- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
M/S. Gulati Construction Co., Jhansi v. Betwa River Board And Another
Factual and Procedural Background
An agreement dated 20 July 1979 was entered into between the parties for construction of the Left Main Earth Dam, Rajghat Project. The work was awarded by respondent No. 1, the Betwa River Board, a body set up under a Central Act whose office is located at Jhansi; a liaison office was also stated to exist in New Delhi. The petitioner is a company with its head office at Jhansi. The tender was floated and accepted at Jhansi and the contract was concluded there, though the formal contract was executed at Lalitpur (U.P.) and the work carried out in district Guna (M.P.).
Certain claims by the petitioner were not admitted by the respondents and, under the agreement, disputes were to be referred to arbitration. By letter dated 16 December 1981 the Chief Engineer appointed a sole arbitrator, who conducted the arbitration proceedings in New Delhi and signed the award on 31 December 1982 at New Delhi. The arbitrator filed the award in this Court with an application dated 30 January 1983 purporting to be under Section 14(2) of the Arbitration Act.
After registration of the award by the Court, the Board filed objections under Sections 30 and 33 raising a preliminary objection that the Court had no territorial jurisdiction. The petitioner filed an application (I.A. 1420/83) to make the award a rule of the Court and to obtain a decree. The registrar had directed notices be sent to the parties and a preliminary issue was therefore framed on the Court's territorial jurisdiction.
Legal Issues Presented
- Does this Court have territorial jurisdiction to try the suit (i.e., to entertain the petition under the Arbitration Act)?
- Whether the fact that the arbitration proceedings were conducted in New Delhi and the award was made and filed there confers territorial jurisdiction on this Court notwithstanding Sections 2(c) and 31(1) of the Arbitration Act.
Arguments of the Parties
Respondent No. 1 (Betwa River Board) — Arguments
- The Board's counsel contended that no part of the cause of action arose within the territorial jurisdiction of this Court and therefore this Court had no jurisdiction to hear the matter.
Petitioner — Arguments
- The petitioner's counsel submitted that the arbitration proceedings took place in Delhi, the award was made in Delhi and filed in this Court; accordingly, this Court had territorial jurisdiction to try the present case.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Sushil Ansal v. Union of India, AIR 1980 Delhi 43 | Interpretation of Section 2(c) read with Section 31(1) of the Arbitration Act: where contract and cause of action are outside Delhi, appointment of arbitrator and award made in Delhi do not confer jurisdiction on Delhi courts. | The Court relied on and respectfully followed this decision to hold that the present Court lacked territorial jurisdiction where the cause of action arose outside Delhi despite arbitration proceedings and award occurring in Delhi. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court analysed jurisdictional provisions of the Arbitration Act. It explained that under Section 2(c) a "Court" means a civil court having jurisdiction to decide the questions forming the subject-matter of the reference if those questions had been the subject-matter of a suit. Section 31(1) requires an arbitrator to file his award in the Court having jurisdiction in the matter.
The Court reasoned that to determine which Court has jurisdiction the proper inquiry is where a suit for recovery of the claim could have been instituted (i.e., the Court in which the cause of action wholly or in part arises). Applying the facts, the tender was accepted at Jhansi, the contract executed in Lalitpur (U.P.) and the work performed in Guna (M.P.). Thus a suit could have been filed in competent courts in Madhya Pradesh or Uttar Pradesh; no part of the cause of action arose in Delhi.
The Court rejected the petitioner's contention that conducting arbitration proceedings in Delhi and making and filing the award there confer jurisdiction on the Delhi Court. It held that filing an award in a Court which lacks jurisdiction does not vest that Court with jurisdiction; Sections 31(2) and 31(3) do not operate to cure filing in a wrong Court where Section 31(1) mandates filing in a Court having jurisdiction. The Court emphasized that jurisdiction cannot be conferred on a court by agreement or by the arbitrator's unilateral choice of venue.
The Court noted a procedural misstep: the Registrar should have returned the award to the arbitrator with directions to file it in a Court having jurisdiction rather than registering it here. Given that the Board promptly objected under Sections 30 and 33 on territorial jurisdiction grounds, the objection was sustained.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The preliminary issue was decided in favour of the respondents. The Court directed that the arbitration proceedings and the award be returned to the arbitrator with a direction that the same should be filed in the Court of competent jurisdiction. I.A. 1420/83 is to be returned to the petitioner for being filed in a Court having jurisdiction. The parties will bear their own costs.
Implications: The direct effect is that the award filed in this Court was not entertained for lack of territorial jurisdiction and must be re-filed in a competent court where the cause of action arose (as identified by the Court). The opinion does not purport to establish a broader novel precedent beyond applying existing statutory interpretation (and it relies on an earlier Delhi decision); no broader implications were discussed in the text beyond the immediate procedural consequence to the parties.
Order accordingly.
An agreement dated 20th July, 1979 was entered into between the parties for the construction of the Left Maim Earth Dam, Rajghat Project.
2. The work was awarded by respondent No. 1. The said respondent is a Board which has been set up under Central Act. It is an admitted case of the parties that the office of the Board is located at Jhansi (M. P.), though a liaison office is stated to be at New Delhi also. The Board was set up for carrying out work of constructing Rajghat Dam in district Lalitpur in the State of Uttar Pradesh.
3. The petitioner is a Company having its head office at Jhansi. The contract was awarded to the petitioner on a tender enquiry having been floated by respondent No. 1 from Jhansi. The tender was submitted by the petitioner at Jhansi and it was at that place that the tender was accepted. It is clear that the contract was concluded at Jhansi, the place where the acceptance of tender took place.
4. It is further admitted between the parties that the actual contract was executed in the office of Superintending Engineer, Rajghat Dam Construction Circle-11, District Lalitpur (U. P.). The work was, however, carried out in the territory of Chanderi, District Guna (M.P)
5. Certain claims were raised by the petitioner. They were not admitted by the respondents. In terms of the agreement between the parties, the disputes had to be referred to arbitration.
6. Vide a letter dated 16th Dec., 1981 issued by the Chief Engineer, Betwa River Board, Jhansi, Sh. S.P Caprihan, Retired Engineer-in-Chief was appointed as the sole arbitrator. The sole arbitrator carried on the arbitration proceedings in Delhi and made and signed his award dated 31st Dec., 1982 at New Delhi.
7. Along with an application dated 30th January, 1983, purporting to be an application under Section 14 (2) of the Arbitration Act, the sole arbitrator filed the said arbitration proceedings and the award in this Court. In para 5 of the application it was stated that vide letter dated 14th Jan., 1983 the petitioner had requested the sole arbitrator that he should file the award in this Court.
8. After the award was filed, by order dated 22nd February, 1983, the Registrar of this Court directed that the award be registered and notices of the filing of the award be sent to the parties. Thereupon I.A 1421/83 being objections under Sections 30 and 33 of the Act were filed in this Court by the Betwa River Board. On the other hand I.A 1420/83 is an application filed by the claimant praying that the award should be made a rule of the Court and a decree in terms thereof together with interest should be passed.
9. In the objections filed by the Betwa River Board a preliminary objection had been taken. The objection was that this court had no territorial jurisdiction to decide the disputes between the parties. On the pleadings of the parties the following preliminary issue was framed :
“Does this Court has territorial jurisdiction to try this suit?”
10. The contention of Sh. Watwani, appearing on behalf of the Board is that no part of the cause of action arose within the territorial jurisdiction of this Court and as such this Court has no jurisdiction to hear this matter. On the other hand the submission of the learned counsel for the petitioner is that the proceedings took place in Delhi, the award was made in Delhi and the same has been filed in this Court and it is only this Court which has territorial jurisdiction to try the present case.
11. According to Section 2 (c) of the Act a Court means a Civil Court having jurisdiction to decide the questions forming the subject-matter of the reference if the same had been the subject-matter of a suit. This means that it is only that Court which will have jurisdiction to decide the matter, in which a Civil suit with regard to the matter which was referred to arbitration, could have been filed. To put it differently, it is only that Court which can be regarded as having jurisdiction to entertain any petition under the Arbitration Act, in which Court a suit for recovery of money could have been filed by the petitioner. In Section 31 (1) it is provided that an award would be filed in any Court having jurisdiction in the matter to which the reference relates.
12. Reading Section 31 (1) and S. 2 (c) it is clear that in order to decide which is the Court which has jurisdiction in the matter to which a reference relates, what has to be ascertained is the Court within which the suit could have been instituted for the claim which was raised in the reference.
13. In the present case, from the facts indicated hereinabove, it is clear that if a suit had to be filed by the petitioner for the recovery of money, the same could have been filed in the Court of competent jurisdiction in Madhya Pradesh or in Uttar Pradesh. The tender was accepted at Jhansi, the formal contract was executed in Lalitpur (UP) and the work was carried out in district Guna (MP). To my mind, therefore, no part of cause of action arose in Delhi. The principal office of respondent No. 1 is admittedly at Jhansi. Merely because a liaison office is in existence in Delhi and the Chairman of the Board resides in Delhi it would not be sufficient to grant territorial jurisdiction to this Court to try the present proceedings. Furthermore, the factum of the arbitration proceedings having been conducted here and award being filed here is also not relevant for the purposes of deciding as to which is the Court of competent jurisdiction. In order to decide as to which Court has jurisdiction to entertain such petitions, reference has to be made, as already noted, to Section 2 (c) of the Arbitration Act read with Section 31 (1). Merely because the arbitrator chooses to hold the proceedings in a place, where admittedly no suit could be instituted, and chooses to make and publish an award at that place it would not give the Courts of that place territorial jurisdiction to decide the matters arising under the Arbitration Act.
14. It is no doubt true that Sections 31 (2) and 31 (3) state that it is the Court in which the award has been filed which will have jurisdiction to decide the matter. In my opinion, however, if an award has been filed in a Court which has no jurisdiction, the provisions of sub-sections (2) and (3) would have no application. It is to be seen that Section 31 (1) enjoins upon the arbitrator to file his award in the Court having jurisdiction in the matter. If he chooses, in violation of the provisions of Section 31 (1) to file the award in a Court which has no territorial jurisdiction, then it cannot be argued that the said Court acquires territorial jurisdiction. It is now well-established that by agreement of parties jurisdiction cannot be conferred on Courts which have no territorial jurisdiction to decide the matter.
15. In the present case the award was filed by the arbitrator in this Court. The proper procedure which ought to have been followed, which has unfortunately not been followed by the Registrar, was that the award should have been returned to the arbitrator with the direction that the same should be filed in a Court having jurisdiction. The Board, at the first opportunity available to it, filed objections under Sections 30 and 33 contending that this Court has no territorial jurisdiction to try this case. In my opinion, the objection is well founded. As already observed, the conduct of arbitration proceedings in New Delhi and the making of the award in New Delhi do not give this Court jurisdiction to entertain the award.
16. Reference may usefully be made to a decision of this Court in the case of Sushil Ansal v. Union of India, AIR 1980 Delhi 43. In that case also the contract had been awarded and executed outside Delhi. The arbitrator, however, had been appointed in Delhi and he had given his award in Delhi. Thereupon an application under Ss. 14 and 17 had been filed in this Court. Sultan Singh J., however, held that on a correct interpretation of Section 2 (c) read with Section 31 (1) of the Arbitration Act, this Court would have no jurisdiction to entertain that petition. I am in respectful agreement with the said decision. In my opinion also, it is only the Court in which the cause of action wholly or in part arises, which would have the jurisdiction to adjudicate upon the matter.
17. For the aforesaid reasons the preliminary issue is decided in favour of respondents. It is directed that the arbitration proceedings and the award be returned to the arbitrator with a direction that the same should be filed in the Court of competent jurisdiction.
18. As a consequence of my aforesaid decision, I.A 1420/83 be returned to the petitioner for being filed in a Court having jurisdiction. The parties will bear their own costs.
Order accordingly.
Alert