of bye-law 5 will not be applicable to the nominee or legal heir of the deceased member (emphasis added). Therefore, bye-law 9 which prevents holders of houses and lands in Delhi from becoming members of the society is not to be applicable to the nominee or legal heir of a deceased member who could transfer his right to become a member to another person, thus, the real purpose served by bye-law 9 (1), therefore, is two-fold. Firstly, it enables the nominee or the successor to transfer his liability to become a member to another person and secondly it exempts such a nominee or successor from, the requirement of bye-law 5, namely, the disqualification attached to holders of lands and houses in Delhi.
17. As is evident from the above, the conditions for being eligible to be a member of a co-operative society as prescribed in by-law 5 though, at the first glance, appear to be identical to the conditions which are prescribed in Rule 25 of the said Rules, dealing with the disqualification for membership but a closer look reveals a significant difference between Rule 25 (1) (c) (i) and bye-law 5 (i) (e). Whereas bye-law 5 (i) (e) provides in positive terms that person shall not be eligible to be a member of the society if he, his wife or any of his dependents own a dwelling house or a plot for building a house in Delhi, on the other hand, as already noted above, Rule 25 (i) (c) postulates that no person shall be eligible for admission as a member of the society if be owns a residential house or a plot of land for the construction of a residential house in Delhi in his own name or in the name of his spouse or any of his dependent children (emphasis added). From the language employed, the legislative intent behind Rule 25 (i) (c) can be ascertained. It appears that the law makers were conscious of the fact that system of “benami” holdings of properties had become a way of life in India and in fact felt concerned about it, so much so that way back in 1972, the Government of India considered it necessary to request the Law Commission to examine the problem of benami held properties with a view to determining whether benami transactions should be prohibited. On the recommendations of the Law Commission contained in its 57th Report, on May 19, 1988, the Benami Transactions (Prohibition of Right to Recover Property) Ordinance, 1988 was promulgated, which was ultimately replaced by the Benami Transactions (Prohibition) Act, 1988. Therefore, with this background in mind, in our view a definite indication of the legislative interest is available in the language of the said Rule and the intent was to disqualify from membership even those persons who held properties “benami” either in their wife's name of in the name of their dependent children. Thus, we are of the considered view that Rule 25 (1) (c) is attracted in these cases where the properties are held benami. Having come to this conclusion, there seems to be little difficulty in holding that the said Rule cannot apply in the cases where properties are acquired by transmission/devolution. We feel that rules 25 and 35 of the said rules have to be read in different contexts. The former takes care of the cases of acquisition of membership or its transfer and the latter the cases of transmission etc. The view, which we have taken, we feel, will give a harmonious construction to the provisions of the said Rules and bye laws, referred to above. A contrary view, in our opinion, will not only make bye-law 9 redundant but may also lead to unreasonable and anomalous results. For example, a member, on being granted membership of a housing co-operative society constructs a house on the plot sub-leased in his favour. He registers his only heir as his nominee. During his life time the said heir also himself/herself acquires a residential house or a plot of land far construction of residential house. It will be extremely unreasonable if on the death of the member, the said heir is told that he/she having incurred disqualification as per rule 25, membership and property of the deceased could not be transferred in his/her favour. More so when the Act, the Rules and the bye-laws are silent on the question as to what will happen to the property after the death of the member in such a situation. We feel, the latter part of bye-law 9 is intended to take care of such a situation.
18. Mr. J.P Gupta, the learned counsel appearing for the society contends that the petitioner's wife being the owner of a residential house, even prior to his applying for membership of the society, he had incurred a disqualification within the meaning of Rule 25 (1) (c) of the said Rules and, therefore, his enrolment as a member on 6th April, 1966 was itself illegal and this being so, he submits, the transfer of his membership in favour of Smt. Partavati Devi was also bad. He, thus, contends that in such a situation any nomination by Smt. Partavati Devi in favour of the petitioner, on the basis whereof the membership was transferred in favour of the petitioner, is of no consequence. Admittedly, no such plea was raised by the society before the Deputy Registrar, whose order has been assailed before us. It is too late in the day now to permit the society to raise such a plea. It does not even merit any consideration. The respondent-Society had acceded to the prayer of the petitioner for transfer of his membership in favour of Smt. Partavati Devi and had in fact recommended the execution of sub-lease in her favour. Even otherwise we find from the membership register of the society, which was produced before us during the course of hearing, that society had admitted new members after the transfer of the plot in question in favour of Smt. Partavati Devi and there was no bar in her being enrolled as a new member in her own right. That apart, even the stand of the counsel for the Lt. Governor and the Registrar is that the said respondents, whose orders have been impugned in this petition have not based their decision, disqualifying the petitioner, on his membership which he acquired in the year 1966.
19. In view of the above discussion, we are constrained to hold that the Registrar travelled beyond his jurisdiction while holding that the petitioner had ceased to be a member of the respondent-Society under Rule 25 (1) (c) (i) of the said Rules and registered bye-laws of the society. We, accordingly make the rule absolute and hereby quash:
(i) the order made by the Lt. Governor, dismissing petitioner's appeal, communicated to him vide letter dated 20-12-1988 (Annexure ‘A’);
(ii) the order passed by the Registrar, communicated to the petitioner vide letter dated 3-12-1987 (Annexure R); and
(iii) the show cause notice issued by the Delhi Development Authority on 5-1-1988 (Annexure W).
There will be no order as to costs.
Rule made absolute.
Alert