Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Shri Daya Ram v. Union Of India & Ors.

Delhi High Court
Jul 21, 1986
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary — Petition under Article 226 (Conservation of Foreign Exchange & Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, a sweeper employed with Air India, was detained under section 3(1) of the Conservation of Foreign Exchange & Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974 by an order dated 12 March 1986 (served 16 April 1986). The grounds of detention alleged that on 15 July 1985 Customs officers at Delhi Airport, after searching the petitioner, recovered two packets containing eight gold biscuits each of foreign origin from his uniform. The gold was seized under the Customs Act, 1962. The petitioner reportedly stated the packets had been given to him by a passenger, Ram Dass Chauhan, who in turn attributed them to one Parminder Singh (also known as Kukku), another passenger on the same flight. Searches of the residences of Daya Ram, Ram Dass Chauhan and Parminder Singh followed. Daya Ram and Ram Dass Chauhan were arrested under the Customs Act and later bailed; Parminder Singh obtained anticipatory bail on 2 August 1985.

The Administrator of the Union Territory of Delhi issued the detention order relying on a list of 33 enclosed documents and stated that he had examined various documents, statements and court applications while forming his satisfaction. The petitioner requested copies of certain documents (including an application referred to at S. No. 24) and made representations; the requested documents were not furnished and requests/representations were ultimately rejected. The petitioner filed a writ under Article 226 challenging the detention order on several grounds; the two primary grounds argued at hearing were (1) non-supply of material documents relied upon by the detaining authority, and (2) excessive delay between the occurrence/investigation and the detention order undermining proximity/continuity.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the detaining authority's failure to supply a document listed among the enclosed documents (specifically the document at S. No. 24, described as an application for anticipatory bail) deprived the petitioner of the right to make an effective representation and/or indicated non-application of mind by the detaining authority.
  2. Whether the delay (approximately eight months after completion of investigation) in passing the detention order defeated the required proximity or continuity between the alleged activity and the detention, thereby vitiating the order.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner asserted that the detaining authority relied on a list of documents and that one document specifically described at S. No. 24 (the application for anticipatory bail of Parminder Singh) was not supplied despite being referred to in the grounds and in the list; this non-supply deprived him of the ability to make an effective representation in violation of Article 22(5) of the Constitution.
  • The petitioner argued that the detention order was passed about eight months after investigation concluded (investigation completed on 5 August 1985; detention dated 12 March 1986 and served 16 April 1986), and that this delay showed a lack of proximity/continuity between the alleged smuggling activity and detention, rendering the detention contrary to the spirit and purpose of the Act.
  • In support of the non-supply argument, the petitioner relied on Vinod Kumar Arora v. Administrator, Union Territory of Delhi & Others (1984 Crl. L.J. 1344) and Mohd. Hussain v. Secretary, Govt. of Maharashtra & Ors. (1982 Crl. L.J. 1848). For the delay argument he relied on Sk. Abdul Munnaf v. State of West Bengal (1974 SCC (Crl.) 857) and Rabindra Kumar Ghosel v. The State of West Bengal (1975 SCC (Crl.) 365).

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents admitted that the document referred to at S. No. 24 was not given to the petitioner but explained this by asserting a typographical error: the list incorrectly described the document as the anticipatory bail application of Parminder Singh, whereas what was intended to be supplied was an application by the petitioner for reduction of bond and sureties. They therefore contended the missing document was not material to the petitioner’s representation and was not relied upon by the Administrator in forming subjective satisfaction.
  • The respondents further contended the application for anticipatory bail of Parminder Singh was not in their power and possession, and therefore could not be furnished; they argued that merely mentioning a document in the grounds did not necessarily require its supply, and that only seized documents referred to in the grounds were mandated to be supplied (relying on the propositions in Vinod Kumar Arora and Mohd. Hussain as they interpreted them).
  • On delay, respondents explained that after investigation the case had to be considered by a Screening Committee which faced scheduling and processing delays; they provided a chronological account of meetings, vetting and processing steps and asserted that the delay was attributable to administrative processing and therefore not undue.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Vinod Kumar Arora v. Administrator, Union Territory of Delhi & Others (1984 Crl. L.J. 1344) Invoked by the petitioner for the proposition that material documents referred to in detention grounds (particularly seized documents) must be supplied so as to enable effective representation; relied upon by respondents to limit supply obligation to seized documents. The Court rejected the respondents' narrow reading that only seized documents need be supplied. The Court held that because the detaining authority had included the document in the list and the Administrator was said to have relied on court applications and related material, non-supply of the listed document indicated either non-application of mind or denial of effective representation.
Mohd. Hussain v. Secretary, Govt. of Maharashtra & Ors. (1982 Crl. L.J. 1848) Similar to Vinod Kumar Arora — cited in connection with the scope of obligation to supply documents referred to in grounds of detention. The Court did not accept the respondents' contention that these authorities permitted withholding non-seized documents; the judgment was treated as insufficient to justify the respondents' failure to supply the document listed at S. No. 24.
Sk. Abdul Munnaf v. State Of West Bengal (1974 SCC (Crl.) 857) Relied on by the petitioner in support of the contention that undue delay between the alleged activity and the detention can vitiate the detention (proximity/continuity requirement). The Court considered the relevance of delay and, after reviewing the timeline and the respondents' explanations, concluded that there was no cogent explanation for part of the delay and that proximity/continuity was lacking; the Court allowed the petition on this ground in conjunction with the document-supply issue.
Rabindra Kumar Ghosel v. The State of West Bengal (1975 SCC (Crl.) 365) Also relied upon by the petitioner for the proposition that delay may vitiate a detention order where continuity/proximity is not shown. The Court treated this precedent as one of the authorities supporting the petitioner's position on delay and found the respondents' explanation for the unexplained portion of the delay inadequate, contributing to the quashing of the detention order.
Judgment of this Court in Crl. W.150 of 1984 (decided 4 January 1985) Referenced by counsel in reply on the question of delay (no detailed rule extracted in the provided opinion). The opinion notes the reference but does not record a detailed application of that judgment's principles; the Court's decision turned on the documentary-supply issue and the unexplained portion of delay identified in the facts.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court undertook a focused analysis of two central matters: (1) the non-supply of the document mentioned at S. No. 24 in the list of enclosed documents and relied upon in the grounds of detention, and (2) the unexplained delay between completion of investigation and passing/serving of the detention order.

On the document-supply issue the Court reproduced paragraphs 10, 13 and 15 of the grounds of detention which (a) referred to Parminder Singh's anticipatory bail, (b) stated the Administrator had "seen and gone through" applications moved in various courts and relevant documents, and (c) stated reliance on material mentioned in the enclosed list. The Court observed that the respondents conceded the document at S. No. 24 was not supplied and that they attributed its inclusion to a typographical error — saying the intended document to be provided was a different application (for reduction of bond and sureties). The respondents also claimed the anticipatory bail application was not in their possession.

The Court found these contentions untenable for two reasons derived from the material on record: first, the Administrator had expressly stated he had "seen and gone through" court applications and other material, and the list included the anticipatory bail application; second, it was inconsistent for the Administrator to claim he relied on a document that the respondents simultaneously said was not in their power or possession. The Court rejected the respondents' attempt to limit the duty to supply documents only to seized documents, concluding that if the detaining authority thought it necessary to include a document in the list and the Administrator purportedly relied on it, non-supply either amounted to denial of an effective representation (contravening Article 22(5)) or demonstrated non-application of mind in the formation of satisfaction for detention.

On the delay issue, the Court examined the chronological explanation offered by the respondents. The Screening Committee and administrative steps accounted for some interval: the Committee began consideration in late September 1985 and processed cases through December 1985. However, the Court identified an additional interval — roughly three months between late December 1985 processing and the issuance of the detention order on 12 March 1986, and a further month until the petitioner's detention on 16 April 1986 — for which the respondents' explanation was not cogent. The Court held that because a portion of the delay lacked a tenable explanation, it was difficult to accept that the requisite proximity or continuity between the alleged occurrence and the detention existed.

Weighing both defects (the document-supply/non-application-of-mind issue and the unexplained delay), the Court concluded that the detention order could not be sustained.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition is allowed; the detention order dated 12th March 1986 is quashed. The Rule is made absolute and the petitioner is directed to be set at liberty forthwith unless required to be detained under any other valid order passed by a court or competent authority.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The petitioner is to be released immediately subject only to any other valid order; the specific detention order impugned in this petition stands quashed.
  • The Court's decision rests on the two factual-legal failings identified: (a) the detaining authority's reliance on a document that was included in its list but not supplied (creating denial of effective representation or non-application of mind), and (b) an unexplained portion of delay undermining proximity/continuity between the alleged smuggling incident and detention. These were the operative bases for quashing the detention order in this case.
  • No broader or novel legal principle was declared beyond the application of existing safeguards (supply of material relied upon in grounds, and scrutiny of delay/proximity) to the facts of this matter; the opinion does not purport to lay down a new precedent beyond its application to the present facts.

Show all summary ...

Sunanda Bhandare, J.:— In this petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India the petitioner has challenged the detention order dated 12th March 1986 issued by the Deputy Secretary (Home), Delhi Administration, Delhi under section 3(1) of the conservation of foreign exchange & prevention of smuggling activities act, 1974 (hereinafter referred to as the Act).

2. In the grounds served on the petitioner alongwith the detention order it was alleged that on 15th July 1985 the petitioner who was working as a Sweeper in Air India was kept under survillance by the Customs Officer at Delhi Airport. He had attended flight No. AI-301 which came from Hongkong/Bangkok on that day. He alongwith other cleaning staff had left the pron area in van No DEV-6260 He alighted near the inter section of the IAC Gate and TMO of Delhi Airport when he was intercepted and was asked in the presence of two independent witnesses if he was carrying any contraband on his persons. Thereafter, his person was searched as a result of which two rectangular packets wrapped in skin-colour adhesive tape were recovered from the pocket in the ‘Nefa’ of the uniform pant he was wearing. On examination of each packet eight gold biscuits of foreign origin weighing 10 tolas each with foreign marking were recovered. The petitioner could not produce any permission from the Reserve Bank of India and therefore, the gold biscuits were seized under the Customs Act 1962 It was further alleged that the petitioner disclosed to the Customs Officers that the two packets recovered from him were given to him by one Ram Dass Chauhan, a passenger travelling from Hongkong to Bombay via Delhi on flight No. Ai-301 which was still on ground ready for departure to Bombay. Ram Dass Chauhan was off-loaded alongwith his baggage by the Customs Officers. The petitioner in his voluntary statement admitted the recovery of the gold biscuits, however stated that these gold biscuits were handed over to him by Ram Dass Chauhan. Ram Dass Chauhan in his statement dated 15th July 1985 stated that these gold biscuits belong to one Sardar Parminder Singh also known as Kukku. The Customs Authorities were informed that Sardar Parminder Singh had also travelled from Hongkong to Bombay alongwith Ram Dass Chauhan and that before reaching Delhi Kukku Sardar took out two packets wrapped in adhesive tapes from his pocket which contained gold and put them in an air sickness bag and slided under his seat and told him to keep this packet in his custody and delivery it to Daya Ram. the petitioner herein In view of this statement of Ram Dass Chauhan the Customs Officer scrutinised the passengers manifest of the flight and noted that Parminder Singh had travelled from Hongkong to Bombay on the same flight and had occupied seat No. 31J. As a follow up action the residential premises of all the three persons namely S/Shri Daya Ram, Ram Dass Chauhan and Parminder Singh were searched.

3. In the grounds of detention it was further stated that Daya Ram and Ram Dass Chauhan were arrested on 15th July 1985 under the Customs Act and were produced before the A.C.M.M, New Delhi on 16th July 1986 and were bailed out by the A.C.M.M, New Delhi on 30th July 1985, however Parminder Singh moved an application for anticipatory bail before the Additional District & Sessions Judge, New Delhi which was granted to him by the Additional District & Sessions Judge, New Delhi by an order dated 2nd August, 1985.

4. In paragraph 13 and 14 of the grounds of detention it was stated by the detaining authority that the Administrator of the Union territory of Delhi had seen and gone throw the applications moved in various courts, replies thereof and the judgments of the court and on consideration of this material the Administrator had no hesitation in arriving at the conclusion that the petitioner bad been engaging and transporting, concealing and keeping smuggled goods and, therefore, was satisfied that he should be detained under the Act in order to prevent the petitioner from engaging in transporting, concealing and keeping smuggled goods. Alongwith the detention order and the grounds of detention the petitioner was given a list of documents containing 33 documents.

5. In paragraph 15 of the grounds of detention it was stated that the Administrator of the Union Territory of Delhi had relied on the material mentioned in this enclosed list while making the order of detention of the petitioner under the Act.

6. On 13th May 1986, the petitioner wrote to the Administrator asking for certain documents to enable him to make an effective representation. In the said application alongwith other documents he asked for the application for anticipatory ball moved by Parminder Singh in the court of Addl. District & Sessions Judge, New Delhi mentioned at S. No. 24 of the list of documents. The documents were not furnished to the petitioner but by way of abundant caution the petitioner made a representation without waiting for the documents on 20th May, 1986. In this representation the petitioner reiterated his demand regarding the documents and also sought leave to amend the representation as and when documents were furnished to him. A similar representation was made to the Central Government which was also rejected on 30th May 1986. On 20th June 1986 both his request for documents as well as representation were rejected.

7. In the writ petition the petitioner had challenged the order of detention on several grounds but the two main grounds urged at the time of the hearing were:

(a) That the non-supply of material documents referred to in the grounds of detention and relied upon by the Administrator, Union territory of Delhi and the detaining authority having deprived him of the right to make an effective representation and also of non-application of mind by the detaining authority by relying on documents which were not stated to be not within the power and possession of the detaining authority. It was stated that application for anticipatory bail of Parminder Singh was mentioned at S. No. 24 of the list of documents given by the detaining authority alongwith the grounds of detention and yet had admittedly not been supplied. Furthermore, on demand by the petitioner also it was not supplied.

(b) The second contention was that the incident was alleged to have occurred on 15th July 1985 and the complaint was made under Section 135 of the Customs Act on 16th July 1985. The investigation was completed on 5th August 1985 and the order of detention alongwith the grounds of detention was issued on 12th March 1986 and served on the petitioner on 16th April 1986 The delay of 8 months in passing the detention order indicates that there was no proximity and/or continuity between the alleged activity and the detention and, therefore, the detention was against the very purpose and spirit of the Act.

8. In support of his contention on the first point learned counsel for the petitioner relied on Vinod Kumar Arora v. Administrator, Union Territory of Delhi & Others, 1984 Crl. L.J 1344 and Mohd. Hussain v. Secretary, Govt. of Maharashtra & Ors., 1982 Crl. L.J 1848 and in support of the second contention he relied on Sk. Abdul Munnaf v. State Of West Bengal., 1974 SCC (Crl.) 857 and Rabindra Kumar Ghosel v. The State of West Bengal, 1975 SCC (Crl.) 365.

9. A counter-affidavit was filed by the respondents in reply to the show cause notice issued by this Court wherein it was admitted that the document mentioned at S. No. 24 of the list was not given to the petitioner, however it was stated that there was a typographical error in as much as the list described the document as copy of the anticipatory bail application but what was intended to be given to the petitioner was the copy of the application moved on behalf of the petitioner for reduction in the amount of bond and number of sureties and not the application for anticipatory bail of Parminder Singh. It was further contended that this document was not material for making a representation inasmuch as the Administrator had not relied on this document while arriving at the subjective satisfaction in passing the order of detention. It was further submitted that the application for anticipatory bail of Parminder Singh was not in the power and possession of the respondents and, therefore, this document could not be supplied to the petitioner. The mere mention of a document in the grounds of detention did not necessarily imply the that document ought to be served on the detenu. It was submitted that only a seized document even if referred to in the grounds was required to be supplied to the detenue as held in Vinod Kumar Arora's case (supra), and Mohd. Hussain's case (supra).

10. On the question of delay it was not denied that the investigation was completed on 5th August 1985, however it was submitted that the order of detention could not be passed till March 1986 because the case had to be scrutinised by the Screening Committee. The reason given for the delay has been stated by the respondent in the affidavit in reply which reads thus:—

“They are wrong and denied. There is no undue delay in passing the detention order. Investigations in the case went on upto August 1985 Proposal to detain the petitioner and other was received in the Home Department on 13-9-1985. Meeting of the Screening Committee was fixed for 23-9-1985. On 23-9-85 cases of S/Shri Vishwanath Khanna, Vijay Kumar Gujral, Soman Rama Bhadran, Hassan Rashid Hussain, Hussain Ebrahim, Dewa Dorjee, Gopal Sherpa, Balraj Singh, Sulkhan Singh and Ahmad Mohd. Ahmad were discussed in the meeting. The present proposal could not be discussed for want of time. On 27.9.1985 it was ordered that first previous cases be processed and then put up the present proposal for detention. Meeting was fixed for 30-10-1985 and in the meantime, previous cases were processed Meeting could not be held on 30-10-85 since the Additional Commissioner of Police who is a member of the Screening Committee was busy in law and order problem. Meeting fixed for 15-11-1985 when this case could not be taken up since the Law Secretary was busy in the Hon'ble Supreme Court. On 26-11-85, cases of Vishwanath Khanna and others were put up tor placing before the Administrator. Meeting fixed for 10.12.1985 when all pending 22 cases including that of the petitioner was considered. Minutes were drawn up on the meantime. On 12-12-1985 the draft grounds of detention order etc. for the detention of Chakravarty Vadrevo and seven other persons were put up for placing before the Administrator. All the cases were processed and formal orders in those cases were issued in the month of January 1986 On 17-2-1986 latest position of prosecution etc. was received from the Customs Department vide letter dated 14-2-1986. After preparing draft grounds of detention, detention orders etc., the present case was put up to the Deputy Secretary (Home). Vetted by the Law Department on 19-2-1986. Case was again put up on 24 2 86. On 28.2.1986 the detaining authority after applying his mind to the facts and circumstances of the case made certain enquiries. The case of the detenue and other accompliance was again put up on 5-2-1986 and the Administrator after due application of mind made order for the detention of the petitioner and his other accomplice on 7-3-1986. Formal orders were issued on 12-3-1986.”

It was, therefore, contended that the delay having been explained did not vitiate the order of detention. Learned counsel replied on the judgment of this Court in Crl. W. 150 of 1984 decided on 4tb January 1985.

11. In order to appreciate the challenge of the petitioner it may be relevant to reproduce paragraphs 10, 13 and 15 of the grounds of detention:—

“10. Shri Parminder Singh aforesaid was not available to the Customs Officer and went underground. He filed application for his anticipatory bail in the Court of Addl. Sessions Judge. New Delhi and he was granted anticipatory bail vide learned Additional Sessions Judge's order dated 2-8-85.

13. The Administrator of the Union territory of Delhi has carefully gone through the facts and circumstances of the cases relevant documents and also the statements of various persons recorded under the Customs Act, 1962 in the subject case. The Administrator has also seen and gone through the copies of applications moved in the various courts, replies thereof and the judgment of the courts.

15. While passing the detention order under the Conservation of Foreign Exchange & Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974 the Administrator of the Union territory of Delhi has relied on the material mentioned in the enclosed list. A copy of these grounds and documents, free translated into Hindi, a language known to you and also enclosed.”

It is thus clear that the application for anticipatory bail has been referred to in paragraph 10 of the grounds of detention. In paragraph 13 of the grounds of detention the Administrator is stated to have seen and gone through the copies of the documents moved in various courts and in paragraph 15 he has relied on the documents mentioned in the list while passing the order of detention. It is not denied by the respondents that copy of the anticipatory bail is mentioned at S. No. 24 of the list of documents which is alleged to have been given to the petitioner alongwith the detention order, however it is stated that it was an inadvertent typographical mistake and it was fairly conceded by the respondent in the affidavit in reply that this application was not given alongwith the documents. In fact, learned counsel for the respondents contended that this document is not in power and possession of the respondents. I find no substance in the contention of the learned counsel for the respondent that only if the document was a seized document and referred to in the grounds of detention it was required to be supplied. In the present case the detaining authority thought it necessary to give this document and, therefore, included it in the list of documents. It was only when the petitioner asked for this document on 13th May, 1986 that it was realised that this document was not in their possession and therefore though it was fairly conceded in the counter-affidavit that the document was not supplied it was stated to be a typographical error in mentioning the same in the list of documents. Even when the petitioners' request was rejected vide latter dated 20th June, 1986 it was not intimated to the petitioner that this document was not intimated to the petitioner that this document was not in the power and possession of the detaining authority. The fact that Parminder Singh filed an application for anticipatory bail and the same was granted to him by the Additional Sessions Judge, New Delhi was mentioned referred and relied by the detaining authority as it is obvious from paragraphs 10, 13 and 15 of the grounds of detention I find it difficult to understand how the document mentioned at S. No 24 which was stated not to be in power and possession of the respondents could have been relied by the Administrator and referred to in paragraph 15 of the grounds of detention by the detaining authority. If the document was wrongly mentioned and it was stated that the Administrator had relied on it there was a total non-application of mind and if the document was rightly mentioned in the list and not supplied the petitioner was denied the opportunity of making an effective representation as guaranteed under Article 22 (5) of the Constitution of India.

12. Now coming to the second question regarding delay in making the detention order. It is not denied that the detention order was passed 8 months after the investigation was completed, however it is stated that the members of the Screening Committee were busy and, therefore, the petitioner's case could not be considered early. From the dates given by the respondent in its affidavit it appears that the Screening Committee took about two months time to scrutinise the case of the petitioner. That is the period between 23-9-1985 to 10-12-1985. The detention order was issued on 12th March, 1986 i.e about 3 months thereafter and the petitioner was detained after a further period of one month on 16th April, 1986. There is no cogent and tenable explanation for these three months. It is, therefore, difficult to accept that there is proximity/continuity between the occurrence and the detention of the petitioner.

13. In the result the petition is allowed. The order of detention dated 12th March, 1986 is hereby quashed. The Rule is made absolute. The petitioner is directed to be set at liberty forthwith unless required to be detained under any other valid order passed by a court or any other competent authority.