- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Mrs. Roma Dev & Ors. Petitioners v. M/S. R. C. Sood & Co. Pvt. Ltd.
Structured Summary of Judicial Opinion (D.P. Wadhwa, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
This opinion concerns a preliminary objection to the maintainability of a winding up petition under the Companies Act, 1956, raised by the respondent company. The company is described (per Clause 8 of its Memorandum) as engaged in colonisation and acting as builders/colonisers. In or about 1962 the company offered plots for sale in "Eros Garden Colony" near Suraj Kund, Haryana, accompanied by large-scale advertisement. The opinion records that a number of persons (the petitioners) paid varying amounts for plots during 1963–64 and later alleged that the company misused those funds, that the substratum of the company had gone, and that it was just and equitable to wind up the company; allegations also included breach of contract, commercial insolvency, and mismanagement.
Procedural history as set out in the opinion: - The petition was filed on 1st February, 1985. At filing there were recorded to be 22 petitioners and it was supported by an affidavit of Mr. R. N. Paul. - By order dated 11th April, 1985 it was noted that some petitioners had died, necessitating an amended petition. An amended petition was filed on 1st July, 1985 (also supported by an affidavit of "Mr. R. N. Pawl" as stated in the opinion). - Objections were raised that the amended petition lacked signatures of the petitioners and that counsel had not filed powers of attorney for all petitioners. A further amended petition was filed on 4th October, 1985 signed by the petitioners and again supported by an affidavit of Mr. R. N. Paul. - The respondent company objected to the affidavit accompanying the amended petition on the ground that it did not comply with Rule 21 of the Company (Court) Rules, 1959 (and Form No. 3), and submitted that the petition was therefore not maintainable.
(The opinion also uses slightly varying numerics in different places — for example, it refers at one point to "as many as 17 petitioners" and at the conclusion refers to the petition as having been originally filed by 22 petitioners and "now there are seventeen petitioners". The summary above reproduces the procedural chronology as stated in the opinion.)
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the winding up petition was maintainable when the affidavit verifying the petition did not conform to the mandatory form prescribed by Rule 21 and Form No. 3 of the Company (Court) Rules, 1959.
- Whether the Court may, in the exercise of its powers (including inherent powers and powers under the Rules), permit the petitioners to file or re-file an affidavit in the prescribed form to cure a defective verification, and whether such permission would affect the date to which the petition relates or prejudice third parties.
- What is the legal consequence of a defective verification of a winding up petition — is it a fatal defect requiring dismissal, or an irregularity amenable to curative amendment?
Arguments of the Parties
Respondent Company's Arguments (as summarized in the opinion)
- The affidavit accompanying the amended petition did not comply with Rule 21 and Form No. 3, and compliance with these provisions is mandatory; therefore the petition is not maintainable and must be dismissed.
- Counsel (Mr. G. L. Rawal) relied on a decision of the Calcutta High Court (Kaya Textiles v. Star Textile Engineering Works, AIR 1968 Cal. 388) that a defect in verification of a winding up petition is fundamentally different from defects in verification of a plaint; in a winding up petition the averments are treated as evidence and the winding up order relates back to the date of presentation — hence permitting re-verification would mean a winding up order would arise on the date of re-verification and create confusion concerning assets and third-party rights.
- The Punjab and Haryana High Court had followed the Calcutta High Court approach in Mool Chand Wahi v. National Paints (P) Ltd. (1984 PLR 182) and that decision was affirmed in appeal (reported 1986 60 Comp. Cus. 402), supporting the contention that re-verification should not be permitted.
Petitioners' Arguments (as summarized in the opinion)
- The petitioners contended that the Court had ample powers to permit them to file an affidavit in the terms required by Rule 21 and Form No. 3 and that the defect, if any, was curable.
- Counsel for the petitioners (Mr. G. R. Chopra) relied on the Bombay High Court decision in Western India Theatres Ltd. v. Ishwarbhai Patel (AIR 1959 Bom. 386 (DB)) which treated such defects as irregularities that could be cured at any time.
- Counsel also invoked the definition of "affidavit" in sub‑section (3) of Section 3 of the General Clauses Act, 1887 (stating that "affidavit" includes affirmation and declaration where law permits), and argued that what was required by Rule 21 and Form No. 3 was an affidavit verifying the petition and that the original verification, in substance, met the Rules' requirements.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Kaya Textiles Private Ltd. v. Star Textile Engineering Works Ltd., AIR 1968 Cal. 388 | Holds that defect in verification of a winding up petition is fundamentally different from a plaint; averments in a winding up petition are to be treated as evidence; a winding up order relates back to the date of presentation; permitting re-verification would change the date of existence of the petition and may create confusion affecting third parties. | The court acknowledged that this judgment supports the respondent's objection but expressly disagreed with its conclusions and declined to follow it in the present case, holding instead that the defect was not necessarily fatal and could be remedied in appropriate circumstances. |
| Mool Chand Wahi v. National Paints (P) Ltd., (1984 PLR 182); appeal reported (1986) 60 Comp. Cus. 402 | The Punjab & Haryana High Court followed the Kaya Textiles approach on the fatality of defective verification and the inadmissibility of post-presentation re-verification. | The opinion records that this decision followed Kaya Textiles; the court in the present case noted these authorities but declined to adopt their restrictive approach, holding that the affidavit defect could be cured in the ends of justice. |
| Western India Theatres Ltd. v. Ishwarbhai Patel, AIR 1959 Bom. 386 (DB) | Observed that the legal consequence of a petition for winding up not being properly signed by the petitioner is a mere irregularity which can be cured at any time. | The petitioners relied on this decision. The court in the present opinion invoked the same remedial principle (treating certain verification defects as curable) while adding that such rectification would not be permitted as a matter of course but only in the ends of justice and on consideration of relevant circumstances. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court's analysis proceeded by careful reference to the statutory and procedural framework and to the content of the affidavit filed in support of the amended petition.
- Identification of the formal requirements: The court set out Rule 21 (affidavit verifying petition) and Rule 18 (affidavits in the first person, particulars of deponent, signature and oath/affirmation) and reproduced the relevant portion of Form No. 3 — which requires statements of truth expressed in the first person and a verification clause in prescribed terms.
- Assessment of the filed affidavit: The court compared the affidavit of R. N. Paul (as filed) with the prescribed form and found that the affidavit "is hardly in the form prescribed and does not meet the requirements of Rule-21 and Form No. 3." The original affidavit similarly did not meet Form No. 3's requirements.
- Consideration of authorities and competing views: The court acknowledged the authorities (Calcutta High Court and Punjab & Haryana High Court) that treated defective verification of a winding up petition as fatal and which disallowed leave to re-verify because of consequences relating back. The court also noted the contrary authority from the Bombay High Court treating such defects as curable irregularities.
- The court's conclusion on curability: With respect, the court disagreed with the view that defective verification is so fatal that it cannot be remedied. The court held that it has inherent powers (noted Rule 9 and the inherent jurisdiction of the Court), as well as procedural powers (Rule 7 and Rule 6), to permit the petitioners to present or file an affidavit in the terms of Rule 21 and Form No. 3 where justice requires. The court emphasized the remedy would be exercised only in the ends of justice and after considering relevant circumstances (including conduct of parties and potential prejudice to third parties).
- Analogy to verification of a plaint: The court imported the general principle applicable to verification of a plaint — that defects in verification are irregularities curable at any stage — and applied a similar approach to winding up petitions while cautioning that curative relief would not be automatic in winding up matters.
- Consideration of relation-back and prejudice: The court noted rules permitting amendment and substitution (Rules 101 and 102) and cited Section 21 of the Limitation Act, 1963, to show that relating back is a recognized procedural device. The court asked the company's counsel to specify concrete prejudice to third parties that would arise from permitting re-verification; the counsel could not point to specific instances beyond general assertions that the company had entered into contracts while the petition was pending.
- Balancing exercise and discretion: Having weighed the competing considerations and found no convincing demonstration of irreparable prejudice to third parties, the court exercised its discretion to permit the petitioners to file a proper affidavit verifying the petition in Form No. 3, subject to conditions (costs and time for filing), given that the petition was at a preliminary stage and not yet admitted.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
OBJECTIONS OVERRULED. The court overruled the respondent company's preliminary objections as to maintainability based on non-conforming affidavit verification. The petitioners were directed to file an affidavit in the form prescribed (Form No. 3 of the Rules) within two weeks and were ordered to pay costs of Rs. 500/-.
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: The winding up petition remains on file and at the admission stage; the petitioners are permitted to correct the defective verification by filing a proper affidavit within the time directed and on payment of the specified costs.
- Court's approach to similar defects: The court articulated that defects in verification of a winding up petition need not invariably be fatal; the Court may, in the ends of justice and after considering circumstances (including conduct of parties and any prejudice to third parties), permit rectification by filing a proper affidavit in terms of Rule 21 and Form No. 3. However, the court emphasized that such permission would not be given as a matter of course.
- Scope of precedent: The opinion expressly disagreed with prior authority (as to finality of defective verification) and set forth the court's discretionary approach in cases where the petition is at a preliminary stage and where prejudice to third parties is not shown to be conclusive. The opinion does not state or claim to lay down a binding rule beyond the facts and discretion exercised in this case.
Final Order Summary: Preliminary objections by the respondent company regarding verification under Rule 21 and Form No. 3 were overruled; petitioners to file the prescribed affidavit within two weeks; petitioners to pay Rs. 500/- costs.
D.P Wadhwa, J.:— In the present winding up petition by this order I am deciding a preliminary objection raised by the company as to maintainability of the petition. The objection is on the ground that the petition is not supported by an affidavit duly verified as required under Rule 21 of the Company (Court) Rules, 1959 (for short the ‘Rules’).
2. The respondent company is engaged in the business of colonisation, and acts as builders and colonisers. This is as per Clause-8 of the Memorandum of Association of the company. It is stated that some time in 1962 the company offered to sell plots of land in the Eros Garden Colony developed by it. There was large scale of advertisement. The colony is stated to be situated near Suraj Kund in the State of Haryana. There are as many as 17 petitioners who, it is alleged, wanted to buy plots and paid varying amounts to the company during the period 1963-64. The details as to which plots these petitioners wanted to buy and were allotted and the amounts paid by them have been set out in the petition. For the purpose of present order it is not necessary to refer to all the details except to note that some of the grounds mentioned for winding up the company are that the substratum of the company has gone and that company is using the amounts paid by the petitioners as plot holders and of other plot holders in other business activities of the company and that company is suffering loss in all its financial activities and that it is just and equitable that the company be wound up. It is alleged that the company is guilty of breach of contract and is commercially insolvent. Again, I need not refer to the alleged acts of mis-management as given in the petition for the purpose of this order. The petitioners feel aggrieved that all these years they have been deprived of their moneys and given false promises.
3. The petition was filed on 1st February, 1985. At that time there were 22 petitioners. It was supported by an affidavit of Mr. R. N. Paul — one of the petitioners. By order dated 11th April, 1985 it was noted that some of the petitioners had did and that had, therefore, necessitated filing of an amended petition. This amended petition was filed on 1st July, 1985. This time also it was supported by an affidavit of Mr. R. N. Pawl. The company raised objection that the amended petition was defective inasmuch as it had not been signed by any of the petitioners. It was signed only by the advocate of the petitioners. It was pointed out that counsel for the petitioners had not filed his power of attorney on behalf of all the petitioners. This led to filing of another amended petition on 4th October, 1985 signed by all the petitioners. Again this was supported by an affidavit of Mr. R. N. Paul. It is this affidavit which has been the subject of objection by the company and it is submitted by the company that the petition must fail on that account as filing of affidavit as required by the Rule is mandatory. It was submitted that the affidavit filed along with the original petition could not be looked in to after the amendment of the petition and again it was mentioned that affidavit also did not conform to the mandatory requirements of the Rules.
4. These submissions were disputed by the petitioners and it was submitted that in any case the Court had ample powers to permit the petitioners to file an affidavit in terms of the Rules.
5. The present petition for winding up is under Sections 433 and 439 of the Companies Act, 1956. It is yet at the admission stage. Section 443 prescribes various modes by which this petition could be disposed of. Rules have been framed by the Supreme Court in the exercise of its powers conferred by Section 643 of the Companies Act. No doubt these have been framed under the statutory powers. Under Rule-6 — practice and procedure of the Court and provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure would be applicable to all proceedings under the Act and the Rules. This would be if it is not otherwise provided by the Act or by the Rules. It is mentioned in this Rule that the Registrar way decline to accept any document which is presented otherwise than in accordance with these Rules or the practice and procedure of the Court. Under Rule-7 the Court has power to enlarge or abridge time appointed by the Rules. Rule-9 saves inherent powers of the Court. The Court has all the inherent powers to give such directions or pass such orders as may be necessary for the ends of justice or to prevent abuse of process of the Court.
Rule — 21 is as under: —
“21. Affidavit verifying petition — Every petition shall be verified by an affidavit made by the petitioner or by one of the petitioners, where there are more than one, and in case the petition is presented by a body corporate, by a director, secretary or other principal officer thereof; such affidavit shall be fixed along with the petition and shall be in Form No. 3:
Provided that the Judge or Registrar may, for sufficient reason, grant leave to any other person duly authorised by the petitioner to make and file the affidavit.”
Under Rule 18 every affidavit is to be drawn up in the first person and should give the particulars of the deponent as mentioned therein. It is to be signed by the deponent and sworn to in the manner prescribed by the Code or the rules and practice of the Court.
6. Under Rule 17 the Forms set forth in Appendix I (which contains Form No. 3), here applicable, shall be used with such variations as circumstances may require.
Relevant portion of Form No. 3 is as under: —
“2. The statements made in paragraphs. . . . . . . . of the petition herein now shown to me and marked with the letter ‘A’, are true to my knowledge, and the statements made in paragraphs. . . . . . . . are based on information, and I believe them to be true.
Solemnly affirmed, etc.”
Let me now set out the affidavit in support of the amended petition. It is quite in brief and is as under: —
“I, Rajendra Nath Paul, the above named, do hereby declare on solemn affirmation as under: —
1. That I am one of the petitioners in the Company Petition No. 22 of 1985.
2. That I have instructed Shri G. R. Chopra, Advocate to prepare an amended Company petition. In the amended petition, those petitioners who could not file the petition for one reason or the other, have been dropped. The company petition now is in accordance with the direction of the Hon'ble Court. The amended petition has been signed by all the 16 petitioners.
Sd/-
DEPONENT
VERIFICATION:
Verified at New Delhi on this 4th day of October, 1985 that the contents of my above affidavit are true and correct to my knowledge, no part of it is false, nothing has been concealed therefrom.
Sd/-
DEPONENT”
No argument is needed to show that this is hardly in the form prescribed and does not meet the requirements of Rule-21 and Form No. 3. In the affidavit in support of the original petition facts have been mentioned which also find mention in the petition. It is stated that the deponent Mr R. N. Paul is one of the petitioners and is fully aware of the facts enumerated in the petition for winding up and that he had been persuing the claims of the petitioners who are party to the petition. This affidavit also in terms does not meet the requirements of Form No. 3 which has been set out above.
7. Mr G. L. Rawal, learned counsel for the company, submitted that since the petitioners did not comply with the mandatory requirements of the Rules, the petition has to be thrown out as not maintainable. In support of his submissions he referred to a decision of the Calcutta High Court in Kaya Textiles Private Ltd. etc. v. Star Textile Engineering Works Ltd. (AIR 1968 Cal. 388) (1) where it was said that a defect in verification of a winding up petition was entirely different than any such defect in the case of a plaint and that different considerations would apply. It was said that the allegations in the plaint could be acted upon only on the proof of the same by evidence or upon admission by the defendant and that the allegations in a petition for winding up were, however, to be treated by the Court as evidence without any further proof. It was also stated in this judgment that a winding up order related back to the date of presentation of the petition and that from such date there was no proper verification then there was no petition at all on which the Court could proceed. On the question as to whether the Court could permit the petitioner to re-file the affidavit the Court observed as under: —
“If leave to verify such a petition is granted, the winding up order would come into existence on the date of such re-verification and this would create a good deal of confusion regarding assets of the company and rights of third parties. Such leave therefore could not be granted.”
This judgment of the Calcutta High Court was followed by the Punjab and Haryana High Court in Mool Chand Wahi v. National Paints (P) Ltd. (1984 PLR 182) (2). This judgment was again confirmed in appeal before the Division Bench of the Punjab and Haryana High Court and that decision is reported in (1986) 60 Comp. Cus. 402.
8. No doubt these judgments do support the objection raised by Mr. Rawal but with great respect I do not find in agreement with the views expressed therein. I do not think that the defect in the verification is so fatal that it could net be remedied. The Court can in its inherent powers allow the petitioners to present an affidavit in support of the petition in, terms of Rule 21 and Form No. 3 if the affidavit originally filed with the petition did not conform to Form No. 3. Of course, this the Court would do in the ends of justice and if the circumstances of the case so required. Mr. G. R. Chopra, learned counsel for the petitioners, said that the defect, if any, was not such that it could not be cured. He, however, insisted that in any case the affidavit filed originally with the petition did in substance meet the requirements of the Rules. In support of his submissions he referred to a decision of the Bombay High Court in Western India Theatres Ltd. v. Ishwarbhai Patel (AIR 1959 Bom. 386 (DB) (3) wherein the Court observed that the legal consequence of a petition for winding up not being properly signed by the petitioner was a mere irregularity which could be cured at any time. Mr. Chopra also referred to the definition of ‘affidavit’ as given in sub-section (3) of Section 3 of the General Clauses Act, 1887. Under this ‘affidavit’ shall include affirmation and declaration in the case of persons by law allowed to affirm or declare instead of swearing. It was the submission of Mr. Chopra that no verification to the affidavit in the present case was required and that Rule-21 and Form No. 3 merely stipulated an affidavit verifying the petition. I think Mr. Chopra is right in this submission of his.
9. It was not disputed that the Court could permit amendment of the petition. As noted above in the present case amended petition was in fact filed and no objection raised. The amended petition would relate back to the filing of the original petition. Under Rule-101 the Court could substitute a creditor or contributory for the original petitioner and in that case would permit such amendment of the petition as might be necessary. Under Rule 102 the amended petition shall be treated as the petition for the winding up of the company and shall be deemed to have been presented on the date on which the original petition was presented. Under Sec. 21 of the Limitation Act, 1963 where-after the institution of a suit a new plaintiff or defendant is substituted or added, the suit shall, as regards him be deemed to have been instituted when he was so made a party. But, there is a proviso and it says that where the Court is satisfied that the omission to include a new plaintiff or defendant was due to a mistake made in good faith it may direct that the suit as regards such plaintiff or defendant shall be deemed to have been instituted on any earlier date. I am mentioning all this to show that dating back of the petition under various circumstances is not something new to the law. If the effect of permitting an act is to Relate back the petition, otherwise initially defective to its original date filing, this could be permitted in the ends of justice and the Court will see if any prejudice is being caused to the other party which could not be compensated by costs or otherwise. A balance has to be struck between two warring parties. If amendment of the petition can be allowed there does not seem to be any reason as to why a defective affidavit verifying the petition could not be rectified. I do not think Court is helpless in a case where, the affidavit verifying the petition is not in Form No. 3 and that the petition invariably has to be dismissed on that account. In the case of verification to the plaint it is now settled that a defect in verification is only an irregularity in procedure and will not be a ground for rejecting the plaint and that it could be cured at any stage of the suit. Merely because the averments in the petition could be treated as evidence without any further proof should not in my view, be a ground for the Court to treat a defective affidavit verifying the petition as fatal to the petition. I would import the same principles as for verification of the plaint except I would say that in case of a winding up petition Court will not permit the rectification of the defect just as a matter of course and would take into account all the relevant circumstances including the conduct of the parties. I did ask Mr. Rawal if the effect of permitting the petitioners to file a proper affidavit would relate back to the filing of the original petition which according to him is not permissible, what rights of the third parties in the present case can be said to have been affected. He could not give any specific instance except to aver that during the period when this petition was pending various other contracts have been entered into by the company with third parties. I am not inclined to accept the submissions of Mr. Rawal and I don't think there is any bar coming in my way in permitting the petitioners to file a proper affidavit verifying the petition.
10. The case is at a preliminary stage and the petition is yet to be admitted. The petition was originally filed by as many as twenty two petitioners and now there are seventeen petitioners. They have made serious allegations against the company and contend that in the circumstances of the case it is just and equitable that the company be wound up. They have stated that all these years the company has misutilised their money. I would not like to push them to a new petition and would permit them to file an affidavit verifying the petition in Form No. 3. I am reminded of the following passage: —
11. “In civil jurisprudence it too often happens that there is so much law that there is no room for justice, and that the claimant expires of wrong in the midst of right, as mariners die of thirst in the midst of water. (Coltan) “
12. If reference is made again to Rule-6 it would appear that it is at the stage of filing that the Registrar could decline to accept any document presented otherwise than in accordance with the Rules or the practice and procedure of the Court.
13. I would, therefore, over-rule the objections of the company as to the maintainability of the petition on the grounds mentioned in paras 2 and 3 of the preliminary objections in its reply. Petitioners would, however, pay a sum of Rs. 500/- as costs. The affidavit in the form prescribed will be filed within two weeks.
Objections over ruled.
Alert