Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mohinder Singh v. The State .

Delhi High Court
Nov 11, 1983
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The case arises from a violent incident following a marriage within interconnected families. Mohinder Singh's daughter, Pramjit Kaur, was married to Paramjit Singh, son of Mal Singh. Mal Singh and his two sons were displeased with the dowry received. Subsequently, at a marriage of Baljit Singh, a relative of Mohinder Singh, Mal Singh and his sons confronted Mohinder Singh alleging insufficient dowry and Paramjit Singh's attendance at the marriage against Mal Singh's wishes. The confrontation escalated into an attack where Mal Singh fired a rifle killing Karak Singh and injuring others. A case under Section 302 IPC was registered.

The Additional Sessions Judge initially granted bail to the accused, reasoning there was no intent to kill Karak Singh specifically. The complainant and others moved to cancel this bail, and the Delhi Administration supported the cancellation. The matter was referred between courts, with the Additional Sessions Judge ultimately refusing to cancel bail, noting no untoward incidents except a subsequent FIR alleging threats by the accused to witnesses and a related proceeding under Sections 107/150 Cr.P.C which was later dropped.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the initial order granting bail to the accused was justified given the nature of the offence and circumstances.
  2. Whether the accused misused the liberty granted by bail, justifying cancellation of bail.

Arguments of the Parties

Prosecution's Arguments

  • The order granting bail was unjustified as the offence involved murder.
  • The accused misused their liberty by threatening witnesses, as evidenced by FIR No. 32/83 and related proceedings.

Defence's Arguments

  • The FIR No. 32/83 was mala fide, lodged without basis and in a police station influenced by the complainant.
  • The accused were arrested and proceedings under Sections 107/150 Cr.P.C were closed due to non-appearance of witnesses.
  • The accused are young and do not reside in Delhi, making misuse of liberty unlikely.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Gurcharan Singh v. State (Delhi Admn) (1978) 1 SCC 118 : AIR 1978 SC 179 Judicial discretion in granting and cancelling bail; importance of nature and gravity of offence, likelihood of fleeing, tampering with witnesses. Guided the court's analysis on bail grant and cancellation, emphasizing the need for valid grounds and careful exercise of discretion.
State v. Sanjay Gandhi (1978) 2 SCC 411 : AIR 1978 SC 961 Cancellation of bail requires supervening circumstances; must be shown on preponderance of probabilities that accused tampered with witnesses or abused liberty. Supported the principle that bail cancellation is exceptional and must be based on concrete evidence of misuse of liberty.
Public Prosecutor v. George Williams AIR 1951 Mad. 1042 Not explicitly detailed in the opinion. Referenced as part of the legal framework concerning bail and its cancellation.
Sita Ram Singh v. The State of Bihar 1973 Cr. L.J 384 Not explicitly detailed in the opinion. Referenced in support of principles related to bail.
State v. Ranjit Singh (1978) 14 DLT 185 Not explicitly detailed in the opinion. Included among precedents guiding bail considerations.
Gokul Das v. The State of Assam 1981 Cr. L.J 229 Not explicitly detailed in the opinion. Referenced in the context of bail jurisprudence.
State v. Jitendra Chopra 18 (1980) DLT 137 Not explicitly detailed in the opinion. Part of the cited precedents on bail and cancellation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court acknowledged that the initial bail order was flawed as it incorrectly characterized the case as not involving murder. This justified reconsideration of bail. Regarding allegations of misuse of liberty, the court considered the prosecution's evidence of threats to witnesses through FIR No. 32/83 and related proceedings. Although the defence argued these were baseless and procedural failures were due to absent witnesses, the court found that accused Mal Singh and Swaran Singh had indeed misused their liberty by threatening witnesses even after bail cancellation applications were filed. There was no such evidence against Sikandar Singh. The court balanced the principles from the cited precedents, emphasizing judicial discretion, the gravity of the offence, and the necessity to prevent interference with justice.

Holding and Implications

The court ordered the arrest and committal to custody of accused Mal Singh and Swaran Singh, cancelling their bail bonds and directing them to surrender forthwith in the trial court. The bail of Sikandar Singh was not cancelled due to lack of evidence of misuse of liberty. The petitions for cancellation of bail were allowed accordingly.

The order does not preclude the accused from applying for bail again in the future. The decision directly affects the custody status of the accused but does not establish any new legal precedent beyond reaffirming established principles on bail cancellation.

Show all summary ...

M.L Jain, J.:— This order will dispose of Cr.M(M) 24 of 1983 and Cr.M(M) 75 of 1983.

2. The brief facts are that Mohinder Singh's daughter, Pramjit Kaurwas married to Paramjit Singh son of Mal Singh.

3. But Mal Singh and his two sons were annoyed with her because of insufficient dowry. Sometime after this marriage, the marriage of Baljit Singh son of Babu Singh a nephew of Mohinder Singh took place in Fazilka on 31-10-1982 which was attended by Paramjit Singh, s/o Mal Singh. The marriage party returned on 1-11-1982. Mohinder Singh had come from his village in Punjab to the house of Babu Singh in Ashok Vihar in connection with the said marriage. The accused persons, namely Mal Singh and his two sons Swaran Singh and Sikandar Singh came there at 11.15 a.m and complained to Mohinder Singh that he had not given appropriate dowry and that at his instance Paramjit Singh attended the marriage of Babu Singh's son, much against wishes of Mal Singh. The three accused then attacked Mohinder Singh. Karak Singh and Chanchal Singh intervened. Mal Singh said that they too would be done to death and immediately started firing his rifle as a result of which Karak Singh fell dead on the spot. Chanchal Singh was attacked by Sikandar Singh with a Khukri and Malkiyat Singh by Swaran Singh with a pole axe. A case under sec. 302 IPC was registered against them.

4. The learded Addl. Sessions Judge Mr. G.S Dhaka by his order dated 7-1-1983 held that though there was no intention to cause the death of Kharak Singh nor was he a target nor was any threat given to him and, therefore, enlarged them on bail bonds in the amount of Rs. 10,000/-. On 12-1-1983 the complainant Mohinder Singh and the injured Chanchal Singh and Smt. Baljit Kaur widow of Kharak Singh moved an application for cancellation of the aforesaid bail. On 28-1-1983 the Delhi Administration has also moved a similar application. Since then challan has been filed and charges have been framed against the accused.

5. When the matter came up for hearing on 5-8-1983 Talwar J. observed that the State ought to have in the first instance moved their application before the Addl. Sessions Judge. Accordingly, the decision of the two petitions was deferred and the parties were directed to move the court of the Adll. Sessions Judge. An application for cancellation of bail was then moved before the Addl. Sessions Judge Mr. Dakha. Mr. Dakha sent the application on 30-8-83 to the Sessions Judge for transferring the application to the court of Mr. P.S Sharma who was by now trying the case. But the learned Sessions Judge by his order dated 1-9-1983 transferred the application to the court of Mr. Dakha. Mr. Dakhy by his order dated 5-9-1983 refused to cancel the bail. He was of the view that after the bail was granted no untoward incident has happened except FIR 32/83 dated 19-1-1983 lodged against the accused in PS Subzi Mandi. There is no likelihood of tampering with the witnesses by the accused. The said FIR was lodged on 19-1-1983 under sec. 506 IPG by Chanchal Singh that he was working in his transport office when the accused Mal Singh and his son Swaran Singh came and threatened him that he had escaped at the time of the occurrence, but would not be spared any more and that they will also see the other witnesses. Swaran Singh even took out a country-made pistol. Chanchal Singh bagged them to spare him and his witnesses. Thereupon Swaran Singh and Mal Singh left the place. It also appears that on 27-1-1983 a case was registered against Mal Singh and Swaran Singh in Subzi Mandi Police Station under sec. 107/150 Cr.P.C These proceedings were dropped on 3-8-1983 because six months had elapsed from the institution of the proceedings, vide sub-sec. (6) of sec. 116 Cr. P.C

6. It is urged in these applications that (1) the order of bail was not justified and it should therefore, be quashed and (2) in any case the respondents have misused the liberty granted to them and, therefore, their bails should be cancelled

7. Dealing with the grant and cancellation of bail, the Supreme Court in Gurcharan Singh v. State (Delhi Admn.) (1978) 1 SCC 118 : AIR 1978 SC 179, laid down that these are matters pertaining to judicial discretion to be exercised on valid grounds. The over-riding considerations in granting bail are the nature and gravity of the circumstances in which the offence is committed; the position and the status of the accused with reference to the victim and the witnesses; the likelihood of the accused fleeing from justice; of repeating the offences of jeopardising his own life being faced with a grim prospect of possible conviction in the case; of tampering with witnesses; the history of the cases as well as of its investigation and other relevant grounds which, in view of so many variable factors, cannot be exhaustively set out. The question of cancellation of bail is certainly different from admission to bail. Ordinarily, the High Court will not interfere with an order of bail granted by the Sessions Judge in favour of the accused. The court has to see whether the order granting bail was vitiated by any serious infirmity for which it was right and proper for the High Court to interfere in the interests of justice. It is essential that due and proper weight should be bestowed on two paramount considerations, viz. likelihood of the accused fleeing from justice and his tampering with prosecution evidence. In State v. Sanjay Gandhi, (1978) 2 SCC 411 : AIR 1978 SC 961, it was observed that it is easier to reject a bail application in a non-bailable case than to cancel a bail granted in such a case. Cancellation of bail necessarily involves the review of a decision already made and can by and large be permitted only if, be reason of supervening circumstances, it would be no longer conducive to a fair trial to allow the accused to retain his freedom during the trial. A bail once granted cannot be cancelled on the off chance or on the supposition that witnesses have been won over by the accused. But in an application for cancellation of bail the prosecution can establish its case by showing on a preponderance of probabilities and not beyond reasonable doubt that the accused has attempted to tamper or has tampered with its witnesses, has abused his liberty or that there is a reasonable apprehension that he will interfere with the course of justice. If the accused hes abused this liberty by attempting to suborn the prosecution witnesses, has forfeited his right to remain free. The power to take back in custody an accused who has been enlarged on bail has to be exercised with care and circums pection. But the power, though of an extraordinary nature, is meant to be exercised in appropriate cases and refusal to exercise that wholesome power in such cases, few though they may be, will reduce it to a dead letter and will suffer the courts to be silent spectators to the subversion of judicial process. Also see Public Prosecutor v. George Williams, AIR 1951 Mad. 1042, Sita Ram Singh v. The State of Bihar, 1973 Cr. L.J 384, State v. Ranjit Singh, (1978) 14 DLT 185, Gokul Das v. The State of Assam 1981, Cr. L.J 229 and State v. Jitendra Chopra,18 (1980) DLT 137.

8. It is contended that the learned Addl. Sessions Judge was wrong in saying that it was not a case of murder and, therefore, the order of granting bail was misconceived and unjustified. I think this contention is correct,

9. As regards the second contention that the respondent accused were misusing the liberty, the prosecution relies upon FIR No. 32/83 and the proceedings under sec. 107/150 Cr.P.C Mr. Sud submitted that the FIR 32/83 was mala fide and without any basis. It was lodged after the application for cancellation was made and in a police station where the complainant has great influence. Mal Singh happened to be in Delhi on 25.1.1983 and was even arrested in a case under sec. 506 IPC by the Subzi Mandi Police. As regards the proceedings under sections 107/150 Cr.P.C the learned counsel pointed out that the proceedings had to be closed because the witnesses did not turn up. The prosecution has so far only made vague allegations. That apart, the accused Swaran Singh is aged 21 years, Sikandar Singh aged 20 years and Mal Singh aged 65 years and they did not live in Delhi to ensure that the opposite party does not create any false ground for seeking cancellation of bail. I have considered this aspect and it appears to me that the accused Mal Singh and Swaran Singh have misused the liberty and that they did not hesitated to threaten the witnesses even after there was move for cancellation of their bail. There is no such allegation against Sikandar Singh. The second ground, therefore, has also got to be upheld against the accused except Sikandar Singh.

10. I, therefore, direct that the accused Mal Singh and Swaran Singh shall be arrested and committed to custody in jail. Their bail bonds shall stand cancelled and they shall forth with surrender in the trial court. The petitions stand disposed of accordingly. This order will, however not preclude them from making a fresh application for bail as and when so advised.

11. Petition allowed