- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Commissioner Of Wealth-Tax, Delhi v. Mrs. Avtar Mohan Singh
Comprehensive Summary of the Opinion (Deshpande, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
The assessee owned and occupied a house at 15A, Aurangazeb Road, New Delhi, as her residence from 1959. Her husband, Bhai Mohan Singh, lived with her from 1959 onwards. Bhai Mohan Singh, being a working director of Messrs. Lepetti Rambaxy Laboratories (Private) Ltd., was entitled to rent-free accommodation from the company; because the company could not provide such accommodation it paid him Rs. 1,875 per month as compensation in lieu of a rent-free house. Bhai Mohan Singh passed that sum on to the assessee.
In the income-tax assessment year 1963–64 the Rs. 1,875 per month was treated as income of the assessee from the house property (calculated under section 23(2) of the Income-tax Act, 1961). For the assessment year 1964–65 the assessee claimed an exemption under section 5(1)(iv) of the Wealth-tax Act, 1957 (exemption for one house exclusively used by the assessee for residential purposes). The Wealth-tax Officer rejected the claim on the grounds that (1) the assessee had already been found to have earned the Rs. 1,875 per month in the income-tax proceedings, and (2) the assessee was sharing the house with her husband who was a tenant or alternatively she lived with her husband in a rented house and the husband was paying a concessional rent.
The Appellate Assistant Commissioner dismissed the assessee's appeal, observing that the husband paid Rs. 15,000 per year as rent. The Income-tax Appellate Tribunal summarized the revenue's objections as (1) the husband paid Rs. 1,875 per month as a tenant (not merely as a family member) and (2) even if he was a family member, the use by the assessee was not exclusive. The Tribunal rejected the second contention and found on facts that the husband occupied the house only as a member of the family; it also held that the Rs. 1,875 was not paid as rent or licence fee by the husband to the assessee but concluded overall that the assessee was entitled to the exemption. The Tribunal, at the instance of the revenue, referred the following question for opinion:
“Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the assessee is entitled to exemption of rupees one lakh under section 5(1)(iv) of the Wealth-tax Act, 1957?”
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the assessee is entitled to exemption of Rs. 1,00,000 under section 5(1)(iv) of the Wealth-tax Act, 1957 (i.e., whether one house belonging to the assessee exclusively used by her for residential purposes is exempt).
- What are the constituent requirements for claiming exemption under section 5(1)(iv) — specifically: (a) the house must be used by the assessee; (b) it must be used exclusively by her; and (c) it must be used exclusively for residential purposes — and whether these requirements are satisfied on the facts.
Arguments of the Parties
Revenue's Arguments
- The Wealth-tax Officer contended that the assessee had already been held to earn the Rs. 1,875 per month from the house in the income-tax assessment (assessment year 1963–64), which undermined the claim that the house was exclusively used as a residence.
- It was argued that the husband was either occupying the house as a tenant (paying Rs. 1,875 per month) or that the assessee was living with her husband in a rented house where the husband paid concessional rent; hence the use by the assessee was not exclusive.
- The Appellate Assistant Commissioner observed that the husband was paying Rs. 15,000 per year to the assessee as rent for occupying the house.
Assessee's Arguments
- The assessee claimed exemption under section 5(1)(iv) on the basis that she had been occupying the house for her own residence since 1959 and that her husband lived with her as a member of her family (i.e., without any independent right to occupy).
- The assessee asserted that the house was used exclusively by her for residential purposes and therefore entitled to the statutory exemption.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court framed the statutory requirements for exemption under section 5(1)(iv): (1) the house must be used by the assessee; (2) the use must be exclusive to her; and (3) the use must be exclusively for residential purposes. The opinion then analysed each requirement against the material facts.
Requirement 1 — Used by the assessee: The court found that this requirement was satisfied because the assessee lived in the house and, as owner, primarily used it; the mere presence of family members did not negate that she used the house.
Requirement 2 — Exclusiveness of use: The court explained that "exclusive" does not mean solitary occupation. It drew an analogy between "use" and the legal concept of possession, invoking Savigny's distinction between corpus possessionis (physical control) and animus possidendi (the intention or right to possess). The court held that the "use" must be judged not only by factual occupation but by the legal capacity or right in which a person resides in the house.
On the facts, the company paid Bhai Mohan Singh Rs. 1,875 per month as compensation in lieu of rent-free accommodation. That amount, being his income, was available for his free disposal. However, Bhai Mohan Singh systematically passed that same amount to his wife each month to cover his residence. The court reasoned that the sum retained the character of a house-rent allowance or compensation for residence even when passed on; by making regular payments to the assessee specifically to cover his residence, Bhai Mohan Singh acquired a capacity or right to occupy more than that of a mere family member occupying in the assessee's right.
The court analysed alternatives carefully: even if Bhai Mohan Singh had not become a formal tenant or paid a licence fee, a person who regularly pays an amount that is in substance a payment for residence cannot be treated as occupying merely as a family member without any right. The court thus concluded that from the moment the regular and systematic payments began, the use of the house by the assessee was shared with Bhai Mohan Singh in a manner inconsistent with exclusive use by the assessee alone.
Requirement 3 — "For residential purposes": The court read "residential purposes" to exclude uses that are income-earning or otherwise ancillary to profit-making. It observed that the clauses of section 5(1) describe occupations that are non-profit-making and therefore purely residential. Because the assessee had derived income (the Rs. 1,875 per month) from the house and that income had been assessed to income-tax, the house could not be said to be used solely for residential purposes. Earning income from the house placed the use outside the scope of "residential purposes" within section 5(1)(iv).
On these combined grounds — the loss of exclusive capacity to occupy (due to the husband's systematic payments) and the fact that the property was used to earn income — the court concluded that the assessee failed to meet the statutory requirements for exemption.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The reference is answered in the negative. Concretely, the court held that the assessee is not entitled to the exemption of Rs. 1,00,000 under section 5(1)(iv) of the Wealth-tax Act, 1957.
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: The assessee's claim for exemption under section 5(1)(iv) was rejected because she did not satisfy the requirement of exclusive use by her alone and the requirement that the property be used solely for residential purposes (the property yielded assessable income).
- The opinion rests on the factual finding that the husband's regular payments (originating as compensation from his employer in lieu of rent-free accommodation) altered his capacity to occupy the house and that the payments were treated as the assessee's income for income-tax purposes; these findings were central to denying the exemption.
- No broader implications or new rule-making precedent are stated in the opinion; the decision turns on the statutory construction of section 5(1)(iv) applied to the specific facts before the court.
Source material: Opinion authored by Deshpande, J., as provided. This summary strictly reflects only the information and reasoning contained in that opinion.
Deshpande, J.:— Under section 5(1)(iv) of the Wealth-tax Act, 1957 (hereinafter called “the Act), “wealth-tax shall not be payable by an assessee in respect of the following assets, and such assets shall not be included in the net wealth of the assessee…. (iv) one house or part of a house belonging to the assessee exclusively used by him for residential purposes”. (Proviso not reproduced as not relevant).
2. The assessee owns a house at 15A, Aurangazeb Road, New Delhi, and has been occupying it for her own residence from 1959 onwards. Her husband, Bhai Mohan Singh, has also been residing with the assessee as a member of her family from 1959. Bhai Mohan Singh, as the working director in Messrs. Lepetti Rambaxy Laboratories (Private) Ltd., was entitled to rent free accommodation from the company. As the company could not provide him with rent-free accommodation, it paid him Rs. 1,875 per month as compensation for its inability to provide him with a rent-free house. As Bhai Mohan Singh lived with his wife in 15A, Aurangazeb Road, he passed on this amount of Rs. 1,875 per month to her. In the assessment year 1963-64, this was treated as the income of the assessee from her house property, namely, 15A, Aurangazeb Road, and was added to the income accruing to the assessee from the said house calculated on the basis of annual value under section 23(2) of the Income-tax Act, 1961. In the assessment year 1964-65, the assessee claimed exemption from the payment of wealth-tax on her house property called 15A, Aurangzeb Road, New Delhi, under section 5(1)(iv) of the Act. The Wealth-tax Officer, however, rejected her claim on the following grounds, namely:
(1) The assessee has already been found to have earned this income of Rs. 1,875 per month from her house property at 15A, Aurangazeb Road, in the income-tax assessment proceeding for the year 1963-64.
(2) The assessee was sharing the house with her husband, Bhai Mohan Singh, who was her tenant, or alternatively, the assessee was living with her husband in a rented house, the concessional rent of Rs. 1,875 for which was being paid by the husband.
3. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner dismissed the assessee's appeal by observing that her husband was paying to her a sum of Rs. 15,000 per year as rent for occupying the house.
4. The Income-tax Appellate Tribunal summed up the objections of the revenue to the claim of the assessee to exemption under section 5(1)(iv) as follows, namely:
(1) The assessee's husband paid Rs. 1,875 per month to the assessee for the occupation of the house as a tenant and not as a member of the family of the assessee.
(2) Even if the husband of the assessee was a member of her family, the use of the house by the assessee was not exclusive.
5. The Tribunal, however, rejected the second contention of the revenue on the ground that the use of the house by the assessee did not cease to be exclusive merely because her husband and the family lived in it with her. As regards the first contention, the Tribunal found that whatever might have been the arrangement and agreement between Bhai Mohan Singh and the company and whatever might have been the reasons for the payment of Rs. 1,875 per month by Bhai Mohan Singh to the assessee, Bhai Mohan Singh occupied the house since 1959 and continued to occupy the same even during the year in which the appeal was heard by the Tribunal, i.e, 1967-68, only as a member of the assessee's family. If the property had been taken by the company on lease from the assessee for the occupation of Bhai Mohan Singh, the amount of Rs. 1,875 per month would have been paid by the company to the assessee directly. Further, it was improbable that such a valuable house property could have been taken on lease for such a small amount of Rs. 1,875 per month. The amount of Rs. 1,875 per month was not paid by Bhai Mohan Singh to the assessee as rent or even as licence fee. The assessee, therefore, used the house exclusively for the purpose of residence and was entitled to the exemption of Rs. 1,00,000 under section 5(1)(iv) of the Act.
6. The question referred to us by the Tribunal for opinion at the instance of the revenue is as follows:
“Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the assessee is entitled to exemption of rupees one lakh under section 5(1)(iv) of the Wealth-tax Act, 1957?”
7. The assessee has to satisfy the following requirements before her claim to exemption under section 5(1)(iv) of the Act can be sustained. Firstly, the house must be used by the assessee. Secondly, it must be used exclusively by her and, thirdly, it must be used exclusively for residential purposes.
8. The fact that the assessee is living in the house with her husband and family is sufficient to show that the house is used by the assessee. The members of the family of the assessee are bound to live with her. If the ownership of the house belongs to the assessee, then it is primarily the assessee as the owner who is using the house. The members of her family living with her only in their capacity as members of the family are not using the house in their own right. Their residence with the assessee, therefore, by itself does not mean that the house is not being used by the assessee herself. The first requirement may, therefore, be said to have been satisfied in the present case.
9. The use of the house by the assessee has to be “exclusive”. Exclusiveness in this context does not mean loneliness. It does not require that the assessee should live alone in the house. The physical residence of her family with her without any legal right to share the use of the house with her does not come in the way of the exclusiveness of the use of the house by the assessee. But the “use” of the house has, like possession of the house, two aspects, namely, the actual use without claim to any right and use with the claim to a right to do so. According to Savigny, the concept of possession has two elements, namely: (1) corpus possessionis, and (2) animus possidendi. It is the combination of the two which completes the concept of possession as the word is used for legal purposes. The same analysis can be applied to the concept of “use”. The user is to be determined not merely by the factual use, but also by the nature of the capacity or right in which the house is used as a residence. The Roman Law maxim “possession borrows a great deal from the right” is significant in this context.
10. The test of the exclusiveness of the use of the house is, therefore, whether she alone is living there as of right. So long as her husband and the family did not have any other capacity or right to live with her except as members of the family, it could be said that the use of the house by the assessee was exclusively by her. But when Rs. 1,875 began to be paid to the assessee by Bhai Mohan Singh, it could no longer be said that Bhai Mohan Singh used the house with the assessee merely as a member of her family and without any right in himself to do so. Rs. 1,875 were received by Bhai Mohan Singh from the company only because the company was unable to provide a residence to him. This money was, therefore, in the nature of a house-rent allowance or compensation in lieu of a rent-free house paid by the company to Bhai Mohan Singh. The money was impressed with this character when it passed from the company to Bhai Mohan Singh. As it was Bhai Mohan Singh's income, he was free to spend it or do with it what he liked. If he had done so, the capacity in which he resided in the house would have continued to be the same, namely, as a member of the assessee's family. If he had paid any other amount of money to his wife for any other purpose then also the explanation for such payment would have to be considered and the mere fact of such payment by itself would not have changed the capacity or the right of Bhai Mohan Singh to live in the house. But, what Bhai Mohan Singh has done is to systematically pass on the amount of Rs. 1,875 received by him from the company to his wife every month. The result is that the character impressed on this payment made by the company to Bhai Mohan Singh continued to attach to it even when Bhai Mohan Singh paid it to the assessee. If Bhai Mohan Singh paid Rs. 1,875 to the assessee as the money which was meant to cover the expenses of his own use of a residence then it could no longer be said that the use of the house by Bhai Mohan Singh was without any right and merely as a member of the family. By virtue of this payment, Bhai Mohan Singh used the house in the right of a person who was paying the assessee for his residence in the house.
11. It may be that Bhai Mohan Singh did not become a tenant of the assessee as such. He may not have paid the amount of Rs. 1,875 even as a licence fee. But, even an invitee who systematically pays to the assessee the amount of money which was impressed with the character of a house rent-allowance or a compensation in lieu of residence cannot be said to be using the house without any right and merely in the capacity of a member of the family.
12. As has been observed by R.W.M Dias in his Jurisprudence (1964) at p. 326, “in English law, as in the Roman law, possession is no more than a device of convenience and policy.” This has been appreciated by a few writers and most clearly by Shartel, who said:
“I want to make the point that there are many meanings of the word ‘possession’; that possession can only be usefully defined with reference to the purpose in hand; and that possession may have one meaning in one connection and another meaning in another.”
13. In the context of section 5(1)(iv), the use of the house and its exclusiveness have relevance not merely to the physical fact of residence but also to the capacity or the right in which a person uses the house as a residence. While the fullest right of ownership of the house was in the, assessee, a smaller right of an invitee paying consideration for his residence inhered in Bhai Mohan Singh. The user of the house by the assessee was, therefore, shared by her with Bhai Mohan Singh from the moment the regular and systematic payment started being made by Bhai Mohan Singh to cover his residence in the house along with his wife. The assessee has, therefore, failed to satisfy the second requirement.
14. The significance of the words “for residential purposes” is two-fold. Firstly, these words are contrasted with non-residential purposes such as commercial purposes which are not present in this case. Secondly, “residential purposes” have to be construed in the context of the exclusive use of the house by the assessee. In this context, it means that the house is used by the assessee solely as a residence and not with a view to make any income or profit from it. The various clauses of section 5(1) of the Act enumerate the types of occupation which are non-profit making and, therefore, merely residential. Under section 5(1)(i) the property held by a trustee or a person under some other legal obligation for a public purpose of a charitable or religious nature is exempted because the holder does not have a beneficial right to the enjoyment of the property. Under section 5(1)(ii) the interest of the assessee in the coparcenary property of any Hindu undivided family of which he is a member is also exempted because the unit of assessment would be the Hindu undivided family. Under section 5(1)(iii) the official residence of a Ruler is, exempted primarily because it is the residence and not used for profit making. Under section 5(1)(iv)(a) agricultural land subject to a maximum is exempted because agricultural income is not taxable under the Income-tax Act or the Wealth-tax Act. Under section 5(1)(v) the rights under any patent or copyright not held as assets of a business and not yielding any income or benefit are exempted. Under section 5(1)(vi) the right or interest of the assessee in a policy of insurance, the money covered by which has not become due and payable to the assessee, is exempted. Similar reasons explain the exemption of the assets covered by the rest of the clauses of section 5(1). What is signified by the words “residential purposes” is not merely the living of the assessee in the house but also the necessary implication that the house is not used otherwise than as a mere residence. Everything that is not included in “residential purposes” is, therefore, excluded from section 5(1)(iv). Any use of the house to earn an income would, therefore, be outside the “residential purposes” of the assessee. The income earning purpose would be other than a “residential purpose”. As the house is used by the assessee not only for the residence of herself and her family but also to earn an income in the nature of the payment made by Bhai Mohan Singh to her, it cannot be said that it is used by the assessee for residential purposes only. This conclusion is further supported by the admitted fact that the income of Rs. 1,875 per month earned by the assessee from this house property at 15A, Aurangazeb Road, is also assessed to income-tax as such. After earning income from the use of the property, the assessee can never claim that the house property is used by her only for residential purposes.
15. For the above reasons, we answer the reference in the negative.
16. Reference answered in the negative.
Alert