Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Addl. Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Delhi-Ii v. Vidya Prakash Talwar

Delhi High Court
Apr 30, 1981
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary — Ranganathan, J. (Income-tax Reference)

Factual and Procedural Background

The assessee, an individual, resided in a house property at 101, Darya Ganj, Delhi from 1957 until late 1964. On 1 December 1963 he entered into an agreement to sell that property to Shanti Devi and received Rs. 25,000 as earnest money; delivery of vacant possession could not be effected and that sale fell through. On 17 December 1963 the assessee purchased a plot in South Extension, New Delhi, and commenced construction of a residential house there in March 1964, expecting to move in when it was completed. Because Shanti Devi would not wait for completion (which occurred only in December 1964), that sale failed.

The Darya Ganj property was ultimately sold to S.P. Bhargava on 29 December 1964, realising a capital gain of Rs. 42,550. The assessee had shifted to the newly constructed house in South Extension on 28 December 1964 and lived there until 1 April 1965, when he leased out the ground floor to Bank of Baroda. He then continued construction (first floor and a barsati) and spent a total of Rs. 91,694 on that additional construction; Rs. 15,000 was incurred up to 31 December 1964 and the balance Rs. 76,694 was spent between January 1965 and November 1966. The ground floor and the added upper floors could be occupied independently; after 1 April 1965 the assessee occupied the first floor and barsati as his residence.

For income-tax purposes the assessee claimed exemption of the capital gain under section 54 of the Income-tax Act, 1961. The Income-tax Officer denied the exemption. The AAC and the Appellate Tribunal allowed the exemption. The Commissioner of Income-tax appealed, and the Commissioner sought a reference to this court asking whether the Tribunal was justified in exempting the Rs. 42,550 capital gain under section 54 notwithstanding that only a portion of the newly constructed South Extension property came to be occupied for the assessee's residence.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Tribunal was justified in exempting the capital gains of Rs. 42,550 from taxation under section 54 of the Income-tax Act, 1961, notwithstanding that only a portion of the newly constructed property in South Extension came to be occupied for the assessee's own residence? (This is the question as originally framed by the Commissioner.)
  2. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the assessee is entitled to the exemption of the capital gains of Rs. 42,550 under section 54 of the Act? (This is the slight reframing adopted by the court and answered by it.)

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
CIT v. Natu Hansraj, [1976] 105 ITR 43 (Guj) The decision explains the legislative object of section 54 (i.e., exemption where capital gains are reinvested in a new residential house used for assessee's residence). The court referred to this decision to elucidate the object and purpose of s. 54 and to support the interpretation that the section seeks to exempt capital gains when reinvested in qualifying residential property.
CIT v. Tikyomal Jasanmal, [1971] 82 ITR 95 (Guj) The case accepts that the expression "house property" covers a unit of house property (an independent residential unit) and is not confined to a single standalone house. The court relied on this authority to justify treating separately occupiable units (ground floor and upper floors) as independent residential units for the purposes of s. 54.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by noting that, although an interesting question arises, the matter is in ultimate analysis a question of fact and the Tribunal's factual conclusions should prevail. The court then read section 54 in full and emphasized the need to understand the section's main part along with its subsequent paragraphs that outline the extent of the exemption.

Two important considerations guided the court's analysis:

  1. The meaning of "house property" in s. 54 is to be understood as encompassing an independent residential unit (the same concept adopted under sections 22 to 27). The court observed that modern multi-storeyed flats mean that "house property" can include a unit which is independently occupiable. The court cited CIT v. Tikyomal Jasanmal for the acceptance of this principle.
  2. The court was concerned only with what the assessee constructed after the disposal (post-sale), and the sufficiency of such construction and investment within the statutory period to qualify for exemption. The ground floor (already constructed before the 29 December 1964 sale) was treated as anterior to the date of sale; the first floor and the barsati, though work began earlier, were completed within two years of the sale and constituted a separate independent residential unit.

Applying these considerations to the facts found by the Tribunal, the court observed:

  • The assessee realised a capital gain of Rs. 42,550 on 29 December 1964.
  • The assessee invested more than that capital gain (Rs. 76,694 invested between January 1965 and November 1966) in the construction of an independent residential unit (first floor and barsati) completed within two years after the date of sale.
  • That residential unit was admittedly used by the assessee for the purposes of his own residence.

Given these findings and the statutory language of s. 54, the court concluded that the statutory conditions for exemption were fulfilled. The court therefore affirmed the Tribunal's conclusion that the assessee was entitled to the exemption under s. 54. Because the matter turned on the facts as found by the Tribunal, the court accepted those factual findings and applied the legal test in s. 54 accordingly.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The reference is answered in the affirmative: the assessee is entitled to exemption of the capital gains of Rs. 42,550 under section 54 of the Income-tax Act, 1961.

Direct consequences and orders:

  • The court affirmed the Tribunal's allowance of the exemption under s. 54 on the facts of this case.
  • The Commissioner (who failed) was ordered to pay the costs of the assessee; counsel's fee awarded was Rs. 350.

Implications (as reflected within the opinion):

  • The court clarified that for the purposes of s. 54 a "house property" may include an independently occupiable residential unit (for example, an upper floor or a separate flat) and that such a unit may satisfy the statutory condition when it is constructed and used as the assessee's residence within the prescribed period.
  • The decision applies the statutory time-limits and investment tests of s. 54 strictly to the post-disposal construction and to the Tribunal's factual findings about the sufficiency of investment and use as residence.

The court's analysis and outcome are grounded in the facts as found by the Tribunal and the statutory language of section 54, as well as the interpretative support drawn from the cited Gujarat High Court authorities.

Show all summary ...

Ranganathan, J.:— Though a very interesting question arises in this income-tax reference, we think that in the ultimate analysis it is only a question of fact and the conclusion of the Tribunal should prevail. We may briefly state the facts.

2. The assessee, an individual, was residing in house property bearing 101, Darya Gan j, Delhi. He sold it eventually on December 29, 1964. It is common ground that the assessee had been residing in the above property from 1957 to 1964. On December 1, 1963, the assessee entered into an agreement of sale in respect of the property with one Shanti Devi and also received an earnest money of Rs. 25,000 from her. Under the terms of the agreement, the assessee had to deliver vacant possession of the said house to Shanti Devi. But this could not be done for reasons to be referred later and the sale fell through.

3. Soon after the agreement with Shanti Devi, i.e, on December 17, 1963, the assessee purchased a plot at South Extension in New Delhi. He also constructed a residential house on this plot commencing in March, 1964. Apparently he expected the house to be completed soon and he anticipated that he would be able to move into this house and deliver vacant possession of the Darya Ganj house to Shanti Devi. But Shanti Devi was not willing to wait until the house was completed which was only in December, 1964, and so the agreement with Shanti Devi fell through.

4. The assessee was, therefore, obliged to negotiate afresh for the sale of the property and it was eventually sold to one S.P Bhargava on December 29, 1964. It is common ground that on the sale of the property effected on December 29, 1964, a capital gain of Rs. 42,550 was realised by the assessee.

5. It has been accepted by the department that on 28th December, 1964, the assessee shifted his residence from Darya Ganj to the newly constructed house in South Extension. He lived in this house till April 1, 1965, on which date this portion of the house, namely, the ground floor, was leased out: by the assessee to the Bank of Baroda. In the meantime, the assessee had also started construction of a first floor and a barsati on the ground floor which was already existing. The total cost of construction of the barsati and the first floor came to Rs. 91,694. of this, Rs. 15,000 was spent up to December 31, 1964, and the balance of Rs. 76,694 was spent between January, 1965, and November, 1966. In other words, the amount invested by the assessee after December 31, 1964, on the construction of the first floor and the barsati exceeded the amount of capital gains of Rs. 42,550. On April 1, 1965, after the ground floor had been let out to the Bank of Baroda, the assessse shifted to the first floor and the barsati and it is common ground that he occupied it as his residential premises.

6. On the above facts, the department had to consider the assessee's claim for exemption under s. 54 of the I.T Act, 1961. The ITO denied the assessee the benefit of the exemption but the claim was accepted by the AAC as well as the Appellate Tribunal. The Tribunal pointed out that there was no dispute that the Darya Ganj property had been used by the assessee mainly (indeed wholly) for the purpose of the assessee's own residence for the statutorily required period. The only further requirement to render the assessee eligible for exemption under s. 54 was that the assessee should have, within a period of 2 years after the date of sale of the earlier property, constructed a house property for the purposes of his own residence. So far as this condition was concerned it was not necessary that the new house constructed should be occupied by the assessee either exclusively or mainly for the purposes of his residence. What had to be seen was whether the construction was for the assessee's residence. After discussing the evidence placed before it, the Tribunal came to the conclusion that the ground floor had been constructed for the purposes of residence and that the assessee's decision to shift to the first floor was taken only later. The assessee's eligibility to exemption had to be determined with reference to the point of time of the sale and immediately thereafter and this condition was satisfied. That apart, the ground floor and the first floor had independent existences of their own and, if a requirement is imported into the section that the new construction should be solely and exclusively occupied by the assessee, even that condition can be said to have been satisfied having regard to the fact that the upper floors had been exclusively under the occupation of the assessee for the purposes of his residence. The Tribunal, for the reasons mentioned above, dismissed the department's appeal and the aggrieved Commissioner of Income-tax has sought for a reference to this court of the following question of law;

“Whether the Tribunal was justified in exempting the capital gains of Rsr˜42, 550 from taxation in terms of section 54, notwithstanding the fact that only a portion of the newly constructed property in South Extension came to be occupied for the assessee's own residence?”

7. Section 54 confers an exemption from capital gains in certain cases in respect of the sale of house property. The section runs as follows;

“54. Where a capital gain arises from the transfer of a capital asset to which the provisions of section 53 are not applicable, being buildings or lands appurtenant thereto the income of which is chargeable under the head ‘Income from house property’, which in the two years immediately preceding the date on which the transfer took place, was being used by the assessee or a parent of his mainly for the purposes of his own or the parent's own residence, and the assessee has within a period of one year before or after that date purchased/or has within a period of two years after that date constructed, a house property for the purposes of his own residence, then, instead of the capital gain being charged to income-tax as income of the previous year in which the transfer took place, it shall be dealt with in accordance with the following provisions of this section, that is to say, —

(i) if the amount of the capital gain is greater than the cost of the new asset, the difference between the amount of the capital gain and the cost of the new asset shall be charged under section 45 as the income of the previous year; and for the purpose of computing in respect of the new asset any capital gain arising from its transfer within a period of three years of its purchase or construction, as the case may be, the cost shall be nil; or

(ii) if the amount of the capital gain is equal to or less than the cost of the new asset, the capital gain shall not be charged under section 45; and for the purpose of computing in respect of the new asset any capital gain arising from its transfer within a period of three years of its purchase or construction, as the case may be, the cost shall be reduced by the amount of the capital gain.”

8. In order to understand the real purport of the section it is necessary to read the main part of the section along with subsequent paragraphs which outline the extent of the exemption available. A perusal of the entire section will show that where an assessee disposes of a property in which he is residing and invests the amount of capital gains derived thereby, within the stipulated period, in a new residential house property either purchased or constructed by him, he will be exempted from tax in respect of the capital gains realised by him. The legislative object of the provision has been explained in the decision of the Gujarat High Court in CIT v. Natu Hansraj, [1976] 105 ITR 43.

9. So far as the present case is concerned, we think, it clearly falls both within the intendment and language of s. 54 if two important considerations are kept in mind. The first is that when the section talks of house property it does not mean an independent and complete house in the sense in which the term used to be understood once upon a time. House property for the purposes of s. 54 has the same meaning as the concept of house property under ss. 22 to 27 which make it clear that the expression “house property” takes into account an independent residential unit. In fact, there can be no doubt, that the section takes into account all independent residential units particularly in these days when multi-storeyed flats are becoming the order of the day. That the expression “house property” would also take into account a unit of house property has also been accepted in CIT v. Tikyomal Jasanmal, [1971] 82 ITR 95 (Guj). Here for the purpose of the present case, the two units comprising the house in South Extension could be occupied independently. The second consideration to be kept in mind in the light of the above is that we are not concerned here with what happened prior to December 29, 1964, when the house at Darya Ganj was sold but only with what constructions the assessee put up thereafter. The ground floor which had been constructed before December 29, 1964, was a separate independent unit and its construction cannot affect the applicability of s. 54 because it was anterior to the date of sale of the Daiya Ganj property. On the other hand, the first floor and the barsati constituted a separate independent residential unit, the construction of which was no doubt started in March, 1964, but gained momentum towards the end of that year and was eventually completed in November, 1966. So far as this residential unit is concerned it was constructed by the assessee within a period of two years from the date on which Darya Ganj property was disposed of It has also been found as a fact by the Tribunal that the investment by the assessee in this property was to the extent of Rs. 76,694 between January, 1965, and November, 1966, and this was more than sufficient to absolve the capital gains realised by the assessee on the sale of the Darya Ganj property. If these two aspects of the case are kept in mind it seems to us pretty plain that in the present case the conditions, for exemption under s. 54 are clearly fulfilled. To sum up: the assessee sold the Darya Ganj property on December 29, 1964: he realised a capital gain of Rs. 42,550; he invested an amount more than the amount of this capital gain in the construction of a house property which was completed within a period of two years after that date; and the house property so completed was admittedly used by the assessee for the purposes of his own residence. In the face of the above findings, we are of opinion that the assessee was entitled to the exemption under s. 54. The question, as referred to us, proceeds on the basis that the assessee had constructed “a portion” of a house property in South Extension but as already pointed out by us the two residential units of the South Extension property should be considered separate and the real question that arises in the present case is I

“Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the assessee is entitled to the exemption of the capital gains of Rs. 42,550 under section 54 of the Act?”

10. We make the slight modification in the frame of the question and answer it in the affirmative and in favour of the assessee. As the Comissioner has failed, he will pay the costs of the assessee. Counsel's fee Rs. 350.

Question reframed and answered in the affirmative.