Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Shri Anar Singh v. Union Of India

Delhi High Court
Apr 17, 1984
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Legal Opinion Summary — Avadh Behari Rohtagi, J. (Oral)

Factual and Procedural Background

Pursuant to a notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 dated 24 October 1961, the respondent, Union of India, acquired land belonging to the appellant in village Jasola. The parcel measured 8 bighas in Khasra No. 18 min, of which the appellant held a half share (4 bighas). The Land Acquisition Collector made Award No. 14/74-75 offering compensation at Rs. 4,500 per bigha. On a reference under Section 18 of the Act the learned Additional District Judge enhanced compensation to Rs. 4,900 per bigha, stating there was no material before him to determine market value and that he was "guided by [his] own experience." The appellant appealed from the Additional District Judge's order dated 9 May 1979 to the court delivering this opinion.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the compensation awarded (Rs. 4,900 per bigha) by the Additional District Judge was appropriate, having regard to market value and the potentiality of the acquired land.
  2. Whether evidence of land values in the adjoining village (Bahapur) may be used as a guide to determine market value for land in village Jasola when there are no sale transactions in Jasola itself.
  3. To what extent the potentiality (prospects of future development) of the land should be taken into account in assessing compensation for compulsory acquisition.
  4. Entitlement to solatium and interest, and whether additional interest under Section 4(3) of the Land Acquisition (Amendment & Validation) Act, 1967 applies because of a gap of more than three years between notification under Section 4 and the declaration under Section 6.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Counsel for the appellant conceded that there were no sale transactions in village Jasola as of 24 October 1961, but argued that the acquired land had "great potential value" which both the Land Acquisition Collector and the Additional District Judge had ignored.
  • The appellant relied on market values determined for the adjoining village Bahapur (ranging from Rs. 14.25 to Rs. 21.35 per sq. yd. in several decisions) as a guide and contended that, by analogy, the appellant's land should be valued at Rs. 10,000 per bigha as at 24 October 1961.

Respondent's Arguments (Union of India)

  • Mr. Mahajan for the Union argued two main points: (a) the acquired land in Jasola, on the far side of the Mathura Road, was less advantageous and had much less development than land adjoining Bahapur on the other side of the road (the acquired land was about two furlongs from the main Delhi-Mathura Road); and (b) the acquired land was subject to the provisions of the Delhi Land Reforms Act, whereas Bahapur land was not.
  • The Union relied on the Additional District Judge's conclusion that there was no material to fix market value and on the judge's own valuation experience which led to the Rs. 4,900 per bigha figure.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Union of India v. Dr. Har Gobind (R.F.A. No. 341/71; decided 2-5-1977) Demonstrates market value fixed for land in village Bahapur (Rs. 19 per sq. yd., notification under Section 4 dated 24-10-61). Used as evidence that market values in adjoining Bahapur were significantly higher than the figure adopted by the Additional District Judge for Jasola, supporting use of adjoining-village transactions as a guide.
Union of India v. Piare Lal (R.F.A. No. 11-D/66; decided 16-8-1976) Shows market value in Bahapur determined at Rs. 20 per sq. yd. (Section 4 notification dated 3-6-1961). Placed alongside other Bahapur determinations to establish a range of market rates in the adjoining village to guide valuation for Jasola.
Amrit Singh v. Union of India (R.F.A. No. 286/77; decided 23-5-1979) Records market price for land (notification under Section 4 dated 24-10-61) determined at Rs. 21,350 per bigha. Used to show high valuations in the general locality (Bahapur/Jasola adjacency) and support the proposition of upward market trend and potentiality of land.
R. N. Tikku v. Union of India (L.P.A. No. 170/80; decided 24-8-1980) Fixes market price at Rs. 14.25 per sq. yd. (notification under Section 4 dated 13-11-1959) and contains an observation by the Division Bench about rising prices and an asserted rate of escalation. The court referred to the Division Bench's observation about an upward trend and the

Legal Opinion Summary — Avadh Behari Rohtagi, J. (Oral)

Factual and Procedural Background

Pursuant to a notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 dated 24 October 1961, the respondent, Union of India, acquired land belonging to the appellant in village Jasola. The parcel measured 8 bighas in Khasra No. 18 min, of which the appellant held a half share (4 bighas). The Land Acquisition Collector made Award No. 14/74-75 offering compensation at Rs. 4,500 per bigha. On a reference under Section 18 of the Act the learned Additional District Judge enhanced compensation to Rs. 4,900 per bigha, stating there was no material before him to determine market value and that he was "guided by [his] own experience." The appellant appealed from the Additional District Judge's order dated 9 May 1979 to the court delivering this opinion.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the compensation awarded (Rs. 4,900 per bigha) by the Additional District Judge was appropriate, having regard to market value and the potentiality of the acquired land.
  2. Whether evidence of land values in the adjoining village (Bahapur) may be used as a guide to determine market value for land in village Jasola when there are no sale transactions in Jasola itself.
  3. To what extent the potentiality (prospects of future development) of the land should be taken into account in assessing compensation for compulsory acquisition.
  4. Entitlement to solatium and interest, and whether additional interest under Section 4(3) of the Land Acquisition (Amendment & Validation) Act, 1967 applies because of a gap of more than three years between notification under Section 4 and the declaration under Section 6.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Counsel for the appellant conceded that there were no sale transactions in village Jasola as of 24 October 1961, but argued that the acquired land had "great potential value" which both the Land Acquisition Collector and the Additional District Judge had ignored.
  • The appellant relied on market values determined for the adjoining village Bahapur (ranging from Rs. 14.25 to Rs. 21.35 per sq. yd. in several decisions) as a guide and contended that, by analogy, the appellant's land should be valued at Rs. 10,000 per bigha as at 24 October 1961.

Respondent's Arguments (Union of India)

  • Mr. Mahajan for the Union argued two main points: (a) the acquired land in Jasola, on the far side of the Mathura Road, was less advantageous and had much less development than land adjoining Bahapur on the other side of the road (the acquired land was about two furlongs from the main Delhi-Mathura Road); and (b) the acquired land was subject to the provisions of the Delhi Land Reforms Act, whereas Bahapur land was not.
  • The Union relied on the Additional District Judge's conclusion that there was no material to fix market value and on the judge's own valuation experience which led to the Rs. 4,900 per bigha figure.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Union of India v. Dr. Har Gobind (R.F.A. No. 341/71; decided 2-5-1977) Demonstrates market value fixed for land in village Bahapur (Rs. 19 per sq. yd.; Section 4 notification dated 24-10-61). Relied upon to show market values in adjoining Bahapur were substantially higher than the award adopted by the Additional District Judge for Jasola and to support using adjoining-village data where Jasola sales were absent.
Union of India v. Piare Lal (R.F.A. No. 11-D/66; decided 16-8-1976) Shows market value in Bahapur determined at Rs. 20 per sq. yd. (Section 4 notification dated 3-6-1961). Placed alongside other Bahapur determinations to establish a regional range of market rates for comparison with Jasola.
Amrit Singh v. Union of India (R.F.A. No. 286/77; decided 23-5-1979) Records market price for land (notification under Section 4 dated 24-10-61) determined at Rs. 21,350 per bigha. Used to demonstrate high valuations in the locality (Bahapur/Jasola adjacency) and to support the proposition that potentiality contributed to higher values.
R. N. Tikku v. Union of India (L.P.A. No. 170/80; decided 24-8-1980) Fixes market price at Rs. 14.25 per sq. yd. (Section 4 notification dated 13-11-1959) and contains Division Bench observations about rising prices and a suggested rate of escalation. The court noted the Division Bench observation about an upward trend and the asserted escalation rate; the present court declined to accept the broad generalisation about the exact rate of escalation but accepted that an upward trend was supported by satisfactory proof.
Robinson Brothers (Brewers) Ltd. v. Houghton ((1937) 2 KB 445) Principle (per Scott L.J.) that a valuer must take into consideration every intrinsic quality and circumstance (including potentiality) that tends to push value up or down when assessing market value. Cited to support the proposition that potentiality is an intrinsic quality relevant to valuation and must be weighed by the valuer before determining the resultant valuation figure.
Raja Vyricherla Narayana Gajapatiraju v. Revenue Divisional Officer (ILR 1939 Mad. 532) Authority that land is to be valued not merely by reference to the use at the valuation date but also by reference to uses for which it is reasonably capable in the future; emphasizes that potentiality must be valued on available materials without imagination. Applied to affirm that potentiality must be considered, that potential must be valued on available evidence, and to reject valuation based solely on the judge's unexplained "experience."

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded through a sequence of legal and factual determinations grounded in the material before it:

  1. The court rejected the Additional District Judge's approach of stating there was "no material" and relying on unspecified personal experience to fix value at Rs. 4,900 per bigha. The court emphasized that a valuation must be based on materials available to the valuer, not unsupported personal predilections.
  2. In the absence of sale transactions in Jasola on the relevant date (24-10-1961), the court held that transactions in the adjoining village Bahapur are a permissible and well-settled guide to market value for Jasola, subject to appropriate adjustments for relevant differences.
  3. The court accepted that market values in the vicinity (Bahapur) showed an upward trend. While it declined to accept a broad mathematical generalisation from R. N. Tikku's Division Bench about a fixed quarterly escalation rate, it found that the upward trend was "affirmatively supported by satisfactory proof."
  4. The court underscored the legal principle that potentiality (prospects of near-future development and other intrinsic qualities) is a legitimate and necessary factor in valuation. It cited Robinson Brothers for the general rule that a valuer must weigh every intrinsic quality and Raja Vyricherla for the proposition that land must be valued by reference to uses it is reasonably capable of being put to in the future.
  5. The court criticized the Additional District Judge for failing to identify or explain the basis of his "experience" and for assessing value on the erroneous hypothesis that the land had no potential. The court held that potentiality must be assessed on materials available to the valuer and not by indulging in imagination.
  6. Applying these principles and having regard to the Bahapur decisions and the proximity and likely similar potential of Jasola land, the court concluded that the appellant's claim for a higher valuation was justified.
  7. On interest and solatium, the court specifically applied statutory provisions: it awarded solatium at 15% and interest at 6% per annum from date of dispossession till payment. Because there was a period greater than three years between the Section 4 notification (24-10-1961) and the declaration under Section 6 (7-12-1966), the court observed entitlement to interest under Section 4(3) of the Land Acquisition (Amendment & Validation) Act, 1967, provided there was no overlap with interest payable under Section 28 of the principal Act.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED.

Core ruling (direct effect on the parties):

  • The court held that the appellant is entitled to compensation at the rate of Rs. 10,000 per bigha for his half share (4 bighas) of the acquired land and ordered payment at that rate.
  • Any amount already paid to the appellant shall be deducted from the awarded amount.
  • In addition to the compensation, the appellant is entitled to solatium at the rate of 15% and interest at 6% per annum from the date of dispossession until payment, and costs.
  • Because there is a gap of more than three years between the Section 4 notification (24-10-1961) and the Section 6 declaration (7-12-1966), the appellant is also entitled to interest at 6% per annum on the market value of the land under Section 4(3) of the Land Acquisition (Amendment & Validation) Act, 1967, provided there is no overlapping in the payment of interest under Section 28 of the Act and Section 4(3) of the Amendment Act.

Broader implications: The opinion reinforces two established principles without purporting to lay down a novel rule of law: (a) in the absence of sales in the specific village, transactions in an adjoining village may be used as a legitimate guide to market value; and (b) potentiality (prospects of future development) is a relevant intrinsic factor that must be taken into account in valuation, subject to being assessed on available material rather than imagination. The opinion does not state that it is creating any new legal precedent beyond applying these principles to the facts of this case.

Appeal allowed.
Show all summary ...

Avadh Behari Rohtagi, J. (Oral):— Pursuant to a notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 the Act dated 24th October, 1961, the appellant's land was acquired by the respondent, Union of India. The land was situated in village Jasola admeasuring 8 bighas bearing Khasra No. 18 min in which the appellant has got only half share, i.e, 4 bighas only, made the award (No. 14/74-75). He offered compensation to the appellant at the rate of Rs. 4500 per bigha. On a reference under Section 18 of the Act, the learned Additional District Judge enhanced the compensation from Rs. 4500 to Rs. 4900 per bigha. He found that there was no material before him to determine the market value of the land. So he said: ‘We have to be guided by our own experience. The Land Acquisition Collector fixed the market value at Rs. 4500 per bigha. I think it should be Rs. 4900 per bigha and I assess it accordingly.” From his order dated 9-5-79 the appellant appeals to this court.

2. Village Jasola is situated on the two sides of Mathura Road. On one side it adjoins village Bahapur. On the other side of the road village Okhla as well as Bahapur adjoin village Jasola. Counsel for the appellant concedes that there is no sale transaction in this village evidencing the market value of the land on 24-10-61, the date with which we are concerned. But he says that the acquired land had great potential value which factor has been completely ignored both by the Land Acquisition Collector as well as by the additional district judge. He has brought to our attention the fact that the market value of the land village Bahapur was ranging between Rs. 14.25 and Rs. 21 per sq. yd. In particular, he referred us to the cases decided by this court in respect of village Bahapur where the market value was determined between Rs. 14.25 and Rs. 21.35 per sq. yard as would appear from the following decisions:—

1. Union of India v. Dr. Har Gobind: R.F.A No. 341/71, decided on 2-5-1977 (1). In this case, the notification under section 4 was issued on 24-10-61. The market value of the land was fixed at Rs. 19 per square yard.

2. Union of India v. Piare Lal: R.F.A No. 11-D/66, decided on 16th August, 1976 (2). Section 4 notification was of 3-6-1961. The market value of the land was determined at Rs. 20 per square yard.

3. Amrit Singh v. Union of India R.F.A No. 286/77 decided on 23-5-1979 (3). Notification under section 4 was issued on 24-10-61. The market price of the land was determined at Rs. 21,350 per bigha.

4. R. N. Tikku v. Union of India: L.P.A No. 170/80 decided on 24-8-1980 (4). Notification under section 4 was issued on 13-11-1959. The market price of the land was determined Rs. 14.25 per sq. yard.

3. These cases are no doubt concerning the land of village Bahapur. Village Bahapur as we have seen, adjoins village Jasola on both sides. If the prices of the land in village Bahapur were rising, it is not possible to say that there was no increase in the value of the land in village Jasola. In R. N. Tikku's case, the Division Bench has observed that during those days of 1959 the prices were rising and there was an increase of Rs. 4 per year. They said, “one can therefore safely say that the rate of escalation was Re. 1 per square yard for every three months”. We cannot assent to this broad generalisation. But we can say this that there had been an upward trend in market values generally is not only indisputable as a matter of opinion, but is affirmatively supported by satisfactory proof.

4. It will not therefore be correct to say, as was observed by the learned judge, that there is no material to guide us in this case. There may not be any sale transaction in village Jasola. The transactions of the adjoining village can be a good guide when there is no evidence available in this village. This is well settled.

5. The learned additional district judge fixed the value of the land at Rs. 4900 per bigha on the hypothesis that the land had no potential. In our opinion he was in error. After all we have to take potentiality into consideration and potentiality means such uses to which land can be put in the near reasonable future. It is the duty of the valuer “to take into consideration every intrinsic quality and every intrinsic circumstances which tends to push the value either up or down, just because it is relevant to the valuation and ought therefore to be cast into the scales of the balance before he looks to see the resultant figure on the dial at which the pointer finally rests”, [per Scott L.J in Robinson Brothers (Brewers) Ltd. v. Houghton (1937) 2 KB 445 (5) at p. 469]. Potentiality of the land in question is one intrinsic quality which we must take into account. As the Privy Council has said:

“For it has been established by numerous authorities that the land is no to be valued merely by reference to the use to which it is being put at the time at which its value has to be determined [that time under the Indian Act being the date of the notification under Section 4 (1)] but also by reference to the uses to which it is reasonably capable of being put in the future. No authority indeed is required for this proposition. It is self-evident.”

(Raja Vyricherla Narayana Gajapatiraju v. Revenue Divisional Officer: ILR 1939 Mad, 532 (544) (6).

6. In our opinion the learned judge assessed the value on a totally wrong basis. Potentiality is a right and proper subject for consideration in ascertaining the compensation to be paid on expropriation. Prospects and possibilities of future development ought to be taken into account in determining the price to be paid for property compulsorily acquired.

7. One other observation must be made here. The learned judge went by his experience. But what is that, experience he has not told us. A case has to be decided not on one's own predelications but on such materials as are available to the valuer. If there are no instances of sale available of this very village it is permissible for the valuer to go to the adjoining village and ascertain the value of the land situated in close proximity. He can then give proper weight to the factors both favourable and unfavourable in the process of evaluation. It has to be remembered that the “value of the potentiality must be ascertained” by the valuer “on such materials as are available to him and without indulging in the feats of the imagination”. [Raja Vyricherla Narayana Gajapatiraju (supra) at p. 548].

8. Mr. Mahajan, on behalf of Union of India, made a twofold, submission. First he said that the land in village Jasola on the other side of the road was not as advantageous as was the land on this side of the road adjoining Bahapur. He said that the acquired land was situated at a distance of two furlongs from the main Delhi Mathura Road. He submits that on one side there was development and on the other side with which we are concerned there was much less development. Secondly, he said that the acquired land was subject to the provisions of the Delhi Land Reforms Act while Bahapur land was not. The fact that it was subject to the provisions of the Delhi Land Reforms Act is not disputed by Mr. Arun Kumar, Counsel for he appellant. But he says that if land in village Bahapur as on 13-11-59 can be evaluated of Rs. 14.25 per sq. yard as was done by the Division Bench in R. N. Tikku's case it would not be unjust and unfair to evaluate the appellant's land at Rs. 10,000/- per bigha as on 24-10-1961. We cannot lose sight of the fact that this village Jasola is adjoining Bahapur. This also must be borne in mind that notification under section 4 was issued on 24-10-1961. One thing is certain. The acquired land had great potential whether it was situated on this side of the road or the other side of the road.

9. In our opinion, it will be fair and just to award compensation at Rs. 10,000/- per bigha as claimed by the appellant. We accordingly order that the appellant will be paid compensation at the rate of Rs. 10,000/- per bigha. Whatever has already been paid to him will be deducted. In addition to compensation he will also be entitled to solatium at the rate of 15 per cent and interest at the rate of 6 per cent per annum from the date of dispossession till payment and costs.

10. As there is a difference of more than three years between the notification under section 4 (24-10-61) of the Land Acquisition Act (the Act’) and the declaration under Section 6 of the Act (7-12-66) the owner will also be entitled to interest at the rate of 6 per cent per annum on the market value of the land under section 4 (3) of the land acquisition (amendment & validation) act, 1967 provided there is no overlapping in the payment of interest under Section 28 of the Act and Section 4 (3) of the Amendment Act.

Appeal allowed.