Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mohd. Abbas Khan v. Bal Bhavan Board And Ors.

Delhi High Court
Apr 23, 1981
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner was appointed on 21-7-1957 as a physical instructor at the Bal Bhavan and National Children's Museum, respondent No. 1, a society registered under the Societies Registration Act and managed by a Board of Management established by a Union of India resolution dated 10th March 1955. On 10.1.1969, the petitioner was suspended on grounds of contemplated disciplinary proceedings and served with a chargesheet containing 13 charges. An enquiry committee held proceedings from 8.3.1969 to 11.5.1969 and submitted its report on 26.5.1969. The Chairman of respondent No. 1 provisionally concluded that the petitioner was unfit for service and proposed dismissal. The petitioner was given an opportunity to make a representation, alleging violation of natural justice and inadequate opportunity to defend himself. On 9.7.1969, the petitioner was compulsorily retired. His review against this order was rejected by the Board, leading him to file the present writ petition challenging the validity of his compulsory retirement following departmental enquiry.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondent society, registered under the Societies Registration Act and established by a Union of India resolution, qualifies as an “authority” within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution and is amenable to writ jurisdiction under Article 226.
  2. Whether principles of natural justice were violated in the disciplinary proceedings against the petitioner, particularly regarding the opportunity to defend and cross-examine witnesses.
  3. Whether the petitioner's compulsory retirement following the enquiry was arbitrary and violative of his fundamental rights under Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution.
  4. Whether a writ petition is maintainable against the respondent society despite the master-servant relationship between the parties.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Principles of natural justice were violated as the petitioner was not given a proper opportunity to present his defence.
  • The petitioner was denied the right to cross-examine the former Director of the institution, effectively curtailing his defence.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Respondent No. 1 is a society registered under the Societies Registration Act and is not amenable to writ jurisdiction.
  • Even if the society is an authority under Article 12, the service bye-laws are not statutory in character, and thus no writ can be issued to enforce them.
  • The relationship between the parties is that of master and servant, and termination of service by the master does not attract writ jurisdiction.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ajay Hasia & Ors. v. Khalid Mujib Sehravardi & Ors., 1981 S.C. 487 Where a corporation or society is an instrumentality or agency of the Government, it is an “authority” under Article 12 and amenable to writ jurisdiction under Article 226. The court applied this principle to hold respondent No. 1 as an instrumentality of the Central Government, thus an authority within Article 12 and subject to writ jurisdiction.
Reference to Article 14 of the Constitution and related cases (1981 S.C. 487 and 1974 S.C. 555) Actions taken arbitrarily by a public authority violate Article 14 (Right to Equality). The arbitrary conduct of the respondent in denying the petitioner a fair hearing was held violative of Article 14.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by examining whether the respondent society qualifies as an authority under Article 12. It analyzed the society's constitution and management structure, noting that it was established by a Union of India resolution, controlled by a Board with government representatives, subject to government approval of rules and budget, and audited by the Comptroller and Auditor-General. These factors demonstrated that the society is an instrumentality or agency of the Central Government, thus an authority under Article 12 and amenable to writ jurisdiction under Article 226.

Next, the court considered the petitioner's contention that principles of natural justice were violated. It found that although bye-laws may not be statutory, they were intended to be followed by the society. The petitioner, as a confirmed employee, was entitled to a fair enquiry. The enquiry process was flawed as the petitioner was denied opportunity to lead evidence and to cross-examine a key witness, the former Director. The abrupt termination of cross-examination and the refusal to hear the petitioner's protests rendered the enquiry arbitrary.

The court held that such arbitrariness breached the petitioner's fundamental rights under Articles 14 and 16. It emphasized that even if the relationship is master-servant, a public authority committing such breaches is subject to judicial review. Hence, the petitioner could challenge the compulsory retirement order by filing a writ petition under Article 226.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition was allowed.

The court's decision directly invalidates the compulsory retirement order against the petitioner due to violation of natural justice and fundamental rights. It establishes that societies established and controlled by the government are authorities under Article 12 and amenable to writ jurisdiction. However, the opinion does not set a new precedent beyond applying existing principles to the facts of this case.

Show all summary ...

FACTS:—

The petitioner was appointed on 21-7-57 as a physical instructor in the Bal Bhavan and National Children's Museum, respondent No. 1. The said respondent is registered under the Societies Registration Act and manages the Institution known as Bal Bhavan and National Children's Museum at New Delhi. Vide Union of India's resolution dated 10th March, 1955 the institution known as Bal Bhavan was founded. The Administration and Management of Bal Bhavan has been vested in the Board of Management established and constructed under the said resolution of the Union of India. By an order dated 10.1.69 the petitioner was suspended on the ground that disciplinary proceedings against him were contemplated. A chargesheet dated 10.1.69 containing 13 charges was served upon him. The petitioner was required to give his reply to the charges within the 15 days. The three-member committee appointed in this behalf started its enquiry against the petitioner on 8.3.69, completed its proceeding on 11.5.69 and submitted its report on 26.5.69 The Chairman of respondent No. 1 agreed with the findings of the enquiry committee and provisionally came to the conclusion that petitioner was not a fit person to be retained in service. The petitioner was given an opportunity to make a representation on the penalty proposed to be imposed, namely, that of dismissal from service. The petitioner made a representation, in which it was contended that principles of natural justice have been violated and sufficient opportunity has not been given to him to put forth his defence and that he had not been heard. By an order dated 9.7.69 the petitioner was compulsorily retired. The review filed by the petitioner against the said order was rejected by the Board. The petitioner, therefore, filed this writ petition challenging the validity of the order of his compulsory retirement after departmental enquiry had been held against him.

CONTENTIONS:—Apart from other contentions the main contention of the petitioner was that principles of Natural Justice have been violative in the case as he was not given an opportunity to put forth his defence. Even the cross-examination by the petitioner of the former Director of the Institution was stopped. The contention of the respondent was that the respondent No. 1 is a society registered under the society registration act and is not amenable to writ jurisdiction and that even though respondent No. 1 is an authority within the meaning of Article 12. service bye-laws framed by the society are not statutory in character and, therefore, no writ can be issued to the respondent society to give effect to non-statutory bye-laws. The relationship between the party is that of a master and servant and, therefore, no writ can be issued as the services of the servant have been terminated by the master.

HELD THAT:—

Following Ajay Hasia etc. v. Khalid Mujib Sehravardi and others 1981 S.C 487 wherein it was held by the Supreme Court that where a corporation or Society was an instrumentality or agency of the Government, it must be held to be an ‘authority’ within the meaning of Article 12 and hence subject to the same basic obligation to obey the fundamental rights as the Government. It was held that a writ petition is maintainable against an authority under Article 226 of the Constitution. All that has to be seen is whether the respondent Society is to be regarded an instrumentality or the agency of the State or not. As already noted the Society was established by a resolution of the Union of India. As per the said resolution the Society is to be managed by a Board of Management. The Board is to consist of Chairman, four representatives of the Government of India, a representative of Delhi Administration, four members to be nominated by the Chairman, not more than one person to be co-opted by the Board and the Director of Bal Bhavan was to act as the Secretary of the Board of Management. The Chairman and the Treasurer are to be appointed by the Government of India though the Director is appointed by the Cdairman. The Rules and Regulations are to be made by the Board of Management but they are to be subject to approval of the Government of India. According to the Memorandum of Association the Society cannot sell, lease, exchange or otherwise transfer all or any portion or portions of the property or assets of the Society without prior written permission of the Government of India. The Budget of the Society is to be submitted for sanction of the Government of India and even the accounts are to be audited by the Comptroller and Auditor-General of India. The reading of the said Rules and Regulations as well as the memorandum leave no manner of doubt that respondent No. 1 is under the full control of the Government of India and is an instrumentality or the agency of the Central Government and is, therefore, an authority within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution of India and, therefore, amenable to the writ jurisdiction of this court. The contention of the respondents was rejected.

Even if it be assumed that the bye-laws are not statutory, nevertheless the bye-laws and C.C.A Rules were meant to be followed by the respondent Society. That apart, the petitioner was a confirmed employee of the respondent. Even apart from bye-laws, principles of natural justice demanded that a regular enquiry should have been held or a fair opportunity should have been granted to the petitioner to defend himself. On 8th March, 1969 the petitioner was specifically informed by the Chairman that the petitioner would have an opportunity to examine witnesses in his defence. No such opportunity was granted. The pettioner was never asked as to whether he would like to lead any evidence. The cross-examination by the petitioner of the former Director of the respondent institution was stopped in the middle when the Presiding Officer stated that former Director was not being examined as a witness. The protest of the petitioner to the abrupt closure of the enquiry met with no success. The action of the respondent was completely arbitrary. Acting arbitrarily would amonnt to breach of Article 14 of the Constitution (1981 S.C 487 and 1974 S.C 555 referred to).

Further held that non-giving of an opportunity to examine witness and taking such a report of the committee to be a valid report and taking action thereon is clearly violative of principles of Natural Justice and is void and arbitrary. Such arbitrary act would be clearly violative of the petitioner's fundamental rights under articles 14 & 16 of the constitution and the petitioner can successfully challenge such an arbitrary action on the part of respondents by filing the present writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution. Even though the relationship between the petitioner and the respondent may be that of a master and servant but if an authority, within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution, commits a breach of any of the fundamental rights of the petitioner he can challenge such an action and in such a case court would be within its jurisdiction and power to grant appropriate relief.

Writ petition allowed.