- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Delhi Development Authority v. Shanti Devi And Another
Factual and Procedural Background
This revision petition under Section 115 of the Civil Procedure Code challenges the order dated 6 November 1980 of the Subordinate Judge, 1st Class, Delhi, which dismissed the petitioner’s application under Order 9, Rule 7 of the Code as time-barred. The plaintiff-respondent No. 1 instituted a suit for injunction against the petitioner, the Delhi Development Authority (D.D.A.). Summons were served for 30 April 1979, but no one appeared and the trial court proceeded ex parte. The trial court adjourned the suit to 16 August 1979 for recording ex parte evidence.
On 16 August 1979 (the next date of hearing), the petitioner filed an application under Order 9, Rule 7 seeking setting aside of the ex parte proceedings. The application alleged that the petitioner’s counsel, Mr. K.P. Sharma, was engaged in a personal matter and therefore was absent when the suit was called; Mr. Sharma filed an affidavit supporting these grounds and stated that he reached court at about 10:55 a.m. and then learned that ex parte proceedings had been ordered. The application was contested by the plaintiff. The trial court dismissed the application on the ground that it was made after the lapse of 30 days from the date of the order proceeding ex parte (30 April 1979). The present revision challenges that dismissal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether an application under Order 9, Rule 7 filed on the next date of hearing (here, 16 August 1979) is barred by any time limit such as 30 days from the date of the ex parte order (30 April 1979).
- Whether the petitioner (defendant) had shown "good cause" for previous non-appearance on 30 April 1979 so as to justify setting aside the ex parte proceedings under Order 9, Rule 7.
- Whether the trial court erred in dismissing the application as time-barred when the application was filed at the next date of hearing provided for by Order 9, Rule 7.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner (D.D.A.)
- The application under Order 9, Rule 7 was filed on the next date of hearing (16 August 1979) as permitted by the rule.
- The petitioner’s counsel, Mr. K.P. Sharma, was unable to appear on 30 April 1979 because he was busy with a personal matter; he reached court at about 10:55 a.m. and then discovered the ex parte order had been passed. This was supported by an affidavit of Mr. K.P. Sharma.
- There is no statutory provision (under the Limitation Act) prescribing a 30-day period for filing an application under Order 9, Rule 7; therefore the trial court’s reliance on a 30-day bar was incorrect.
Respondent (Plaintiff)
- The application was contested by the plaintiff and the trial court treated the application as barred by the lapse of 30 days from the ex parte order; the opinion does not set out further detailed particulars of the plaintiff’s arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined Order 9, Rule 7 and the absence of any prescribed limitation period under the Limitation Act for applications to set aside ex parte orders. It noted the text of Order 9, Rule 7, which permits the defendant to apply "at or before such hearing" (the adjourned hearing) and to be heard if he assigns good cause for previous non-appearance.
Applying that provision to the facts, the court found that the petitioner filed the application on the next date of hearing (16 August 1979), which is squarely within the procedure contemplated by Order 9, Rule 7. The court rejected the trial court’s reasoning that a 30-day limitation applied: there is no rule that an application under Order 9, Rule 7 must be filed within 30 days of the ex parte order.
The court then considered whether "good cause" had been shown for absence on 30 April 1979. It relied on the affidavit of Mr. K.P. Sharma (counsel for the D.D.A.), which stated he was engaged in a personal matter, arrived at court at about 10:55 a.m., and thereupon discovered that ex parte proceedings had been ordered. The court accepted this as good cause for non-appearance.
On that basis the court set aside the ex parte order dated 30 April 1979, allowed the petitioner to appear and contest the suit, directed the petitioner to file a written statement on the next date of hearing, and directed the petitioner to appear before the trial court on 13 October 1981. The court made no order as to costs.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The court set aside the order proceeding ex parte dated 30 April 1979 and allowed the petitioner’s application under Order 9, Rule 7. The petitioner was permitted to appear and contest the suit; the petitioner was directed to file a written statement on the next date of hearing and to appear before the trial court on 13 October 1981. No order as to costs was made.
Implications: The decision directly effects the parties by restoring the petitioner’s right to be heard and to defend the suit; the ex parte order was set aside. The opinion does not discuss broader implications or purport to lay down a new legal precedent beyond the court’s interpretation and application of Order 9, Rule 7 to these facts.
This revision petition under S. 115 of the Civil P.C is directed against the order dated 6th Nov., 1980 of the Subordinate judge, 1st Class. Delhi whereby he dismissed the petitioner's application under O. 9, R. 7 of the Code on the ground that the application was barred by time. The brief facts are as follows :—
The plaintiff-respondent No. 1 filed a suit for injunction against the petitioner D.D.A The summons of the suit was served on the petitioner for 30th April, 1979 but no body was present and therefore it was proceeded ex parte. The trial court adjourned the suit to 16th Aug., 1979 for recording ex parte evidence. The petitioner made an application under O. 9, R. 7 of the Code on 16th Aug, 1979 before the trial Court alleging that Mr. K.P Sharma. Advocate was the counsel for the Delhi Development Authority who was engaged in the case and he was busy in his personal matter, he could not attend the case at the time when it was called for hearing, that at about 10-55 A.M when the counsel for the petitioner attended the Court he came to know the petitioner had been proceeded ex parte and the date fixed was 16th Aug., 1979, The application was supported by the affidavit of Shri K.P Sharma, Advocate counsel for the D.D.A This application was contested by the plaintiff. The trial Court by the impugned order held that the application was made after the lapse of 30 days from the date of the order proceeding ex parte and therefore, dismissed the application. The order proceeding ex parte was passed on 30th Apr., 1979 and the matter was adjourned to 16th Aug., 1979, O. 9, R. 7 of the Code reads as under :—
“Where the Court has adjourned the hearing of the suit ex parte, and the defendant, at or before such hearing appears and assigns good cause for his previous non-appearance, he may, upon such terms as the Court directs as to costs or otherwise, be beard in answer to the suit as if he had appeared on the day fixed for his appearance.”
Under the Lim. Act no period is prescribed for filing an application for setting aside the order proceeding ex parte. Under R. 7 of, O. 9 of the Code the defendant is allowed to file an application at or before the next date of hearing and if he assigns good cause for his non-appearance on the previous date of hearing the Court may set aside the order proceeding ex parte. The application by the petitioner-defendant under O. 9, R. 7 was made on the next date of hearing i.e 16th Aug., 1979. Thus it is clear that the defendant-petitioner filed the application in accordance with O. 9, R. 7 of the Code. It must therefore be held that the application was filed in accordance with law. There is no rule that an application under O. 9, R. 7 is to be filed within 30 days from the date of the order proceeding ex parte. The next question is whether there was good cause for the absence of the petitioner-defendant on 30th Apr., 1979 before the trial Court. Counsel for the D.D.A Mr. K.P Sharma filed his own affidavit that on 30th Apr., 1979 he was busy in his personal matter and therefore he could not attend the Court at the time when the suit was called by the Court. He further states that he reached the Court at 10.55 A.M and came to know that the ex parte proceedings have been ordered against the petitioner-defendant. There is good cause for the absence of the counsel on 30-4-1979. The order dated 30th Apr., 1979 proceeding ex parte against the petitioner defendant is therefore set aside and the petitioner-defendant is allowed to appear and contest the suit. The petitioner may now file the written statement on the next date of hearing before the trial Court. The petitioner is directed to appear before the trial Court on 13th Oct. 1981. No order as to costs.
Order accordingly.
Alert