- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Smt. Leela Wati v. Smt. Ganga Devi
Factual and Procedural Background
This is a revision petition under S. 25-B(8) of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958, filed by the petitioner to challenge an eviction order passed by Shrimati Manju Goel, the 4th Additional Rent Controller, Delhi, under Section 14(1)(e) of the Act. The respondent had applied for leave to defend under the procedure prescribed by Section 25-B within the time mentioned in the summons, but the Additional Rent Controller refused leave to defend on two grounds: (1) the tenant's application for leave to defend was supported by a short-form affidavit which did not reproduce the paragraphs of the application; and (2) on the merits, the Controller concluded that the application did not disclose facts entitling the tenant to leave to defend.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether an affidavit in the short form that refers to and adopts the accompanying application for leave to defend is sufficient for the tenant's application under S. 25-B, or whether the application paragraphs must be reproduced verbatim within the affidavit.
- Whether the facts set out in the tenant's application (i) that the original tenant was Ram Nath and his heirs including the answering respondent and two daughters are necessary co-tenants, (ii) that there is an ownership dispute (claim that Makhan Lal was the owner and petitioner's ownership was denied), and (iii) that the landlord does not bona fide require the accommodation because she has other ample accommodation — jointly or severally disclose triable issues justifying leave to defend under S. 25-B.
Arguments of the Parties
Respondent's Arguments
- The respondent attacked the refusal of leave to defend both on the short-form affidavit point and on the merits.
- On the affidavit point, learned counsel for the respondent relied on two judgments of the Court (Gian Chand v. Roop Narain and Jagir Singh v. Mohinder Kaur) to argue that a mere short-form affidavit—which states that the contents of the accompanying application are true and should be read as part of the affidavit—is sufficient and should not non-suit the replying tenant.
- On the merits, the respondent's application for leave to defend alleged three factual points: (a) that Ram Nath was the original tenant and his heirs (the answering respondent Shrimati Leela Wati and her two daughters Miss Vijay Kumari and Miss Indu) were co-tenants and necessary parties; (b) that Makhan Lal was the owner and petitioner's ownership was disputed; and (c) that the petitioner did not bona fide require the accommodation because she and her family had ample accommodation in another house (a double-storeyed house owned by the petitioner’s husband).
Petitioner's (Landlord's) Arguments
- The petitioner (landlady) disputed that Ram Nath was ever the tenant of the petitioner and contended that the rent receipts and relevant proof were not on record (initially); she maintained that Ram Nath had died before she became owner and therefore the plea of co-tenancy was not established.
- On ownership, the petitioner asserted ownership (purchased the house on 4th March 1968); later a photostat copy of a sale-deed was placed on record.
- Concerning the ground of personal requirement, the petitioner contended that the tenant should be required to prove facts about the size and insufficiency of the existing accommodation (i.e., it was for the tenant to show why the landlord's claim of need was not genuine or that other accommodation was reasonably suitable).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Gian Chand v. Roop Narain, 1979 Rajdhani LR 469 | That a short-form affidavit which states that the contents of the accompanying application may be read as part of the affidavit is sufficient; mere use of short form should not non-suit the replying tenant. | The Court endorsed this view and held that the Rent Controller was wrong to require reproduction of the paragraphs in full within the affidavit; the short-form affidavit must be read together with the application. |
| Jagir Singh v. Mohinder Kaur, AIR 1979 Delhi 245 (reported alongside Gian Chand) | Same principle as Gian Chand: short-form affidavit is not a ground for non-suiting the tenant. | The Court relied on this authority to conclude that the affidavit form used by the respondent was sufficient and that the Controller erred in treating it as defective. |
| Smt. V.L. Kashyap v. R.P. Puri, 1976 Rajdhani LR (Notes) 131; AIR 1977 NOC 205 | That only a specific and positive plea raised by the tenant would be sufficient to defeat an ejectment petition (as applied by the Rent Controller). | The Rent Controller relied on this judgment to find that the tenant had not pleaded sufficient facts; the revising Court noted the Controller had misapplied the standard and criticized the summary rejection based on that reliance. |
| Santosh Kumar v. Bhai Mool Singh, AIR 1958 SC 321 (Supreme Court) | It is dangerous to refuse leave to defend merely because proof is not on record; the state of proof can only be determined after a defendant is allowed to enter appearance and defend. The affidavit stage requires assessing whether, if the facts alleged were proved, they would afford a plausible defence. | The Court quoted and followed this principle to hold that the Controller should not have required proof at the leave stage and should have granted leave where triable issues were plausibly disclosed. |
| Smt. Vidyawanti v. Taken Dass, 1974 Rajdhani LR 23 | Illustrates the consequences when ejectment is sought against only one of several co-tenants: co-tenants not prosecuted remain able to assert their rights and an eviction cannot automatically bind them. | The Court cited this Division Bench decision to support the proposition that if Ram Nath was the tenant and his heirs are co-tenants, ejectment proceedings against only one of them would not necessarily dispossess the others and that this raised a triable issue. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded in two main analytical strands corresponding to the two grounds on which leave had been refused.
Affidavit form issue:
- The Court examined the short-form affidavit used by the respondent which stated that the contents of the accompanying application for leave to defend (paras 1–5) were true and should be read as part of the affidavit, and noted that the verification at the bottom swore to the contents.
- Relying on prior decisions (Gian Chand and Jagir Singh), the Court held that it would be too technical to require reproduction of the application paragraphs inside the affidavit; the short-form affidavit is generally used and must be read together with the application. Thus the Controller erred in refusing leave on that technical ground.
Merits — whether a triable defence was disclosed:
- The Court identified three factual contentions in the tenant's application: (a) that Ram Nath was the original tenant and his heirs (including the answering respondent and two daughters) were co-tenants and necessary parties; (b) that there was an ownership dispute (Makhan Lal alleged to be owner and petitioner's ownership denied); and (c) that the landlord did not bona fide require the premises because she had other accommodation.
- On the co-tenancy point the Court emphasized that succession of tenancy to natural heirs upon the death of a tenant is a legal consequence: if Ram Nath had been the tenant, tenancy would pass to his heirs. The Controller wrongly required proof that Ram Nath was the tenant at the leave stage instead of asking whether facts alleged, if proved, would raise a triable issue. The Court noted that rent receipts in favour of Ram Nath were ultimately produced and are now on record; even if filed late, the Controller should not decide the matter on imaginative evidence but should allow trial where a triable issue is disclosed.
- The Court cited S. 25-B(5), observing that the Controller "shall give" leave if the affidavit discloses such facts as would disentitle the landlord from obtaining possession on the relevant ground — hence the nature of the facts alleged governs the grant of leave rather than the presence of conclusive proof at that stage.
- Regarding ownership, the Court observed the matter was not seriously contested in view of a photostat sale-deed on record and said nothing further on that point.
- On the question of personal requirement (S. 14(1)(e)), the Court explained that whether the landlord has "no other reasonably suitable accommodation" involves fact-sensitive inquiries: who are dependants, the financial status of the family, the size and suitability of other accommodation, whether other family members are in fact dependent, and similar considerations. These are questions of fact which cannot be decided summarily at the leave stage. The Court rejected the petitioner's submission that the tenant must conclusively prove insufficiency at that stage.
- The Court relied on the Supreme Court's reasoning in Santosh Kumar v. Bhai Mool Singh to underscore that the proper test at the affidavit stage is whether, if the facts alleged by the defendant were duly proved, they would afford a plausible defence; proof comes later after leave is granted and trial is held.
- Concluding from these points, the Court found that the Additional Rent Controller had misdirected herself and had erred in refusing leave to defend on both the affidavit-form technicality and the merits where triable issues had been plausibly raised.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Court allowed the revision petition. It set aside the order of ejectment and remanded the matter to the Additional Rent Controller with a direction to grant leave to defend and to proceed to trial. The Court ordered that the marks made in its judgment be disregarded in the trial and directed that parties bear their own costs. Parties were directed to appear before the Rent Controller on 9th May 1980.
Implications: The direct effect of the decision is that the eviction order is vacated and the tenant is to be granted leave to defend, with the issues remitted for trial on the merits. The Court emphasized the correct legal standard for deciding leave under S. 25-B (i.e., whether the affidavit discloses facts which, if proved, would disentitle the landlord) and criticized summary refusal of leave where plausible triable issues exist. The opinion applied existing precedents but did not purport to lay down a novel binding principle beyond applying those authorities to the facts of this case.
D.K Kapur J.:— This is a revision under S. 25-B (8) of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958, intituted by the petitioner to challenge the eviction order passed by Shrimati Manju Goel, 4th Addl. Rent Controller, Delhi under S. 14 (1) (e) of the said Act. The facts of the case show that the respondent mentioned in the eviction application had applied for leave to defend under the procedure prescribed by S. 25-B within the time mentioned in the summons, but leave to defend was refused on two grounds.
2. Firstly, the application was accompanied by the short affidavit stat ing “that the contents of the accompanying application for leave to defend of paras 1 to 5 are true to my knowledge and the same may be read as part of this affidavit”, but the learned Additional1 Rent Controller thought that the paragraphs themselves must be reproduced in the affidavit. Secondly even on the merits and the facts stated in the application, the learned 4th Addl. Rent Controller came to the conclusion that no facts were stated which entitled the tenant to leave to defend.
3. Learned counsel for the respondent has attacked the order of the Additional Rent Control on both points. He says that it has been held in two judgments of this Court reported as Gian Chand v. Roop Narain, 1979 Raj-dhani LR 469 and Jagir Singh v. Mohinder Kaur, (AIR 1979 Delhi 245) at page 563 of the same report, holding that the mere fact that the affidavit was in short from was insufficient to non-suit the replying tenant. I fully endorse this view. It is too technical to hold that the paragraphs of the application must be reproduced in the affidavit before they can be read as part of the affidavit. The statement in the affidavit reading that the contents of the application should be read as part of the affidavit is sufficient. The verification at the bottom of the affidavit swearing to the contents of the affidavit, shows that the Controller had to read the application as part of the affidavit. This short form of affidavit is generally used in almost all Courts in India and can not be disregarded for the purposes of a case under the Delhi Rent Control Act. So, the order of the Rent Codtroller is wrong on this point.
4. It is now necessary to deal with the second point because even if the application for leave to defend is dealt with on the merits, the learned Additional Rent Controller has found that no facts are disclosed in the application which whould justify the grant of leave to refend. Three points are mentioned as being facts entitling the respondent the leave to defend. Firstly, it was alleged that the original tenant was Ram Nath whose heirs were the answering respondent Shrimati Leela Wati and two daughters Miss Vijay Kumari and Miss Indu. It was claimed that these two were necessary parties to the suit. Secondly, it was claimed that Makhan Lal was the owner of the house and the petitioner's ownership was denied. Thirdly it was claimed that the petitioner did not bona fide require the accommodation because she had ample accomodation in the house she was living. It was stated that she was living with her husband who owned a double storeyed house situated in Mohalla Mantola Paharganj, New Delhi. It was said that the entire house was with the petitioner and her family and the ejectment application was filed mala fide. It was also claimed that the ground floor of the house in which the respondent was living was also with the petitioner.
5. On these three points, the Rent Controller held that it was not sufficient to claim that Miss Vijay Kumari and Miss Indu were co-tenants. It was also necessary to show that Ram Nath was a tenant earlier. It was held that the Rent Controller strongly felt that the plea about Ram Nath being the original tenant and the other heirs being co-tenants was a sham and bogus plea. On the second point about ownership, it was stated that even the petitioner did not dispute that Makhan Lal was the previous owner from whom the petitioner had purchased the property in 1968, Which was not disputed. On the question of accommodation, the Rent Controller stated that the actual accommodation with the petitioner was not disputed nor was it disputed that the petitioner had four sons and hence the accommodation was obviously in sufficient for her. The Court relied on Smt. V.L Kashyap…Petitioner v. R.P Puri…, 1976 Rajdhani LR (Notes) 131; (AIR 1977 NOC 205)* to hold that only a specific and positive plea raised by the tenant would be sufficient to defeat the ejectment petition.
6. It is quite obvious that the learned Additional Rent Controller has completely misdirected herself on the questions as to what points have to be taken into account when leave to defend is to be granted. On the first point, the respondent did not at first produce rent receipts in favour of Ram Nath, but did file some shortly before the judgment was delivered and they are even now on record. Assuming that these receipts were filed too late for consideration, it must be kept in view that the Rent Controller has only to find out whether there is a case requiring trial not to decide the case on imaginary evidence to reach the conclusion that it is not triable. The provisions of sub s. (5) of S. 25-B state that the “Controller shall give to the tenant leave to contest the application if the affidavit filed by the tenant discloses such fact as would disentitle the landlord from obtaining an order for the recovery of possession of the premises on the ground specified in cl. (a), etc……”
The words “shall give to the tenant leave to contest” depend on the nature of the facts disclosed. The facts disclosed was that Ram Nath was the original tenant and the answering respondent, i. e. Shri-mati Leela Wati was the widow whereas there were two daughters, namely, Miss Vijay Kumari and Miss Indu who were also heirs to the tenancy. It cannot be doubted that if a tenant dies, the tenancy passes to all the natural heirs and if the tenant was Ram Nath then the tenancy would pass to the widow plus the two daughter. Apparently, the Rent Controller wanted the faet that Ram Nath was a tenant earlier to be proved before considering the correctness of the question. The principle to be applied in ascertaining whether leave is to be granted is not to require the proof of the fact to be given before the fact is put to trial and to find out if there is a point which requires trial. On this point, there could not be a better illustration than this case. In paragraph No. 14 of the eviction petition under consideration. Shrimati Leela Wati is mentioned as a tenant in the property from a time before the purchase by Shrimati Ganga Devi, the petitioning landlady.
It is also stated that no rent note is with the petitioner. In the reply to the application for leave to defend the same position is taken up. The landlady stated that Ram Nath was never a tenant [of the petitioner in the premises in suit. This is because the said Ram Nath had died before Ganga Devi came on the scene. So what had to be ascertained was whether Ram Nath was a tenant under the previous landlord namely Makhan Lal Jain. Even in the reply, it is stated by the landlady that she purchased the house on 4th March, 1968. So, she should have either obtained the information from the previous landlord or she should have some other proof of that Ram Nath was not a tenant in the premises at any time. This is not even stated in the affidavit opposing the application for leave to defend.
7. Learned counsel for the petitioner has referred to a Division Bench judgement of this Court in Smt. Vidyawanti. v. Taken Dass, 1974 Rajdhani LR 23, showing the consequences that arise when a case of ejectment is brought against only one of the contestents. In that case also, Pishori Lal was the tenant and his heirs were Shrimati Vidyawanti and his three sons and three daughters. But afterwards the landlord brough a petition for ejectment only against Tarlochan Lal leaving the widow and other sons and daughters. After the eviction order had been obtained, the other co-tenants raised a plea that they were entitled to remain in the property and were not bound by the eviction decree. This case was accepted by the Division Bench and the eviction was not permitted to continue. In the present case if Ram Nath was the tenant, it does not matter if the rent receipt was issued in favour or Shrimati Leela Wati, because it would appear that at the time of Ram Nath's death, these two daughters were or must have been quite young.
It is a bit surprising that the Rent Controller should have given the judgment holding that the defence is sham and bogus when before the order was passed the rent receipts in favour of Ram Nath had been filed and they are now on record and show that Makhan Lal Jain was receiving rent from Ram Nath for the very property for a considerable period and that period seems to be up to the year of 1962, or so. The later receipts are in favour of Mrs. Ram Nath. It cannot be said that these receipts have to be disregarded because they are filed later. As a matter of fact, it is very necessary to focus attention on the fact that evidence is led after a triable issue is disclosed and not before. Once the leave has been granted, then all these facts would have come on record. In the judgement of Supreme Court Santosh Kumar v. Bhai Mool Singh AIR 1958 SC 321 the great danger involved in refusing leave to defend merely because proof is not on record has been pointed out. There, the Supreme Court said:—
“But it cannot reach the conclusion that the defence is not bona fide arbitrary. It is as much bound by judicial rules and judicial procedure in reaching a conclusion of this kind as in any other matter………”
Then, later in the same judgment, it is stated as follows:—
“That at once raised as issue of fact. the truth and good faith of which could only be tested by going into the evidence and as we have pointed out, the learned trial Judge held that the defence did raise a triable issue. But he held that it was not enough for the defendants to back up their assertions with an affidavit; they should also have produced writings and documents which they said were in their possession and which they asserted would prove that the cheques and payments reffered to in their defence were given in payment of the cheque in suit…………”
Refusing this line of reasoning. the Supreme Court observed as follows
“The learned Jpdge has failed to see that the state of proof can only come after the defendant has been allowed to enter all appearance and defend the suit, and that the nature of the defence has to be determined at the time when the affidavit is put in. At that stage all that the Court has to determine is whether “if the facts alleged by the defendent are duly proved” they will afford a good, or even a plausible, answer to the plaintiff's claim. Once the Court is statisfied about that a leave cannot be withheld and no question about imposing conditions can arise, and once leave is granted, the normal procedure of a suit, so far as evidence and proof go, obtains.”
These observations show the way in which these questions have to be approached. The Court has not to decide the falsehood or correctness of what is stated, but has to see that if these facts are on record what would happen. Of course there may be some completely outrageous defences raised which may be summarily rejected by the Controller. But, if there is a plausible defence, it is the duty of the Controller to put the matter to trial and allow leave to defend. I may here point out that in the case decided by the Supreme Court I have just referred to leave was refused by the trial Court, it was also refused on revision by the Circuit Bench of the Punjab High Court at Delhi and was only allowed by the Supreme Court on special leave by the defen dant.
The observations are indicative of the fact that it is very easy for a Controller or Tribunal to non-suit a party by merely following a summary procedure without going into the merits or demerits of the actual facts. Here, we have a case where a positive plea had been taken by the respondent that she was not the only tenant, but her two daughters were also co-tenants. It wrs based on a plea that her deceased husband was the original tanant. The The Rent Controller thought that it was a far-fetched or imaginary or a made up plea. However, the petitioner did produce, though very late, receipts in favour of Ram Nath. This would have been sufficient to warn the Controller that she was making a mistake and so she should have granted leave.
8. Taking the next part of the case about the ownership, this has not been seriously pressed, because there is a photostat copy of a sale-deed. The mere production of the sale deed in such circumstances should be sufficient to establish the landlord's ownership. So I say nothing on this point.
9. I now come to the third point which raises an equally interesting point, The landlady had come to the Court claiming ejectment for personal need and the need of her dependant family members. She admitted that at present the family was living in a house belonging to her husband. She also admitted that there was a separate house, but whose dimensions were very small. She claimed that her four sons two of whom were married, her two daughters-in-law and two grand children were all living together in that small house belonging to the landlady's husband and the accommodation was sufficient. She said she wanted the property in dispute for the accommodation of herself and her dependant family members.
This was denied by the present petitioner claiming that the accommodation was quite ample and it was a double storeyed house which was fully in possession of the landlady and her family. It was further claimed that the second floor of the said house, i. e., the one from which eviction was sought from the upper floor was in possession of the landlady This raised, ipso facto, a question as to whether the existing accommodation was sufficient or insufficient for the landlady. There was no question of refusing Ieave to the respondent in such circumstances. Learned counsel for the petitioner landlady contends that in such a case it is for the tenant to prove the fact concerning the size of the rooms and their insufficiency and such other circumstances as would disentitle the landlady from getting an eviction order. 1 cannot accept this submission for the simple reason that here the ground on which eviction is claimed is quite different.
10. Section 14 (1) (e) of the Act requires that eviction will be granted if the landlord personally requires the premises for his own use or the use of his family members dependant on him, provided that he has no other reasonably suitable accommodation. The question as to whether the present accommodation is reasonably suitable raises questions as to who are the dependant, members and whether the existing accommodation is sufficient which are questions of fact which cannot be possibly decided in the manner suggested by the counsel for the landlord or landlady. The reasonableness of the accommodation depends on the financial status of the family. It also depends on what the other family members are doing. It may be that the sons are reasonably employed and not dependant on the mother. It cannot be said that the husband is dependant on the wife when he himself owns a house. It is not so simple a question as to be abstractively decided without a trial. The section is generally worded to cover all sorts of cases in different situations.
There may be a case in which the landlord has not a large house, then the question of his requirement cannot be settled without trial. Then, there may be a case in which the landlord has a comparatively small house which is insufficient for him. But here is a case of a landlady whose husband owns a house in which the family members are living. The fact that the ownership of the two houses is of different persons and the question as to who is dependant on whom and what are their requirement cannot be decided without trial. It is obviously a novel point which requires leave to be given. Furthermore, it cannot be assumed that the plan given by the landlady discloses the correct size of all the accommodation or discloses all the correct accommodation. There may be other rooms in the house which are not disclosed in the plan. Lastly it is the case of the petitioner that the landlady has an accommodation on the ground floor of the house which eviction is prayed for. The size and dimensions of that accommodation have also to be taken into consideration. It was, therefor, not a case in which leave should have been refused.
11. I would according accept this Revision Petition, ‘set aside the order of ejectment and remand the case back to the Additional Rent Controller for trial after giving leave to defend. The marks made in this judgment will be disregarded in the decision which must be based on the actual facts ascertained in the course of the trial. I leave the parties to bear their own costs. The parties to appear before the Rent Controller (Shri Brajesh Kumar) on 9th May 1980.
Petition allowed.
Alert