Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Bank Of Baroda v. Prakash Warehouse

Delhi High Court
Mar 20, 1980
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (D.R. Khanna, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This suit was brought by the Bank of Baroda (plaintiff) against five defendants for recovery of Rs. 4,17,729.85. Three separate bank accounts opened by defendant No.1 (a firm of which defendants No.2 to No.4 are partners) with the plaintiff gave rise to the claim:

  • A current account opened on 4-8-1975, giving rise to a claim of Rs. 3,15,722.04 against defendant No.1 and its partners (defendants No.2–4) due to overdrawing.
  • A cash-credit account opened on 22-4-1975 with a drawing facility of Rs.25,000, for which defendant No.5 had stood as guarantor (document dated 19-4-1975); on this basis the plaintiff claimed Rs. 40,133.51 against all defendants including defendant No.5.
  • A loan account opened on 14-6-1975 with a credit facility of Rs.40,000, for which Rs.61,874 was claimed against the defendant-firm.

The aggregate claim against defendants No.1 to No.4 was for Rs.4,17,729.85; the relief against defendant No.5 was limited to Rs.40,133.51 (the cash-credit account) because he was guarantor only for that account.

Defendants No.1 to No.4 remained ex parte. Defendant No.5 contested the suit and in his written statement raised a preliminary objection of misjoinder of causes of action and improper valuation for court-fee purposes. The court framed, inter alia, these two issues for adjudication:

  1. Whether the present suit against defendant No.5 is bad for misjoinder of causes of action? If so, to what effect?
  2. Whether proper court-fees has not been paid by the plaintiff?

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether including defendant No.5 in the same suit with the other defendants amounts to bad joinder/misjoinder of causes of action given his limited connection (guarantor only for the cash-credit account) to one of the three distinct banking transactions.
  2. Whether the plaint is properly valued for court-fee purposes when it embraces multiple distinct subjects (the three accounts) and whether aggregate or separate court-fees are chargeable.

Arguments of the Parties

Defendant No. 5's Arguments

  • He was guarantor only for the cash-credit account (facility of Rs.25,000) and therefore his liability, if any, is confined to that account alone.
  • The amount claimed in respect of the cash-credit account (Rs.40,133.51) is triable by the District Court; the High Court is not competent to try that portion.
  • The other two accounts (current and loan) arose from separate, independent transactions in which he had no involvement; they were not inter-linked or mutually dependent, each giving rise to separate causes of action.
  • His impleading with respect to the other two accounts was therefore unwarranted and amounted to multifariousness (misjoinder).

Plaintiff's (Bank of Baroda) Arguments

  • The three accounts provided an overall facility to defendants No.1 to No.4 to obtain overdrafts and thus were inter-linked; there was a common nexus among them.
  • Reference was made to Order 1 Rule 5 of the Code of Civil Procedure to submit that it is not necessary that every defendant be interested in all reliefs claimed in a suit against him.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded principally from statutory provisions in the Code of Civil Procedure and the Court Fees Act that were expressly cited in the opinion. The judge examined the interplay between Order 1 Rule 3 and Order 2 Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure and considered Order 1 Rule 5 and Section 17 of the Court Fees Act as they related to the facts.

Step-by-step reasoning as stated in the opinion:

  1. Interpretation of Order 1 Rule 3 (Who may be joined as defendants): both clauses (a) and (b) must co-exist — there must be a right to relief arising out of the same act/transaction or series of acts/transactions (nexus) and, if separate suits were brought, a common question of law or fact would arise. If a defendant is not involved in certain matters and there is no common question, impleading cannot be sustained.
  2. Interpretation of Order 2 Rule 3 (Joinder of causes of action): this rule allows a plaintiff to unite several causes of action against the same defendant(s) only where the defendants are jointly liable in respect of each cause of action sought to be joined; emphasis is on cause of action and joint liability.
  3. The two rules address the same problem from different angles: Order 1 Rule 3 focuses on joinder of parties (defendants) where a common nexus and common questions exist; Order 2 Rule 3 focuses on uniting multiple causes of action where defendants are jointly liable for each cause.
  4. Order 1 Rule 5 (that not every defendant need be interested in all reliefs) operates only if the conditions of Order 2 Rule 3 and Order 1 Rule 3 are satisfied.
  5. Application to facts: the current account and the loan account involved defendants No.1–4 jointly and raised common questions; those two causes of action could properly be joined and tried together to avoid multiplicity of suits. Defendant No.5, however, had no connection with the current and loan accounts and was only concerned with the cash-credit account (a distinct transaction or series of transactions). There was no nexus or common question of fact or law linking the cash-credit account to the other two accounts insofar as defendant No.5 was concerned.
  6. Conclusion on misjoinder: the joinder of the cause of action related to the cash-credit account and the impleading of defendant No.5 was bad and unsustainable; that subject-matter had to be separated from the present High Court suit because it was plainly triable by the District Court.
  7. Relief and procedure directed: the cash-credit account matter was to be separated and pursued in the appropriate Court (District Court). The remainder of the suit (current and loan accounts) against defendants No.1–4 was to proceed in the High Court. The plaintiff was allowed the option to drop defendant No.5 if limitation issues arose so that the entirety of the three accounts could be pursued in the High Court.
  8. Costs: defendant No.5 was entitled to costs assessed at Rs.200.
  9. Court-fee analysis under Section 17 of the Court Fees Act: where a plaint embraces two distinct subjects, the plaint is chargeable with the aggregate amount of fees that separate plaints for each subject would attract. The plaintiff conceded that separate court-fee should be computed for each subject-matter (current account and loan account). Because the cash-credit subject-matter was to be separated, the court observed that the court-fee already paid may suffice for the remaining two subjects when valued separately; additional fee may be required only if defendant No.5 is dropped.
  10. Procedural direction: because defendants No.1–4 were ex parte, the plaintiff was directed to produce ex parte evidence against them in terms of the order on March 31, 1980, and to inform the court which of the two courses (separate the cash-credit matter or drop defendant No.5) it chose before that date.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The portion of the suit relating to the cash-credit account (for which defendant No.5 was guarantor) is improperly joined with the remainder of the suit and must be separated; that part is plainly triable by the District Court and therefore must be pursued there. The suit on the basis of the current account and loan account against defendants No.1–4 shall proceed in the High Court.

Direct consequences for the parties (as given in the opinion):

  • Defendant No.5's impleading in respect of the cash-credit account is held to be bad and that subject-matter is to be separated from the present suit and pursued in the appropriate District Court.
  • Defendant No.5 was awarded costs of Rs.200.
  • The plaintiff must produce ex parte evidence against defendants No.1–4 by March 31, 1980, after indicating whether it will separate the cash-credit subject-matter or drop defendant No.5 (the latter option was suggested if there is a limitation difficulty).
  • On court-fees, the plaintiff conceded and the court noted that separate valuation and computation of court-fee for the current and loan accounts is required; the fee already paid may suffice after separation, but additional fee may be necessary if defendant No.5 is dropped.

No broader legal implications or new precedent-setting pronouncements are discussed in the opinion; the decision addresses the proper joinder of causes of action and valuation for court-fee in this specific factual context and resolves the parties' rights accordingly.

Show all summary ...

D.R Khanna, J.:— This suit brought by the Bank of Baroda against the five defendants for the recovery of Rs 4,17,729.85p., has arisen in the following circumstances:—

2. A current account was got opened by defedant No. 1 firm, of which defendants No. 2 to 4 are partners, with the plaintiff on 4-8-1975. Defendant No. 5 had then introduced defendants No. 2 4 to the plaintiff. On the basis of this account, the plaintiff is seeking a decree of Rs 3,15,722.04p. against defedant No. 1 and its partners. This larg liability has resulted as the defendant-firm has been overdrawing.

3. Another account known as cash-credit account, was got opened by defendant No. 1 with the plaintiff on 22-4-1975. This had drawal facility of Rs 25,000/-. Defendant No. 5 had stood as guarantor for this account and had executed a document in this direction on 19th April 1975. On the basis of this account the plaintiff claims a decree for Rs 40,133.51p, against all the defendants including defendant No. 5.

4. A third account styled as loan account, was opened by defendant No. 1 with the plaintiff on 14-6-1975, and the credit facility allowed in this was for Rs 40,000/-. A sum of Rs 61,874 is claimed due and payable by the defendant-firm on the basis of this account.

5. The total of all these amounts due came to Rs 4,17,729.85p, for which a decree is claimed in the suit against defendants No. 1 to 4. However, the relief against defendant No. 5 is restricted to Rs 40,133,51p. out of this amount, as he had stood guarantor for the second account only styled as cash-credit account.

6. Defendants No. 1 to 4 are ex-parte in this suit. Defendant No. 5 alone is contesting the suit. This defendant raised in his written statement a preliminary objection about the misjoinder of a cause of action and the defendants. This suit was also pleaded to be not properly valued for purposes of court-fee.

7. Consequently, the following issues on which adjudication has been sought first, were, inter alia, frame :—

“1. Whether the present suit against defendant No. 5 is bad for misjoinder of causes of action? If so, to what effect? OPD-5.

2. Whether proper court-fees has not been paid by the plaintiff? OP Parties.”

8. The sum and substance of the case of defendant No. 5 on issue No. 1 is that he had stood guarantor with respect to cash-credit account only which had credit facility of Rs 25,000/-, and, therefore, his liability, it at all, can be confined to this account only. The amount under this account claimed by the plaintiff is Rs 40,133.51p., and the suit to this extent is triable by the District Court. So far as the other two accounts are concerned, it is pointed out that this defendant has absolutely nothing to do, nor the plaintiff is claiming any relief qua him on their basis. The three accounts were the result of separate independent transactions by the other defendants with the plaintiff and they were not inter-linked or mutually dependent on each other. Each account thus, it is contended, gave rise to separate cause of action in favour of the plaintiff. Defendant No. 5, however, is in no manner interested or concerned with the other two accounts, and therefore, his impleading as defedant in so far as the suit concerned those accounts, was patently bad and unwarranted. The suit on this ground is, therefore, stated to suffer from multifariousness.

9. From the side of the plaintiff, on the other hand, it is asserted that the three accounts provided an overall facility to defendants No. 1 to 4 to obtain over-drafts from the plaintiff, and thus there was an inter-link between them. Reference has been made to Order 1 Rule 5 of the Code of Civil Procedure Code, in order to show that it is not necessary that every defendant should be interested in all the reliefs claimed in any suit against him.

10. In my opinion, the controversy raised depends upon the interpretation of the provisions contained in Order 1 Rule 3 and Order 2 Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The former is to the following effect:—

“R. 3. Who may be joined as defendants:

All persons may be joined in one suit as defendants where—

(a) any right to relief in respect of, or arising out of, the same act or transaction or series of acts or transactions is alleged to exist against such persons, whether jointly, severally or in the alternative: and

(b) if separate suits were brought against such persons, any common question of law or fact would arise.”

Order 2 Rule 3 is in the following terms:—

“R. 3. Joinder of causes of action.

(1) Save as otherwise provided, a plaintiff may unite in the same suit several causes of action against the same defendant, or the same defendants, jointly; and any plaintiffs having causes of action in which they are jointly interested against the same defendant or the same defendants jointly may unite such causes of action in the same suit.

(2) Where causes of action are united, the jurisdiction of the Court as regards the suit shall depend on the amount or value of the aggregate subject-matters at the date of instituting the suit.”

11. these two Orders and Rules really deal with the same problem from two different standpoints. The former makes provision in what circumstances different persons can be imupleaded as defendants in the same suit. Under this, the requirements of both the provisions contained in clauses (a) and (b) must co-exist. Firstly, it should be shown that the right to relief in respect of the same act or transaction or series of acts or transactions exists against the persons impleaded as defendants jointly, severally or alternatively. There must be some common link or nexus. Secondly, it must also be shown that the case is one where if separate suits were instituted against the defendants, any common question of law or fact would arise it is enough if there is one question common to all defendants which is of sufficient importance in proportion to the rest of the action. In case, therefore, one of the defendants is not, in any manner, involved in certain matters about which relief is claimed against the other defendants, and there is no common question of fact and law in which he is jointly interested with them, then his impleading cannot be sustained. A right to relief cannot be said to arise out of the same act or transaction if the case against each defendant is entirely distinct or separate in its subject-matter from that of the other defendants.

12. The scope of Order 2 Rule 3, however, is confined to uniting in the same suit of several cause of action against the same defendant or same defendants jointly. The emphasis here is on the cause of action. It is a condition precedent to the applicability of the Rule that the defendants must be jointly liable in respect of each and every one of the causes of action sought to be joined.

13. A suit against several defendants on causes of action accrude against each of them separately and in respect of which they are not jointly liable, is bad for misjoinder. However, even in cases not strictly falling under these provisions, recourse to Order 1 Rule 3 is still permissible if the several causes of action are so connected with the same act or transaction or series of acts or transaction, as to give rise to a common question of law or fact at the trial.

14. These two Orders and Rules thus strike a balance between the fundamental concepts that multiplicity of suits should be avoided and that the trial of suits should not be embarrassed by simultaneous investigation of totally unconnected controversies.

15. As regards Order 1 Rule 5 which envisages that every defendant need not be interested in all the relief claimed, the same comes into operation only if the requirements of Order 2 Rule 3 and Order 1 Rule 3, are otherwise satisfied.

16. With this background of the state of law, it is apparent from the narration of facts above that so far as the current account and the loan account were concerned, the plaintiff could have joined together the two causes of action as defendants No. 1 to 4 were jointly concerned with both of them. They involved common questions, and the single suit has avoided multiplicity of proceedings. However, defendant No. 5 is not, in any manner, concerned with these two accounts and, therefore, has no common interest with the order defendants about them. His liability, if any, is confined to the cash-credit account and this was a distinct transaction or series of transactions from the other two accounts, and there was no nexus between them. There is no question of fact and law involved in this account which can be treated as common with the other two accounts. It must, therefore be held that the joining of the cause of action with respect to the cash-credit account and the resultant impleading of defendant No. 5 in this suit is bad and cannot be sustained. The plaintiff must, therefore, separate that subject-matter from the rest of the suit. Normally the choice should be left over to the plaintiff to decide which particular action he is inclined to pursue in the suit. However, the relief claimed under the cash-credit account is plainly triable by the District Court, and, therefore, cannot be brought in the High Court. It is this part of the action, therefore, which has to be separated from the present suit and pursued in the Court concerned in accordance with law. The rest of the suit on the basis of the current and loan accounts against defendants No. 1 to 4 shall proceed. In case of limitation difficulty, the plaintiff can drop defendant No. 5. This suit on the basis of all the three accounts can then proceed.

17. Defendant No. 5 will be entitled to costs which are assessed at Rs 200/-.

18. As regards issue No. 2, since the present suit embraces two distinct subjects, the plaint is chargeable with the aggregate amount of fees to which the plaints in suits embracing separately each of such subjects would be liable under the Court Fees' Act. This is made clear in Section 17 of the Act. The plaintiff in this connection conceded that separate court-fee should be computed on each of the subject-matters. Thus the relief claimed under the current account should be separately valued and so also the relief under the loan account. However, now then the subject-matter relating to the cash-credit account may have to be separated, the court fee already paid may more than suffice the requirements if the other two reliefs are separately valued. No further court-fee may, therefore, be filed. However, it may have to be filed if defendant No. 5 is decided to be dropped.

19. The suit being ex-parte against defendants No. 1 to 4, the plaintiff is directed to produce ex-parte evidence against them in terms of the above order on March 31, 1980. Before that, the plaintiff may bring on record which of the two aforesaid courses, it decides to adopt.

S.VOrdered accordingly.