- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Smt. Jai Devi & Others v. Sh. Jodhi Ram & Others S
Structured Summary of the Opinion (S.N. Andley, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
Babu Ram (one of the sons of the deceased Kalyan Dass) instituted Suit No. 567 of 1957 in the Subordinate Judge I Class, Delhi, for partition of certain properties on behalf of himself, his sons (including appellants Nos. 2 to 4 and Rattan Lal). The defendants included his brother Jodhi Ram, Jodhi Ram's sons and his mother. On December 31, 1957, Babu Ram filed an application stating that he intended to withdraw the suit and prayed that it be consigned to the record room; both Babu Ram and Jodhi Ram supported this withdrawal by statements in court and the suit was dismissed. No liberty was reserved to institute a fresh suit and the Court did not grant permission to withdraw with liberty to institute a fresh suit. Appellants Nos. 2 to 4 were minors at the relevant time.
On November 3, 1958 Jai Devi (appellant No. 1) and her sons filed a suit for partition of the same properties against Jodhi Ram, his sons, Mohan Devi (wife of the deceased) and Babu Ram; they alleged the earlier withdrawal by Babu Ram was vitiated by fraud and illegal. The Subordinate Judge appointed Sat Parkash, the Ahlmad of the Court, as guardian-ad-litem for three minor sons of Jodhi Ram because their eligible relatives would not act as guardians.
On written statements the trial Court framed three preliminary issues: (1) whether the plaint was properly valued for court fee and jurisdiction, (2) whether the suit was barred by Order 23, rule 1 CPC, and (3) whether the plaintiffs had locus standi to bring the suit during the lifetime of a particular defendant. Issue No.1 was decided in favour of the appellants; Issue No.3 was decided partly in favour of some plaintiffs and against Jai Devi; Issue No.2 was decided against the appellants and the suit was dismissed. The cause title and the decree failed to indicate the Ahlmad appointed as guardian-ad-litem, instead showing Jodhi Ram as guardian of his minor sons.
The present appeal was filed in time. In the memorandum of appeal the three minor respondents (Nos. 5–7) were shown as represented by their father Jodhi Ram and not by the Ahlmad. At hearing respondents contended the appeal was incompetent because the guardian-ad-litem appointed by the trial Court was not shown as their guardian in the memorandum of appeal. The appellants sought time and filed applications to issue notice to the Ahlmad and to amend the memorandum of parties to substitute Sat Parkash, Ahlmad, as guardian-ad-litem. The Ahlmad was given notice, appeared, and counsel was appointed for him at the appellants' cost. The High Court made the order issuing notice without prejudice to respondents' right to raise limitation or incompetency points; the appellants then sought amendment of the cause title (C.M. No. 229 of 1970).
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the memorandum of appeal was incompetent because the guardian-ad-litem appointed by the trial Court (Sat Parkash, Ahlmad) was not shown as the representative of the minor respondents in the memorandum of appeal.
- Whether the suit (the fresh suit for partition filed by Jai Devi and her sons) was barred by Order 23, rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
- Preliminary issues framed at trial (as relevant): whether the plaint was properly valued for court fee and jurisdiction; and whether the plaintiffs had locus standi to bring the suit during the lifetime of the specified defendant.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- Notice of the appeal had been issued and accepted by Jodhi Ram as guardian of respondents Nos. 6 and 7 without protest; respondent No. 5 had attained majority and received notice himself.
- At the time of filing the appeal the petitioners (minors) were minors during the pendency of the trial suit; their mother (co-plaintiff and next friend) was illiterate; counsel in the appellate Court was different from that in trial Court; consequently, in the memorandum Jodhi Ram was shown as guardian (as in the trial Court's judgment) — implying the omission was one of misdescription and was rectifiable.
- They applied for issuance of notice to the guardian-ad-litem (Sat Parkash) and for amendment of the cause title to substitute Sat Parkash as guardian-ad-litem (C.M. No. 229 of 1970).
Respondents' Arguments
- The appeal was rendered incompetent because the guardian-ad-litem appointed by the trial Court for respondents Nos. 5 to 7 had not been shown as their guardian in the memorandum of appeal when filed.
- At the trial they urged that the present suit (filed by Jai Devi and her sons) was barred by Order 23, rule 1 CPC because an earlier suit on the same subject-matter had been withdrawn by Babu Ram without permission or liberty to institute a fresh suit.
- They relied upon precedent (Tankeswar Das v. Bhagaban Chandra Choudhury) to support the submission that omission of the trial court appointed guardian-ad-litem in the memorandum of appeal rendered the appeal improperly filed.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Tankeswar Das & another v. Bhagaban Chandra Choudhury & others, A.I.R. 1968 Assam & Nagaland 61 | Reliance by respondents to urge that if the guardian-ad-litem appointed in the trial Court is not shown as representing the minor respondents in the appeal, the appeal cannot be held to have been properly filed. | The Court considered the case relied upon by respondents but expressly disagreed with its application to the present facts and rejected the contention that omission of the guardian-ad-litem rendered the appeal incompetent. |
| Lala Gur Prasad v. Smt. Laxmi Devi, A.I.R. 1968 All. 201 | Authority relied upon (by respondents) regarding parties added after limitation expired — used to argue against late additions of parties. | The Court distinguished this case as concerning adding parties after limitation expired (giving life to a dead case) and held it was not applicable to a case of mere misdescription of an existing party (i.e., omission of guardian's name). |
| Bachh Raj v. Sunder Mal & others, A.I.R. 1963 Rajasthan 119 | Authority for the proposition that amendment to include the guardian-ad-litem in the cause title is a case of misdescription and is capable of being rectified even at the stage of hearing of the appeal. | The Court relied upon this authority to support allowing amendment of the cause title and treating the omission as a curable misdescription. |
| Rup Chand v. Dasodha & another, I.L.R. 30 Allahabad 55 | Pre-Code authority holding that guardian-ad-litem is not a party and omission to name guardian in memorandum of appeal does not render appeal ineffective; limitation does not run from appointment of guardian. | The Court relied on this reasoning to hold that an appeal filed against a minor without naming the guardian-ad-litem is competent and curable. |
| Laxman Karan & another v. Bansidhar, A.I.R. 1960 A.L.J. 423 | Holds an appeal filed against a minor without a proper guardian is competent. | The Court cited this case to reinforce that a memorandum of appeal against a minor for whom no guardian is appointed cannot be treated as a nullity. |
| Ali Yacin v. Bhagwan Das & others, A.I.R. 1947 Allahabad 357 | Authority holding that a suit against a minor for whom no guardian is appointed is not a nullity. | Cited to support the principle that omissions relating to guardianship do not render proceedings nullities; applied in reasoning that the appeal was competent. |
| Rai Satyadeya Narayan Sinha & others v. Tirbeni Prasad & others, A.I.R. 1936 Patna 153 | Supports the position that procedural omissions concerning guardianship do not necessarily invalidate proceedings. | Used as part of the body of authority supporting competence of appeal despite omission of guardian-ad-litem in the memorandum of appeal. |
| Tulsiram v. Shyamlal Ganpatlal & another, 1960 Madhya Pradesh 73 | Another authority in the line supporting competency of proceedings against minors despite defects in guardianship representation. | Relied upon as further authority that an appeal against a minor remains competent where guardian-ad-litem is not properly shown. |
| Bajah V. Maheswara Rao V. Bajah V. Bajeswara Rao, 1967(1) M.L.J. 175 | Holds that suits for partition (and redemption) involve recurring causes of action; withdrawal of such suits does not preclude filing a fresh suit even if permission under Order 23, rule 1 CPC was not obtained. | The Court relied on this authority to conclude that a suit for partition is not barred by Order 23, rule 1 CPC when an earlier suit had been withdrawn without liberty to institute a fresh suit. |
| Thota China Subba Rao & others v. Mattapalli Raju & others, A.I.R. 1950 Federal Court 1 | Noted to the effect that provisions like Order 9, rule 9 or Order 23, rule 1 do not debar a mortgagor from filing a second suit for redemption because the cause of action is recurring; analogous principle for partition suits. | The Court cited this authority to support the recurring-cause-of-action principle and to analogize that Order 23, rule 1 does not bar filing a fresh suit for partition. |
| AIR 1949 Nagpur 366; AIR 1944 Sindh 192; AIR Madras 112; AIR 1935 Madras 909; AIR 1924 Allahabad 905 | Various authorities cited in support of the proposition that partition (and redemption) suits involve recurring causes of action and are not barred by withdrawal without liberty. | The Court cited these authorities collectively to bolster the conclusion that Order 23, rule 1 CPC does not bar a fresh partition suit after withdrawal of an earlier suit. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded in two analytical stages: first addressing the competency of the appeal (the guardianship/representation point), and then the substantive question whether the fresh partition suit was barred by Order 23, rule 1 CPC.
On the guardianship/competency point the Court observed that under sub-rule (5) of rule 3 of Order 32, a person appointed as guardian-ad-litem for a minor defendant continues as such throughout all proceedings arising out of the suit, including appellate proceedings. The respondents relied upon a decision (Tankeswar Das) to contend that omission of the trial-appointed guardian-ad-litem from the memorandum of appeal rendered the appeal improperly filed. The Court, however, emphasized that the real party to an appeal is the minor himself and that so long as the minor is made a respondent, omission to show the trial-appointed guardian-ad-litem in the memorandum of appeal is a misdescription only and does not affect competency. The Court relied on a number of authorities (including Bachh Raj, Rup Chand, Laxman Karan, Ali Yacin and others) establishing that such omissions are curable and that an appeal against a minor without proper guardian is competent. On that basis the Court allowed the amendment sought in C.M. No. 229 of 1970 to show Sat Parkash, Ahlmad, as guardian-ad-litem in the cause title.
On the substantive issue (Issue No. 2) whether the suit was barred by Order 23, rule 1 CPC, the Court accepted that, as a general proposition, a party who withdraws a suit without permission to bring a fresh suit or abandons part of the claim is precluded from pursuing the abandoned relief or bringing a fresh suit on the same cause of action. However, the Court held that this general rule does not apply to suits for partition (and analogously to redemption) because those actions involve recurring causes of action. The Court relied upon Bajah v. Maheswara Rao and several other authorities to support the proposition that even where liberty to institute a fresh suit is not granted on withdrawal, a plaintiff may nonetheless file a fresh suit for partition at any time. Applying this principle, the Court concluded the present suit for partition filed by Jai Devi and her sons was not barred by Order 23, rule 1 CPC despite the earlier withdrawal of Babu Ram's suit without liberty.
Following that analysis, the Court set aside the judgment and decree of the Subordinate Judge that had dismissed the suit on the basis of Issue No. 2, allowed the amendment to the cause title to show the guardian-ad-litem, and remanded the matter for trial on the merits before the Commercial Subordinate Judge, Delhi.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
The Court allowed the amendment to the cause title to show the guardian-ad-litem (Sat Parkash) and held that the fresh suit for partition was not barred by Order 23, rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The judgment and decree of the Subordinate Judge based upon Issue No. 2 were set aside and the case was remanded for trial on merits.
Implications and direct effects:
- The amendment sought in C.M. No. 229 of 1970 (to substitute Sat Parkash, Ahlmad, as guardian-ad-litem of respondents Nos. 5–7) was allowed: the omission in the cause title was treated as a curable misdescription.
- The Subordinate Judge's dismissal of the suit on the ground that it was barred by Order 23, rule 1 CPC was set aside; the case was remanded to the Commercial Subordinate Judge, Delhi, for trial on the merits.
- The parties were directed to appear before the Commercial Subordinate Judge, Delhi on 5th May, 1970.
- The parties were directed to bear their respective costs of the appeal.
Broader precedent: The Court relied on existing authorities concerning recurring causes of action for partition and the curability of misdescription as regards guardianship; the opinion does not purport to establish a novel legal principle beyond applying and reaffirming those authorities.
S.N Andley, J.:— The first appellant is the mother of appellants Nos. 2 to 4. She is the wife of Babu Ram, one of the two sons of deceased Kalyan Dass. For himself and on behalf of his sons, appellants Nos. 2 to 4 and another son Rattan Lal, Babu Ram instituted suit No. 567 of 1957 in the Court of Subordinate Judge Ist Class, Delhi, for partition of the suit properties and accounts on the ground that the said properties were joint family properties. The defendants to this suit were his brother Jodhi Ram, the latter's sons and his mother. On December 31, 1957, Babu Ram filed an application merely stating that he inttended to withdraw the suit and did not want to pursue the same and prayed that the suit may be consigned to the record room. Both Babu Ram and Jodhi Ram supported this application by their respective statements recorded on the same date and the suit was dismissed. Liberty was not reserved by Babu Ram either in his application or in his statement in Court to institute a fresh suit in respect of the subject matter of this suit nor was permission granted by the Court to withdraw with liberty to institute a fresh suit. It may be stated that appellants Nos. 2 to 4 are minors.
Thereafter Jai Devi and her sons filed the suit out of which the present appeal arises on November 3, 1958 against Jodhi Ram, his sons, Mohan Devi wife of the deceased Kalyan Das and Babu Ram. This suit was for partition of the very same properties and for accordance etc. in respect thereof. It was also prayed in this suit that the withdrawal by Babu Ram of the earlier suit was vitiated by fraud and was illegal, ineffective and without jurisdiction.
Since three of the sons of Jodhi Ram (defendants Nos. 5 to 7) were minors and their eligible relations were not prepared to become their guardians for the suit, the Subordinate Judge appointed Sat Parkash, Ahlmad of his Court, as guardian-ad-litem.
On the written statements filed, the Subordinate Judge framed the following three preliminary Issues :
Issue No. 1—Whether the plaint has been properly valued for purposes of court fee and jurisdiction ?
Issue No. 2—Whether the present suit is not barred by Order 23, rule 1 C.P.C ?
Issue No. 3—Have the plaintiffs a locus standi to bring a suit for partition in the life time of defendant No. 9?
Issue No. 1 was decided in favour of the appellants. Issue No. 3 was decided in favour of plaintiffs Nos. 2 to 5 but against Jai Devi appellant No. 1. Issue No. 2 was decided against the appellants and as a result of the finding on this Issue, the suit was dismissed leaving the parties to bear their respective costs. Even though the Ahlmad of the Court of the Subordinate Judge had been appointed as guardian-ad-litem, necessary corrections were not made in the cause title of the plaint by showing that the Ahlmad had been appointed guardian-ad-litem of the three minors sons of Jodhi Ram and the name of Jodhi Ram continued to appeal in the plaint as their guardian. What is more, even in the decree which was drawn up consequent upon the dismissal of the suit, Jodhi Ram was shown as the guardian of his three minor sons and the name of the Ahlmad who had been appointed guardian-ad-litem was not indicated in the decree-sheet.
The present appeal was filed, it is not disputed, well within time. Respondents Nos. 5, 6 and 7 were shown in the memorandum of appeal as being represented by their father Jodhi Ram and not by the Ahlmad of the Court. When this appeal came up for hearing on January 7, 1970, the respondents took up a point that the appeal had been rendered incompetent as the guardian-ad-litem appointed by the trial Court for respondents Nos. 5 to 7 had not been shown as their guardian in the memorandum of appeal. The counsel for the appellants wanted time to investigate the matter and when the appeal was taken up for hearing on January 30, 1970, an application : CM. No. 47 of 1970, was filed by the appellants. In this application it was stated that notice of this appeal had been issued by this Court and had been accepted by Jodhi Ram as guardian of respondents Nos. 6 and 7 without any protest while respondent No. 5 who had attained majority in the meantime had received it himself. It was further stated :—
“That the petitioners were all minors during the pendency of the suit in the trial Court, their mother who was a co-plaintiff and their next friend was an illiterate lady and their counsel in the appellate Court was different from the one engaged in the trial Court and, therefore, in the memo of parties filed alongwith the grounds of appeal, Jodhi Ram was shown as the guardian-ad-litem of defendants 5 to 7 as in the copy of the judgment.”
It was, therefore, prayed that the notice of the appeal be issued to Sat Parkash, Ahlmad of the trial Court as guardian-ad-litem. Notice of the appeal was accordingly issued to Sat Parkash, Ahlmad, who appeared and for whom Mr. B.R Sabharwal was appointed as an Advocate at the cost of the appellants. This order was made without prejudice to the respondents' right to urge the question of limitation and the incompetency of the appeal as filed. Thereupon, the appellants filed another application, C.M 229 of 1970 for amendment of the memorandum of parties so as to substitute the name of Sat Parkash aforesaid as the guardian-ad-litem of respondents Nos. 5 to 7 in place of their father Jodhi Ram (respondent No. 1). This application is opposed and it is urged that the appeal as filed was incompetent as the name of the guardian-ad-litem, Sat Parkash, was not shown in the memorandum of appeal when filed.
There is no doubt that under sub-rule (5) of rule 3 of Order 32 of the Code of Civil Procedure, a person appointed as guardian-ad-litem for a minor defendant continues as such throughout all proceedings arising out of the suit including proceedings in any appellate Court. Reliance is placed by the respondents upon the decision reported in A.I.R 1968 Assam & Nagaland 61 in re : Tankeswar Das and another v. Bhagaban Chandra Choudhury and others(1) to urge that if the guardian-ad-litem appointed in the trial Court is not shown as representing the minor respondents in the appeal, the appeal cannot be held to have been properly filed. With respect, we do not agree.
The real party to an appeal is not the guardian-ad-litem appointed but the minor himself. So long as the minor is made a respondent, the mere fact that the guardian-ad-litem appointed by the trial Court is not shown to represent him in the appeal would not affect the competency of the appeal.
Reliance is next placed on A.I.R 1968 All. 201 in re : Lala Gur Prasad v. Smt. Laxmi Devi(2). In this case the co-mortgagees were sought to be made parties after the period of limitation had expired. It was held that if the co-mortgagees are allowed to be made parties after the period of limitation had expired by the amendment of the plaint, such amendment would amount to giving life to a case which was already dead. This was not a case where the co-mortgagees had been made parties but there was a defect in their description. This case can, therefore, be of no assistance to the respondents.
There is on the other hand abundant authority for the proposition that amendment of the cause title by including the name of the guardian-ad-litem as representing the minor is a case of misdescription. The first case is reported in A.I.R 1963 Rajasthan 119 in re : Bachh Raj v. Sunder Mal and others (3) where it is observed :
“Subsequent steps taken by a party to secure the proper representation of the minor, whether he is a plaintiff or a defendant, can validate the earlier irregularities, if any in the mention of the next friend or guardian-ad-litem of the minor. Thus, where the minor was actually joined as a party to the suit and his next friend was also a party to the appeal not only in his individual capacity but as a next friend of another minor, then the fact that a minor was not, at the time of the institution of appeal against him, described as a minor and was not represented by his next friend is a case of misdescription and is capable of being rectified even at the stage of hearing of appeal.”
In I.L.R 30 Allahabad 55 in re : Rup Chand v. Dasodha and another(4), which was a case before the present Code of Civil Procedure, the defendant to the suit was a minor and was represented in the trial Court by the guardian-ad-litem. In the memorandum of appeal which was filed, the guardian-ad-litem was not made a party to the appeal. The decree in this case did not state the fact that there was a guardian-ad-litem. The memorandum of appeal was filed within time but an application was made after the expiry of the time allowed for the presentation of the appeal to add the name of the guardian-ad-litem to the record. It was contended that the appeal was not complete until the guardian-ad-litem was added and that when that was done, the appeal was barred by limitation. This contention was repelled. The reasoning adopted was that a suit was brought against a minor before a guardian was appointed and that limitation runs from the date of the plaint and not from the appointment of a guardian. The same reasoning was applied as governing a memorandum of appeal. It was pointed out that a guardian-ad-litem is not a party to the suit or appeal. He is merely named in the record as the person appointed by the Court to look after the interest of the minor. It has been held in A.I.R 1960 A.L.J 423 in re : Laxman Karan and another v. Bansidhar(5), that an appeal filed against a minor without a proper guardian is competent. If a suit against a minor for whom no guardian is appointed is not a nullity as held in A.I.R 1947 Allahabad 357 in re: Ali Yacin v. Bhagwan Das and others(6), a memorandum of appeal against a minor for whom no guardian is appointed cannot also be a nullity. To the same effect are cases reported in A.I.R 1936 Patna 153 in re : Rai Satyadeya Narayan Sinha and others v. Tirbeni Prasad and others(7) and 1960 Madhya Pradesh 73 in re : Tulsiram v. Shyamlal Ganpatlal and another(8). We are, therefore, of the view that the present appeal cannot be held to be incompetent when filed and we hereby allow the amendment of the cause title of the appeal as prayed in C.M No. 229 of 1970.
Coming to the merits of the appeal, the only Issue which require determination is whether the suit out of which the present appeal has arisen was barred by Order 23, rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The learned Subordinate Judge came to the conclusion that where a party withdraws a suit without seeking permission to bring a fresh suit on the same cause of action or abandons a part of the claim, he is precluded from claiming the abandoned relief or from bringing a fresh suit on the same cause of action. This proposition, as a general proposition, is correct but it does not apply to suits for partition. In 1967(1) MLJ 175 in re : Bajah V. Maheswara Rao V. Bajah V. Bajeswara Rao(9) it has been held that :—
“So far as a suit for partition or a suit for redemption is concerned, it is exiomatic that, when the plaintiff withdraws his suit, he will be entitled to file a fresh suit as the cause of action is recurring cause of action. Even if the plaintiff is not granted permission, under Order 23, rule 1, Civil Procedure Code, he will nevertheless have a right to file a suit for partition at any time he pleases.”
To the same effect are the cases reported in AIR 1949 Nagpur 366; AIR 1944 Sindh 192; AIR Madras 112; AIR 1935 Madras 909 and AIR 1924 Allahabad 905. We may only mention one other case reported in A.I.R 1950 Federal Court 1 in re : Thota China Subba Rao and others v. Mattapalli Raju and others, where it has been observed :—
“Provisions like Order 9, rule 9 or Order 23, rule 1 will not debar the mortgagor from filing a second suit for redemption because, as in a partition suit the cause of action in a redemption suit is a recurring one.”
Even though, therefore, liberty was not reserved while withdrawing the earlier suit, the present suit would not be barred by Order 23, rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
In the result, we set aside the judgment and decree of the learned Subordinate Judge based upon his finding on Issue No. 2. The case is remanded to the Court of the Commercial Subordinate Judge, Delhi, for trial on merits. The parties are directed to appear before the Commercial Subordinate Judge, Delhi, on 5th May, 1970.
In the circumstances of the case, we leave the parties to bear their respective costs of the appeal.
A.N.K Case remanded.
Alert