- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Smt. Shanti Devi v. State & Ors.
Factual and Procedural Background
Shri Gopal Singh, a retired High Court judge and bachelor with no issue, founded the Gopal Singh Trust through a deed executed on 11.10.1973, later modified in 1975. The trust aimed to promote charitable objectives including health, education, upliftment of backward and poverty-stricken people, and international goodwill. The founder relinquished all personal interest in his properties, dedicating them to the trust's charitable purposes. He was the sole trustee during his lifetime, entitled to remuneration, and intended to appoint trustees after his death.
At the time of execution, a building at 10, Niti Bagh, New Delhi was under construction to serve partly as the trust's office and partly for letting. Shri Gopal Singh died on 15.9.1977 without appointing any trustees or constituting a Board of Trustees, as contemplated in the trust deed. Subsequently, a dispute arose over possession of the trust properties among his relatives.
On 1.6.1978, Shanti Devi (claiming to be the adopted daughter and legal representative of the founder) and her father Sant Singh applied under section 34 of the Indian Trusts Act 1882 for the district judge's opinion and directions regarding trust administration and leasing of 10 Niti Bagh. They claimed to be trustees and sought court directions for leasing the property.
The application was opposed by other family members and the Niti Bagh Welfare Association. During proceedings, multiple parties offered to rent the premises. Shanti Devi and Sant Singh sought to withdraw their application on 5.8.1981, alleging a settlement, but the district judge refused the withdrawal on 11.8.1981 and made interim orders regarding licensing parts of the property to certain advocates. Shanti Devi and Sant Singh challenged this refusal by filing a revision petition, which was eventually heard by a larger bench due to the importance of the issues and absence of precedent.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether section 34 of the Indian Trusts Act 1882 applies to the Gopal Singh Trust, which is a public charitable trust.
- Whether Shanti Devi, claiming to be the adopted daughter and legal representative of the founder, has any legal standing to act as trustee or seek court directions under section 34 of the Act.
- The proper legal framework and court jurisdiction for administration and management of a public charitable trust when no trustees have been appointed.
- The validity of the application under section 34 of the Act and the appropriate remedy for administration of the trust.
Arguments of the Parties
Shanti Devi and Sant Singh's Arguments
- Shanti Devi claimed to have been adopted by Shri Gopal Singh and asserted herself as his legal representative and sole heir.
- They claimed to be trustees of the Gopal Singh Trust and appointed Sant Singh as managing trustee, relying on section 73 of the Indian Trusts Act 1882.
- They sought the court's opinion and directions under section 34 of the Act for proper administration and leasing of the trust property at 10 Niti Bagh.
- They applied to withdraw their petition after an alleged settlement with opposing parties.
Opposing Parties' Arguments
- Amir Singh, Hans Raj, and the Niti Bagh Welfare Association opposed the application and the withdrawal.
- Other parties, including advocates who offered to rent the premises, contested Shanti Devi and Sant Singh’s claims and sought court orders for licensing the property.
- The district judge refused the withdrawal of the petition and proceeded to license parts of the property to other parties.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Deoki Nandan v. Murlidhar, (1956) SCR 756/759 | Distinction between private and public trusts: beneficiaries in private trusts are definite individuals; in public trusts, beneficiaries are an uncertain and fluctuating body. | Affirmed that Gopal Singh Trust is a public charitable trust excluded from the Indian Trusts Act 1882. |
| Gopu Kalandavelu Chetty v. Semi Royer, ILR 28 Madras 517 at 520 | Section 73 of the Indian Trusts Act applies only to private trusts and not to charitable trusts. | Rejected Shanti Devi’s reliance on section 73 for appointing herself as trustee. |
| Budres Das Mukim v. C L. Jehurry, ILR 33 Calcutta 789 (806) | Definition and liability of a trustee de son tort (a person acting as trustee without title). | Held Shanti Devi to be a trustee de son tort and not entitled to court advice under section 34. |
| Ramdas Bhagat v. Krishna Prasad, AIR 1940 Patna 425 at 429 | Court’s power under section 92, G.P.C to remove trustee de son tort and appoint new trustees for charitable trusts. | Supported the court’s jurisdiction to appoint trustees and administer the charitable trust under section 92, G.P.C. |
| Sudree Das v. Chunni Lal | Court’s authority to supervise execution of trust deed and give directions for administration of charitable trusts. | Emphasized that the court can intervene to administer the trust despite absence of trustees. |
| Wormley v. Wormley, 21 U.S 421 at 463 (1623) | Fiduciary duty of trustees not to profit from trust and the nature of trustee responsibilities. | Illustrated the fiduciary principles applicable to trustees generally. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court began by distinguishing between private trusts, governed by the Indian Trusts Act 1882, and public charitable trusts, which are excluded from the Act’s operation as per its preamble and section 1. The Gopal Singh Trust was held to be a public charitable trust, created for the benefit of an uncertain and fluctuating body of persons, thus falling outside the scope of the Indian Trusts Act.
The court noted that Shanti Devi’s claim to be the legal representative and trustee was baseless, given the express provisions in the trust deed excluding heirs from claims and the inapplicability of section 73 of the Act to charitable trusts. Her self-appointment as trustee was characterized as that of a trustee de son tort, who cannot seek court advice under section 34.
Section 34 of the Indian Trusts Act was deemed inapplicable to the trust in question. Instead, the court relied on section 92 of the Code of Civil Procedure (C.P.C), which provides the appropriate remedy for public charitable trusts, including the power to settle schemes, appoint trustees, and authorize management of trust property.
The court emphasized that the absence of appointed trustees does not invalidate a trust and that courts of equity have inherent jurisdiction to enforce trusts by appointing trustees and supervising administration. The application under section 34 was thus misconceived and non-maintainable.
Lastly, the court noted the interim arrangement regarding the trust’s bank account and expressed the need for proper legal proceedings to administer the trust.
Holding and Implications
The court allowed the revision petition and held that the application under section 34 of the Indian Trusts Act 1882 was incompetent and not maintainable.
The direct effect of this decision is the dismissal of the application filed by Shanti Devi and Sant Singh seeking directions under section 34 for trust administration. The court clarified that public charitable trusts are governed by section 92 of the C.P.C, which provides the proper legal framework for administration and appointment of trustees in such cases. No costs were awarded.
No new precedent was established beyond reaffirming the exclusion of public charitable trusts from the Indian Trusts Act and the applicability of section 92 C.P.C for their administration.
Avadh Behari Rohatgi, J.:— Shri Gopal Singh was a retired judge of the High Court for the States of Punjab and Haryana. He was a bachelor. He had no issue. He founded a charitable trust called Gopal Singh Trust. He executed a deed of trust on 11.10.1973 which was subsequently altered in some respects by another trust deed dated 30.6.75 The deed recites that the trust is created “with a view to promote charitable objects such as health and medical facilities education & training of boys and girls and adults for acquisition of knowledge and development of character so as to make them healthy and educated citizens, for amelieration and uplift of backward and poverty-stricken people of India, for international good will and understanding and for bettering the lot of women and children.”
The founder divested himself of and relinquished all interest in his properties, investments and assets and directed that these shall be devoted to the objects of the trust. The objects of the trust, stated shortly, are to set up dispensaries, hospitals, to run educational institutions and boarding houses, to impart good education to students, to improve the lot of weaker sections of society, to promote international understanding and goodwill elimination of war and preservation of peace, to set up homes for the aged and infirm, destitutes, widows and orphans. These are all purposes beneficial to the public. Social advantage is their main characteristic. They are secular, humanitarian, educational and international in nature. The main idea of the settler was that the trust should provide some of the indispensables of a settled community. So wide ranging are the objects of the trust, so varied is the settler's menu.
The trust deed provides that the founder shall be the administrator and manager of the trust and will be remunerated with Rs. 1600/- per month. After his death the trust shall be managed by a trustee or trustees as may be declared by him. So Shri Gopal Singh was the sole trustee in his life time.
At the time the trust deed was executed the founder was constructing a building in Niti Bagh, a lawyers' colony where he had been allotted a plot by the Niti Bagh Cooperative Society. This was House No. 10, Niti Bagh, New Delhi. The trust deed provides that “such portion of the building at 10, Niti Bagh, when completed, may be used for office of the trust and for carrying out its purposes and objects as the sole trustee or the trustees deem it necessary. Its remaining portion be let out.”
Shri Gopal Singh died on 15.9.1977 He did not appoint any trustees as was contemplated by him in the deed of trust. The deed provides for the constitution of a Board of Trustees. Clause 5 says:
“If in case of appointment of Board of Trustees, any one of the trustees retires, resigns, dies, neglectful or wanting in capacity to act as a trustee, the appointment of that trustee shall be by the remaining trustee or trustees. In a meeting of the Board of Trustees, when so appointed, simple majority decisions by the Board will be effective on any question arising in the management of the affairs of the Trust,
But the founder did not appoint any trustee, as we have said. Nor did he constitute any board of trustees. Shri Gopal Singh had two brothers, Sant Singh & Lal Singh. Sant Singh has a daughter Shanti Devi. Lal Singh is dead. He has left behind two sons—Amir Singh & Hans Raj. On the death of Shri Gopal Singh there was a scramble for possession of trust properties.
On 1.6.1978 Shanti Devi and her father Sant Singh made an application under section 34 of the Indian Trusts Act 1882 (the Act) to the district judge seeking his opinion, advice and direction for the due administration of the trust properties of Gopal Singh Trust. In the application Shanti Devi alleged that the founder bad adopted her, who was misplace, as his daughter. She claimed to be the only heir and legal representative of the founder of the trust. She also claimed that she was the do facte trustee of Gopal Singh Trust. She declared herself as a trustee and appointed her father, Sant Singh, as a managing trustee. This appointment of herself as trustee and her father as managing trustee was alleged to have been made by Shanti Devi in the purported “exercise of her powers confeired by section 73 of the Indian Trusts Act 1882.”
Shanti Devi and Sant Singh alleged that they were vitally interested in the proper management and control of Gopal Singh Trust and with a view to administer the trust property and also for their own protection they seek the opinion, advice and direction of the court for the purpose of leasing out 10 Niti Bagh, the building constructed by Shri Gopal Singh. They prayed that “apprepriate advice and/or direction in the matter of management and administration of trust property of Gopal Singh Trust, in particular 10 Niti Bagh, New Delhi in relation to leasing out the said property in whole or in part and the maintenance of library housed in the said property be made and the said property be directed to be given on lease or licence on such rent or licence fee as may be best available, by the petitioner”.
This applicatian was opposed by Amir Singh and Hans Raj sons of Shri Lal Chand, and the Niti Bagh Welfare Association. During the pendency of the case, two advocates of this court, Shri J. Mahajan and Shri Satya Dev Sharma, made applications to the court that 10 Niti Bagh or part thereof may be let out to them and that they were prepared to pay such rent as may be considered reasonable by the court. Subsequently, a third application was made by M/s Universal Commercial Corporation for premises being given to them on rent and they offered to pay Rs. 14,000/- per month. Yet a fourth offer came from another party for taking the premises on a rent of Rs. 17,000/- per month.
When these offers were before the court Shanti Devi and Sant Singh made an application on 5.8.81 under O. 23 rule 1 C.P.C that they wanted to withdraw their application as a settlement had been reached between them on the one hand and Amir Singh & Hans Raj on the other. This application for withdrawal of the case was resisted by all parties except Amir Singh & Hans Raj.
On this application the question arose before the district judge whether he should allow Shanti Devi & Sant Singh to withdraw the main petition under section 34 of the Act. This application was strenuously contested by Mr. Sharma. Mr. Mahajan, Niti Bagh Welfare Association and other contenders for renting the house. The learned district judge by order dated 11.8.81 held that he could not allow the petition to be withdrawn & refused the application under O. 23 rule 1 C P.C As regards the rival claims of the parties for premises being given on rent to them, he ordered that the first floor of 10 Niti Bagh be given to Mr. J. Mahajan on a licence fee of Rs. 3000/- per month. The second and the top barsati floors, he said, be given to Mr. Satya Dev Sharma as a licensee on a licensee fee of Rs. 3000/- per month. Since the premises had already been given to another party by Shanti Devi & Sant Singh, the district judge ordered that possession be given to Mr. J. Mahajan and Mr. S.D Sharma immediately. From the order of the district judge this revision petition has been brought by Shanti Devi & Sant Singh.
The matter in the first instance came before Charanjit Talwar J. The learned judge thought that in view of the importance of the question involved and in view of the fact that there is no case law on the point the matter should be heard by a larger bench. This is how the case has come to us for decision.
We would emphasis what has often been overlooked that the Indian Trusts Act of 1882 does not apply to public trusts and charitable trusts. As the preamble of the Act states it is “an act to define & amend the law relating to private trusts & trustee.” Section 1 of the Act says that nothing herein cantained “applies to public or private, religious or charitable endowments”. Therefore, all charitable trusts are excluded from the operation of the Act. Admittedly, Shri Gopal Singh founded “an express trust for public purposes of a charitable nature”, to use the language of section 92, C.P.C The object of the trust clearly show that it is a charitable turst. All charitable trusts are public trusts. Public trusts and charitable trusts are synonymous expression. They are essentially different from private trusts in that the beneficiaries are uncertain. A1 charitable trusts are for the benefit of the public and they are enforceable by the Advocate General suing on behalf of the public or more persons having an interest in the trust with the leave of the court. Sec. 92 is the special remedy for “public charities”. In the case of a breach of trustor where the direction of the court is necessary for the administration of a public charity a suit can be instituted in the court of the district judge for one or more of the reliefs mentioned in the section.
The Act applies to private trusts only. The most fundamental distinction between private & public trusts depends upon the character of the proson for whose benefit they are created. The essential difference between a private and public trust that in the former the beneficiaries are defined and ascertained individuals who within a definite time can be definitely ascertained but in the latter he beneficial interest must be vested in an uncartain and fluctuating body of persons eithar the public at large or some considerable portion of it answering particular description.
In Deoki Nandan v. Murlidhar, (1956) Supreme Court Repotrs 756/759 it was observed by the Supreme Court:
“The distinction a private and Public trust is that whereas in the former the beneficiaries are specific individuals, in the latter they are the general public or a class thereof. While in the former the beneficiaries are persons who are ascertained or capable of being ascertained, in the latter they constitute a body which is incapable of ascertained on the latter they constitute a body which to incapable of ascertainment”.
“The following statement of law in Lawin on Trust, Fifteenth Edition, pp. 15, 16 was approved:
“By public must be understood such as are constituted for the benefit either of the public at large or of some considerable portion of it answering a particular description. To this class belong all trusts for charitable purpeses, and indeed public trusts and charitable trusts may be considered in general as synonymous expression. In private trusts beneficial interest is vested absolutely in one or more individuals who are, or within certain time may be, definitely ascertained.
A public or charitable trust has for its objects the members of an uncertain and flucturting body. Such a trust is permanent and indefinite in character and is not confined within the limits prescribed to a settlement upon a private trust. (Lawin 16th ed. p. 7). A charity once established can never fail: a charity once established does not die, though its nature may be changed. If by a change in social habits and needs or by a change in law, the purpose of an established charity becomes superfluous or illegal, or otherwise cases to be beneficial to the community, it is the duty of the trustees to apply to the court for a cyprcs scheme. (Halsbury 3rd ed. vol. 4 p. 209. See also 4th ed. vol. 5 page 310).
Private trusts are clearly distinguishable from public trusts. It is important to distinguish cases of charitable endowments from those of private trusts and to remember that the Act of 1882 is confined only to private trusts other than religious or charitable endowments. This distinction of capital importance has been overlooked in this case. The proceedings have dragged on and no one brought it to the notice of the learned judge that the application under section 34 of the Act was not maintainable because Shri Gopal Singh created not a private trust but a public charitable trust. Public charitable trusts are outside the scope of the Act. The application ought to have been dismissed on this short ground.
There is one other point, Shanti Davi Claims that she was adopted by Shri Gopal Singh and that as a legal representative of the settler she is entitled to act as a trustee. She says that she is the successor in office on whom the trust property has devolved. This is the foundation of her claim This claim is baseless. In the trust deed the founder declared that he was a bachelor and had no issue. To his properties, investments and assets which were settled on trust, he declared in the trust deed that, none of his heirs-in-interest shall be entitled to raise any claim thereto”. Shanti Devi is not legal representative of the founder in view of the express provision in the trust deed. Nor can she found her claim on section 73 of the Act which applies to private trusts. Section 73 of the Act does not extend to charitable trusts. (See Gopu Kalandavelu Chetty v. Semi Royer, ILR 28 Madras 517 at page 520).
In our opinion, no application can be made under section 34 of the case of a charitable trust such as was created by Shri Gopal Singh. Shanti Devi has no right “to seek opinion, advice or direction of the court” under section 34 because she is not a trustee appointed under the trust deed. She has appointed herself as the trustee on the specious ground that she is the legal representative of the deceased founder. In respect of a charitable trust no one can appoint himself or herself as a trustee in the manner Shanti Devi has done unless the trust deed so provides. Under section 92, C.P.C the court can settle a scheme, appoint new trustee, authorise the whole or any part of the trust property to be let, sold, mortgaged or exchanged. Under section 34 of the Act the court will not give opinion, advice and direction in the case of a charitable trust to a person who cannot be better described than as a trustee de son tort. Courts do not give advice to intermeddlers, efficious bystanders or self-styled trustees. Shanti Devi is doing all that the claims wrongly and without any title. “A person who without title, chooses to take upon himself the character of a trustee becomes a trustee de son tort. He is liable to account for what he has done or what he has received while so acting and cannot be heard to say that he had no right to act as trustee. Budres Das Mukim v. C L. Jehurry, ILR 33 Calcutta 789 (806) per Woodreffe. J. See Mukharjec. ‘Hindu Law of Religious and Charitable Trust’ 4th ed. p. 471-472). A trustee de son tort cannot say to the court, “give me advice”.
The concept of trust posits a useful division between responsibility and benefit. The trustee is recognised as the owner at law. But on him is imposed the equitable duty of carrying out the terms of the trust. The beneficiaries are the equitable owners. Behind the ‘hedge of trustees’, to use Maitland's phrase, this division takes place. But no trustee can make a profit from his trust. To those who stand in a fiducisry position the only advice that can be given is the hallowed orison, ‘lead us not into temption’. (Wormley v. Wormley 21 U.S 421 at 463 (1623) per Johnson, J.).
That the settler did not appoint trustees has never prevented courts of equity from enforcing a trust. A trust will not fall for want of a trustee. This is the principle on which courts have acted. Under section 92 G.P.C the court can appoint new trustees for the administration of the trust what had made the trust so effecitve is the co-operation of the court may be asked to supervise the execution of the trust deed. If the directions of the court are necessary for the administration of the trust a suit can be brought under section 92, G.P.C The directions such as are necessary for carrying out the trust can be given to a trustee, either the existing trustee where is there one, or the new trustee, where one is to be appointed. (Sudree Das v. Chunni Lal supra at p. 899). In a sub under section 92 the court can remove a trustee de son tort and appoint a new trustee. (Ramdas Bhagat v. Krishna Prasad A.I.R 1940 Patna 425 at 429).
In our opinion the application under section 34 was misconceived and ought to have been dismissed in limine. section 92 G.P.C is the answer.
There is some money in the trust account in the bank. The parties have agreed before us that they will not operate the account for a month to enable proper proceedings to be brought for the administration of Gopal Singh Trust.
For these reasons we allow the revision petition and hold that the application under section 34 of the Act is incompetent and not maintainable and dismiss the same but without costs.
Alert