- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Baldev Raj v. Savitri Bai .
Summary of the Opinion (G.R. Luthra, J. — Oral)
Factual and Procedural Background
This revision petition under section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure challenges an order dated January 23, 1981 of Shri R.C. Chopra, Senior Sub Judge, Delhi, concerning whether a temporary mandatory injunction may be issued as an ad interim measure and under what circumstances.
The dispute concerns flats and shops in Jangpura Extension Market. The block has 10 shops on the ground floor and 10 corresponding flats on the first floor. Flat No. 4 (originally allotted to and purchased from Dr. Roshan Lal) belongs to the plaintiff-respondent, and Flat No. 5 (originally allotted to and purchased from Nannu Mal) belongs to the defendant-petitioner.
The plaintiff alleged she had access to Flat No. 4 through Flat No. 5. That access was obstructed in mid-March and, on April 7, 1980, a wall (marked CD in the plaint plan) was constructed blocking the access. The plaintiff filed a suit (application dated May 19, 1980) seeking (a) a mandatory injunction directing demolition of the wall CD and restoration of the old arrangement (raising the old existing wall shown as FD) to restore access to Flat No. 4, and (b) a perpetual injunction restraining the defendant from obstructing access.
The trial court refused the application for temporary mandatory injunction on the ground that, although there was a prima facie case, the plaintiff was not occupying Flat No. 4 and therefore would not suffer irreparable injury warranting an interim mandatory injunction. The plaintiff appealed, and the Senior Sub Judge passed the impugned order directing the defendant, during the pendency of the suit, to make an opening in wall CD of specified dimensions, to construct a separating wall between points F and D, to allow execution of the directions by the plaintiff if not complied with, and to furnish security of Rs. 2,000/-, together with a restraint on the defendant from obstructing access via specified staircase and balcony areas.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a temporary mandatory injunction can be issued as an ad interim measure during the pendency of a suit and, if so, under what circumstances.
- Whether a temporary mandatory injunction can be granted when the alleged obstructing act (construction of the wall) occurred before the institution of the suit, and whether the appellate court had jurisdiction to grant such relief.
Arguments of the Parties
Defendant-Petitioner (as presented in the opinion)
- Submission that mandatory injunctions may be issued only in extremely rare cases and, traditionally, only to restore the status quo existing on the date of institution of the suit.
- Relied on Mandan Pictures Ltd. v. Art Pictures Ltd., A.I.R. 1956 Calcutta 428, to support the contention that mandatory injunctions are exceptional and limited to restoration of prior status quo.
- Contended that the wall in question was constructed on April 7, 1980 — before the suit (May 19, 1980) — and therefore the lower appellate court lacked jurisdiction to issue a temporary mandatory injunction.
- Argued that because the plaintiff did not occupy Flat No. 4 and lived in Bombay, there was no real inconvenience or irreparable injury warranting an interim mandatory injunction.
Plaintiff-Respondent (as presented in the opinion)
- Asserted an established right of passage to Flat No. 4 through Flat No. 5 based on earlier allotments, administrative decision by Rehabilitation Authorities, and a prior civil compromise which resulted in construction facilitating access (including a curved wall feature).
- Alleged that the defendant removed the curved wall and constructed a blocking wall (CD), thereby totally depriving plaintiff of access to Flat No. 4 and necessitating the suit and interim relief.
- Placed on record an application (dated December 15, 1980) and an affidavit of the plaintiff’s husband stating he comes to Delhi often and would stay in the flat if access is restored; also stated that the plaintiff’s attorney was living in the flat to manage it.
- Relied on a Local Commissioner's on-site report (dated July 8, 1980) that found no other access to Flat No. 4 except through Flat No. 5 and noted remnants of the curved wall, supporting the claim of obstruction.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Mandan Pictures Ltd. v. Art Pictures Ltd., A.I.R. 1956 Calcutta 428 | Authority for the proposition that mandatory injunctions are to be granted only in extremely rare cases and, traditionally, for restoring the status quo as of the institution of the suit. | The defendant relied on this case to argue the lower appellate court had no jurisdiction to issue the interim mandatory injunction because the wall was constructed before the suit. The court considered this authority but rejected any rigid rule that confined mandatory injunctions solely to restoration of the state of affairs existing on the institution of the suit. |
| Shirang Padmanabh Porob Dessai v. Mariano Francisco Jacques, A.I.R. 1975 Goa, Daman & Diu 23 | Illustration that a mandatory injunction can be granted in an exceptional case (here under inherent powers under section 151 of the Code) to remove a wall blocking sewage and rainwater, where otherwise severe harm (flooding) would result. | The court relied on this decision as a precedent showing that mandatory injunctions may be granted in cases of extreme hardship. It analogised the flooding harm in that case to the present situation of total lack of access to Flat No. 4, concluding that a mandatory injunction was justifiable on similar grounds of extreme hardship. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court began by acknowledging the general proposition that temporary mandatory injunctions are exceptional and should be issued only in rare cases. However, it rejected a rigid limitation that such injunctions may only be used to restore the status quo as of the institution of the suit. The court observed that human affairs present varying and unforeseen situations where strict rules would be inappropriate.
The court accepted the principle illustrated in Shirang Padmanabh Porob Dessai (A.I.R. 1975 Goa, Daman & Diu 23) that mandatory injunctions may be appropriate where extreme hardship would otherwise result (in that case, flooding). The court considered the present case to present a comparable situation of extreme hardship because Flat No. 4 was rendered totally inaccessible by the construction of the wall in question.
The Local Commissioner (appointed at the plaintiff's request) inspected the site on July 7, 1980 and reported on July 8, 1980 finding (i) no other access to Flat No. 4 except through Flat No. 5, and (ii) remnants indicating that a curved wall had been demolished — a curve that previously left a passage. The court noted these factual findings were not disputed.
Addressing the defendant's contention about non-occupation of the flat by the plaintiff, the court held that occupation was immaterial: the plaintiff retains a right to use the flat at any time. The court also noted the plaintiff had evidence (application and affidavit) that her husband frequently comes to Delhi and that her attorney was residing in the flat to manage it. Considering these facts, the court concluded there was a prima facie case, the balance of convenience favored the plaintiff, and irreparable injury would result if the injunction were not granted.
On that basis, the court found the lower appellate court's order granting the temporary mandatory injunction to be justified, and proceeded to dismiss the revision petition as lacking merit while making certain procedural directions (see Holding and Implications).
Holding and Implications
Holding: The revision petition was dismissed and the order of the lower appellate court directing a temporary mandatory injunction was sustained.
Specific consequences and directions contained in the opinion:
- The court stated the petition is dismissed with costs and directed the petitioner to comply with the order of the learned lower appellate court within 15 days.
- Parties were directed to appear before the trial court on April 14, 1981.
- A copy of this order along with the records of the trial court was to be sent to the trial court immediately.
- Counsel fee of Rs. 200/- was awarded.
- The lower appellate court's order required the defendant to open wall CD (6 feet by 3 feet) and construct the separating wall between F and D during pendency, to furnish security of Rs. 2,000/-, and imposed a restraint on obstructing access via staircase P–P1 and balcony ABCFG; the revision court's dismissal leaves those measures in place (as reflected by the directions to comply).
Note on textual inconsistency: the opinion contains the sentence "Hence I do not find any force in the petition and dismiss the same with costs" (indicating dismissal), and concludes with the short line "Petition allowed." Both sentences appear in the provided text. The summary above records the dismissal and the practical directions issued by the court because the body of the opinion explains dismissal and directions; the final short line "Petition allowed" is reproduced here as a literal part of the provided opinion but is inconsistent with the detailed disposition immediately preceding it.
Broader implications: The court articulated that while temporary mandatory injunctions are exceptional, they are not limited strictly to restoring the exact state of affairs existing on the date of the suit; they may be granted in cases of extreme hardship where refusal would cause irreparable injury. The opinion does not purport to lay down a novel legal rule beyond applying those principles to the facts, and no express new precedent is declared.
G.R Luthra, J (ORAL):— Main question involved in the present revision petition under section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure (in short code), which is directed against an order dated January 23, 1981 of Shri R.C Chopra, Senior Sub Judge, Delhi, is as to whether a temporary mandatory injunction can be issued as an ad interim measure during the pendency of the suit and if so under what circumstances?
2. In Jangpura Extension Market, New Delhi, there is one block of building consisting of 10 shops on the ground floor and 10 flats on the first floor. There is one flat on every one of the shops. Flats are numbered as 1 to 10 and likewise shops are also numbered as 1 to 10. There is common stair case for approach to flats Nos. 1 and 2. There is another common stair case for approach to flats Nos. 5 & 6 and yet another one for approch to flat Nos. 7 and 8. There is no stair case for reaching flat Nos. 3 & 4 as well as flats Nos. 9 and 10. Flat No. 4 belongs to the plaintiff-respondent (hereinafter referred to the plaintiff). Flat No. 5 belongs to defendant petitioner (hereinafier referred to as the defendant.)
3. According to the plaintiff she has been having access to flat No. 4 through flat No. 5, which was obstructed in the middle of March and thereafter on April 7, 1980 was blocked by construction of wall, shown as CD in red colour in the plan attached with the plaint. Therefore, she brought a suit praying for the following reliefs:—
(a) a decree for mandatory injunction directing the defendant to demolish and remove the wall shown in red colour in the site plan at point CD and to raise the old existing wall shown in green colour at point FD thereby to restore the said premises in its old original condition so as to give free access to the plaintiff to her flat through the balcony and staircase.
(b) a decree for perpetual injunction restraining the defendant, his agents, and employees from creating any obstruction to the plaintiff's access to her flat through the balcony and staircase.
4. Asslertions of the plaintiff are as follows. Entire block of building belonged to the Rehabilitation authorities. Office of the Regional Settlement Commissioner, Jam Nagar House, New Delhi allotted flat No. 4 to Dr. Roshan Lal and executed a sale deed in the year 1960 in favour of the latter. Flat No. 5 was similarly allotted to one Nannu Mal. Dr. Roshan Lal used to have passage to his flat No. 4 through an open space in flat No. 5. In the year 1962 Nannu Mal tried to construct a wall for obstructing that passage. Dr. Roshan Lal complained to Rehabilitation Authorities. After a lot of contest it was ultimately decided by the said authorities that Dr. Roshan Lal had right to have passage through flat No. 5 for access to flat No. 4. Thereafter there was also civil litigation and ultimately there was a compromise. It was provided that a balcony would be constructed in which toilet of flat No. 5 would have a curve in the wall so as to give access to the occupant of flat No. 4 through aforesaid balcony. That compromise was acted upon, construction was made accordingly and Dr. Roshan Lal had been using the passage from flat No. 5 for acces to flat No. 4.
5. Details of contest before the Rehabilitation Authorities and contest in the civil proceedings are given in the plaint but the same are not being mentioned here because those will be necessary at the final decision of the case and not at this stage of issue of temporary injunction.
6. Plaintiff purchased flat No. 4 from Dr. Roshan Lal while defendant purchased flat No. 5 from Nannu Mal. As already mentioned defendant removed curved wall of toilet in the balcony of flat No. 5 and constructed a wall with a view to obstruct passage giving approach to flat No. 4. That necessiated the suit.
7. Plaintiff brought an application dated May 19, 1980 for issue of temporary mandatory injunction directing the defendant to demolish wall shown as CD in the plan attached with the plaint which was causing obstruction in the approach to flat No. 4 from flat No. 5 and for further issue of injunction restraining the defendant from creating such obstruction till final disposal of the suit. That application was rejected by the trial court, on the ground that although there was prima facie case, yet as flat No. 4 was not occupied by plaintiff there would not be any irreparable injury to her for avoidance of which temporary injunction was needed. Plaintiff went in appeal which was accepted by learned Senior Sub Judge by way of passing impugned order, operative portion of which reads as under:—
“The defendant is hereby directed to make during the pendency of the suit, an opening in wall CD of the height of six feet and width of three feet with a view to give access to the appellant or her attorney or her agents to her flat No. 4 and he is also directed to construct a wall between points F & D so as to separate the flats Nos. 4 & 5 during the pendancy of the suit. The defendant should comply with these orders within ten days, failing which the piaintiff/appellant through her attorney shall be free to put the above said directions in execution with the help of the labour engaged by them. It is, however, ordered that the plaintiff/appellant through her attorney should furnish a security of Rs. 2,000/- in the trial court within ten days with an undertaking to reimburse the respondent for damages in case it is ultimately held by the trial court that the plaintiff/appellant was not entitled to the relief claimed by her. The defendant/respondant is further restrained during the pendency of the suit in the court below from obstructing the appellant, her attorney or other persons going to flat No. 4 in any way whatsoever from the staircase P to P1 and balcony ABCFG.”
8. First contention of the learned counsel for the defendant is that mandatory injunction cannot be issued except in extremely rare cases and that too only for restoring status-quo existing on the date of the institution of the suit and that the same cannot to granted for bringing about new state of things. He, in this respect relied upon a judgment of Calcutta High Court in Mandan Pictures Ltd. v. Art Pictures Ltd. A.I.R 1956 Calcutta 428. He pointed out that in the present case even according to the allegations of the plaintiff wall directed to be demolished by the lower appellate court was constructed much before the institution of the suit that the said wall, as per allegations contained in the plaint was constructed on April 7, 1980 while the suit was brought much later on May 19, 1980, that therefore, lower appellate court had no jurisdiction to issue temporary mandatory injunction.
9. There is no doubt that the temporary injunction can be issued only in rare cases when there are compelling circumstances. But issuance of the same cannot be confined to only one situation of restoration of state of affairs as existing on the institution of the suit. Human affairs are so varying and unforeseen that such a rigid rule cannot be laid down. There can be very hard case where ends of justice demand issue of injunction. In Shirang Padmanabh Porob Dessai v. Mariano Francisco Jacques, A.I.R 1975 Goa, Daman & Diu 23 Additional Judicial Commissioner of Goa Daman and Diu held that a mandatory injunction could be granted in exercise of inherent powers under section 151 of code for removing a wall which was blocking a sewage and flow of rain water. That was a case of extreme hardship because but for issue of mandatory injunction there was bound to be flooding of the property of the plaintiff during rainy season. In the present case also there is extreme hardship to the plaintiff because there is no access to flat No. 4 at all and the same is lying absolutely blocked on account of construction of the wall in question by the defendant. At the request of the plaintiff Shri D.C Pandy, Advocate was appointed as Local Commissioner. He went on the spot on July 7, 1980 and gave a report dated July 8, 1980. According to him there was no other access to flat No. 4 except through flat No. 5 Actually that fact is not disputed. Further Local Commissioner found that a curved wall seem to have been demolished because remanants of the same were existing on the spot. It was on account of that curve in the wall that passage was left for having engress and agrese to flat No. 4. When there is such blocking of flat No. 4 lower appellate court was fully justified in granting mandatory injunction.
10. The learned counsel for the petitioner contended that the plaintiff was living at Bombay, that flat No. 4 was not being used and that therefore, there was hardly any inconvenience to the plaintiff if the same remained closed during the pendency of the suit and hence there was no justification for issue of temporary mandatory injunction. He pointed out that it was for that reason that trial court had refused to access to the request of the plaintiff for grant of such an injunction.
11. Firstly, it is immaterial whether flat No. 4 is being used or not. The plaintiff has a right to use the same at any time she likes. Then there is an application dated December 15, 1980 supported by an affidavit of husband of the plaintiff (Shri Roop Chand) on record of trial court to the effect that he comes to Delhi very often and would like to stay in the flat if the passage of the same is not blocked. Further it is the case of the plaintiff that her attorney has been living in the flat with a view to manage and look after the same. I totally agree with the learned lower appellate court that there is prima facie case and the balance of convenience favours the plaintiff and it is absolutely necessary to issue injunction, as granted by the lower appellate court, for saving plaintiff from an irreparable injury of being totally debarred from using or having access in the flat No. 4.
12. Hence I do not find any force in the petition and dismiss the same with costs. The petitioner has been given 15 days time to comply with the order of the learned lower appellate court. Parties have been directed to appear before the trial court on April 14, 1981. A copy of this order along-with records of the trial court shall be sent to the trial court immediately. Counsel fee Rs. 200/-.
13. Petition allowed.
Alert