Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sunder Dass v. Asthetic Exports (Private) Ltd., And Others

Delhi High Court
May 18, 1983
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, Sunder Dass, was employed by M/s. Asthetic Exports Pvt. Ltd. as a machine man in the printing section from 16-10-1978 on a consolidated monthly salary of Rs. 1100 as a permanent employee. To induce him to leave his prior employment the management gave him Rs. 3,000 as an advance and Rs. 850 as ex gratia. After approximately two months of service, from 21-12-1978 he was not permitted to enter the factory or resume duty; no written termination order was issued.

The petitioner raised an industrial dispute. By order dated 7-8-1982 the Labour Court held the dismissal illegal, concluded the management had not followed the prescribed procedure, and ordered reinstatement with continuity of service. The Labour Court refused to award back wages on the ground that the workman had not placed material on the record to show he remained unemployed after termination, following Krishan Murari Lal Kapur v. Zodiac Press.

The workman filed a writ petition under Article 226 challenging the Labour Court's refusal to award back wages. In his claim he had prayed for reinstatement with full back wages and in evidence he testified, in cross-examination, that since the date his services were terminated he was unemployed. The management's reply had only asked that the claim be rejected as “false”; it did not advance specific material showing the workman was gainfully employed or other exceptional circumstances.

The High Court considered Supreme Court decisions between 1978 and 1980, concluded the normal rule is that when a dismissal is declared void reinstatement with full back wages follows, placed the burden on the employer to plead and prove exceptional circumstances, and modified the Labour Court's award to direct payment of full back wages from 21-12-1978 to 7-8-1982 and costs of Rs. 300. The reinstatement order otherwise stood.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether it is correct to refuse back wages to a workman where the termination of his services is held illegal and he is ordered to be reinstated with continuity of service.
  2. Which party bears the burden of proof to show that the normal rule (reinstatement with full back wages) should be departed from — specifically, whether the employer must plead and prove exceptional circumstances such as the workman having been gainfully employed during the period of enforced idleness.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's (Workman's) Arguments

  • The petition of claim (18-8-1979) prayed for the illegal termination to be set aside and for reinstatement with full back wages and continuity of service.
  • In evidence (cross-examination) the petitioner stated: “Since the date my services were terminated I am unemployed.”

Respondent's (Management's) Arguments

  • The management's written reply characterised the claim as “false” but did not advance specific material showing the workman was gainfully employed or proving exceptional circumstances to deny back wages.
  • Mr. Munjal, for the management, supported the Labour Court's refusal of back wages and relied on authorities (Daily Tej Pvt. Ltd. and Malik Dairy Farms) and the Krishan Murari Lal Kapur principle that the workman must produce material to substantiate that he remained unemployed.
  • At a later stage the management asserted that management functions had been transferred to Albion Mills Pvt. Ltd. (on 7-7-1982), but this was not pleaded before the Labour Court and was not proved in the award.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Krishan Murari Lal Kapur v. Zodiac Press, 1976 (33) F.L.R. 76 (H.L. Anand, J.) Held that a workman claiming back wages must produce sufficient material to show that, after termination, he remained unemployed or was otherwise unable to earn what his employment would have entitled him to; back wages do not follow automatically on setting aside dismissal. The Labour Court relied on this decision to refuse back wages. The High Court held this view is no longer good law in light of later Supreme Court decisions and declined to follow it.
G.T. Lad v. Chemicals and Fibres India Ltd., AIR 1979 S.C. 582 Part of the line of Supreme Court authority establishing that setting aside an illegal termination ordinarily leads to reinstatement with full back wages; illegal termination is treated as void. Used by the High Court as part of the controlling Supreme Court jurisprudence to support the "normal rule" that back wages follow reinstatement unless exceptional circumstances are pleaded and proved by the employer.
Hindustan Tin Works v. Its Employees, AIR 1979 S.C. 75 Authoritatively explained that reinstatement with continuity and back wages is an appropriate remedy where termination is invalid; rejected the application of common law mitigation and non-enforcement doctrines in this context. Described by the High Court as the locus classicus; the Court relied on its reasoning (including the passage by D.A. Desai, J.) to reject the Labour Court's approach and to affirm the normal rule in favour of awarding back wages.
Gujarat Steel Tubes Ltd. v. Its Mazdoor Sabha, 1980 Lab. I.C. 1004 (S.C.) Affirms that an illegal order of termination is non est (void) and that the award of full back wages ordinarily follows when termination is declared void. Relied upon to support the conclusion that the normal rule is reinstatement with full back wages and that departures are exceptional.
Surendra Kumar (Surendra Kumar Verma) v. Central Govt. Industrial Tribunal-cum-Labour Court, New Delhi, 1980 Lab I.C. 1292 (S.C.) Supports the proposition that the normal remedy is reinstatement with back wages and that only exceptional circumstances justify departure; courts may mould relief where exceptional factors exist. Used as authority for the proposition that departures from the normal rule are permissible only in exceptional cases and that the employer must plead and prove such circumstances.
Delhi Transport Corpn. v. Ram Kumar, 1982 Lab. I.G. 1378 (Division Bench: Rajindar Sachar & M.L. Jain, JJ.) Held that it is for the employer to establish and prove that the workman was gainfully employed during the period of enforced idleness; no presumption of gainful employment arises. The High Court applied this principle to place the burden of proof on the management to show any gainful employment or other exceptional circumstances negating back wages.
Suresh Chandra v. State of Orissa, 1982 Lab I.C. 748 (Orissa High Court) Adopted the view that the employer must prove the workman was gainfully employed during enforced idleness; no presumption of gainful employment. Cited as corroborative authority for the allocation of the burden of proof to the employer.
Daily Tej Private Ltd. v. Lt. Governor, Delhi, 1979 (39) F.L.R. 302 (S.S. Chadha, J.) Relied upon (by the management) as supporting the proposition that back wages could be refused if the workman failed to place material to substantiate his claim (Chadha J. relied on Krishan Murari Lal). The High Court noted that this decision follows Krishan Murari Lal and concluded it is no longer good law in light of subsequent Supreme Court decisions.
Malik Dairy Farms v. Its Workers' Union, 1968 (2) L.L.J. 523 (Bombay High Court) Used by the management to support refusal of back wages where no material was produced by the workman. The High Court held this decision is inconsistent with later Supreme Court authority and is no longer good law on the issue of burden and awarding back wages.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by situating the issue in the context of recent Supreme Court jurisprudence (decisions from 1978–1980). It identified a settled legal position: when a dismissal is declared void or illegal, reinstatement with continuity of service ordinarily follows and, as a rule, an award of full back wages should accompany such reinstatement. The Court described an illegal termination as non est — as if it had never been made — and therefore reasoned that back wages logically flow from a declaration that the termination was void.

The Court acknowledged that the "normal rule" admitting back wages is subject to exception in truly exceptional circumstances (for example, closure of the industry, or the workman having secured better employment). However, the Court emphasized that the burden of proving such exceptional circumstances lies squarely on the employer/management. The management must specifically plead and produce material evidence to establish that the normal rule should not be followed.

Applying these principles to the present case, the Court held that the Labour Court was not justified in refusing back wages on the sole ground that the workman had not produced independent material showing unemployment. The High Court observed that the workman had specifically prayed for reinstatement with full back wages, and in evidence had stated he was unemployed since termination. In contrast, the management did not plead or prove that the workman had been gainfully employed during the period of enforced idleness or any other exceptional circumstance that would justify departure from the normal rule.

The Court further addressed the management's later assertion that management functions had been transferred to a third party (Albion Mills Pvt. Ltd.), noting that such a transfer was not shown in the Labour Court award nor pleaded before that Court. Independently, the Court observed that even if such a transfer had occurred, the Labour Court's award would be binding on a transferee under the Industrial Disputes Act (referencing Sec. 18(3)(a) and (c) in the opinion).

The Court also engaged with the broader legal policy: labour law's emphasis on social security and the decline in applicability of nineteenth-century common law doctrines (such as mitigation of damages or refusal to specifically enforce personal service contracts) in this context. This policy consideration reinforced the textual authorities requiring back wages as the ordinary consequence of void dismissals.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The High Court modified the Labour Court's award and directed that the management of Asthetic Exports Pvt. Ltd. and M/s. Albion Metal Pvt. Ltd. (respondents 1 and 3) pay full back wages to the workman from 21-12-1978 to 7-8-1982. The Labour Court's reinstatement order with continuity of service was left intact. The respondents were also directed to pay Rs. 300 as costs.

Implications:

  • The decision applies and reinforces the line of Supreme Court authority that an illegal dismissal is ordinarily to be treated as void and that reinstatement with full back wages is the normal remedy.
  • The opinion places the burden on the employer to plead and prove exceptional circumstances (including any claim that the workman was gainfully employed during the period of enforced idleness) if it seeks to avoid awarding back wages.
  • The Court expressly stated that prior decisions taking an opposite view (notably Krishan Murari Lal Kapur, Daily Tej Pvt. Ltd., and Malik Dairy Farms) are no longer good law in light of the Supreme Court authorities cited; the decision therefore aligns the High Court with the prevailing Supreme Court position rather than establishing a novel precedent.
  • If a transfer of management or establishment is alleged after the fact, such a transfer must be pleaded and proved; notwithstanding such a transfer, awards under the Industrial Disputes Act bind transferees as provided in the statute (as noted in the opinion).

Show all summary ...

A.B Rohatgi, J.:— The question of award of backwages has been troubling the courts and the legislature. In what cases backwages must be awarded to the workman who is ordered by the Tribunal to be reinstated in service.

2. George Orwell once wrote, “How right the working classes are to realise that the belly comes before the soul not in the scale of values but in point of time.” One of the most important facts about life is that human beings cannot get on without food, clothing, and shelter. Most modern men regard it as the most important fact of all, and spend most of the waking hours of a brief lifetime in trying to deal with it.

3. These are the facts. The petitioner Sunder Dass was employed by the management of M/s. Asthetic Exports Pvt. Ltd., respondent No. 1, as a machine man in their factory in printing section with effect from 16-10-1978 on a consolidated salary of Rs. 1100/- per month as a permanent employee. Previously he was working in another factory. He left that service and joined Asthetic Exports Pvt. Ltd. As he was asked by this management to leave the previous concern and to join them they also gave Rs. 3000/- as an advance and Rs. 850/- as ex gratia payment to avoid loss caused to him by leaving his earlier employment.

4. The petitioner worked with the management hardly for 2 months. From 21-12-1978 he was not allowed to enter the factory and join duty without issuing any written order of termination of service.

5. The petitioner raised an industrial dispute about his illegal termination of services. The labour court by order dated 7-8-1982 found that the dismissal of the workman was illegal. Without following the procedure of law the management dismissed him. For this course there was no justification in the view of the labour court. The workman was appointed on a permanent basis. He was simply asked to go away. The labour court thought that this was in defiance of the procedure prescribed by law. It came to the conclusion that the workman was entitled to reinstatement with continuity of service.

6. On the question of back wages the labour court took the view that he was not entitled to back wages because he had not placed any material on record to substantiate his claim. Following the decision in Krishan Murari Lal Kapur v. Zodiac Press, 1976 (33) F.L.R 76 decided by H.L Anand, J., it held that the workman was bound to produce sufficient material to show that alter termination of service he remained unemployed and was not able to earn anything. In its opinion the petitioner had filed to make out a case for back wages. So no back wages were awarded. Only reinstatement was ordered.

7. The workman has brought this writ petition under Art. 226 questioning the validity of the Labour Court's refusal to award him back wages. In his petition of claim dated 18-8-1979 the workman prayed to the tribunal that the illegal termination be set aside and the management be directed to reinstate him with full back wages and continuity in service. In paragraph 6 also he said much the same thing. In the reply of the management nothing has been said why the workman was not entitled to back wages. All that was said was that the labour court may kindly reject the “false claim”. When the stage of evidence arrived the workman appeared as his own witness on 23-9-81. In cross-examination the management put a question to him. To this he gave this answer: “Since the date my services were terminated I am unemployed.”

8. The question for decision is: Will it be right to refuse back wages to the workman where it is held that the termination is illegal and that he is entitled to reinstatement with continuity of service? In support of its view the labour court has solely relied on Krishan Murari Lal Kapur (supra).

9. In view of the recent decisions of the Supreme Court in G.T Lad v. Chemicals and Fibres India Ltd., AIR 1979 S.C 582, Hindustan Tin Works v. Its employees, AIR 1979 S.C 75, Gujarat Steel Tubes Ltd. v. Its Mazdoor Sabha, 1980 Lab. I.C 1004 (S.C) and Surendra Kumar v. Industrial Tribunal cum-Labour Court, 1980 1 Lab. I.C 1292 (S.C) the legal position admits of no doubt. The setting aside of an order terminating the services of a workman must ordinarily, as a matter of course, lead to the reinstatement of the Workman. An illegal order of termination is non est. A void dismissal is just void and does not exist. (See Gujarat Steel Tubes Ltd. (supra) at P. 1041). It is as if the order had never been made. The award of full back wages must therefore follow once the order of termination is declared to be void. This is the normal rule. Ordinarily this normal rule must not be departed from. But there may be exceptional circumstances which make it impossible or wholly inequitable vis-a-vis the employer and the Workman to direct reinstatement with full back wages. For instance the industry might have closed down or might be in severe doldrums; the Workman concerned might have secured better or other exceptional cases the court may mould the relief but ordinarily the relief to be awarded must reinstatement with full back wages. (See Surendra Kumar Verma v. Central Government Industrial Tribunal-Cum-Labour Court, New Delhi, 1980 Lab I.C 1292).

10. The burden of proving that the normal rule should be departed from because the case is an exceptional one lies on the management. Special circumstances most be pleased specifically by the management and should be proved by producing the necessary material in this behalf.

11. Hindustan Tin Works v. Its employees (supra) is the locus classious on the subject. In an eloquent passage D.A Desai J. at P. 77 said:

“The spectre of common law doctrine that contract of personal service cannot be specifically enforced or the doctrine of mitigation of damages does not haunt in this branch of law. The relief of reinstatement with continuity of service can be granted where termination of services found to be invalid. It would mean that the employer has taken away illegally the right to work of the workman contrary to the relevant law or in breach of contract and simultaneously deprived the workman of his earnings, if thus the employer is found to be in the wrong as a result of which the workman is directed to be reinstated, the employer could not shirk his responsibility of paying the wages which the workman has been deprived of by the illegal or invalid action of the employer Speaking realistically where termination of service is questioned as invalid or illegal and the workman has to go through the gamut of litigation, his capacity to sustain himself throughout the protracted litigation is itself such an awesome factor that he may not survive to see the day when relief is granted. More “so in our system where the law's proverbial delay has become stupifying. If after such a protracted time and energy consuming litigation raring which period the workman just sustains himself, ultimately he is to be told that though he will be reinstated, he will be denied the back wages which would be due to him, the workman would be subjected to a sort of penalty for no fault of his and it is wholly undeserved. Ordinarily, therefore a workman whose service has been illegally terminated would be entitled to full back wages except to the extent he was gainfully employed during the enforced idleness. That is the normal rule. Any other view would be premium on the unwarranted litigative activity of the employer.”

12. Following the decisions of the Supreme Court a division Bench of Rajindar Sachar and ML Jain JJ. of this Court in Management, Delhi Transport Corpn. v. Ram Kumar, 1982 Lab. I.G 1378 has held that it is for the employer to establish and prove that the workman was gainfully employed during enforced idleness. No presumption of being gainfully employed can be raised. The same is the view of a division bench of Orissa High Court in Suresh Chandra v. State of Orissa, 1982 Lab I.C 748.

13. Applying the principles laid down by the Supreme Court to the present case I do not think the labour court justified in refusing to award back wages to the Workman.

14. Mr. Munjal on behalf of the Management has tried to support the view of the labour court. He has referred me to Daily Tej Private Ltd. v. Lt. Governor, Delhi, 1979 (39) F.L.R 302 and Malik Dairy Farms v. Its Workers' Union' Union, 1968 (2) L.L.J 523 in support of his submission that back-wages were rightly refused to the workman on the ground that he had failed to produce any material on the record to substantiate his claim. The first decision cited by Mr. Munjal is a decision of S.S Chadha J. Chadha J. relied on Krishan Murari Lal (supra). In Krishan Murari Lal Kapur at P. 79 H.L Anand J. had said:

“Now it is well settled that the claim of back wages would not succeed merely because the termination or dismissal is set aside. The aggrieved workman would still be bound to make out a case for award of back wages by producing sufficient material which may show that during the period of his forced unemployment by the management he had remained unemployed or partly employed or was otherwise not able to earn what his employment, if subsisting with the management, would have entitled him to.”

15. In the light of the latest decisions of the Supreme Court the view taken in Krishan Murari Lal cannot be said to be good law any longer. Anand J. decided Krishan Murari Lal in 1976. The decisions of the Supreme Court rendered between 1978 and 1980 establish that the normal rule is to award back wages whenever the court orders reinstatement. This normal rule can be departed from only in exceptional cases. So it was enough for the workman in the present case to make a prayer of reinstatement with full back wages which he did. It was for the management to show that this normal rule should not be followed and departure should be made therefrom because there were exceptional circumstances requiring a departure. This the Management had to plead and to prove. This they failed to do. It was not for the workman to say anything more than what he averred in the writ petition. In evidence it was established that he remained unemployed after the termination of his services. What more is required of him. The burden was fairly and squarely on the shoulders of the management to prove that back wages should not be awarded to the workman. The view that it is for the workman to make out a case for award of back wages by producing sufficient material on record is now absolete. Hindustan Tin Works and Gujarat Steel Tubes Ltd. (supra) decively reject that view.

16. The ideas of nineteenth century freedom of contract have lost their appeal today. Social security is the dominant note of labour law. Law has not stood still. The “felt necessities of the time” have compelled the courts and the legislature to abandon the doctrine of mitigation of damages which was the corner-stone of the common law. If a workman is able to keep his body and soul together somehow during retrenchment and reinstatement there is no good reason why he should be denied back wages which logically flow from the declaration of illegal termination of services.

17. It is my duty to follow the Supreme Court. I cannot follow Krishan Murari Lal Kapur decided by H.L Anand, J. or Daily Tej Pvt. Ltd. decided by S.S Chadha J. They are no longer good law.

18. As the division bench of this Court has said that it is for the employer to establish and prove that the workman was gainfully employed and therefore should not be awarded back wages or some other exceptional circumstances may be pleaded and proved by the employer so that the court exercises its discretion in favour of the management. The decision of the Bombay High Court in Malik Dairy Farm (supra) is no longer good law in view of the decision of the Supreme Court to which I have referred.

19. Mr. Munjal said that the powers and functions in respect of management of the printing factory in Mayapuri where the workman was employed have since been transferred by Asthetic Exports Pvt. Ltd. to Albion Mills Private Limited, respondent No. 3. This is stated to have been done on 7-7-1982. But there is nothing in the award to show this. Nor was it pleaded before the labour court. This has not been proved by any cogent evidence. But even if it is so, the award of the Labour Court would be binding on the parties to the industrial dispute as well as to the transferee of the establishment to which the dispute relates (See Sec. 18(3)(a) and (c) of the Industrial Disputes Act).

20. In the result I order the management of Asthetic Exports Pvt. Ltd. and M/s. Albion Metal Pvt. Ltd. respondents 1 and 3. to pay full back wages to the workman from 21-12-1978 to 7-8-1982. The award of the Labour Court is modified to this extent. The relief of reinstatement granted by it will stand. The respondents will also pay Rs. 300/- as costs.