Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

S.K Sen Petitioner/Senant v. Kunwarani Chandra Kunwar /Landlord.

Delhi High Court
May 18, 1981
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judicial Opinion — Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

A petition under Section 14(1)(e) of the Delhi Rent Control Act was filed by the owner-landlady, Smt. Kunwarani Chandra Kunwar, seeking eviction of the tenant S.K. Sen from the first floor of premises No. X-6, Hauz Khas, New Delhi. The ground pleaded was that the landlady bona fide required the premises for her residence. The tenant contested the petition and was granted permission to defend. After hearing and considering evidence led by both sides, Shri J.D. Kapur, Rent Controller, Delhi, allowed the ejectment. The tenant, feeling aggrieved, filed the present revision before this Court.

Relevant factual details recorded in the opinion include:

  • The tenancy in dispute concerned the first floor; the second floor (measuring 37' × 15') had fallen vacant by end of 1977 and remained in the landlady's possession.
  • The tenant stated he had been let the premises from 1 March 1975 at Rs. 800 per month; prior to that Engineers India Ltd. had been the tenant at Rs. 600 per month for that floor and had shifted to the ground floor at a higher rent later.
  • The landlady and her husband had been residing at No. D-154, Defence Colony, New Delhi, allotted to her husband by his employer (Indian Oil Corporation). Her husband’s employment termination date was originally 30.4.1978 but was extended to 31.3.1979; subsequently the couple had been residing at Jaipur due to lack of suitable accommodation in Delhi.
  • The landlady asserted she had no accommodation in Jaipur of her own and that the second-floor accommodation in Delhi (described as a Barsati with attached bath and kitchen) was unsuitable for her family's requirements.
  • The landlady's family, as described, comprises her husband, one married son and one married daughter; the latter two reside outside Delhi but visit sometimes. The husband had earlier been D.I.G. of Police in Rajasthan and belonged to a Jagirdar family.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Rent Controller's finding that the landlady bona fide required the premises for her residence (under Section 14(1)(e) of the Delhi Rent Control Act) was open to interference in revision.
  2. Whether the landlady had suitable alternative accommodation (notably the second-floor Barsati) such that her claim of requiring the first floor would be mala fide or an attempt to obtain higher rent.
  3. Whether any legal error or illegality arose from the Rent Controller's evaluation of the evidence warranting interference in revisional jurisdiction.

Arguments of the Parties

Tenant's Arguments

  • The tenant argued that the landlady was motivated by a desire to obtain higher rent: evidence cited included that in 1975 the landlady charged higher rents when floors fell vacant (Engineers India Ltd. shifting and higher rents being charged for the ground floor).
  • The tenant contended that the landlady already possessed the second floor (vacant since 1977), which would suffice for her requirements and thus the eviction claim was not bona fide.

Landlady's Arguments

  • The landlady asserted she bona fide required the first-floor premises for her residence and had no suitable accommodation in Delhi; she and her husband were residing at Jaipur for want of suitable accommodation in Delhi and had no property in Jaipur.
  • She admitted possession of the second floor since 1977 but characterised that accommodation as a Barsati (exposed to sun and rain hazards and least suitable for the family's requirements given their status and life previous to that) and thus inadequate for her reasonable requirement.
  • The landlady emphasized her family circumstances and status (husband formerly a senior police officer, belonging to a Jagirdar family) to contextualise what would be suitable accommodation for her family.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court reviewed the record and evidence and declined to interfere with the Rent Controller's factual findings. The reasoning proceeded along these lines, as articulated in the opinion:

  1. The Court observed that the Rent Controller had concluded that the landlady was the owner, had no suitable accommodation in her possession, and bona fide required the premises for her family's residence. These findings were characterised as essentially factual appraisements.
  2. The Court stated the settled principle that an owner-landlord is the best judge of his or her requirements and that a court should not substitute its opinion so long as the owner's judgment is not fanciful or mala fide. The Court emphasised that what is “reasonable requirement” depends on facts and circumstances (nature of available accommodation, status and standard of living, family extent) and that no rigid rule applies.
  3. Applying that principle, the Court accepted the landlady's explanation that the second-floor Barsati was unsuitable (being exposed and makeshift) and that it would be unjust to force her to adjust there while tenants remained in the main building.
  4. The Court considered the tenant's contention about prior higher rents charged in 1975 and found that such past conduct did not necessarily negate the present bona fide requirement where the claim was otherwise supported by evidence.
  5. The Court noted evidence that the landlady had no accommodation of her own at Jaipur and was living there because of non-availability of suitable accommodation in Delhi. The Court regarded the circumstance that the Barsati had been kept vacant and that the landlady sought to use it along with the first floor as supporting, rather than undermining, her bona fides.
  6. The Court recorded that if the landlady later acted inconsistently with her representation (for example, by letting out the premises at a higher rent), the tenant would have a remedy under the Delhi Rent Control Act to seek delivery back of possession. This observation underpins the Court's conclusion that present findings of bona fide requirement are not conclusive against future tenant relief if the landlady's conduct belies her representation.
  7. Finally, having considered the “totality of circumstances,” the Court found no legal infirmity or error in the Rent Controller’s exercise of jurisdiction or assessment of evidence that would justify interference in the revision petition.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The revision is REJECTED and the Rent Controller's order allowing ejectment is upheld.

Direct consequences and implications recorded in the opinion:

  • The revision filed by the tenant was dismissed with costs.
  • The petitioner-tenant was permitted three months' time to vacate the premises.
  • The Court noted that if the landlady subsequently relets or acts contrary to her stated intention to occupy, the tenant has statutory remedies under the Delhi Rent Control Act to seek delivery back of possession; thus the Court did not treat the present decision as foreclosing future tenant relief should facts change.
  • The opinion does not indicate that it establishes any new legal precedent; the decision rests on the application of established factual appraisal principles in the context of Section 14(1)(e) proceedings and the Court explicitly found no legal error in the Rent Controller's factual findings.

This summary is restricted to and derived exclusively from the content of the provided opinion. No facts or conclusions have been added beyond what appears in the text.

Show all summary ...

D.R Khanna, J.:— A petition under Section 14(1)(e) of the Delhi Rent Control Act for eviction of the tenant, S.K Sen, from premises constituting of first floor of X-6, Hauz Khas, New Delhi, was brought by the owner landlady Smt. Kunwarani Chandra Kunwar, pleading that she bona fide required the same for her residence. The tenant contested the petition and sought permission to defend which was granted. Later, however, the ejectment was allowed by Shri J.D Kapur, Rent Controller, Delhi, after considering the evidence which both the sides had led. The tenant now feeling aggrieved has moved the present revision before this Court.

I have heard both the sides and considered the entire evidence on record. In my opinion, no interference is called for in the assessment of evidence by the learned Rent Controller. He has some to the conclusion that the landlady is the owner of the premises, and has no suitable accommodation in her possession and further that she, in fact, bona fide requires the premises for her family's residence. These are essentially factual appraisements, and I do not see any legal implications involved in them which should justify interference in the revision. No material evidence has been ignored nor any extraneous circumstance taken into account.

At the time when the eviction petition was moved, the landlady was residing with her husband at premises No. D-154 Defence Colony, New Delhi. This had been allotted to her husband by his employer, the Indian Oil Corporation, when he was employed with that Corporation as Chief Vigilance Officer. His employment was due to expire there on 30.4.1978 He, however, got extension up to 31.3.1979 Ever since then he and his wife have been residing at Jaipur, the place to which they orglnally beiong, for want of suitable accommodation in Delhi. According to them, they want to settle in Delhi where they have this property. At Jaipur they are not owning any property.

The defence set up by the tenant was that he was let out the premises in dispute on 1.3.1975 at Rs. 800/- per month. Prior to that the Engineers India Ltd. was the tenant there at Rs. 600/- per month. This concern shifted to the ground floor from that date at the rent of Rs. 1,250/- per month; while earlier the landlady was getting Rs. 1,100/- per month only for that floor. From these circumstances, it was sought to be urged that the landlady was keen for higher rent, and the present petition was also motivated for that purpose.

It was also pointed out that the second floor of the property in dispute covering an area measuring 37′ × 15′ fell vacant by the end of 1977, and remained in possession of the landlady. The same, it was urged, could well suffice her requirements. The landlady admitted that this second floor has been in her possession from the time it was vacated in 1977, but asserted that it was in the nature of Barasati, and was least suitable for her family's requirements, considering the status and the life that they had led in the past.

It need hardly be impressed that an owner-landlord is the best judge of his requirements, and so long as his judgment is not fanciful or mala fide, the Court should not substitute its own opinion. Similarly, he has a right to make himself comfortable. What is the reasonable requirement of a person depends upon the facts and circumstances of each case. No hard and fast rule or an inflexible approach can be adopted which must govern each and every case. The nature of the accommodation available, the status and standard of living to which the person has been accustomed to and the extent of his family are some of the broad considerations which have to be kept in view. In the cirumstances when the landlady in the present case has stated that the second floor accommodation in her possession, which is more in the form of a Barsati with attached bath and kitchen, is not suitable and sufficient for her requirements, the same cannot be treated as a mala fide stand. It would not be just to require her to adjust in a small accommodation which is open to the hazards of the sun and rain in odd seasons, and allow the main building to remain with the tenants. After all the purpose and satisfaction of owning a house are of no avail if one has just to be a by-stander and required to adjust onself in a makeshift arrangement.

The evidence has come on the record that the petitioner has no accommodation of her own at Jaipur, and has to live there because of non-availability of suitable accommodation in Delhi. The circumstance that she has kept the Barsati vacant, and wants to avail that along with the first floor from which eviction is being sought, shows that she is not motivated to enjoy higher rents only. In any case, if she later acts in a manner as to belie the representation made that she intends occupying the premises and lets it out at higher rent, recourse is available to the tenant under the Delhi Rent Control Act to seek delivery back of the possession.

The mere fact that in the year 1975 the landlady charged higher rents for the first and second floor when they fell vacant, should not justify rejection of her present claim, when it is otherwise found to be bona fide. The landlady's family is, at present, constituted of her husband, one married son and a married daughter. The latter two are, of course, at present residing outside Delhi. They, however, according to them, do visit them off and on.

As regards the status of the landlady, it has been brought out that her husband was earlier a Deputy Inspector-General of Police in Rajasthan, and belongs to a Jagirdar family.

Considering the totality of the circumstances, I do not find any force in this revision, much less that any infirmity in law or error in the exercise of jurisdiction exists in the present case.

The revision is, therefore, rejected with costs. The petitioner-tenant, however, is allowed three months' time to vacate the premises.