Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Anand Sarup v. The State .

Delhi High Court
Jan 30, 1987
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeal by Anand Sarup challenges the judgment and order dated 30-11-1977 of the Special Judge, Delhi, which convicted him under S. 161, I.P.C. and S. 5(2) read with S. 5(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act. The trial court sentenced him to one year rigorous imprisonment on each count and a fine of Rs. 100/- (with two months R.I. in default); the imprisonment terms were to run concurrently.

The prosecution case (summarised from the record): Hari Babu Vashisht, a tenant whose landlord had appealed an eviction order, required a certified copy of the lower court order for an appeal hearing set for 5 Aug 1976. After a sequence of visits to the Copying Agency and an order by the Incharge Copying Section that the copy be prepared, Hari Babu alleged that the accused (a L.D.C. posted at the Copying Agency) asked for Rs. 10/- as a bribe to expedite the copy and that he handed over two Rs. 5/- notes to the accused. Hari Babu had complained to the Anti-Corruption Branch; the investigating officer arranged two independent panch witnesses, mixed phenolphthalein powder with the notes and supervised handing over of the notes, after which the accused was apprehended and a chemical test was performed.

The accused's recorded defence (under Section 313 Cr.P.C.) denied demanding or accepting a bribe and presented a version that the complainant either tried to plant the notes on him or that there was no occasion for him to demand or accept money because he was not involved in the preparation or delivery of the certified copy. At trial the prosecution led 17 witnesses; the accused led one witness. The trial court convicted; the present appeal challenges that conviction.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the two currency notes (Ex. P-1 and Ex. P-2 of Rs. 5/- each) were voluntarily accepted by the accused as illegal gratification or whether an attempt was made to insert the notes into his pocket so as to falsely implicate him in a corruption case.

Arguments of the Parties

Prosecution's Case (as presented at trial)

  • The complainant, Hari Babu Vashisht, said the accused asked for Rs. 10/- as bribe and, when the complainant handed over two Rs. 5/- notes, the accused accepted them.
  • The Anti-Corruption Branch's Inspector arranged for two independent panch witnesses and mixed phenolphthalein with the two notes; on handover the Inspector and panch witnessed the accused being apprehended and a chemical test later produced a pink reaction when the accused's hand and pocket were tested.
  • Prosecution called 17 witnesses to support the narrative and relied on the recovery of the notes and the chemical test report to link the accused to acceptance of bribe.

Accused's Defence

  • The accused denied that the complainant's son approached him for a certified copy and admitted only that Hari Babu came with a slip on 3-8-1976 and was told his application was missing and to apply afresh.
  • He denied the prosecution version of events on 4-8-1976 — he denied asking the complainant to come inside, denied asking for or accepting money, and denied that Rs. 10/- was recovered from his left pant pocket. He claimed that the complainant tried to put something into his pocket and that the Inspector entered shortly thereafter.
  • He produced one witness in defence; he stressed that he had no involvement in preparation or delivery of the certified copy and therefore had no occasion to demand or accept money as alleged.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Panalal Damodar Rathi v. State of Maharashtra, (1979) 4 SCC 526; AIR 1979 SC 1191 After introduction of S. 165-A IPC, evidence of the person who offers a bribe must be treated as that of an accomplice; "the evidence of the complainant should be corroborated in material particular." The court relied on this guideline to insist on corroboration of the complainant's testimony; it concluded that corroboration in material particulars was lacking in the prosecution case and that the complainant could not be placed on a better footing than an accomplice.
State of Bihar v. Basawan Singh, AIR 1958 SC 500 Where the evidence of an accomplice is uncorroborated, a judge must indicate in judgment the caution exercised and reasons why it was safe to convict without corroboration; in jury-less trials the judge must give reasons for considering corroboration unnecessary. The court applied this cautionary principle and found that the trial court failed to give reasons satisfying the required rule of caution — the appellate court therefore scrutinised whether corroboration existed and concluded it did not.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by applying the legal principles cited above to the evidence on record and evaluated whether the prosecution had established beyond reasonable doubt that the accused voluntarily accepted the two currency notes as illegal gratification. The reasoning unfolded in these steps:

  1. Standard of caution: The court noted the effect of S. 165-A IPC and the guidance from Panalal Rathi and Basawan Singh, emphasising that the complainant (person who offers bribe) must be treated as an accomplice and that corroboration in material particulars is required; a judge must indicate why it is safe to convict without corroboration.
  2. Evaluation of panch witnesses: The court examined the testimony of the two panch witnesses (P.W.2 L.N. Filokand and P.W.3 Saran Gulati) and found that they did not support the prosecution. Both stated they neither heard the conversation nor observed the passing of the currency notes; they reached the spot after the inspector had already caught hold of the accused and thus their evidence did not corroborate the complainant.
  3. Chemical examiner's report: The court observed that the chemical examiner did not certify the presence of phenolphthalein powder in respect of the recovery from the accused's left pocket. This lack of scientific confirmation undermined the prosecution's assertion of a positive chemical link between the recovered notes and the accused.
  4. Independent documentary and third-party evidence: The court considered evidence from Shri Shanti Narain Gupta (Incharge Copying Section) and other clerks which established that the copy requested by Hari Babu was to be prepared and delivered without involvement of the accused. Mr. Gupta recorded that a fresh application was filed and the copy would be delivered; Nanak Chand supported that the copy was being compared and would shortly be ready. This indicated the accused had no occasion to demand or accept a bribe in relation to the copying/delivery process.
  5. Missing corroborative items and investigative gaps: The court noted the prosecution's claim that the notes were wrapped in a piece of paper; that wrapper was neither recovered nor produced and the investigating officer did not attempt to test it. The court found no satisfactory explanation for the absence of this wrapper.
  6. Contradictions in the complainant's statements: The court catalogued material contradictions between the complainant's testimony in court and his earlier statement under Section 161 Cr.P.C. Notably, the complainant's account that the accused asked "Laye Ho" and asked him to come inside was not present in the earlier statement; earlier statements attributed the handling of the slip and issuance of the second application to another clerk. These contradictions went to the root of the prosecution case and diminished the reliability of the complainant.
  7. Legal synthesis and conclusion: Given (a) absence of corroboration in material particulars, (b) panch witnesses who did not observe the key act, (c) failures in chemical confirmation, (d) documentary evidence showing the accused had no role in processing/delivery of the copy, and (e) material contradictions in the complainant's statements, the court concluded the prosecution had failed to prove that the accused voluntarily accepted the notes as illegal gratification. The court held that recovery of money, if divorced from reliable circumstances of payment, was insufficient to sustain conviction.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED — CONVICTION SET ASIDE; ACCUSED ACQUITTED

Direct effect on the parties:

  • The appellate court allowed the appeal, set aside the order dated 30th Nov. 1977 of the Special Judge, Delhi, and acquitted the accused (Anand Sarup).
  • The bail bond furnished by the accused was discharged.

Implications:

The opinion emphasises adherence to the cautionary rules applicable when the complainant is effectively an accomplice (post S. 165-A IPC) and reinforces that corroboration in material particulars is required; because the opinion is confined to the facts of this case and does not purport to lay down new law, its practical consequence is the reversal of the conviction here rather than the establishment of a new precedent.

This summary is based exclusively on the information contained in the provided opinion and does not introduce any material beyond that text.

Show all summary ...

1. The present appeal by Anand Sarup is directed against the judgment and order dt/- 30-11-1977 of the learned Special Judge, Delhi holding him guilty under S. 161, I.P.C and S. 5(2) read with S. 5(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act. He was sentenced to undergo R.I for one year on each count and a fine of Rs. 100/- only; in default of payment of fine to further undergo R.I for two months. Both the sentences of imprisonment were directed to run concurrently. In order to appreciate the challenge of his conviction it is relevant to keep in mind few salient features of the prosecution case.

2. Hari Babu Vashisht is a tenant. His landlord had filed an eviction case against him. The case was decided in his favour. The landlord had preferred an appeal which was pending in the court of Shri M.K Chawla, the then Additional District Judge. The next date of hearing was 5th Aug. 1976. Hari Babu Vashisht asked his son Shekhar Vashisht to apply for a certified copy of the order of the lower court dt/- 31st Jan. 1976. This was required to be filed in the appellate court. The copying Agency gave the date as 19-6-76. On that date, the copy was however not ready. On 3-8-76, Hari Babu Vashisht himself went to the Copying Agency (Civil). He enquired from the accused, who was posted as L.D.C about the fate of his application. The accused informed him that his application was not available and that he should apply afresh. Hari Babu Vashisht was not satisfied with the reply. He approached Shri Shanti Narain Gupta, Incharge Copying Section. On Shri Gupta's request Hari Babu moved a fresh application for the copy on the same day and gave the same to another Clerk for registration. That clerk had given the date for collecting the copy as 10th Aug. 1976. As the copy was required to be produced on 5th Aug. 1976, Hari Babu Vashisht again approached the Incharge Copying section. Shri Gupta made an order that the copy be prepared and given to him on the next day. Hari Babu Vashisht also approached the accused for urgent need of the certified copy mentioned in the said application. The accused assured him that in case he pays Rs. 10/- as bribe, the work will be done. Hari Babu Vashisht agreed to pay the said amount on the next day.

3. In the meantime Hari Babu Vashisht approached the Anti Corruption Branch at Tis Hazari Delhi and lodged the report. The case was marked to Pt. Chander Sain, Inspector. He recorded the statement, summoned two independant witnesses, completed the formalities of mixing the two currency notes of denomination of Rs. 5/- each with phenolphthalein powder and noted down their numbers. The complainant was sent along with the two witnesses to the Copying Agency. The panch witnesses were given clear instruction to remain near the complainant, to hear the talk and observe the passing of the currency notes to the accused. On reaching the office of the Copying Agency on the next date, the complainant asked the accused if the certified copy was ready. The accused then asked him if he had brought the money, to which he replied in the affirmative. The accused then directed Hari Babu to come inside. On reaching near him the accused said “give the money”. The complainant took the notes and handed over the same to the accused. At that time one of the Panch witnesses was standing outside window No. 1 while the other was watching from outside window No. 2. Immediately after handing over the two notes to the accused, the complainant rubbed his hands and gave the required signal to Pt. Chander Sain, Inspector and the two witnesses. They immediately rushed to the spot and caught hold of the accused by his hand. The Inspector asked the accused if he had accepted the bribe from the complainant to which he replied in the affirmative. The inspector then arranged for a glass of water, got the hand of the accused in one of the chemical dipped and his pocket of the pant washed in the other glass. The solution turned pink. The inspector then completed the formalities at the spot. After completing the investigations in due course of time, challan was filed in court.

4. The accused when examined under S. 313 of the Cr. P.C inter alia, took up the stand that at no point of time S. hekhar Vashisht son of the complainant approached him for the supply of certified copy. However, he admitted that Hari Babu Vashisht came to him on 3-8-1976 with a slip. On examining the record he informed the complainant that his application was missing and that he should apply afresh. He also took the complainant to Shri Shanti Narain Gupta, Incharge of the Copying Agency who also advised him to make a fresh application on which Sh. Gupta ordered that the copy should be supplied to him on 4th Aug. 1976. The accused denied the prosecution version that on 4-8-1976 Hari Babu Vashisht had contacted him at window No. 1 or presented slip or he ever asked him to come inside the room. He also denied having accepted any amount from the complainant or a sum of Rs. 10/- was recovered from the left side pocket of his pant by Inspector Chander Sain. According to him on 3rd August, 1976 the complainant exchanged hot words with him on account of missing of his application and on 4th Aug. 1976, when he came inside to enquire about the certified copy, he tried to put something in the pocket of his pant. And he prevented him from doing so. Just then the police inspector entered the room and asked him to raise hands.

5. In support of the case the prosecution examined as many as 17 witnesses while the accused produced only one witness in his defence. The learned lower court, as observed earlier, on consideration of the oral as well as documentary evidence on record convicted and sentenced the accused, the result of which is not to the liking of the appellant.

6. The only material question that requires determination is as to whether the currency notes Ex. P-1 and Ex. P-2 of the denomination of Rs. 5/- each were accepted by the accused as illegal gratification voluntarily or an attempt was made to insert these notes in the pocket of his pant with a view to involve him falsely in a corruption case.

7. Before adverting to this question it will be relevant to keep in mind the status of the complainant, after the introduction of S. 165 A of I.P.C The Supreme Court in a case Panalal Damodar Rathi v. State Of Maharashtra, (1979) 4 SCC 526 : AIR 1979 SC 1191 : (1979 Cri LJ 936) laid down the following guide-lines:—

“that there could be no doubt that the evidence of the complainant should be corroborated in material particular. After introduction of S. 165-A of the I.P.C making the person who offers bribe guilty of abetment of bribery the complainant cannot be placed on any better footing than that of accomplice and corroboration in material particulars connecting the accused with the crime has to be insisted upon.”

8. To what extent his evidence is to be corroborated a note of caution has been laid down in the judgment reported as the State Of Bihar v. Basawan Singh, AIR 1958 SC 500 : (1958 Cri LJ 976). On this aspect the Supreme Court lays down as under:—

“The uncorroborated evidence of an accomplice is admissible in law but it has long been a rule of practice which has virtually become equivalent to a rule of law, that the Judge must warn the jury of the danger of convicting a prisoner on the uncorroborated testimony of an accomplice. Where the offence is tried by a Judge without the aid of a jury, it is necessary that the Judge should give some indication in his judgment that he has had this rule of caution in mind and should proceed to give reasons for considering it unnecessary to require corroboration on the facts of the particular case before him and show why he considers it safe to convict without corroboration in that particular case.”

9. The second note of caution which the court has to keep in mind is that in a case of bribery, mere recovery of money divorced from the circumstances under which it is paid is not sufficient to convict the accused when the substantive evidence in the case is not reliable.

10. Applying the principles of law referred to above to the facts of the present case it can safely be held that the learned court has failed to come up to the expectations of the above rules of caution. The reasons are not far to seek. In the first instance both the panch witnesses P.W 2 L.N Filokand P.W 3 Saran Gulati, whose services were requisitioned by the Inspector on 4th Aug. 1976 to be the panch witnesses, have not supported the prosecution case at all. Both of them have gone to the extent of saying that they neither heard any conversation between the complainant and the accused nor observed him passing the currency notes to the accused. In fact they were standing at a position from where they could not have a glance at the transaction. Both of them reached at the spot when the inspector had already caught hold of the accused. Their evidence thus does not advance the case of the prosecution. Secondly, the report of the chemical examiner in so far as the insertion and recovery of the notes from left hand pocket of the pant of the accused is concerned, did not certify the presence of phenolphthalein powder. This circumstance is also against the prosecution.

11. Now only the evidence of the complainant is to be seen, if at all it advances the prosecution version. The evidence on record goes to show that neither on 3rd or 4th Aug. 1976 Hari Babu ever came in contact or had the occasion to deal with the accused. In fact the accused had no occasion to make a demand or accept the bribe as alleged. On 3rd Aug. 1976 when the complainant was informed that his application for supply of certified copy is missing, the matter was brought to the notice of the Incharge Copying Section, who in turn required the complainant to file a fresh application. According to Shri Shanti Narain Gupta, Incharge Copying Section the fresh application was moved by the complainant at about 4.30 p.m and the slip Ex. P.W 2.G was issued to him by another receipt clerk. Shri Gupta directed the said clerk that copy should be prepared., and delivered to Shri Hari Babu definitely on 4th Aug. 1976 as he was to produce the same before the Court on 5th Aug. 1976. To this effect also a note was recorded on the application itself, by Mr. Gupta. The Clerk concerned prepared a Robkar for the record keeper Mauza clerk concerned and got collected the file on the same day. However Mr. Gupta went on to say that on 4th Aug. 1976 at about 2.30 p.m the complainant came to him and enquired about the certified copy. He then asked Mr. Nanak Chand who was sitting opposite his seat as to what had happened to that copy. Nanak Chand told the Incharge copying section that the copy is being compared and that within a short time it would be ready for delivery Nanak Chand supported this version. This part of the prosecution evidence goes to show that the accused had no occasion to deal with the receipt of the application, preparation of the copy or its delivery thereof to the complainant on any of these two dates. It is not understood as to why the complainant should pay the money when the accused was not at all connected either with the issue or preparation of or in any way concerned in helping the complainant in getting the certified copy. In fact Hari Babu was sure to get the copy, after the Incharge had passed the order in this behalf. The evidence of the complainant does not find corroboration from any reliable quarters. Rather the prosecution witnesses cut across his stand.

12. It is the case of the prosecution that two currency notes of Rs. 5/- each smeared with phenolphthalein powder were kept wrapped in a piece of paper before delivering the same to the accused. Unfortunately neither the paper used as wrapper was recovered from the accused nor produced by the complainant at that time. Even the investigating officer did not make any attempt to locate the said paper or dipped it in the solution to certify that the notes were mixed with phenolphthalein powder. In fact there is no worthwhile explanation as to where that wrapper vanished.

13. Furthermore there are a number of contradictions in the statement of the complainant itself which go to the root of the matter. It is the case of the complainant that on 3rd Aug. 1976 when he was told about the misplacement of his application for certified copy he contacted the Incharge copying section, Mr. Shanti Narain Gupta. At that time Mr. Gupta is alleged to have enquired from him if he had a talk with the dealing Assistant at the counter to which the complainant replied that he had already talked to him. At this Mr. Gupta told the complainant that he should do whatever the dealing Assistant had told him to do. This part of his statement does not find place in his statement recorded under S. 161 of the Cr. P.C with which he was duly confronted. On the other hand it has come on record that the accused was not the dealing clerk on that day. The second material contradiction brought on record is the handing over of the second application to the accused. The name of the accused does not find mention in his earlier statement Ex. P.W 12.A wherein it is recorded that the second application was entertained by another clerk and the slip was also given to him by the said clerk. He also admitted that the date given on his application was mentioned by the same clerk and not by the accused. The third contradiction is with respect to the manner of demand and payment of bribed amount to the accused. Before the Court the case of the complainant is that when he showed the slip Ex. P.W 2.G to the accused, the accused asked ‘Laye Ho’ to which he replied ‘Haan’ thereafter the accused asked him to come inside. This part of the very material ingredient of the demand unfortunately does not find mention in his statement Ex. P.W 12.A. The confronted portion is as under:

“I do not remember if I made the statement before the I.O that when I came to the window to collect the copy and showed him the slip, the accused asked me ‘Laye Ho’ and I replied ‘Yes’ (Haan).”

14. This part of the statement does not find place in the statement recorded by the police under S. 161 of Cr. P.C This contradiction by itself knocks down the demand of bribed amount by the accused from the complainant.

15. As a result of the above discussion it can safely be concluded that the prosecution has failed on all the fronts firstly there is absolutely no corroboration to the solitary statement of the complainant, secondly there are material contradictions in the statement of the complainant itself, thirdly the recovery of money by itself, even if admitted to be correct, divorced from the circumstances under which it was paid is not sufficient to convict the accused, fourthly, the report of the Chemical Examiner knocked down the basis of acceptance of the bribe and lastly, the circumstances to indicate that the accused was not at all concerned with the preparation of the certified copy or delivery thereof either on 3rd or 4th Aug. 1976. In the result, the appeal is allowed. The order dt/- 30th Nov. 1977 of the Special Judge, Delhi is set aside. The accused is acquitted. The bail bond furnished by the accused is hereby discharged.

16. Appeal allowed.