Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Bishan v. The State .

Delhi High Court
Nov 11, 1983
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeals (Cr. A. 23/83 and Cr. A. 68/83) arise from convictions under Section 392 IPC with sentence enhanced by application of Section 397 IPC. The appellants were sentenced to rigorous imprisonment for seven years and appealed against conviction and sentence.

On 4-10-1981 at about 3:00 p.m., near a public latrine in Siibzi Mandi, the accused allegedly threatened Ram Sumer (PW 4) with knives and took his purse containing Rs. 73/- and two receipts. After the accused had gone about 20 paces, Ram Sumer raised an alarm; the public chased and apprehended the accused, recovered knives, and Ram Sumer recovered his purse from accused Bishan. The public had also given beatings to the accused. The police were informed by one Ganga Ram Pradhan. SI Om Prakash (PW 5) arrested the accused, who were described as smelling of liquor. Ram Sumer produced the purse, currency notes and receipts before the police; the accused were medically examined. Shiv Dayal (PW 1) corroborated Ram Sumer's version.

The accused denied the prosecution case: Bishan alleged that Ganga Ram Pradhan was inimical and had falsely implicated him; Lalla stated he had consumed liquor and was merely standing among spectators. The trial Judge accepted the testimony of the prosecution witnesses and held that the knives recovered were deadly weapons capable of attracting Section 397 IPC. On appeal, the primary question raised concerned whether the knives recovered could be characterized as deadly weapons to invoke Section 397 IPC; the appellate court reviewed the evidence and relevant authorities and altered sentence accordingly.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the knives recovered from the accused could be considered "deadly weapons" so as to attract the provisions of Section 397 IPC (and thereby justify the enhanced sentence imposed).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The appellants challenged the prosecution's case by pointing to the large number of bystanders at the scene and the fact that the police produced only the complainant and a sweeper (Shiv Dayal) while withholding other independent witnesses.
  • Bishan argued that Ganga Ram Pradhan was inimical to him and had falsely implicated him.
  • Lalla's case was that he had consumed liquor and was merely standing among the spectators, not participating in the robbery.
  • Counsel for the accused relied on Balik Ram v. The State (1983 (5) DRJ 12) to argue that knives are not deadly weapons per se and that whether a knife is deadly is a question of fact depending on design and manner of use.

Respondent / Prosecution's Arguments

  • The prosecution highlighted authorities holding that a knife may be a deadly weapon and relied on Phool Kumars. Delhi Administration, AIR 1975 SC 905, where the Supreme Court described a knife in hand as a deadly weapon capable of frightening or terrorizing victims.
  • The prosecution also relied on State of Himachal Pradesh v. Wazir Chand and others, AIR 1978 SC 315, where a knife was described as an indisputably dangerous weapon in the context of fatal injuries.
  • On this basis, the prosecution urged that the knives used by the appellants should be held to be deadly weapons for the purposes of Section 397 IPC.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Balik Ram v. The State, 1983 (5) DRJ 12 Knives are not deadly weapons per se; whether a knife is deadly depends on its design or the manner of its use and is a question of fact for prosecution to prove. The court relied on and adhered to this view, treating Balik Ram as supporting the proposition that the mere fact a knife was used does not automatically make it a deadly weapon; the court refused to depart from this view.
Phool Kumars. Delhi Administration, AIR 1975 SC 905 Described a person "armed with a knife" as carrying a deadly weapon open to victims' view and sufficient to frighten or terrorize them. The court distinguished this authority, noting that Phool Kumar did not discuss the design of the knife and that the question before the Supreme Court there was interpretation of "use" of the weapon; the appellate court did not construe it as overruling the principle in Balik Ram.
State of Himachal Pradesh v. Wazir Chand and others, AIR 1978 SC 315 Observed that a knife can be a dangerous weapon; in that case the manner of use produced fatal injuries and the weapon was described as dangerous. The court noted this case related to Section 304 Part I IPC and that the dangerous character there was established by the manner of use and resultant fatal injury; it did not displace the Balik Ram principle for Section 397 analysis.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court accepted the testimony of the complainant (Ram Sumer), the corroborating witness (Shiv Dayal), and the police officers regarding sequence of events, arrest and recovery. The appellate court identified the central legal question to be whether the recovered knives were "deadly weapons" for application of Section 397 IPC.

The court considered precedent and legal principles:

  • It recalled the statement in Balik Ram that knives are not deadly per se; their status depends on design or manner of use and is a question of fact for the prosecution to establish.
  • The court examined the prosecution authorities relied upon: Phool Kumars (AIR 1975 SC 905) — where the Supreme Court described a knife in hand as a deadly weapon in the context of "use" and fear caused — and State of Himachal Pradesh v. Wazir Chand (AIR 1978 SC 315) — a Section 304 Part I case where the knife's dangerousness was demonstrated by the fatal injuries inflicted.
  • The court distinguished those decisions from the present case, observing that Phool Kumar did not address design and that Wazir Chand involved fatal injuries demonstrating deadly use; neither compelled departure from Balik Ram's fact-sensitive approach under Section 397.
  • The court relied on the recovery memo which described the knives as meant for cutting vegetables; the blades measured 6" and 3½". The court concluded that the knives, by design, were for cutting vegetables and that their manner of use in this occurrence was not such as was likely to cause death.
  • On that basis, the court held the prosecution had not proved that the knives were "deadly weapons" within the meaning contemplated for invoking Section 397 IPC.

Holding and Implications

The appeals were partly allowed.

Holding:

  • The convictions under Section 392 IPC were maintained.
  • The court concluded the knives recovered were not deadly weapons for the purposes of Section 397 IPC and therefore the sentence enhanced under Section 397 could not be sustained; accordingly, the sentence was reduced from rigorous imprisonment for seven years to four years.

Implications:

The direct effect is a reduction of the appellants' sentences from seven years' rigorous imprisonment to four years while leaving the convictions under Section 392 intact. The opinion applies and follows the fact-sensitive principle that whether a knife is a "deadly weapon" depends on design and manner of use; the court did not announce a new legal principle beyond its application of existing authorities.

Show all summary ...

M.L Jain, J.:— This judgment will dispose of Cr. A. 23/83 and Cr. A. 68/83. The appellants were convicted under Sec. 392 and sentenced with the aid of Sec. 397 IPC to rigorous imprisonment for seven years. Hence, these appeals.

2. On 4-10-1981 at about 3.00 p.m the accused appellants threatened Ram Sumer (PW 4) near the public latrine in Siibzi Mandi with knives and relieved him of a purse which contained Rs. 73/- and two receipts. When accused had gone about 20 paces, Ram Sumer raised an alarm. The public chased the accused, apprehended them and recovered knives. Ram Sumer snatched his purse from accused Bishan. The public had also given beatings to the accused persons. In the meanwhile, the police had been informed by one Ganga Ram Pradhan. SI Om Prakash (PW 5) came and arrested the accused who were smelling of liquor. Ram Sumer produced before him the purse, currency notes and receipts. He also got the accused examined by a medical officer. Shiv Dayal (PW 1) corroborated the version of Ram Sumer.

3. The case of the accused Bishan is that Ganga Ram Pradhan was inimical to Bishan and he falsely implicated him. The ace of Lalla accused is that he had consumed some liquor and was standing amongst the spectators.

4. It was pointed out that the police claimed that there was on the spot a large number of people but the police produced only the complainant and sweeper Shiv Dayal, while other independent witnesses were available. It is also in evidence that the accused persons were drunk and were falsely implicated. Ganga Ram who is said to be inimical to Bishan and as whose instance the accused were implicated was also present there, but the police withhold him. It was urged that the prosecution case was false. The learned trial Judge was, however, of the view that Shiv Dayal is a resident of the same place and had come to use the public latrine when the occurrence took place and had seen Bishan snatching the purse from Ram Sarup and then running away. The learned Judge believed the story put forward by Ram Sumer and Shiv Dayal. It was urged before him that the knives recovered in the case are meant for cutting vegetables and they were not deadly weapons. The learned Judge observed that the knives were no doubt meant for cutting vegetables, but they could be used as a weapon of offence and if they are so used they were capable of causing death and penetration of blade of such a knife in the vital organ could be fatal. He, therefore, held that the knives that were recovered were deadly weapons.

5. As far as the merits of the case are concerned, the learned counsel for the appellants did not have much to say. Indeed, I see no reason to disbelieve the testimony of Ram Sumer and Shiv Dayal and the police officers as to the sequence of arrest and recovery made by the police in the aforesaid manner. The sole question that was earnestly urged before me was whether the weapons recovered could be considered deadly weapons so as to attract the provisions of Sec. 397 IPC. According to the recovery memo, the knives that were recovered from both the accused were knives meant for cutting vegetables, though the blade of one was 6″ long and of the other was 3½′ long. Can such weapons be described as deadly weapons?

6. The learned counsel for the accused cited Balik Ram v. The State, 1983 (5) DRJ 12. In that decision; I have observed as follows:

“Knives are weapons available in various sizes and may just cause little hurt or may be the deadliest. They are not deadly weapons per se such as would ordinarily result in death by their use. What would make a knife deadly is its design or the manner of its use such as is calculated to or is likely to produce death. It is, therefore, a question of fact to be proved and prosecution should prove that the knife used by the accused was a deadly one.”

The learned Addl. Public Prosecutor Shri D.R Sethi, on the other hand, drew my attention to Phool Kumars. Delhi Administration, AIR 1975 SC 905, para 5. It was observed therein as follows:

“So far as he is concerned he is said to be armed with a knife which is also a deadly weapon. To be more precise, from the evidence of PW 16 Phool Kumar had a knife in his hand’. He was, therefore, carrying a deadly weapon open to the view of the victims sufficient to frighten or terrorize them.”

It was pointed out that nothing was said in this case on the design of the knife and yet the Supreme Court held that the knife is a deadly weapon. Another decision; on which Mr. Sethi relies is State of Himachal Pradesh v. Wazir Chand and others, AIR 1978 SC 315, in para 25 whereof it was observed that the accused has wielded a weapon like a knife, indisputably a dangerous weapon. On the basis of these observations, Mr. Sethi urged that the knife is indisputably a dangerous weapon and, therefore, it should be held that the knives which the appellants used in this case should be held to be deadly weapons. The cases on which Mr. Sethi relies do not in any way run counter to the view that I have adopted in Balik Ram (supra). In Phool Kumar (supra) the question turned upon the interpretation of use’ of the weapon and who actually used the weapon. Nobody raised the question whether the knife recovered was a deadly one or not. But ‘I should presume that it was of a design which was likely to cause death. The other case Wazir Chand (supra) was a case under Sec. 304 Part I IPC and not a case under Sec 397 IPC dealing with a deadly weapon as such. Yet, what was said was that a knife is a dangerous weapon. In that case the accused had caused with it four injuries out of which one in the chest was fatal. We do not know about its design but the manner of use was certainly deadly. I, therefore, do not see any reason to depart from the view I have taken in Balik Ram (supra). It is proved in this case from the recovery memo itself that the knives were designed for cutting vegetables and could not be considered to be deadly. Their manner of use was also not such as was likely to cause death. I am, therefore, unable to agree that the accused can be sentenced under Sec. 397 IPC. In the interests of justice, I think the sentence of four years will meet the ends of justice for an offence under Sec. 392 IPC.

7. Accordingly, I partly accept these appeals. While maintaining the convictions under Sec. 392 IPC, I reduce the sentences of the appellants from rigorous imprisonment for seven years to four years.